2nd Commandment Violations

Have You Not Read

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:11

Welcome to have you not read a podcast seeking to answer questions from the text of scripture for the honor of Christ and the

00:18

Edification of the Saints before we dig into our topic. We humbly ask you to rate review and share the podcast.

00:24

Thank you I'm Andrew Hudson joining me today are Michael Durham Kyle Smith.

00:31

We're gonna jump right into our first question received from one of our viewers recently Evangelicals seem to be talking more these days about racially accurate depictions of Jesus I see no issue with this, but I have noticed it has also led to more discussions about Second Commandment violations commonly known as 2cv on social media

00:52

I was not raised to believe that a picture of Jesus in a children's Bible or anywhere else was a 2cv

00:59

But I'm seeing more and more respected pastors who feel that any picture of Christ is a 2cv

01:05

Is this a real issue? And if so, where is the line? What do you think about that Michael?

01:11

Well, that sounds like one of those questions that has a lot of questions kind of built into it so I think since the the main concern is about the

01:24

Second Commandment we should Go look at what the Second Commandment says

01:29

So obviously you can go to Exodus chapter 20 or Deuteronomy chapter 5

01:34

I'm happen to be in Deuteronomy 5 and the C verse 6 begins with the

01:41

Decalogue these 10 words the 10 Commandments I am the Lord your God who brought you out of the land of Egypt out of the house of bondage

01:49

You shall have no other gods before me. There's commandment number one. Here's commandment number two

01:55

I'm saying that because Protestants count verse 7 you shall have no other gods before me is commandment 1 and Then beginning in verse 8 they begin to count commandment number 2

02:09

Roman Catholics Combine those first two together as the first commandment and wait till they get to the coveting commandment and split those up into two

02:21

The reasons for that will are probably fairly apparent now verse 8

02:27

This is a second commandment You shall not make for yourself a carved image any likeness of anything

02:33

That is in heaven above or that is in the earth beneath or that is in the water under the earth

02:41

You shall not bow down to them nor serve them for I the Lord your

02:46

God am a jealous God Visiting the iniquity of the fathers upon the children to the third and fourth generations of those who hate me but showing mercy to thousands and to those who love me and keep my commandments so We notice that so that God says

03:03

I am the Lord your God. I have redeemed you from Egypt Therefore here's how you shall now live and this second series of you shall not is very specific to not make a carved image a

03:20

Graven image a likeness of anything in the created order for the purpose of bowing down to them serving them and God explains that he's a jealous

03:32

God. He's not going to tolerate that at all So this question is concerned about second commandment violations now we understand that a carved image a graven image is in principle a painted image a

03:48

Computer -generated image even an image that we may bring up into our mind and craft in our mind even that matters so Anything that is

04:00

Crafted by man according to man's imagination according to man's capacities

04:07

That's what we're talking about here The commandment is not to be read so narrowly that we're only talking about when you get a knife out or to work on wood

04:16

Or a chisel and hammer to work on stone and so on I think everybody understands that so the concern is about second commandment violations

04:25

The question is are people creating images of Jesus are people creating images of Jesus so that they may

04:34

Bow down to them and serve them that they may worship them. Is that what is going on?

04:40

Is that the concern that is being brought up in in this question? Many pastors are being more vocal concerned about violations at the second commandment because creating any kind of image of Jesus Not only runs the risk of depicting him inaccurately

04:59

Okay, but then also leading people into a false worship

05:05

So let's just take an obvious example. I always say a seven -year -old child of ours goes to Sunday school and Receives a

05:14

Bible story about Jesus feeding the 5 ,000 as a picture of Jesus lifting the bread and the fish to heaven and he's praying to the

05:23

Father to bless the food The disciples are all around people out in the crowd, you know holding their stomachs

05:28

They're hungry, you know, and they're going to color this picture while the teacher teaches to reinforce the lesson

05:35

Do we have here a violation of the second commandment? What do you think? I would say no.

05:41

Okay Why would you say no Kyle? I think it comes from the standpoint of the child isn't explicitly worshiping that and seeing that depiction of Jesus as their

05:55

God as their deity, it's simply a Reinforcement to the story that they're being taught at that point

06:05

Okay, is there any sense in which you know, have you ever experienced this? You know that there is a

06:11

Instructions with the color sheet to to venerate the image of Jesus on the page

06:18

Not in any coloring book I've used. Yeah, I'm not it's been a while though. Not seen that right?

06:24

okay, and now there is of course the Concern.

06:30

Well, let's not even get close to violating any of the commandments So this is idea of fencing the law

06:37

So, let's make sure we don't get even close to breaking any of these very important commandments

06:43

So let's let's fence the law a little bit and not get anywhere close So in the creating of images of Jesus, does this get anywhere close?

06:53

Does this get close? Maybe it maybe it's not a second commandment violation, but but are we treading in dangerous waters if perchance

07:03

Let's say I'll give you I'll give you a very specific example There was a new family in my former church and they've been out of church for a long time

07:11

They're just kind of getting back in and looking for community really their son had a few disciplinary, you know problems

07:18

And they're trying to find a good fit for him You know They start coming to church and to encourage the young man in the stories of the

07:25

Bible the dad buys him the action Story Bible Okay And it's got it's basically a big fat comic book and it has all the stories of Scripture in comic book form

07:37

And he thinks it's the coolest and of course the other kids thinks this kid's got the coolest Bible ever and they're you know

07:44

Looking at all the pictures and all that kind of thing So is this treading and dangerous ground as far as the second commandment?

07:50

What do we think? I mean again, let's look at this It says you shall not make for yourself a carved image

07:57

Any likeness of anything that is in heaven above or that is on the earth beneath or that is in the water under the earth

08:02

You should not bow down to them nor serve them. This is a bad thing to do So I have a question

08:08

I guess is this to be separated into individual elements of you shall not do this and you shall not do this and you

08:15

Should not do that or is it rather taken as a whole that the creation of these carvings are meant towards veneration or obeisance or service

08:26

Right, I think that they're they hold together and the whole idea of making a carved image

08:31

For example all kinds of carved images were made expressly for the temple

08:40

Even cherubim were carved There were pomegranates that were carved into the pillars there.

08:47

It was all kinds of carved images Everywhere in the temple and that wasn't the problem

08:52

Even the the Ark of the Covenant had a mercy seat And there was a lot of carving a lot of shaping going on there.

08:59

But in regards to any of these Elements they were not being Revered they were not to be revered.

09:07

No one was to you know, bow down and worship these things So it's definitely not a separation of elements here in this commandment

09:15

It's not saying any carved image is bad because we see how much God delights in art in the instructions that he gave in the

09:26

Construction of the tabernacle and the temple also we see how much God delights in imagery when we read his word our imaginations are

09:36

Amply excited by the visuals that God creates He wants us to be using our imaginations and crafting in our mind the visuals that he gives to us

09:46

God is for that which is good and true and beautiful and art is a gift from him

09:52

So he's not against carved images per se just by themselves He's against anyone

09:59

Crafting them so as to bow down to them and worship them So regarding that Jesus Christ being the center of everything

10:07

Christ has the preeminence in all things it would make sense that people and I forget the name of the man who does this but He's been creating art for some time and releasing it through his website and on YouTube and so on It's called full of eyes and his work goes out to various countries

10:24

And since they go it goes out to Latin American countries He has a big disclaimer at the front of many of his videos saying these images are not

10:33

To be worshipped. They are not for veneration. These are to glorify God glorify Christ These are not meant for worship and he makes that very very clear.

10:43

I think he's being sensitive to the Proclivities of some of his audience.

10:49

Mm -hmm. That's exactly what I was thinking just in terms of you know the Catholic tradition and you have very much veneration as part of that in images, especially so yes, so Is somebody wants to honor and glorify

11:07

God and so they want to make a piece of art, okay What's the the favorite subject of the scriptures?

11:14

What's the what's the central? Reality of the universe. What are we gonna?

11:19

Well, it's Jesus Christ the God -man the incarnation So makes sense that art will be made about Christ now

11:28

Let's we have to dig a little deeper now, I think because for some people It would make sense to them that if a picture was made of Jesus, it would be worthy of worship right because it would be a depiction of the one who deserves all praise and so they would consider it their obligation to worship it or to venerate or to be led in worship by this image informed by this image as to the worthiness of Christ and therefore

11:58

I worship by use of this image, which I think would be a Violation of the second commandment, but we've got a little dig a little bit deeper as to why it can't why is it possible?

12:09

Why is it possible to create an image of Jesus? Okay, and not be idolatrous

12:16

Right, isn't he God? Isn't he God in human flesh? Ryan mentioned to us earlier a great passage that Jesus says to Philip Philip Have you known me so long and if you've seen me you've you've seen the father

12:30

All right, so how are we to understand what goes on here How is it that an image if you try to draw an image of Jesus?

12:39

You're not trying to draw an image of God any ideas why the two are different Part of me wonders if it gets down to the physical reality of it that he came down in bodily form the

12:56

Incarnation and he is here in our world with us

13:01

I can see you across the table from me right now. I can look at my wife I can see my kids the beauty of them the majesty of them the same thing applies to Jesus Christ His physicality is just as important as his deity.

13:15

And so by maybe saying well We shouldn't be depicting Christ in any image form in some way diminishes his condescension to us

13:26

Right. So when we think about the nature of the incarnation and this has been worked out for us helpfully by the creeds whether you start with Nicaea and Constantinople and Chalcedon the the fullness of Christ humanity is a full humanity.

13:43

The fullness of his deity is a full Divinity he is as much God as God is

13:49

God and he is as much man as man is man This extends even to according to the creeds it extends even to the will even to the emotions

14:00

To the very to the very soul of the matter. There is nothing there is nothing lacking in Christ's humanity and there there is no communication of the attributes between divinity and humanity so that the the divine nature of Christ does not leak into the

14:21

Human nature of Christ and thereby improve it and the human nature of Christ does not soak into the divine nature of Christ and thereby lessen it that he is two natures in hypostatic union one person the mystery of the incarnation and the creeds lead us to this biblical truth that we can have we have several examples that we may

14:49

Just simply affirm by you know Looking at these different passages by way of negation saying we are not saying that he is some kind of third kind some sort of unique mixture but that he has two natures in one person and by this we may say

15:06

By dealing with the human nature of Christ that he was a

15:11

Jew They lived in the ancient Near East That he was born of Mary that he was a lineage of David that he ate certain types of foods

15:21

He encountered a certain type of environment There were certain types of genetics involved means that he's going to look a certain way

15:29

He's not going to be he's not going to be as tall as an NBA player Right.

15:35

He's not going to be as a fair -skinned as a Norwegian Okay, he's not going to have certain features that sometimes are depicted in the child's

15:46

Coloring book or a in stained -glass windows So we recognize that in the humanity of Jesus and we recognize the fact that he was a

15:55

Jew living in the ancient Near East at A certain time period we recognize that well We don't really know what he looked like But he looked like the people around him like, you know

16:03

Hebrews says he was like one of his brothers Isaiah says he wasn't much to look at he wouldn't didn't have an attractive appearance

16:11

He was only around 30 But then like the the Pharisees were saying you're not 50 yet if they wanted to insult him better They would have said you're not 40 yet, right?

16:19

But he must have looked a little bit older than than he was and we were just guessing at some of these

16:25

Nuances as we read the text, but we don't know No, we do know some things that we want to try to accurately depict but we don't know exactly look like One question

16:36

I guess I have is in that vein Do we just as people as fallen creatures when we don't know something do we tend to just project on to?

16:47

What we think that thing actually is based on either our experiences or our desires of?

16:54

What we want that to be and that may be getting a little bit to the heart of the question Especially the racially accurate depiction part.

17:02

Yeah writers are told to write what you know, but the whole projection thing You know draw what you know where I see around me.

17:09

I'm gonna I'm gonna draw that I'm gonna depict that I'm gonna think that That's why we're that's why when we're dealing with this concern of racially accurate

17:19

Depictions of Jesus there's a whole background to those types of concerns and statements and it's hard to know what those concerns might be for some people they're going to be wanting to push to push back against what they see as the theological import of the white

17:37

Jesus and the black Jesus and the gay Jesus and so on and so forth for Others they're going to see some of those depictions

17:46

They're going to say Well, we shouldn't be engaging in any of that All of that is a breaking of the

17:53

Second Commandment and that's where the problem is guys And so I hear some of those concerns.

17:59

I Think that we can say that it's fine to strive for at least more realistic or accurate depictions of Jesus in our art forms while at the same time recognizing that those who

18:16

Would advocate for racial Jesus's are then in themselves those constructions are false and Intentionally so and should be rejected that can lead ultimately to Second Commandment violations if You keep on telling people

18:35

Somehow for some reason if you start telling people that Jesus was white European I don't remember everybody ever saying that I mean,

18:44

I you know, I haven't ever found anybody who teaches that but people do teach That Jesus and depict

18:50

Jesus as a black man And they say Jesus was black and they color him black and don't like and then they disciple people and say that he was black

18:57

Okay, but then behind that they fill in all the details about what that means that would be a violation of the

19:04

Second Commandment because the engraving here the carving here is the building up of Something that Jesus was not and Jesus is a

19:12

Jew Right. Jesus is a Jew. He was born of Mary. He grew up in Nazareth I mean we have the the details of his life so we don't have to fill that in So to the degree

19:23

I would say this to the degree that we are fast and loose with our depictions of Jesus That can be a problem if we are intentionally trying to disciple and instruct

19:33

Folks that Jesus was something that he was not Okay, I would agree at that level that you're getting into Second Commandment violations

19:42

So there was someone published an article a few years back that the

19:48

Jesus was on the the sexual Spectrum that he was struggling with his sexual identity

19:53

Right, and that he didn't know if he was a straight or gay or somewhere in between, you know

19:59

Well, what is that? What here's the? LGBTQ Jesus Right when you're doing that that is idolatry little children beware of Idols the

20:12

Apostle John says 1st John 5 21 and that's important for all of us to be aware of Do you have any other thoughts?

20:21

I think I would just say it comes down to your motivations If you're motivated by the truth, then you are going to want to have as accurate depiction

20:32

Ethnically racially of Jesus as you can but if your motivation is to appease a group of people who want to score a point and you capitulate to that You're doing more than just giving them a point

20:48

You're letting go of something very important So that's probably where I would I would leave that other than first of all

20:55

I'm thankful that I got this question ahead of time so I could prepare to keep up with you guys But one of the things that I thought about looking at this question art came up and I know you've already mentioned art several years

21:06

Ago, I was able to read with my dad and my brother Nancy Peercey's book saving Leonardo where she talks about art within the scope of human history

21:15

But particularly how it relates to our worldview and I couldn't remember For the life of me where she talked about or address this issue

21:24

But I know that she did so I was able to Find her on Twitter reached out to her on Twitter and she actually responded to how about that?

21:31

So she gave me the page number and everything, but it kind of relates to the Reformation I guess you could say within the context of history the whole idea of Iconoclasm where you have destruction of religious images.

21:44

Yes for a variety of reasons goes all the way back to the Byzantine period with Constantine and The people in the the 7th and 8th century back then but it resurfaces over and over again in Church history and one of the areas that it resurfaced again was during the

22:03

Reformation when you had the Reformers come in and Basically have a problem with the images that the

22:12

Catholic Church at the time Really didn't have a problem with and wanted to push as forms of art and she pointed me to page 80 86 in her book

22:23

Under the heading matter is spiritual, you know, just a few quotes from that It's been pretty interesting to read but she says one of the regrettable results of the

22:32

Protestant Reformation Was a surge in iconoclasm the smashing of statues and images

22:37

This had nothing to do with opposition to art per se but had everything to do with concerns over theology

22:43

In the visual arts the Reformers charged that imagery had slid into idolatry

22:49

Just as the brass serpent in ancient Israel had become an idol and we can see that in 2nd

22:55

Kings chapter 18 So the Reformers come in especially the Calvinist she says and they sought an austere uncluttered form of worship found and Focused on the word instead of the image or ritual to emphasize

23:09

God's transcendence they whitewashed over religious paintings on church walls leaving them plain and Unadorned so now you have this challenge to the

23:19

Catholics of the day with regard to imagery and They come back and they use the same defense that was used back in the

23:26

Byzantine era Saying that they had been successful then in their defense through the doctrine of the

23:33

Incarnation Which is kind of what we've been talking about here images were acceptable They argued because Christ is the image of the invisible

23:40

God seen in second it's seen in Colossians chapter 1 verse 15 Mm -hmm.

23:46

The word became flesh Therefore the material world has the dignity of being an avenue of divine presence

23:52

One historian explains God himself through Christ had taken on human form and thus revealed the earthly world to be capable of bearing the divine

24:01

It's with this justification the Christian use of images sought to lift the visible and earthly to the dignity of reflecting the invisible or Eternal so I found that quite fascinating to kind of read through and see, you know, there is a push -pull between you know these two completely you know diverging sects of the

24:24

Christian faith and I think we can kind of come to a point of agreement with them on this.

24:30

Am I wrong? Well, I'd say there is a point of agreement because what is said there I think is is fine.

24:36

It's just easily forwarded by Either, you know Greek Orthodox or Roman Catholics into because of the

24:43

Incarnation therefore we can venerate through statues It's not that much farther to go ahead and just push that forward and I think that people sense the danger of that and say

24:51

Okay, we're done with it all. Okay, but this is the same thing that we have time and again the the scriptures have tons of Warnings about wine, but wine never goes away.

25:02

So this is something where For example, if somebody got up and preached against wine and they would be unbiblical

25:11

Okay, if they got up and they asserted the warnings against wine and then said here's what it actually is supposed to be used for Biblically, then they would be correct in the same sense images

25:21

I mean how many times do we see in the scriptures? Warnings against the wrong use of imagery the wrong use of images.

25:27

Well, that's everywhere But then we also have passages that show what art is for and how it's good

25:33

So our tendency is when we sent something possibly dangerous Sometimes we we throw the whole thing away, right?

25:40

It's just completely away, but we are called to a level of maturity where we've got to grow up and use dangerous things

25:46

Right and then use them properly and use them rightly So I would say that there there is agreement and there has to be biblical qualification for for those assertions

25:58

Because it's as I said new people can kind of sense the danger in it Is this a moment to consider the weaker brother?

26:06

Well, I would say yeah, there's always the need to be considerate about those things so for example

26:15

You know here at our church. We don't have a Lot of imagery around what we have is probably not like You know overly intentional or anything we just This is just our church house that we gather at as a church family, you know

26:31

So we don't have a lot of imagery going on. I don't use Imagery as a rule.

26:37

I think I broke my rule one time, but I don't use imagery and when I preach I don't put anything up on the screen and there is a thought of the weaker brother in regards to that I've not watched the

26:49

Jesus film. I've not watched Mel Gibson's the passion I've not watched I've actually not watched the chosen

26:57

Series I saw the the Christmas one when they they came out like the what do you call it? The the first episode kind of like a pilot hit the pilot.

27:05

Yeah, I saw the pilot but I haven't watched the chosen I have watched the one I've watched the cartoon

27:11

Jesus he walks among us the voice of the martyrs the cartoon for the kids or whatever I like that one because they quote a lot of scripture in it

27:18

And I think it's great for kids and all that but I in general I just don't I don't watch I don't have a necessary Conviction about that, but it's not because I'm against images of Christ.

27:28

I just don't think anybody can really do it. Well Amen, I just think it's like everybody's failing at it

27:35

Miserably, but I I don't I don't worship the images in my head, but I do

27:43

Imagine what is it like for Jesus to talk with his disciples? What is it like when he's teaching?

27:49

What is it like when he gets angry and I am given Permission to imagine those things, but I'm not worshipping the images in my head

27:57

You see and this is where it's like I think just it's important to be

28:03

Just honest with where where we're at on those things. Yeah, so I think there's a opportunity to be careful about those who do have convictions, but Still there is

28:13

I love Rembrandt I'm a huge fan of a lot of really well -done art and I've got a lot of it on my computer that you know

28:21

Kind of cycles through All right. Well, thank you for that question What are you thankful for?

28:27

I'm thankful for answered prayer had a lot of struggles this last week week and a half and thankful for the

28:34

Lord answering prayers Not just and just thankful for the prayers of the the people of God our church family who prays for us

28:42

I'm thankful that he hears their prayers and our prayers. It's just a constant reminder of how

28:50

Dependent we are upon the Lord how we've got nothing and We just have to look to him for everything on a daily basis many times.

28:59

It's just a moment by moment basis So that's I'm just very thankful for that. I would say

29:05

I'm thankful for brothers sharpening each other Just to be in a body that cares about the truth cares about one another and Honestly just enjoys the company of each other and That we can sit down open the word together and just talk frankly about it ultimately yielding each of us

29:29

Individually to what the truth of Scripture says and if there's a question we can bring it up and talk it out

29:37

That's one of the beautiful things about the Christian faith when you ultimately have you know fellow believers who you can trust and Who at the end of the day you love?

29:50

Regardless of even if at the end of the day, there's still maybe a point of disagreement there You know that they love you.

29:59

You love them and you want the best for them. So I'm thankful for that You kind of see a little bit of that modeled in the

30:07

New Testament with the disciples asking questions, right? That's what disciples do. They they also ask questions of the master

30:14

We are so blessed to be able to ask questions of the master and we have his word With us not only that he has not left us orphans

30:23

I'm very thankful to God that through unity and faith the Holy Spirit's indwelling I we are not deficient in any way that Christ is fully satisfactory