The New Civil War - Election or Free Will — Shane Idleman

Hi, my name is Shane Eidelman. I pastor West Side Christian Fellowship, and I recently gave a message on salvation. Election, free will, sovereign grace, all these different controversial things. But I want to give a brief introduction because I've noticed over the years, and I've spoken at many different cross-denominational lines.

Division Within the Body of Christ

I've got friends in the Calvary Chapel movement. I've got friends, Charismatic, Pentecostals. I've got friends in the Acts 29 movement with Mark Driscoll. Of course, we love Matt Chandler and Mark Driscoll and all, Francis Chan, and all these great men of God that God is clearly calling.

But there seems to be a huge division, what I call divisiveness in the body of Christ. We're shooting brothers who are shooting brothers who are wounding our own. And these issues should become a healthy debate and allowing people flexibility has now become so rigid and so dogma that we go into our own camps.

I'm on this side. What side are you on? Instead of spending energy evangelizing, preaching, building each other up, encouraging, we've become so divided on this issue that it's really raising a concern within my own mind that what direction are we taking?

Love as the Mark of Christian Discipleship

Is love truly guiding us? Is love truly guiding us? Jesus said that my disciples, actually the world will know that you are my disciples, by your love, your love for one another, not how well you translate the Greek and the Hebrew and your pneumatology and your eschatology and your theology, not by your hermeneutics and your homiletics, not by your sermon preparation.

Did it have a inductive, deductive, immediate approach to it? Is your theological persuasion, does it line up exactly with mine? They'll know that you are truly His disciples by your love. That's as much as we don't want to admit it.

We want to avoid it. We don't like that verse. The truth still stands. Love must underscore everything. It must undergird everything. It is a true characteristic of those who are truly filled with the Spirit of God.

God's Sovereignty and Human Responsibility

Now on that note, I primarily lean towards the Reformed faith in regard to theology and erring on the side of God's sovereignty. I love, of course, Augustine and his debate with Plagian and you get up to Luther and Erasmus and his great work on the bondage of the will.

You look to John Calvin and his institutes and the commentaries, Urig Zwingli and John Knox in Scotland. You get to the Puritans and the writings of Richard Baxter. The Reformed pastor is one of his greatest works and, of course, Thomas Goodwin and John Owen and all these great men of God that have came before us.

You look to the late D. Martin Lloyd-Jones and C .H. Spurgeon and I love reading these men. So there's not a problem with theology. The problem comes with trying to understand God's sovereignty. He's clearly sovereign, yet man has a responsibility to repent and to believe.

And for every, we have to remember, for every George Whitefield, God brings a John Wesley. For every D. Martin Lloyd-Jones, he's going to bring a A .W. Tozer. For every Paul Washer, there's gonna be a Leonard Ravenhill.

For every John MacArthur, there's gonna be a C .S. Lewis. So we've gotta start, I believe, being so divisive on these issues. Yes, have strong convictions. Yes, these are foundational truths that have shaped the church for years, but I'm seeing too much division, too much brother shooting brother, too much arrogance, too much pride in what should be a healthy debate has turned into really, really a strong battle over different theological positions.

A Healthy Tension Between Sovereign Grace and Human Choice

You can even look back at C .H. Spurgeon's sermon back in 1858 on sovereign grace and man's responsibility. He said that those two things are like two lines. They run parallel, and we don't know where they cross until eternity.

So there needs to be a, what I call a healthy balance there or a healthy tension. We have to understand that God is sovereign. Yes, yet we're commanded to repent and to believe. But as I conclude this introduction, I wanna remind the viewers that you have to ask yourself this question.

Testing Doctrine by Its Spiritual Fruit

It begs the question, is your stance, now let's be honest here, let's be genuine, let's be humble, let's be real. Is your stance, is your stance leading to love, joy, peace, contentment, long-suffering, gentleness, kindness, goodness, self-control, the fruit of the spirit, or is your stance leading to rigidness, dogma, arrogance, anger, and a critical spirit because the ladder is a slippery slope on which many never return?

Fighting the Right Theological Battles

So I just encourage you, as John Piper said, we can be so obsessed with doctrinal error that we lose the ability to rejoice in doctrinal truth. Let's make sure we're fighting the right fights.