Keep sharing good news without ads.
Andrew is joined by Pastor Claude Ramsey to talk about passing maturity onto the next generation of apologists.
That's all that we need only sufficient, but the only thing that couldn't be done for okay. So we don't need baptism then because it's the only thing. Is it is it the only thing or is it not. Do you need to be baptized or not?
Because if you need to be baptized, it's not sufficient. It is true that you are an extremely skilled debater and you're good.
This is apologetics live to answer your questions your host from the driving for eternity ministries.
We are barely live. Well, I'm almost alive but we are alive. So they welcome to apologetics live. I'm your host Andrew Rappaport. Don't bring in my co-host Mr. Drew of Anita. Howdy. Howdy. You're you're a dead man reader, right?
You're a dead guy reader. That's read the dead guys. Yes.
Yeah, it is. That is something I try to push everyone to do. Read the dead guys because they have so much to teach us. And we need to be taught.
You don't want them reading my books. I'm so sad, you know, I'd rather.
You want me dead I get it.
When you die, I will be promoting your books forever.
We're cracking up our guests backstage.
So.
I'm gonna give a little bit of a warning first off. I may take myself off camera go backstage at different times throughout the show tonight because well, I'm Struggling with a cold and I may need to just blow my nose and things like that at times.
And I'm not gonna have you guys have to watch or hear that so Don't be surprised. Yeah, I am a somewhat of a professional but.
You don't have a cough button. I.
Do I have a cough button, but I have to take the video out too. It's not just enough for the cough button.
Yeah. Yeah, we don't want to see you blow your nose. Yeah, you know, so.
But we do a couple things. You know when I'm wrong you guys know first first thing I want to do is correct when I'm wrong and I was wrong about Two weeks ago. We had there were during the show. We there was also a debate going on with James White and Layton flowers and I made a statement there.
I said that I made a prediction that Layton flowers would be very calm and it would give the Appearances if he was winning a debate because he was so calm and mellow. I.
Got that wrong. I'm sorry.
I got around to watching the debate and I Would admit I was surprised Layton was emotional. Even even on the verge of yelling.
It was.
Which is odd because the first time they debated he looked like he was just lost and he didn't know what to do. You know and so but now I didn't watch this one and I was going to watch it but the reason I didn't watch it and haven't watched it is because of watching how Layton acts on Twitter and Then all of his minions and I go I don't I don't want to watch it.
You know because at this point you're just showing me that dr. White is the bigger person and he most likely won the debate anyway.
Yeah, I think I think their first debate gave Layton a platform. Mm-hmm, right? There's second debate Was really about because I've heard I heard Layton is now leaving The seminary. I'm gonna be doing Soteriology one-on-one full-time.
So I Think that the second debate was just to rally the the truth. He I'll tell you this. He did a response video to the debate and I've always said false teaching pays because just in the super chats I calculated five six hundred dollars in super chats.
Just in one video. I was like I've had for a day's work, right?
Yeah for for two hours of rambling I mean Folks, you know those we have a super chat button that you have there. So look at this. I said I was gonna be said I was wrong about something and and Greg Moore says so you're becoming Presbyterian awesome.
No, I I said Greg that I was had to correct something that I was wrong about not right about. I mean Yeah, we should give a shout-out to Greg Moore. He his uh, he's got that podcast Tournament and it's it it has gotten a little bit out of hand.
I mean people down bribes. You know here here because because uh, you know apology a studios throughout bribes. I I actually said, okay. That's it. I wasn't sure who to vote for In that contest and I said, okay, that was it I was gonna vote against Apology, and then I find out that the other guys bribe people with.
Hey, we'll give you tickets to work our conference right now.
We were because because matter of theology was on their tree, right?
Greg is saying how do I do a super chat. Get on YouTube and you can do a super chat? Oh, yeah, he's on by the way super chats. We always respond to we always read those but matter of theology was in it, right?
Yeah, so so matter of theology we have yet to make it out of the first bracket into the second round. And so if I didn't know we could bribe people I would have done that. I would have been like I will buy 10 Puritan paperbacks and You know, I will give them away to random people who vote for us.
Well, okay. I Think that first off if matter of theology. Produced an episode this year. You might had a better shot. I'm just saying Okay. All right. So, um Greg Moore is saying I don't see it because you're on Facebook.
You have to go over to the YouTube.
There should there should be on YouTube. Yeah, super chat is a YouTube function. Yeah. Yeah.
So the other thing is last week we did a debate. And I want to address something that we we had in that debate. So I watched there they're literally a five hour response to us and to be fair wasn't completely five hours because.
Some of that was.
Um.
Some of that did involve You know, it was like I think three hours of response video to the debate and two hours. They got someone that came in that didn't know didn't understand, you know anything and and they were trying to Bring him over to their way of thinking.
So. It was. But you know, they did three hours response to a two-hour debate, let me see if I could. If I could provide a response in maybe five minutes maybe even less.
They accused us of. I think they accused both Matt slick and I.
Of.
Kind of mocking them or.
You know.
Not not being So so I Forgot I'm trying to remember the wording that they use but basically accuses of mocking. I challenge you to go look at it and see if if we were mocking. There were times that I think what they didn't like was that at one point I I said quite clearly that the fact that they were Misrepresenting our position the debate was over.
It was interesting because they they basically in their response video said that we did not address any of.
The.
We didn't address any of the You know the historical issues that they were bringing up and In my closing comments, I mentioned the fact that they failed to provide that the debate was on whether their view of The Trinity being one person one God was biblical not historical Biblical so they had to show that it's in the.
Bible.
Right, right. Yeah. Yeah, so so, I don't know what was the What was the title or the which is the thesis right? What is the. The title of it. Is it? Let's see if I could. The Trinity is biblical.
Well, yeah, I think it was. It was their view of Monarchianism is monarchianism biblical.
Was the yeah, so so so once you have that right the title that's. Then when you come into the actual discussion, right and you're doing your opening statements. That's where you're giving your thesis statement which is I'm going to show that monarchianism is in fact biblical beyond the shadow of a doubt or.
You your position you're in Matt's position. We are going to demonstrate beyond a shadow of a doubt that monarchianism is not biblical. Right, and so now you have your position and it's centered on the Bible.
Not history. Now you can use history, but. Ultimately, that's that's an irrelevant point because the point is is it biblical correct, which is what Matt and I focused on. So if you were to bring up a historical argument from someone in history, I'm not obligated to respond to it.
I'm obligated to respond to what? Biblical arguments you make or don't make.
Good correct, correct. So that's why I didn't bring up any I didn't address any other historical stuff. It was really interesting because they made a comment at the end, which I corrected, you know, we I couldn't do it in the.
Because it came up in the question when people were making questions, you know the audience questions. He made the comment that there was a textual variant in Matthew 28 19 and 20 that says that it doesn't say Baptizing in the name of the Father the Son of the Holy Spirit.
He said baptizing in my name he claimed there was a textual variant and I you instead of Promoting the the ministry I use that time to since I had no other time to correct it I figured that had to be corrected that I just didn't want to leave that standing and in there in their after show they They basically were mocking Matt and I because in in the after show that Matt did from the debate I Mentioned that I look through all my Greek apparatus and there is no textual variant in there other than the word.
Amen and so. What ended up happening was they They mocked that by saying because because on Matt goes and gets his Greek apparatus and he's looking and he goes. No, you're right there there is no textual variant there and so basically their argument against that was Well, of course, there's no textual variant in those it can be shown because all the publishers don't want you to know that.
That right there told me they're in the conspiracy land like the flat earthers because I hate to disappoint them, but The Greek New Testament that we when we do Greek apparatuses are based on all the Greek manuscripts.
Yeah, and there's not publishers for those things. There are copies of them that we find there. They weren't published. Publishers existed because of before the printing press existed by the way.
Yeah.
So the thing with doing textual criticism and this is the whole point of textual criticism is to get back to the original. What is authorial intent? What did the author write not what did a scribe several hundred years after the author wrote.
Think the author should have written. So when you look at those apparatuses. They're full of textual variants because that's the whole point of doing textual criticism. So that you can see the variants you can you can know what manuscripts they show up in.
What manuscripts? They don't show up in. So, you know a good range of when did this enter into the test? And then how to deal with it from there. That's the whole point of doing it. So for them to leave out a textual variant doesn't make any sense.
Yeah, and so. It was something where when I when I saw it like. These are like basic things. They were very mocking by the way of Matt and I. When they when they did do that, so I thought that was quite interesting to say the least.
There but the reality is They still did not understand it and they don't think that they're wrong in doing this. But they were forcing upon Matt and I a view of three gods. They got into a thing saying because I made a comment when they asked me a question about it and I said.
I'm not Mormon and.
They were saying that well, we're not saying, you know, there's a difference with Mormonism, you know Mormonism believes in three gods. That was the point. I was making that Mormonism believes in three gods.
I'm not Mormon. So what they tried to do in that in their post debate was to say Oh, look at all this other stuff that Mormonism holds to that's not what I was bringing up I was bringing up the fact that they say that we believe in three gods now if you're doing a debate.
If I was to characterize them as denying the deity of Christ, they would be upset with that. They would call it out. They would say that that's not what their position is and The debate would be over at that point but they didn't like when I did that because They're debating their view is biblical and instead of arguing for their view being biblical They argued that the Trinity was something that was made up.
It wasn't in the Bible. In fact, they they they wanted me to give them a verse From the Bible where I find that and I gave them the issues the issue is and I said this the Trinity is a Solution to a problem the problem that we see is you see God the Father God the Son God the Spirit all called God all doing the things only God could do all having attributes only God can have all having titles only God can have and Yet they're separate and distinct now in their view.
They want to say there's one King Monarchian ism the one monarch and they want to say that that's one person one God and Then when I bring out the distinctions and that's when I debate folks. You don't see me do as as you see them try to just throw everything in the kitchen sink at me.
I Just deal with a couple of passages. I don't want to deal with everything. Just focus in on a few passages that make the point that's why I focused on the baptism because the baptism was one where you see all three members and Yet they're distinct from one another now once they said that that distinction was manifestations.
That's the same thing. They're they're recognizing the distinction and.
That was what we were trying to point out is that there is one God yet. There is three persons that are distinct. And that was the whole point that I was trying to to make them they recognize that distinction it's like, okay well, there you go once you recognize that that's.
That was the the goal of it in and yet there's one God and I had to point out. We believe there's one God. I even take that into their after show to their post. I'm like you do believe that you do know Matt and I believe in one God.
I mean there the whole argument even in their in their after show was to say oh if you you know, if You know look at Deuteronomy 6 Andrews Jewish. He should know that's one. I said it was. You know, it was funny because he asked me a question when I mentioned I Mentioned about the holy holy holy and I said it was there for emphasis.
His first question to me was, you know, so I forgot and he admitted he was being cheeky. You know when he was like, well, you know as God, you know. Something they repeated three times. At that point like, uh, did you pay attention to what I said because I actually said During the debate.
I said it was you know there for emphasis so I almost and I I'm gonna give him a break on that because I think that We always have to realize in a debate. You're not saying everything you'd like to say.
You know, it's in the heat of the moment you're thinking you're trying, you know, it's you're jotting down notes. I mean Matt and I are both writing, you know constantly during the debate while they're talking.
So we're listening and writing to Do yeah, if you've never done a formal debate. It's it's not as easy as he as people think as they sit back and just watch.
If you if you want an exercise Listen to a debate and try to take notes from a debate from what everyone's saying. You won't be able to do it. Well, you will but I mean it's it's hard.
I mean you have to practice at it because the thing is you have to you have to listen and Take notes because you got to remember anything that you're saying. You say it's gonna come back in cross-examination or in questions.
So yeah, so what. So what I mean is you're not gonna be able to get everything right? So like in a debate You're you're listening you're taking notes as fast as you can as clear as you can as best as you can.
But and you're listening to what they're saying, but sometimes there's something that sticks out that you have to address. Because that one thing is the thing that characterizes everything else that they're saying.
So then you have to hit that but you only have so much time in order to do that. So like you're saying you can't hit everything or say everything that you would like to. So you almost have to pick and choose your timing and what you're saying and then how to condense that.
So it's really a Good exercise in getting your brain going and how to think on your feet.
Yeah, now I know we have our guests backstage before I bring them in. Amy is backstage and She was not able to come in last week because she doesn't have good reception. So she calls from her car. And so I want to bring her in first if we can.
So that before she has to drop off. Although she's not on camera. So I hope that she's still there. So let's bring her in.
She was.
Amy are you there? She was previously, but Amy are you there?
Yes, I have not been raptured today.
Well, that's good that that means that you're you're getting more of your theology from me rather than that slick guy that you called it.
I'm enjoying both the same amount.
Oh.
No, and I do definitely have competitions and it's usually about who can pay for dinner. You know, I mean next time you call into his program. Just ask him. Ask him how many times he's bought me dinner.
How many times I've bought him dinner? He'll love the question. Trust. Yeah, but his is.
I'm into April 2022. So so far. I've got Matt slick one and you just like numerous.
Only one. Yeah, it's still only one in me. Okay, we don't know the count. So for folks who don't know so Amy contacted us. She emailed the ministry. And I know that she's been binging old episodes of the rap report because she's been commenting on them and apologetics live and I forget how you you found out you found us I think through apologetics live and from there found Matt slick and started Following him as well.
And I know you've called his program a couple times. How did you find us again? I.
Don't I I really don't even remember how the whole thing started. It's just one of those. Because I had been listening to true crime that that's why I've been binging on like for like six weeks before I found you guys.
I.
Not tell you how I came across it and I was like It's been a whole new world and just like I don't want to waste too much of your time but my dad was like the cornerstone of Faith in our family, you know, he was the one that everybody went to and he passed away in 2018 and like finding you and Matt.
Has this been? Amazing. I've had so many questions Answered that I haven't felt I could like ask. Anybody and you know questions, I didn't even necessarily know I had but just listening to you guys has been truly a blessing.
So, do you have any questions for us tonight.
Okay. Well, is it topical?
Well, you can ask anything if it's really hard. We'll bring in our guest and make him answer them.
Honestly, what's been on my heart and mind lately is I'm in a family full of girls. I do have a brother but I have three sisters and then I've got 13 nieces and one nephew and One of my nieces just started her freshman year college and right before college she came out as a Practicing homosexuality and you know, I was I was raised in a Christian home and was taught that that was a sin.
I don't think we ever talked about it a whole lot like around her growing up. So, I don't I don't know but So this is a new territory for me. I love her to death, but I'm not sure how to like approach The topic of Sin and salvation and all of that with her right now.
Well, you could bring up the issue of sin and salvation and never bring up homosexuality. In fact what I would what I would say to do is to not bring it up because she will. Like that's so when I went when I go to the gay pride parades not that I I've been to a few of them.
I don't go for them. You know, I just the couple times I've been to them is because we already planned an outreach and It happened to be at the same time. So I've just I have not purposely gone to to them to do evangelism, but When I'm at those I never bring up the issue of homosexuality.
Because I don't have to I could bring up lying.
Stealing.
Coveting all of those things. But they will focus on homosexuality and I'll the the reason I do that is because I will ask them Why are you bringing that up? Because they know it's a sin against God. That's why they're bringing it up.
And so that's why I don't I let them bring it up so that I could show that their own conscience. Reveals that and one of the other things I'll ask people you are may already know the answer to this with with it.
You know your knees. I'll ask them what church they grew up in. Because 10 plus years ago 10 you know 10 15 years ago any hardcore atheist a Guy that was just coming out. Yeah, there is no God. I would say what church did you grow up in and Thousands of times I asked that only once did someone not grow up in church.
And and what it was was that the thing to show you're rebellious against Christianity and really your rebellious against your parents your church your upbringing. Was to go atheist now in the last 10 plus years, it's to go transgender or homosexual and then transgender and so.
Really what they're doing is they're trying to make this statement against the way they were they were raised within Christianity and That's why you see so many people that are in this very very active in that grew up in a church.
It's because they they grew up in a church where they weren't saved and they were trying to rebel against their upbringing and They they're showing their hatred for Christ by doing this and so it's it's actually very easy to bring it up if you if you Don't bring up the homosexuality with her right away because she'll bring it up but bring up sin lying stealing coveting.
You know, well looking with lust we'll we'll come up with with that. You know, so it'll be a thing that comes out that way does that help.
And if you want to break the tension you can always just impersonate Ray Comfort and just.
You gotta get the accent, right?
Yeah, I'll have to practice a little bit yeah.
See that he you just have to understand son drew. Ray gets away with things. I I told ray. Ray and I were out evangelizing once and we're at hunting a beach. I He gets done. Scotty was up then ray and then it was me.
And I'm sitting there like afterwards we go. We're driving back to Ray's house and I said Ray you you get away with things. I could never do one this lady before I.
Got up.
There was this woman that was not properly dressed. It's like you're at a beach. I get it, right but He gets up on the box because like Ray was sharing the gospel with someone and she claimed she was a Christian and didn't like The way Ray was evangelizing and so she got on the box because she wants to talk to Ray and Ray puts his hand out.
In front of her turns his head and it's like ma 'am. I can't look at you. You got to dress yourself first. Like if I said that I would be smacked. I'm like, how do you get away with it? He goes cuz I'm short and I talk properly.
So he knows the accent helps the height he's not that intimidating.
It works for him. I can't do that. I thought it was the button-up shirts and the khaki shorts with the pulled up socks. That whole look.
Well, um.
Amy would in I don't know if you'd feel comfortable, but if you want to give us her name we could pray for her. We have we have an audience. For folks who are in the chat that regularly. I mean, we have some real prayer warriors that people Usually raise prayer requests in the chat.
So and if you don't give her name, we know your name and she's your niece so we could do it that way.
Well, I'm nervous because there's only like ten people in the whole state. And if I give you even just her. Know her name is Gabby.
Okay, so folks be praying for for Gabby specifically be praying for Amy to have opportunities to share the gospel with Gabby.
So yeah, and if I can say Amy a Lot of times people avoid these situations because they know it's going to lead to an emotional response and it could lead to an argument and it could lead to Well, you just don't love me and you know a crazy argument like that.
And so people avoid it because they don't want to deal with that kind of confrontation. And so what you have to do is you have to be faithful to God's Word, right? So the best way that you can show that you actually love Gabby is to give her the gospel and to talk with her about these things because.
Because what a lot of people do is they don't talk whether they have a family member or anything. They won't address it. They won't talk to anyone. Well, nothing shows that I hate that person more and I desire them to go to hell than to keep silent about their sin.
Yeah, so so it's just one of those things you have to be faithful to what God's Word says. And trust the Holy Spirit to do the work and I'll also say that.
Because it can get emotional know that going into the conversation. So.
When you start that conversation know that She may want to avoid it may want to act act out or really lash out emotionally. When she does that just remind her how much you love her.
The fact that she's behaving this way Has nothing to do with how you love her and you could you could ask her about her upbringing because It usually is a direct tie to something. She with most of the people it's.
They didn't like what they considered legalism In their upbringing. They didn't like all the rules.
And.
This is their their way of rebelling and lashing out. And so you could ask her, you know, could that be? Ask it as a question, but you you don't want to get emotional with her either, right? Just tell her how much you love her.
Right, and I think that that is kind of a fear maybe I hadn't recognized until just now is that I will also get emotional in the sense that like Why did I wait for her to like come out to make Sharing the gospel with her an issue like just so much of them a long time ago, but that's kind of why I Preface all this by saying like my dad was that guy.
I didn't. You know when he lost and it kind of fell Fell part in a way and I uh never took on that responsibility for myself and I should have.
Well, this is the problem with our culture. It's very hard to keep.
The the kids I mean look.
Uh.
If the kids are on tiktok or anyone that's on tiktok, but you know I mean tiktok is purposely designed by the chinese government. To destroy america and and they're they're you know. In china, they're open about it.
You know, they're openly saying that it is a tool they use You know to corrupt the generation. So americans won't have. People that are inventing things and and stuff like that. So, uh that we won't have a good.
You know, uh.
Army and and things so. They know what they're doing. They're they're looking to. Uh destroy our culture. And so it's it's working.
But uh. So it's it's hard and I hope you see that, you know, if you if you see in the chat I know you were driving but if you see in the chat people are saying they're praying for you praying for gaby, so I hope you see that.
Do you have any other?
Go ahead.
Oh insane. I really appreciate it. I'm um, i'm actually at the truck stop right now. I don't want to even get on the highway till your show's done. So I'm gonna hang out hang out for a little bit.
All right, well I will i'm gonna put you backstage if you have questions that you want to come in. There is a private chat that you can just let us know and we'll bring it back in. Sound good.
Sounds great. All right.
So really, uh quickly before we bring the happy calvinist himself on.
I want to I I I do want to play one clip here and and Drew you have to let me know if I I think I found a way to get rid of the echo we used to have when I play clips. But I I just want to play this. This is from the remnant radio.
Um, this is on them responding to the calvinist uh calvinist documentary. Because people say that it's me dodging. I just want to put this on the record. Let's play this so we have this Recorded. This is what they said.
You know, we want to. Michael you said this already and i'm gonna just repeat this we want to appeal to Um less the maker of the film and other people that were in it as brothers. I think what has grieved me about the film uh is.
How.
How quickly the accusations of False teacher false prophet and charlatan get thrown out by people in that video and I actually think that is divisive. Um. They don't mention cardinal doctrines that that any of us who are continuationists have denied.
What they mostly do is is talk about prophecies that aren't fulfilled and therefore people are false prophets. And so again, I I think. My hope is that we can have a civil conversation eventually with some of these people.
I think the hardest part for me and a lot of this is we've tried to have conversations with guys like justin peters. Uh, we've tried to to Dialogue on some level and we've had a few that that are willing to show up on the scene like coasty hinn And tom schreiner, but the others that they won't come on the show and part of that reason is Um is they actually think that we're dangerous and I I think unfortunately we're going to say the same.
We actually think cessationism is dangerous and we have a number of reasons for why that's the case. But we'll that will probably be at the conclusion of whatever this series comes to.
Just for the record. I want to you know, make sure this is is clear here. They said that they're. They're frustrated because they're trying to get people on to have a discussion. So for the people who say i'm dodging the remnant radio i'm right here.
You want to have the discussion? Let's have it. You want to have a debate? Let's Have it. I'm not dodging. I'm not afraid of the discussion. But not only not only the head one debate. I said here I am.
He said sure. We're trying to get that together for october. I'm, not afraid. I'm, not dodging. I'm right here. Waiting. We've tried, you know, we've had several people that said oh, I know these guys i'll get you in touch with them.
I have not heard boo. No one has contacted me from there. I've tried to contact them through their youtube the email they have there. But for for the constant thing of saying, well, we're trying we're trying but no one's willing to um.
You know, they admit that they call us dangerous. And then say that they're really upset that people call them dangerous. Okay, yeah, no, but let's be really clear. I'm, not afraid to have the discussion.
If you want to actually have an honest discussion Let's have it. But i'll call you out if you use logical fouls, you know, logical fallacies are invalid arguments. Maybe that's what they're afraid. Yeah, so.
So the thing that gets me is the accusation of That they just throw out Uh people in our camp. They just throw out. Um. False teacher how easy it is to to throw that that title out. It's actually not Right.
No one no one that I would say, you know, or I know throws out the term heretic. Just on a whim without thinking about it. So it's because people Like us we actually take the time we listen to more than one sermon of what some of these people are saying.
We listen to their interviews. We see what they're doing. We see what they're teaching and then once we have Uh done our research. Then we make the conclusion according to what scripture says. But he throws out this thing.
We've tried to have justin peters on to talk about these things. Okay, justin peters did the conversation with sam storms and michael brown. I don't think he needs to have the conversation with you because he had.
The conversation with people who are the leader who I guess could be considered leaders or heavy hitters of the charismatic movement. So, what does it benefit justin to go on remnant radio. Anyway, it really doesn't.
Well.
I I would I would say that it it could benefit in the in furthering the discussion to show the issues.
The issue they had with sam storms and michael brown was over the fact that those two are they're kind of more of the the intellectual side of the charismatic movement.
Look when we we at least you would think until you watch the discussion and you go. How'd you come up with that? Okay, you're you're talking about martin luther 500 years ago, but you're completely oblivious to kenneth copeland today.
What's wrong with you?
Yeah, and I guess the one thing um that I would say with that is they were appealing to the fact that Justin is the one that's done all this research. Okay, then. Why why are you not listening to justin?
Right.
I I just want to point out that you know, because I i'm still getting comments from people saying i'm dodging these guys. Because they're putting out challenges. I'm not dodging and the thing I keep saying is why don't you ask them why they're dodging me?
Because look anyone can come in any week and ask any questions on this program. You could come in you want to have a debate on that topic. Come on in you're prepared for a debate. I'm not. You have the advantage.
I'm not afraid. That's the advantage of having the truth on your side. I'll just go to scripture. And read it, you know.
So yeah, so andrew I sent I text you a picture. Did you get it? Oh, yeah, I got that. Okay, so so because humble clay Made this post I want I want you to share that picture. Let me see if I can I might have to save it.
So because humble clay he said peters and osmond versus brown and storms. Peters and osmond destroyed Their opponents and it was a long conversation and sometimes it was tough to get through. I text justin afterwards.
And after I watched it and I said that was really tough to get through just listening to sam storms And uh and michael brown because they just almost refused to hear What jim and justin were saying. But I made this meme?
After listening to it and I sent it to justin because it was right because I knew it was right up justin's alley. And it's it's exactly what I thought about. And he had a good laugh. I actually posted it on twitter.
Um, so I don't know.
I I have to pull it. Yeah. Yeah, what I got to do is I have to save it as a picture. Uh, let me let me maybe I could just pull it into A word document really quick. See the the issue is that I don't want to.
To show it i'd have to show all of the people i've been texting. So for privacy reasons, I don't want that up on screen. So give me a good moment, that's one thing we're sharing from. From there. So but now that I have it in a word document I just need to make it a little bit bigger.
This is what happens on live Shows here folks is that you get to hear me talk through what i'm doing so that you go. That's really boring if he's just getting no Saying nothing at all. So here we go. So this is what you you did and you'll have to explain this.
Yeah, so so I made this meme and on the top is jim and justin on the bottom is sam storms and michael brown. And over them I gave a name right? So jim is luke. And justin is beau. Sam is coy. And michael is vance.
Now this comes from the dukes of hazard if you grew up watching the dukes of hazard. And this and justin grew up watching dukes of hazard loves dukes of hazard. He and I have had conversations about the dukes of hazard.
Luke and beau. Are the real dukes? They're the real deal.
Now.
At some point they decided The producers to do away with luke and beau and bring in their cousins coy and vance and it was the worst absolute uh failure in tv history. Okay, not just dukes of hazard history, but tv history.
And so every time.
I at least picked the the luke and beau. I had no idea who the. That when you sent this to me. I'm like who is coy and vance?
So, yeah, so but and and so just so when I sent it to justin he had a good laugh. And he said but I really think jim should have been beau and I should have been luke. And I said well I I said that's originally how I had it.
But if you watch the show, you know Beau is the one who mostly drives the general lee and luke is the passenger. And justin is the one who's done all the research and he's basically driving that general lee of the argument.
And jim is along for the ride.
Helping out. So the question is Do I send this to michael brown and ask his thoughts?
But he.
He might look at he might look at it the same way I did and go. Uh, yeah, I don't get the context but he. He might but I'll have to ask him if he watches the show. All right. Let's uh, let's I. We have some comments that were coming in.
But before we do we should bring our guest in. Who we should do it right away. I'm shaving his beard or brushing his beard there, you know, look at that. This is claude ramsey for folks who don't know and I should take our banner off so everyone can see what he calls himself.
The happy.
Calvinist is what he calls himself the happy calvinist Claude. Welcome to the program.
Thank you. You could just put me backstage. I'm enjoying listening to you all.
You were I was watching wisdom.
So claude you and I is that now is that theological wisdom or dukes of hazard wisdom because we have.
All of it all of it together. I was getting that when I saw that when I saw that meme. I got it right off the bat. I remember that. Because i'm an old dude. So I remember the dukes of hazard cards like baseball cards and on the back of them They had Pieces of a puzzle, which was the generally jumping something.
You had to get all the cards and put them together. Yeah.
Okay, I didn't know they had that. And and you know, are you just rubbing it in again the fact. So so we go to this. This conference is the open air theology conference. And andrew you have to understand in every room I think I looked like the young guy.
And in every room I was the oldest one. It was so depressing.
That's crazy because i've been in rooms with you, you know, and I know i'm the young guy. So and I looked up.
We had one guy that i'm like he's got to be older than me all white hair white beard. He's like i'm 36 37. I was like no and everyone's like yeah, i'm like.
Ah.
I think I walked up on that conversation. Didn't I outside the auditorium doors? Yeah the entranceway. Kt wants to know if you're amish.
So you and I met at the open air theology conference last year. Yes, sir and uh after last year. Hearing you preach for the first time there was one thing that I wanted to make sure in this year's conference.
And when I looked at the agenda and I said this In my if anyone heard my my talk there. I said there was just one thing when I looked I just said I was so glad that I was before Claude ramsey and not right after Claude ramsey because if you haven't heard claude preach before.
Um, he's one of the more passionate preachers and I really did not want to follow him. Because after he gets done preaching it's like. Yeah, okay. Here's the boring talk now and hence, you know. We had keith get up and he's talking about the different styles of everyone and and he's you know.
What do you say about andrew after listening to claude? He's very professional professorial, you know like a professor.
That's professorial, yeah. Like okay. Thanks. I don't even know that word. That's a big word.
So so you were talking so we're at the calvinist conference. Why calvinism was the topic this year and and your topic was.
Why calvinism matters?
So why does it matter?
Well, as I mentioned in the yes in the sermon in the address.
Number one because it is a sound systematic theology that can be held to. Looked at so it's very very important.
Yeah, I would agree. I think that um I think that we did a really good job. I mean the way jeff really laid it out. That's why I drew earlier. Yeah, I mean just it really he wanted to tell a story.
You know, it was funny because you know. You know last year he he put me last because you he you when you do a conference. You either you're going to put speakers that you want either going to hold people there or get people there first first and last.
Usually tells you like who you want to to hold the crowd or who you want to get the crowd to get early and so. Last year, I was one. I was I think I might have been the last speaker before the q a or one of the last.
And then.
Um, which I you know, it's always hard because you have to. You're still i'm like, I don't know about you, but i'm always prepping until I preach it. So I'm still like thinking about what i'm gonna say still working on it.
We kind of had kevin. Haye did the same thing. We're gonna make sure kevin Haye goes right because we we shared uh airbnb with with kevin and a bunch of other guys. And kevin was just working on his message every.
I don't know how he was doing it. Because every night we're sitting there and arguing over theology and he's at the dining room table in the next room just working away. We're like, you know every once in a while i'm yelling kevin.
What do you think about this? He's like i'm studying. So I was glad to go first. It was great I went for but the reason he had me first is because I did the history of calvinism kind of lay out. Really?
Okay. This is where how we've gotten to where we are today. So, you know with a topic of why calvinism your topic was extremely important because. Hey, this is why it's important you know, then we got into the calvinism luther and and lots of other things and and jeff.
You know wrapped it up.
You know trying to make sure layton heard his message to know that Layton's wrong, but. But it was. It was a lot of fun.
I I it really was and that was mentioned in the drew earlier in the uh, the the comrade the fellowship In in the gospel and that's and that's what's key. I think too that everybody was probably expecting, you know us for us to have pictures of calvin up on the on the stage and Bowing and asking people to ask calvin into their heart, but it was just solid biblical gospel messages one right after the other.
There was nobody that could leave there having listened to those sermons and said this was about calvin. No, it was about christ jesus the lord.
Yeah, um. Though you would say that Reality is I think people weren't listening.
Yeah, you had someone didn't you andrew that that said something about worshiping calvin?
Yeah, I did. Um, and and even though it was in my message We know that we don't worship cat. We don't find the the reality is. And this was the whole point of the message is. What we call calvinism? Didn't originate with calvin.
That's right. I mean I tried to show look it didn't originate with luther. It didn't originate with augustine. It didn't originate with paul it originated with god. Right, we got it. God gave it in the bible.
We have this. From you know, yes paul wrote a lot where we where we gleaned from but not it's not just with paul. But historically everyone's like oh you got it from calvin you worship calvin and yet calvin was dead.
Before the five points of calvinists of calvinism existed. You know, it's like. You know, by the way arminius was dead. By the time of the remonstrance and the five points of the remonstrance that the five points of calvinism You know responded to by the way.
You know for those who heard my my talk I I threw a fun thing out there if you're able to say i'm so calvinist i'd be a six point calvinist if there was six points and. Just for our friend. Greg moore.
Who's a presbyterian? I I had no when doing the study. I realized that the original response to. For folks who don't know so that the the followers of arminius. Uh were known as the remonstrance. They they came up with the five articles of the remonstrance and originally.
The the the followers of bisa. Who is a follower of calvin? Um. But so arminius was also a follower of calvin. So but the followers of bisa ended up having eight points in response to the five points of the remonstrance.
And one had to do with children being saved through the covenant. So I was I was when I threw that out there for greg and he wasn't in the room at the time I was like, oh he's here. He could he's got his one chance.
But he wasn't trying to help out a presby and they're never around. Yeah. Yeah.
Tried to throw him a bone. He wasn't there. But but yeah, I mean both calvin and arminian were dead at the time that the That the what we call the five points of arminianism and the five points of calvinism really started and.
The five points The of the the five articles of the remonstrance are not what's held to today like the latent flowers Would not hold to the five points of the remonstrance specifically total depravity because they they they would hold to a biblical view of total depravity and that's why I ended up talking about the the calvinism of Jacob arminius, which you know we we have a private chat with all the speakers and.
When I gave my outline a bunch of guys were like, what are you going to say for that? I want to hear that point but. And you know, that's the thing people don't realize is arminius thought he was a calvinist.
And and there's a lot of points especially early on he agreed with calvin. But then he kind of went astray but nowhere near as far as his followers went. I mean. You know and so that's that's actually why.
After the response to the remonstrance all of those arminian pastors Were considered heretics and thrown out of the church because of what it naturally leads to right open theism and so. So all of them were kicked out of the church and you can also you can actually see the history of this In the calvinist documentary.
So so jody says asking calvin into your heart now, that's hilarious. But we hear this. I mean, you know. You know, I mean I had I had someone tell me.
That you know.
I was worshiping calvin and i'm like.
I read calvin. But nowhere near as much as I read many other people.
Mm-hmm.
Yeah, most and that's a thing like most. People who are reformed in their theology who would call themselves calvinists. They don't spend their time reading calvin. They may own the institutes and they may glance at them once in a while, but they don't own the complete works of calvin.
They most likely won't even glance at them. Because we have other resources namely scripture that we actually get these doctrines from. We don't we actually don't need calvin. If if calvin didn't exist.
It just would have been somebody else who systematized it and that's only that's the only reason why it's called calvinism because he systematized it. And it just would have been somebody else. And but the doctrine would have still been the same that originated with god like andrew says.
Amen.
And and that's the thing we have to recognize that Calvin, I mean he systematized a lot of it but not in the form that we look at it today. What people call calvinism today? Did not exist in calvin's time.
Right, so.
One of the things that's even that's very interesting is people think calvinism only deals with predestination and election. They don't understand.
That.
The totality of reformed theology deals with the entire council of god all of sola scriptura. And and they wouldn't even know that calvin only wrote a little bit. Compared to all of his other writings.
He only wrote a little bit on predestination and election. He wrote of a great deal on prayer. He wrote a lot about the holy spirit. He wrote a lot about just scripture in general and the church. But he only gets labeled as this one thing predestination and election and it goes so far beyond that.
Correct.
So, um. Yeah, I I will admit it is always so distracting with it with the chat. Um, amy amy who's been binging different episodes of rap report of and and this show. And uh, I I didn't start so I don't see where it is, but she was referring to my.
You know, I always say i'm Reportion. My last name is rap report and so kt said. My initials are arr. So she says it's aurism. And so we'll see that rolls off the tongue better.
Oh my.
Well, they have the pirate translation of the bible. You could use that that could be here. That could be your official translation the r the r translation.
So so.
I wanted to have you on to you know. We could keep talking about the conference if you want because I your your talk was was great. Um, I did want to have you on because I wanted to talk about something that you and I are involved in.
Which is passing the torch. You just got done teaching a class on that and I wanted to. I wanted to you know talk about what. What haps is trying to do with that. Um, I wasn't sure when he contacted me.
I I kind of thought it was a compliment and then I realized maybe not because he called me up and said Hey, you know, we see a lot of young guys that just need some discipleship in apologetics.
Could really use some guys from you know, the old guys. You you old mature guys. I went. Okay, wait. First I thought this was going to be really complimentary. But then I realized wait, you just called me old like so the value I offer is that i'm old.
Okay. But it's the idea that he wants to get so you know, and i'll be honest I think in in the age of social media. When I started out we didn't have social media.
Apologetics, I do believe has changed With The advent of of social media Jason cave saying old old equals wise yet not always. Jason, if you if you want you want remember this is andrew we're talking about here.
Well, no, no you because he just made a blanket statement old equals wise I can disprove that in one name joe biden.
Okay, moving on.
What he wanted to do is to um to develop something where. You know, we could have some of the older guys have who've matured in the faith. Um, I I forget the the passage I think there's a passage that paul has maybe in ephesians and then john writes talks about kind of three stages of.
Of us, you know, he's young men. As fathers as older men and kind of pointing a picture that like when we're young we first get saved. It's just like Oh, like I just want to I want to read everything from the bible and you have that excitement.
And then you get to that stage as the you know, where you just want to attack falsehood. You want to attack the devil? And then you get to that older stage where you're just loving the lord, you know, I think and there's something to be said about that and I think.
It is helpful to have guys who have gone before us. Who have are at that stage where they've mellowed out and they're not the cage stage. Taking younger guys under the wing. And and that's really what haps is trying to do with this.
And so you you taught your the the course.
I guess that makes you an old guy as well. Congratulations. You have some white in that beard of yours. I Don't have any white showing in my beard. I'll have you know.
See now I need to grow mine out because mine does have some gray in there. So I I should have grown it out. So haps could have seen that and i'm gonna be like look see i'm old too.
This is why I keep mine nice and short, right? There was a question in the q a at the conference about the beards. Right, and I was really quick to say I keep a very nice short beard. I have a beard. It's just shorter than yours.
That's all.
A lot of a lot of ladies shave so.
Yeah, it's just it's just a negative beard right. It's in the minuses it just throws you backwards man statement.
Okay, so what do you Comment so so. Talk about what your experience with passing a torch what you're looking to. Give into that get out of that what your thoughts are about the the whole school that that haps is trying to run here.
Obviously, this is a fantastic idea and that is exactly you know, how he presented it to all the folks. He's asking to teach um, I know there may be some younger guys teaching too, but the point is that with the advent of the uh, accessibility of the interwebs um, there's a.
Everybody wants to be like r .c. Sproul said a theologian, right? However. There there must be wisdom. There must be or there must be knowledge, of course. But there must be wisdom in the application of the knowledge.
And just because we know something doesn't mean we have to say something at all times. Like what you mentioned earlier to amy, right? Uh, you don't even have to bring up homosexuality. The fact that you're presenting the gospel and sin is brought forth, right?
It it's self identity. Sin is self-identifying really and truly it is but in that the point was to to gather these these men and to uh to just One, you know as far as the interwebs go One-on-one communicate with these men and pour into these men number one the scripture, but number two is the love because We're called in the word of god To do good to all men, but to especially them that are of the household of faith.
What we don't need to see. I'm sorry, but what we don't need to see.
When I say the passionate preacher he can't even have a conversation without. Getting emotional and having some of that passion come out. Well.
What we don't need to see is a bunch of men. Who have their head full of knowledge? But they ain't saved. And they're teaching dead orthodoxy. And the goal is not to not to teach dead orthodoxy nor is it to teach experience over knowledge but to balance the two.
Like riding a bicycle. It's the plainest simplest illustration of all but listen if you lean too far right. On a bicycle you're gonna fall over. If you lean too far left. You're gonna fall over. If you stop pedaling you're gonna fall over.
And the beautiful thing about being Gospel being and again, this is focused and aimed really truly our class was at men who felt like they are called to be preachers. And I stressed to the men in which this was a fantastic group of men that we had.
But I stressed to them the importance of not just wanting to be a street preacher. Right because that's kind of the thing. That's a popular thing and it's good thing. It's wonderful. It's needed. However, when we're talking about being called to preach we're talking about the local church where the local church congregation Is actually getting fed the word of god.
They're not getting fed microwave meals, but they've got. Uh, they've got elders. They've got pastors who are actually laboring in the word number one because they're saved number two because they love god because they're saved and number three because they love the people that they're preaching to.
Very very important there. So that that was the aim and the goal is to communicate those things to those men.
Yeah, no, you I don't know if you wanted to Go through it, you know, I know you had your slides here. So I don't know if you want to go through that. We do I do. We do have a couple questions that came up earlier.
We could before we get to your slides, maybe we should bring some. So this is a lengthier question. I don't know who Who asked this because it says facebook user which is usually haps but hold on andrew.
Can I get real quick because it brought this. What claude was just saying brought this to my mind and it's. It's a command from paul in second timothy chapter four and it begins in verse one where he says.
I solemnly charge you in the presence of god and of christ jesus Who is to judge the living and the dead by his appearing in his kingdom? And then he goes into the command is to preach the word. But why do you preach the word?
Because you are in the presence of god and you are in the presence of christ. Therefore how you preach the word matters. And then the character of the man which paul addresses in First timothy. Yes matters.
That's why he gives characters and then one skill to teach but everything else is a Characteristic trait a man you must have and if you don't have that.
Get out of the pulpit. Amen.
You have such strong views.
I'm, so controversial.
All right, so this is back I think from from the conference. So, uh, you know.
Someone we're talking about the conference. So i'm sorry to cover claude up there with the question. It's just facebook users said who is kevin thompson? He's got layton with him nodding in approval to this.
Here's. Here's what kevin said to uh to layton like three weeks ago. Quote. If you're elect You're saved regardless of whether christ died. And if you're not elect, you're not saved regardless of whether or not christ died.
So that seems to be the only piece of information that would actually constitute good news for a person and that is Never listed as good news in scripture. So I see a mismatch what the bible calls the and then it got cut off.
Who is kevin thompson? Uh, do you know? I mean, I only know the reaction we had at the conference where he was kind of, you know, he was recording the.
Debate when he wasn't supposed to be. Um, was that who that was? Yeah, that's who that was and uh, you know, he put it up on on social media when he wasn't supposed to and.
But I I never i've never met him. I didn't know anything about him. Do you know anything about him?
Not right off the top of my head, okay.
So, sorry. Facebook user we we. Your your quote was too long. So we didn't get the whole thing so, um. But uh, matt is saying thank you for addressing the comment by kevin thompson. The guy kevin is wild.
Okay.
Don't.
Don't know. Uh, and if amy's still listening if she had she had a question backstage. I was just going to bring her in but she dropped out. So if she comes back in we'll. Uh, we'll let her come in and ask it.
So melissa asked this. Humbly. I could not believe how condescending sam storms was not to mention that justin. Kept getting cut off mid-sentence by both of them. That is something that uh Was. Yeah, I don't know.
He was being justin was definitely being cut off a bunch in that discussion. Where discussion we're talking about is the discussion of justin peters jim osmond with uh I almost said latent flowers. Uh, although they do have the same view it but uh, michael brown and and sam storms.
Uh so.
One one thing that is different when you have a discussion versus a.
A debate.
A discussion is more free flow flowing. Sorry free flowing and I will I will give kind of a. You know, maybe uh an excuse for michael brown. Because being jewish michael being jewish myself being jewish.
I understand how jewish people argue and so.
It.
There are times where it's hey, let me just jump in for clarification. Jump in for clarification and Justin is kind of a good old southern boy. So he's you know, he's more polite and so. Yeah, um, they were cutting him off quite a bit um, and so it it did make it where I think if I think if there had been A moderator to to just to allow people to have the time To finish a thought that would have been better and you could still have the discussion.
They wanted it. They didn't want it as a debate.
Um, okay. I see amy back in. Don't let me bring her up and she could ask so amy. Are you there again? Maybe she's not. She's muted. Okay, we'll leave her up and amy just unmute yourself and pop in when whenever you want and to ask your question and if not, i'll just read your question, but.
Uh put this one up. Melissa asks to drew. I enjoy the short videos that you've been posting on facebook. Very edifying brother. Wait, you must have You you starred this one so that I would read it. Wow.
Okay. Hey your arm hurt.
I took a page out of andrew's playbook is what I did. Oh, is that what I do? Okay.
They are encouraging. I've been watching.
There's.
Sermons. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So some of them are very good. So so most of the time whenever i'm asked to preach it's not recorded or if it is recorded it's very bad quality. So the ones that are I try to get them cut up into little short snippets that might encourage people.
And then there's ones uh from a lecture series that I gave on uh, It's called the foundations of expository preaching and what's funny is Claude what you were talking about what you were teaching the very first lecture Is about are you called to preach and it goes through the characteristics of are you called to preach and I think I did that Three years ago when I when I first gave that uh that lecture series.
And then I have and then I have people randomly that ask me questions and i'll try to make short videos to answer their questions.
So, why don't you make short clips out of this show here.
Would you like me to do that? I can do that. Sure I can do that for you because on my tiktok I do have ones where uh, the one where just chris helped me, uh. Host and it was me chris and justin. So I have some clips of that but i'll i'll get some from this from this episode.
So kevin shaffer has a question here. What do you think about someone who is attending the church? And started their own bible study without any communication with the leadership.
Hmm.
Uh, i'll go first and i'll let you guys jump in on this. Uh, I would have a lot of questions for you kevin first. Who's involved in the bible study is going to be the first thing? If if the bible study is made up mostly of people from the church.
Then I would have a real issue that they didn't go through leadership. Okay, if you're if you're looking to have a bible study with the church the church you attend. And not have it as part of the church.
I would have concern with it now. Let me just say. A lot of people think well, I just started bible study. What's the big deal? It's from a pastoral perspective. And and a lot of people sitting in the pews don't Understand what goes through pastor's mind and what pastors have to deal with.
Because a lot of things pastors deal with. They keep within the leadership. All right. They don't go sharing when there's problems in the church and so. There's a lot of times that you have people who start a a bible study.
And then the bible study becomes a real problem for the church. It's the a lot of times it's the first step of a church split. Someone that gathers people for a bible study. They start talking bad about the leadership.
Something they don't like and then that's the cause of a split and so for that reason. If if they're doing it without the leadership's knowledge If they're doing it purposely. That's a real problem.
Because if they're trying to you know, if if I as a pastor Have someone that's doing a bible study in the church and they don't want it as part of the church But they're inviting the church I'm instantly i'm gonna have red flags.
And i'm gonna i'm gonna. You know as a pastor, I would put a stop to that. Um, and i've i've had other pastors do the same thing and i've counseled other pastors to do that if they're purposely not wanting it to Be a church function or under church leadership.
But they do want to.
Have it with church people. That's concerning.
Uh, if it's just a bible study with. You know, like I know people i've gone to church with people that had a bible study in their old church. And they came to our church and they still do that bible study and some of the people from our church attended the bible study.
And it's not it's not a church specific thing. Uh, I think it's okay to do that. I still would argue that You you do that through your pastor. Your pastor should know about it. So I attend the church.
My pastor knows that I do this show every thursday night. He's aware of it. Uh, he's aware and and prays for you know, like we'd have debates or different topics that come up. He'll be praying for that.
Because i'm accountable to him.
Now have I been doing this show longer than i've been to that church? Yeah. Do I have to do that? No, I don't have to do that. Um, but it is a way of showing the respect to the pastor. If you've been listening to my rap report podcast and rap reports rap report.
Just search rap report rap with two p's.
I've been going through a series on what is a pastor. Uh, we got two more episodes left at least I think.
That is dealing with One i'm going to deal with how to encourage your pastor. Do you know how encouraging it is to for your pastor to let him know? That you're going out of town for a week or two. So he doesn't wonder where you are.
People don't think about that. So when all of a sudden there's a bible study that starts happening uh a pastor hears about it. And usually hears about it because something was said in the bible study that someone else comes to the pastor and brings up.
And it's like hey. Uh, what do you think about this pastor? He's like wait this study's going on and and who's teaching it.
A lot of times it's when that happens. It's someone that the that the person knows the pastor would not let him teach. But he wants to teach. And that becomes a problem. Because the pastor may have a reason for that person not teaching and that person because often what you have is people who are looking to pray on the church and they come in they I mean i've seen this as as a pastor and as a Just a church member.
People that come in the church and they're they just look for they want to gather a following within a church and so if you have someone doing a bible study without communicating it to leadership or Their with their blessing i'd be concerned in fact and and drew you you know this because you filled out our paperwork.
Uh to be part of the christian podcast community. One of the questions we want to know is who's your pastor? Right, we we want to know is your pastor. We have a question. Does your pastor know you're doing this podcast and we've had people go my pastor doesn't know that.
Well go talk to him first.
We want to make sure people are doing a podcast that's not a church bible study but you know, we want to make sure that your pastor's aware of it and You know is saying we we bless this so i'll throw this out claudette.
I don't know if you you're a pastor. What would be your thoughts?
Well, that would be looking at the question. Um, so number one. They are they attending the church or are they members are just attending or are they members of the church? Because it goes back to what you said.
They're just looking to draw a following uh, and then as being a church member, they should be have been made aware before they join the church that.
The standards of the church, right? Basically, uh. Not just the confessional statements of the church. But the constitution of the church the makeup of the church the government of the church how how things are set up.
Who is allowed to teach who is not allowed to teach biblically so on and so forth? So that would be one of the questions I would ask. The individual. Are they are they members or are they just attenders of the church?
And then. Um, if they're starting their own bible study, is there a reason why maybe they've started that bible study? Maybe they've got questions or concerns not and again not going straight to the negative.
But maybe they genuinely have questions and concerns that they're trying to answer on their own without spiritual uh wisdom and leadership from the elders of the church.
Yeah, so I mean instantly my first thought in reading that question was if they're not communicating with the leadership. That's a problem. Whether so if you're going to do it. Uh with people in the church.
You must go through church leadership if you're doing your own outside of the church. You must go through church leadership if you're a member of that church now. I saw it where I was a member of a church.
They asked a guy who had uh, Yeah, he has he and his wife. They were doing worship at the church. But they also had four teenage children and they asked him to do a lead a bible study a home group. And they didn't want to do it.
But instead what they did without anyone at the church knowing it was they started a home group, but it was for teens. And so they started pulling some of the kids from the youth group, right? And so but what does he want to do?
He doesn't want to have that church oversight in what he's doing. So red flag. Right, but I mean you guys hit on all the major points. I don't really have much to add to it. Um, are they are they qualified to teach.
This person they may not be an elder. But do they at least meet the qualifications of an elder to where we can trust them to be to lead a bible study? Something like a bible study. Um. Yeah, I think you guys hit on all the major points.
Well, you know.
Excuse me, you know the the thing is is that What we we have to have in in things like this Is is really You know something like what I had this morning a nice cup of integrity That I got from my squirrelly coat joe's coffee.
It was good. I had some it was it's it's a cashew honey molasses milk chocolate flavoring and it was great. I had a great cup of integrity this morning.
You know, I I. It's just something you have to have in and so.
Now you.
Claude you enjoyed the coffee that we had there at the conference, right?
Well, i'm not a coffee drinker. I'm not tough enough to drink coffee. I did give that bag of squirrelly joe's coffee away at our 1689 study which we have on sunday nights. I usually get bonus points for folks answering questions, but but I actually gave a real prize.
So, yeah, yeah, this is this is good. You know good coffee and and yet you're supporting a christian so, uh. A family-run business, so that's good. But you know, I do have a question, you know.
Maybe you guys can help me out. You know, if you guys want to get folks if you want to get yourself a good cup of coffee go to striving fraternity dot org slash coffee to order your.
Your.
Coffee from squirrelly joe's and if you use the promo code sfe you get 20 off on your first purchase. So what you do is you go in?
The way it is is that when you go to you fill out the your order at the checkout. There's a little thing at the top to click on to open up the box to put in Your promo code of sfe that lets them know that you you heard about it here.
So that he will keep supporting the show. So please go get lots of coffee. You get a good night of sleep with your my pillow using the promo code sfe at mypillow .com. But when you wake up in the morning, you might need to get a good Wake up, I would say good to a good cold plunge.
It lasts longer than coffee.
But.
Uh about 90 minutes after you wake up having a little caffeine is good get yourself some good Squirrelly joe's coffee, but you know, I I see a problem. And and folks in the chat, maybe you can help me out.
Uh, I would I i'm appealing to you if I could do a poll I would do it you know, it's squirrelly joe's coffee and and does there seem to be a. Possibly I don't know. Maybe this is a a copyright issue, you know there look at this.
This is the squirrel chatter. And squirrelly joe's coffee logo. I i'm just wondering whether I I you know, did squirrel chatter copy from squirrelly joe's? I mean he keeps On you know on squirrel chatter if you listen to that podcast gene client continuously talks about You know squirrelly joe's coffee.
So, you know, I have a suggestion I have a suggestion I I think maybe that That he he he copied the logo that you know, maybe I could be wrong. I mean it could be that you know. But but maybe squirrelly joe's should just solve the problem and just here you go stick gene client's face right on there.
There you go. That's that's how he should have that that squirrelly joe's coffee Is to have it with with gene client's Arm around the cup. There you go. Hey gene. That's what you should do. Maybe if you did that gene, you could then get your you know squirrelly joe's saying.
Hey, we want to we want to support your show. Um, by the way, I do think this is kind of interesting. I'm showing there a bag of honesty. Can can anyone figure out what's wrong with this picture? The bag of honesty what type of coffee is that caffeinated Decaffeinated what is wrong with this?
The coffee real coffee is dishonest. It's not real coffee. Got I got to talk to squirrelly joe about that, you know. He's got one that is half caffeinated and half Decaffeinated for those people that don't want the full caffeine.
That one's called responsibility I'm not sure that's really responsible to be half and half.
I'm, just saying help me out folks.
To have half and half half caffeinated half decaf. I mean that that's like trying to live in the world and be in christ at the same time. I mean it just doesn't work.
So so quick poll. Who who thinks that uh gene client squirrel stole Squirrelly joe's uh logo. We'll just we'll do a poll out there. I think there's actually a way I could do a poll within. Uh, at least on youtube through through the app.
I thought there was a way we could do that, but I don't know how to do it offhand. So. But uh, but yeah, so go get yourself a good a good cup of squirrelly joe's coffee. Uh, I hope that uh, you'll enjoy that i've been enjoying mine.
Like I said, we I went to my daughter's and I brought a bag of integrity out there. So we had that that was good. So, um.
All right, let me see if we could bring amy in now. I'll bring her in and see amy if you want to unmute yourself and then you could ask your question. Oh, I just see in the private chat. She says I can hear you now.
Okay, there you go. You are muted. So amy go ahead. I know you're muted because we hear a hissing. But we don't hear amy.
All right.
Uh, i'm gonna mute you until. Figure out what what's wrong with your mic and then let us know in the private chat. I will read. The question she had for us. And it was actually a clip. I think she's referring she said noland and I don't think it was.
I'm not thinking it was noland, but. Then again, she's binging old episodes. So she said I listened today to the the debate with noland. I think I i'm trying to remember that the pastor from the church of christ.
Uh pastor that we had it start norm, I think it was a norman. Yeah, that was pastor norm. Norm, so that's who I think she's referring to because I don't remember a noland. But it with my memory. Yeah, so she says uh the debate with noland.
Um, okay. She just said yes norm. Okay, so uh with so debate with pastor norm uh from the church of christ one question I had.
If.
And when you have time. If someone like him is still saved since they believed even if they're attached works to it.
Or.
What about people under his care that don't know any different? So the issue for folks that don't know, uh norm and that's the clip that I played actually in the very beginning Norm was the guy that believed you needed to be baptized to be saved.
Uh, that's where he called me a very skilled debater because all of a sudden he got trapped. Uh, he got trapped because he said that.
He realized that he's saying that the gospel is essential and that it's the only thing. And then I bring up baptism and he realizes he wants to say That baptism is essential also and he got stuck and instead of trying to i'll give him the credit instead of trying to just come up with some Nonsense like lean flowers would do.
Uh, he just realized he was caught. And he just passed it off as well. You're a very skilled debater. And you're very good at what you do. Uh-huh. But I I would say this to the question amy. Um. What you have there is you have Someone who I I don't think you can be saved believing that your works save you.
And so if if his you can you can be confused and people under his care Could believe in a biblical gospel and and believe that they're getting baptized because it's commanded. But if they believe that they're saved because they got baptized not because they believed in christ.
That becomes a difference and you know, let me play the longer version of that with norm so that you could hear how you know, it's this is. Well, I got a three minute version or a minute and a half version of it.
So let's do the the minute and a half.
But you'll hear how he gets trapped because he realizes. He's believing in something other than just the gospel. And and so if they if they're believing in something that's works based. In galatians all says that is anathema.
It's another gospel. Um, and this is what he says in galatians chapter one starting in verse 9 and verse 10 he says.
Or is it sorry? It's verse 8 and 9. He says but if we Or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to what we we have preached to you He is to be accursed. As we've said before and I say again if any man is preaching to you a gospel contrary to what you received He is to be accursed.
And it works. And he's saying this to people.
I don't argue that paul is saying that angels would come down and preach a different gospel. Unless they're demons, right? But he's using exaggeration there. That's paul's style. He's saying if anybody does this even if an angel does this.
Okay, so he's doing it for emphasis. And so he says they should be accursed. He's speaking to people. In this book in galatians. Amy, he's speaking to people who got saved. But then these judiazers jewish people that were so used to the traditions of jewish law.
They were telling the gentiles when they come to christ. Well, yes, you believe in christ, but you have to be circumcised you have to live kosher and that's what Paul is addressing in this book is people who are saying you have to be under the law doing works.
And so he's saying it's accursed. It's a different gospel. It's the strongest word he could use. To to say that they're accursed and therefore I would say Uh that if you have someone that's teaching a message like norm was doing that baptism is required for salvation.
No, he he can't be saved and the people under him that are believing what he believes that their baptism saves them. I think would would Be in the same boat, but I think there could be people that read the bible and and get saved uh and have a Proper view that of what the scriptures say that they're saved by grace alone.
Do you have anything you want to add to that or you or claude or should I play the clip so you know what we're talking.
About.
I would I can glean from the context of the question and what you've said there. Um, I I and I think it's important for us to consider and to to understand the the sovereignty of god in the matter of salvation that.
Certainly.
False teaching like what that man is doing Is damnable heresy? Because it's adding works to the making works the requirement of salvation rather than Salvation by grace alone through faith alone in christ alone, which is justification by faith alone in god alone.
Um, I think uh, it's important for us to keep in mind though False teaching is dangerous and it's deadly. But god is so sovereign That he is able to save folks despite false teaching. So we should never never Let up on the striving for the necessity of sound doctrine.
But we should also consider and remember that even in the midst Of folks sitting under false teaching like that that god is able to save them. And there will be some that I would say that god would save that does save despite the false doctrine.
But it's it's the exception rather than the norm. And so that's the uh, I think that's the head one of the heavy burdens that's placed on pastors that when we stand before Congregation and we open the word of god to our congregations And teach people Towards the congregation the local church or even here again on the on the internet, right?
When we do that, there's a great And a heavy responsibility That anybody who opens their mouth in the name of god Needs to stop and think about before they do or say anything.
And I was laughing because that that pun I think was unintended when Claude said that. It's the exception not the norm speaking of pastor norm.
Maybe they accept not the rules. It's funny because I didn't even catch it. Now it's even funnier. Yeah.
Amy said, uh, he really was not going to loosen. Uh loosen up and listen. I felt embarrassed for him. It was a bit uncomfortable.
It got uncomfortable for him. Um, because he got caught. Really? I mean our discussion drew. Were you on that one? I know I wasn't I was listening.
I was in the comments, but I could so that was I remember because those conversations took place. When we were my wife and I were living with my in-laws. And we didn't I didn't we didn't really have good internet reception or anything so I couldn't be on but I was in the comments and uh, yeah, it was it was hard because.
Uh what you were saying? He just didn't want to hear. And so he kept trying to force his view in there. Even though he kept contradicting himself and he kept pointing it out and you kept saying well, wait, wait.
No, you you can't have that. And it was just rough to listen to on on his part.
Yeah, well I mean. So maybe maybe we'll play the longer version of this so people get context. Because we want to talk about how apologetics for next generation, right? And claude this is what we're trying to do pass on the wisdom learning from our mistakes pass that on to the next generation.
Um, and and what I tried to do in this was. So so as we listen, let me give what I was trying to do so that you can as a listener you hear. And you know what to listen for now. What I was trying to do is I do this often.
I want to take if someone is arguing a. What I want to do is go over to b. See if there's agreement on b something that contradicts a. Get him to argue that he believes in b which contradicts a. And when he does that.
Then bring a back into the discussion. So when this discussion what i'm arguing is the what is the essential? Of you know is it basically is the gospel is believing in christ the essential. Is that all that's needed?
And when he agrees to that then I bring baptism back into the discussion to say, okay. Then how you know, do you need to be baptized to be saved and that's when he realized he he got stuck. Yeah, so well, let's give a listen now i'll give us this longer one in context.
What if christ's death on the cross? Was was not sufficient. He requires your. I never said that and I wouldn't say that and it's you know, extremely Offensive to attribute that to me. Okay, so you're saying that that you that christ's death was sufficient.
Right, that's all that we need only sufficient but the only thing that couldn't be done. Okay, so we don't need okay. So let me pause it there. Notice there there was something I said. He said no, that's not what i'm saying.
What am I doing trying to clarify? This is something teaching the next generation. This is what You know claude and I want to try to teach the next generation, right? You don't just go Arguing for something, you know stopping at clarification.
I'm trying to stop them get clarification. Now i'm realizing okay, let's clarify what is what's necessary for salvation. That's the whole thing. Is baptism necessary. Let's get clarification. That's what I was trying to do.
Now, let's see if I can play it again baptism then because it's the only thing. Is it is it the only thing or is it not do you need to be baptized or not? Because if you need to be baptized, it's not sufficient.
I'm.
It it is true that you are an extremely skilled debater and you're good at buying, you know things around so. Uh, they get pretty twisted up and and you know, was it pretty twisted up? It was right then this guy he he said that is he's saying that it's the essential thing is christ and then it's.
Well, what about baptism right when you bring a back in he's he's stuck. And and this is what ends up happening with it is he wants to go off on on different tangents now he. Right. That was the clip that I played at the very beginning, but here's how it ended up going after that.
And you're very skilled. I'm just asking you the same question. This is this is what I have been consistently saying i've not been inconsistent in anything i've said this is what i've been consistently.
Saying that the gospel is the death burial and resurrection of christ on the cross for my sins. That's the gospel paul said that we obey the gospel. We obey that form of doctrine delivered to us we obey the gospel when we Are are baptized into christ for the remission of our sins so that we can be raised to walk with him in newness of life.
And that's romans chapter six. Okay, so so that again didn't answer it was it what you said is fine. Just doesn't answer the question. Okay. So what did I do right there? This is the thing. You know like this program here is to train you to do apologetics.
That's what we're doing here. This is why we break things like this down what i'm doing at that point is. You can let a person go just. When they get caught this is what they do. They'll just ramble for a long time and hope that they're they ramble long enough that you forgot what your original question was.
So you don't ask it again. Okay. And so what I do Is I note when people do that and i'll do exactly that if you watch this program enough times you see me do that here.
I just go.
Okay, you didn't answer the question. Let's get back to the question. That's what I did. That's good to do.
Yeah, andrew, you're so good at debate. You're you're good at twisting things up. The problem is. You didn't twist anything up. All you said was is this sufficient. And all we need and he said yes, this is sufficient.
Right that agreeing with b. Yes, this is sufficient. Okay, so then we don't need a. Well, you're good at twisting things up. I've been consistent. Well, no, you haven't. You just said you agree with this.
But that's not. That's not what he said when he first came on. And the whole point of his argument is that you must have baptism in order to be safe to the point that you made to him. Well, then the gospel's not sufficient then is it right?
That's not twisting anything. That's not even b. You don't even have to be a skilled debater to do that. All you got to do is just listen and pay attention to what he's saying and then just ask the question.
Right just re-ask it again.
I mean it's folks to do apologetics. It's not that you have to have some skills in debate in.
In.
How to make arguments how to. A lot of it's just listening. And and knowing to ask questions. Um, you know matt said he tried to say he got tricked but really he tricked himself via fallacy argumentation.
So let me put i'll play the rest of it. I'll ask it again. Okay, please do. Was christ. So you're saying christ's death on the cross was sufficient, right? Absolutely. 100. What do you mean by sufficient?
I mean that christ Sacrifice on the cross is uh, what was necessary to pay the price for my sins. Was it all that's necessary or just partially. Okay, i'm going to stop it there. Why did I ask that question?
For clarification.
Exactly i'm trying to get clarification on and what i'm doing is breaking it down in parts.
So let's deal with this in small pieces. Then let's get one thing because he you notice the pause that he had there. He knew he was trapped. He wants to say christ what christ did on the cross was sufficient.
Nothing else is needed. But he also wants to say baptism is needed. And he can't reconcile those two and it may be the first time he's been challenged with it because. A good thing to do is to break things down into smaller pieces.
So let's let me i'll play the rest of it then.
What's up?
If christ's death on the cross Was was not sufficient. He requires your power. I never said that and I wouldn't start it all the way over. Sorry. Extremely. Well, we heard it we heard enough of it. I want to get to what I want to get to the to.
Passing the torch. Because I know you you brought some some of your notes up Claude, so you want me? Let's you want me to share share those? Yes, sir.
Those.
So so I mean I just to say that you know, the the idea when we're doing.
Doing uh.
Debates or or apologetics making an argument. We have to be listening To what people are saying and sometimes what we have to do is help them listen to themselves. Yeah, um. You know, that's part of it is is just exposing and that's what questions do is to expose the problems in their thinking, you know, and that's.
Really what you're doing what you're doing in the clarifying is you're exposing to him The power that his presuppositions have on him. Right, and so so all of us who. When we first got into presupposition Presuppositional apologetic we've all heard kind of the analogy story of the guy who thought he was dead.
Right where he thought he was dead. They kept asking him. Why do you think you're dead and he goes? Well, I don't. I just believe that i'm dead. And so eventually they take him to the doctor and the doctor says I know how I know how to convince this guy.
Do dead men bleed? He says well, no dead men don't bleed. So they prick his finger blood comes out and he says what do you think of that? And he goes, huh? Dead men do bleed right? That's the power of the presupposition.
And so the point of andrew breaking it down like that is to say, okay. Let's start here. Do you agree with this? And then just move step by step by step because then you say if you agree with this. And this is sufficient meaning.
This is all we need then by. Logically, we don't need this this is not sufficient.
Therefore.
We don't have to have this in order to be saved if christ is all we need.
So this so We want to get to In. So we talked a little bit about this earlier, right. The passing of torches. The idea. This is for us old guys, thanks haps.
To teach younger guys, which I think is important. I think it's good. And so you did a class on. Well, you called it the art of prophesying. Uh, and the and the calling of the ministry william arkens.
I like it.
Yes your textbook. Actually a third of the book was our textbook.
Yeah, I and.
You wanted to go through a little bit of what you taught and I think this will be helpful. So let me put out an appeal. If there's some younger Men, I don't know if women are allowed to be part of a class.
Yes.
Okay, so if there's young if there's some younger men or women that would like to.
Uh be.
Participating in this in this school.
Uh, we're.
You know, we're training up people. Get you know. Contact. Contact me and i'll get you in touch with haps. You know to get in touch with me just. Uh email me at info At striving for eternity dot com. Info at striving for eternity dot com.
That'll get to me and i'll send you over to haps.
Claude what. So you wanted to go over a little bit of what you had taught during this the course that you had so.
So just a very quick run through. Um basically, um, and this is a blurb from the back of the book sinclair ferguson had posted or Made this and he actually wrote the um wrote the forward too, I believe but He said few things are more evident in contemporary churches than the decline and the importance attached to what is said from their pulpits.
Which which what some of the things that's been talked about tonight, of course, and you talk about them regularly. But the deeper tragedy he said is that in many places the church has become a valley of dry bones.
Something is needed to waken the dead and to breathe new life into the people of god again the title of the book the art of prophecy catches folks off guard because Of the misdefining of the term and the idea of what biblical prophecy is in our day and in our time.
Particularly the last 100 150 years or so, but I mean, I know it goes back even further than that, but still yet. Still yet when we talk about Prophecy, uh, we are actually talking. Uh, let me get to that slide real quick.
So prophecy again definitional terms understanding what we're talking about Contact contextually is very important. But the study of prophesying involves a commitment of the mind to acquire the ability to exercise prophecy rightly so with prophecy is we're talking about the word of god and if the Exclusive subject of preaching is the scriptures then we're pointing to the scriptures.
So there needs to be a an ability To rightly divide the word of god really so that was one of the things that we we communicated to the guys every week. Was when you think of a synonymous terms when you think of prophecy think preaching.
So that you you don't get it confused or mixed up. But when we preach when we prophesy as Proclaimers of the gospel we it's a solemn public utterance. It's a serious thing again. We mentioned that earlier and i'll move right through this but it's always related to the worship of god.
That's key related to the worship of god and the salvation of our neighbors. So when we hear the term prophecy from a christian perspective We should always understand it to be what was spoken by god through the prophets and the apostles.
In relation to that's the connecting term there in relation to the redemptive Work of jesus both past present and future. It always points us to the messiah and again going to the important and significant nature of the local elders and pastors in the church the function of preaching.
It's instrumental in gathering together all of the elect because the church uh as in philippians you were talking about philippians earlier before we uh, Started the the podcast tonight. But but that's the thing that the gospel has to be our rallying point.
It has to be our center. It has to be our Uh our gathering place. It has to be our focus. The gospel and what happens when we focus on a right interpretation of the scriptures the second Of the twofold value of preaching happens it drives away the wolves from the fold.
So you get to a situation where maybe like the question that was asked somebody's teaching their own Bible study right without Without any supervision without any direction. Why maybe again? Maybe they just don't know or maybe they just don't like what's being communicated and taught if it's solid Sound biblical doctrine, but what happens when we do rightly interpret the word it drives away the wolves from the fold of god.
And again basic things two parts of interpretation of the scripture. Two parts of interpretation of the scripture number one the preparation of the sermon that has to be done. That is a necessity and then the preaching of the sermon you should never try to preach the sermon before you made preparation for the sermon.
I mean, it's pretty pretty straightforward. That's funny. You say that because what comes to my mind is everyone that says I had a sermon prepared. But the lord spoke to me. Gave me such and such.
You could do that if you have. I mean I have done that at times where I I've done the study. Yeah, so I have the notes and it you know, so I that's okay but more what I was laughing at was the the fact that.
You know, I I know people that.
Literally tried to tell me That i'm wrong in doing all the prep that I do for a sermon. Yeah. How does the holy spirit move is what I've been told. You gotta you just gotta get up there and let the spirit lead you.
Uh, yeah. No, that's called rambling.
Right, and then and that comes down to a terminal terminological issues, too. You know miscommunications throughout history and time and just culture. Like, you know, I came up at country churches, right?
And I heard that all the time. But to understand I think it's more correct not to say Uh, because I I mean as a young preacher I had to go back, you know long years ago. I'd said that before and I had done that however.
As you grow and you mature in the lord, it's not wise to say um. But it's not it's not wise to say i'm not gonna i'm not gonna go with my preparation. I'm not gonna go with my teaching because I don't feel like it's the right thing to do.
Right, but unless unless. Contextually there are things that come up and that's actually one of the things here i'll move to that slide.
So it's this it's application of the of this preparation the skill by which the doctrine which has been Properly drawn from scripture is handled in ways that are appropriate to the circumstances. Certainly there are circumstances and again The focus is the local church now.
All everybody has nowadays on the internet is a conference sermon mentality many folks Negate and lessen the importance and the significance of the local congregation. But this is what we're talking about in this class to these to these guys is that there are appropriate circumstances.
To bring up and to communicate different things in a local congregation. Why? Well, because there are circumstances in local congregation that may not be happening everywhere all around the block. Or all around the world.
It's particular to that congregation like with the corinthians in in The new testament, right? There were particular things that paul addressed that we have preserved for us in the text so, uh going on because I know it's about time, uh, I don't want to take any more time than necessary, but passionate theology passionate theology.
Uh, this is something that um, this is one of the things that I feel very strongly about and it's uh. And i'll just read this perkins it's a quote from perkins, but he said ministers are few in number.
Then do all you can to increase their number the greater the number the lighter the burden on each individual man. So let every minister both in his teaching and his conversation work in such a way that he honors his calling.
So that he may attract others to share his love for it and what we communicated in this particular class. When we when we quoted that was this that the church. The weight and the burden of a local congregation is not all on the elders and the pastors but it is truly carried by the believers in christ and so what the minister has a responsibility to do Is to demonstrate both by his conversation.
By his practice his his orthopraxy his life. And also in his preaching that this is not a burden. Listen, if a man says he's called of god and is pastoring a church. Listen, and I not and I understand that there are times that things get heavy and things get hard.
And things get out of control. But if a man Stands in the pulpit and he preaches not of as a matter of fact, I want to I want to read first corinthians. Oops, sorry first corinthians chapter 9 I believe it's verse 15.
Let me get there paul said this. He said, uh, wait, sorry. Nine back one chapter I can quote it. He said this. He said yeah, though I did to quote the king james. Yeah, though I preach the gospel. I have nothing to glory of.
For necessity is laid upon me. And yes woe unto me is if I preach not the gospel. A man cannot a man called of god can't get out from underneath the calling of the ministry. He will die before he does that.
Because god has determined this to be so. And and god intends to use this man in a way that it's going to edify and to encourage the body of christ so the the man of god should be. Should demonstrate to the congregation to the people that we're preaching to that.
It's not a burden. Again, we talked about some different applications practical applications instruction correction uh, and then um I believe it was the class before the last the seventh or eighth class, but we talk we we walk the the folks the men through first corinthians to.
Uh two essentials to preaching the word hiding of human wisdom in the demonstration of the spirit again. Clarifying that the hiding of human wisdom is not Neglecting to get knowledge and wisdom, but it's understanding that we don't stand when we proclaim the gospel.
We do not stand. Bragging or standing on what we think we understand and what we know. But we are standing on what is what is written what is said what is done. And what is certain and for sure that is unfailing and that is unflinching.
That's what it means to not hide. You know or to hide human wisdom and then to depend on the work of the spirit because of man. Woman boy or girl is not going to be saved outside of the sovereign. Regenerating work of the holy ghost of god in their hearts and in their minds saving them.
And then the expectations of the minister of the gospel teaching by example. Uh godliness that stems from regeneration. That's where it all begins. You gotta you must be born again. Whitfield said it.
Preached it all the time a lady asked him one time Whitfield why do you always preach you must be born again? He said my my lady because you must be born again. If if you're going to see the kingdom of god, you're going to have to go.
You're going to have to go god's way and then so we we just walked we walked through like I said, we walked through a whole lot with these with these men and there was uh, I believe one of hap's friends hannah stoddard took the class and in his uh, Fiancee or his wife.
I'm not sure if they're married yet or not, but they uh. She took the class and she seemed to be very knowledgeable about the questions. She Had asked and communicated, but I just want to thank you for letting me be on tonight.
Let me talk with you all I truly enjoy. Uh being Had have enjoyed being on here and enjoy your your your friendship. And your fellowship in the gospel andrew again keep up the good work for the lord man.
Appreciate it brother.
You're always welcome on. It is an open show for anyone to come. You can. You know, yeah.
Well that. Well, that's a lot like happening. I want I want to have you andrew because you're old. The only only qualification is you're living and breathing. You've got the lake come on.
Look look all i'm saying is Sometimes I can't be here and it's good for andrew to have someone to hold his hand, uh through some of these things. So Okay. Yeah, you have an invitation.
Kathy's saying thank you. Happy calvinist. She corrected the spelling there.
Jason says thank you. Happy calvinist. Yeah, so actually we should mention you got a podcast for people to go and check out as well. So, why don't you let folks know about that the here I stand theology podcast.
To be honest, basically the bulk of what's on there the last Half a year probably primarily are sermons. I've just put up the sunday sermon on there just to keep putting video on there.
The bulk and majority of what's on there right now is probably the sunday sermon. But there are some sporadic podcasts from here to there. So, um, well, you know, like I said to drew maybe if you did.
Some some more podcasting. You might have made it out around one of the contests there. I did make it out around one.
I'm gonna go.
Right at round two. Oh, you. Yeah, and I was against james white in round two. So I was like, yeah.
Yeah, so.
Someone asked why this show wasn't in there. I'm like because I didn't get a say in it like, you know. Although the the the two that won that there's one guy that's on both shows. So it's like so either way he won.
Yeah, brian. So they've won. Yeah, he won the tournament.
Yeah one way or another.
I guess that the uh drew you sent me, uh the full uh message. From I guess it was matt. You want to do you want to engage should we you want to read that and We get it we we'll leave it to happen. We'll leave it to a claude.
We'll ask him to respond.
Okay, I can uh, I can read it. Yeah. So we're gonna start over right and this is a. I see why it was cut off because it's very very long. It's very long. Yeah, but it says who is kevin thompson? And how could anyone possibly be this far off about anything ever?
And of course he's got latent flowers with him nodding in approval to every straw man. The emoji face to the facepalm emoji. Uh, if you're. And he's quoting and he says quote if you're Elect you're saved regardless of whether christ died and if you are not elect you're not saved.
Regardless of whether or not christ died. Uh, so that seems to be the only piece of information that would actually constitute good news for a person. And that is never listed as good news in scripture.
So I see a mismatch. What the bible calls the good news is not good news if calvinism is true to anyone. And election is good news in calvinism, but that's never listed as good news in scripture. So I see a huge mismatch with the news.
So when I look at it to me. The content of it is a different gospel or there really is no gospel. Because even people like piper and sproll will say quote you can't really know if you're elect until you're dead.
End quote the data set Is not good news. That's the point that i'm making end quote.
Okay, so let me ask this question claude. His argument is based on uh, the statement that was read there and i'm trying to read what drew sent me.
Are the elect Saved. Let me. I want to make sure I word this well are the like when we think of it in time. Are the elect saved before they repent. In time. So I guess what i'm trying to get to is he's saying the elect are saved whether they believe or not.
It's the election that makes all the difference. And I so let me ask it that way. Then instead of for you Do calvinists believe? That election is what saves us. Or That regeneration saves us.
Regeneration saved us saves us based on the death burial and resurrection of christ. And election, uh is only a piece of the puzzle. What does romans 8 tell us right? There's the golden chain of redemption.
Here we go, right? Oh, she goes. Oh, yeah. That's the calvinist go-to. It's not the calvinist go-to. It's the biblical go-to.
Those whom he called. Or i'm, sorry those who meet predestined those who called. So we have a logical order a connection a sequence. God does not try to do anything. As yoda would say he he either does or does not right.
He's quoting yoda or it does not. The the the challenge is for Uh us as human beings is that we're fine. We're finite and god is infinite. If we could understand infinite Ideas and infinite principles Then it wouldn't be an issue.
It wouldn't be a problem. But the least little challenges that come up There is there's it's it's almost. And I I will say this just to give the benefit of the doubt. It's almost a Uh, maybe in I don't know if instinct is the right word, but it's a knee-jerk reaction To automatically say I don't like that.
Therefore. It's not true. There's a lot of things that we don't like. You want to know how many times? If we think how many times that we open god's word and we go to reading through a text even as we're maturing in the faith, we read a text and we We cringe and we draw back and we say I don't know if I like that or not.
It says it.
What else are you gonna do? Well, that's the same logic that people use when they deny hell, right? The bible speaks of it, but I don't like it. It makes me uncomfortable. Therefore i'm going to redefine it and it's not what scripture actually says it is.
It is the same thing with calvinism. That's right.
Yeah, no. Melissa is saying that kevin thompson is a hardcore open theist. Well, that might be and that would explain a lot.
That would explain, you know, I know that layton flowers is softening on open theism. Maybe, you know, he says it's because he's met some other open theists and he's. So I think he's on his on his way there.
Uh, that'd be the consistent.
Way that he's going but well if I remember the order correctly when Dr. White first started engaging with him. Uh, I think. Because it came up because I want to say a lot of things came about through a discussion with william laine craig.
And layton was going in towards mullinism. And then he kind of stumbled upon provisionism or created provisionism, uh, and and now is kind of moving into that open theism because mullinism provisionism open theism that they all kind of have the same ideas of god.
Right that he's not really omniscient and he's not really sovereign. He's just doing the best that he can do. With the hand that he has in the only in the best world that he foresaw that he could create with the best possible outcome they're all Essentially tied together to say the same thing just different names.
Yeah, I mean I I think what you see in his in the the statement made here Election Is something that's in the mind of god. Being who's outside of time, you know things. When you try to argue, oh, well someone's elect whether they believe or not they're going to be saved then you don't understand.
A the the nature of god be what election is. When we talk about being saved We're talking about something in time. That's right. It's a human thing. It's when god works within time.
There's a point where we're not saved in a point that we are saved. Yeah, but god always knew. We would be saved because he knows everything.
You know, yeah, like like you said, I mean when they want to get around that they end up trying to say well Molinism which hopefully i'll have a debate with a guy that works for Fertilite and flowers eric hernandez.
We've we've had him on the show many years ago on molinism uh, but the the issue there is to to Molinism is the idea that god looked at all the possible things that humans would freely choose and then he picked one.
And so he picked one, but it was our choices.
So they're trying to say he he knows all things. He knows all the things that could have been. And selected something and said, okay. This is the one that gives the greatest glory. What a very weak god.
Well, it's it's a god that is ultimately, you know, it makes a god who is.
Subject to human will.
The other side open theism that you mentioned for folks who may not know what that is. It's the idea that god really doesn't know all things. He's a good guesser. That's how he does. Prophecy but he. He waits till we make decisions till we choose things And then based on our choices Then he responds.
And so.
Reactionary. But yeah, thanks.
What they're trying to do is save god's character. And and human free will. But what I I think what ends up being more important in both those cases is human free will. And they're trying to figure out how god works with human free will not how human free will works with god.
Yeah now I mean just if you look at the quote How it starts off. He already just really refutes himself or he he brings in a non-argument. If you're elect you're saved regardless of whether christ died.
If christ didn't die. No one's not elect. Yeah.
That's exactly right. Yeah, and and that's the whole thing of I mean, so and this is what to do folks. When you're when you're challenged with these things, what are we doing? We're just breaking down what's being said?
We're defining our terms. What is election? What is regeneration what is salvation? That's what we're doing. It's really not that hard. We can all do this.
You know, um.
And I mean, that's what we you know for claude and I for the you younger apologists. We want to encourage you this. This is the whole thing of we should not have a thing where we just look to the james whites and the you know, the the old white beards and guys have gone before us that have learned this.
Um, look james white has forgotten more theology than most of us know.
But it's because he's been doing it for a long time, you know. People sit there and say oh hi I can't do apologetics like you. You haven't been doing it long enough. That's all I mean, I you know this july I turned 40.
You know spiritually. Right. I'll be i'll I'll be safe 40 years doing apologetics for probably a good 30 38 years of them so.
Do it for that long and you're going to get better if you're learning from your mistakes. If you're doing it like This guy kevin thompson. You're not learning from your mistakes. You're just keep repeating the same errors.
But you also don't learn and you don't get better if you don't just go out and talk to people either. If you're not given the gospel, you're not going to learn anyway so you have to actually be obedient to Going out and evangelizing talk and you don't have to go be a street preacher.
You can just go to the store. Right, you you can talk to the cashier wherever you're at. It can just be on a walk go to a park just sit with someone at a bench. Right, it doesn't have to be anything extravagant.
It's just starting the conversation. Talking about christ and then the more you do it the more because what's gonna here's what's gonna happen. We've all had it happen to us. They're gonna ask us a question.
We don't know. We're gonna have to go. You know what? I don't know that but I can I i'm gonna have to go. Study that and then you go study it. Guess what? You know it.
Yep, and and then you get back to them with the answer.
Well claude, it's always great having you on. You know, you you are uh, the happy calvinist. You're always smiling.
But uh, you're full of wisdom, we're glad that uh, you're part of the. You know passing the torch that you're passing on the wisdom that you've you've gleamed to a next generation. And so, uh, you know now problem is I have to hope.
At least there's a couple classes between you and I so I don't have to.
No, those those those folks will be blessed. By the way passing the torch is the facebook page. That you can get those on as well. I started, uh yesterday by posting a First class on the here. I stand theology podcast so it can be watched there as well.
And then each week subsequent i'm gonna uh add The next week so okay two will be posted up next week there on the on the.
Passing the torch on facebook. Yes, we'll eventually get a website. I'm sure yeah.
All right, guys. Thank you so much for having me on. I'm gonna jump out. Okay. Yep.
Folks next week, uh, we have for let you know what's we got coming up.
Next week we're I still have it open because I haven't heard uh trying to get keith foskey and uh, redeem zoomer who did a debate on evolution both professing believers both reformed. One believing in evolution being resume reformed zoomer and then keith is not believing in evolution.
So I would like them to come on have further discussion. We'll see if it happens. I haven't heard from a reformed zoomer yet.
You know, you know what we should get. We should try to get another debate and have jason lyle moderate.
That would be really hard for jason. Say anything. Um.
But uh, april 4th, it'd be a great lesson in humility is what it would be.
Yeah. Uh april 4th, we're gonna have dr. Call widmer creationist. He's gonna come in uh, april 11th, we'll be discussing full preterism. I I. Put it out if there was a guy that said he would be willing to debate it and when I said, okay I will get someone to debate it with you and he said oh no, I gotta be anonymous because of my in time views.
Okay, in other words, i'm too scared to actually.
Defend. I like a monologue not a dialogue. That conversation was out there. Yeah, it was like yeah, I want to talk but I only want to talk here and we're like. This is not the platform to do that. Let's actually have the conversation.
Yeah, so we'll see, you know, we set it up either way. We will learn from uh, some some brothers about what full preterism teaches and uh,.
Why it's.
It's bad. So that's what's coming up. I hope that this has been helpful encouraging educational. Hope that you will share this with others. Uh, if you have gotten a lot out of it The best thing you could do is text it to some friends if there's some things you learned.
Hey check this out at this time stamp. Um, you know, let others know about it. Maybe text this to five friends. We would appreciate that. All right. And so with that we would just encourage you to strive to make today an eternal day for the glory of god and we will See you next time.
Have a great day.