Who Really Owns God’s Word? - Jon’s Journey to Freely Giving Scripture

Selling Jesus

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Hi, I'm John. I founded a company for creating apps for mission called gracious tech.

00:07

I Also started let's copy church Which is a website advocating for releasing ministry resources from copyright which you can find at copy dot church

00:17

While I am passionate about the complete free giving of ministry resources It's been a long journey where I have at times gone back and forth about what terms ministry resources should be licensed under So I'll share a bit about what has led me to have such strong convictions

00:33

About what scripture says on this topic and how it should be applied to us today My first encounters with copyright and trying to monetize creations was back in high school

00:44

For my major work in my last year of high school I developed a software program designed to assist students in their studies helping them manage their assessments and keep track of things

00:54

During that time I experienced what I now like to call Pre -launch anxiety you see after dedicating an enormous amount of time to crafting and perfecting something

01:05

You begin to become very possessive over it What if someone comes along and takes what

01:10

I've worked so hard to create? What if they copy it and potentially profit from all the effort

01:15

I've poured into it? Especially when you've poured over a year's worth of work into it as I had

01:21

It's a daunting thought in an attempt to protect my study program I reached out to an intellectual property lawyer

01:28

I wanted to learn everything I could about copyright and patents hoping to safeguard my creation looking back

01:36

It's quite amusing to think about it back then I hadn't fully grasped just how expensive legal services could be and ironically

01:44

I never actually got around to publishing that project due to becoming busy with other commitments

01:51

Despite never releasing it I had spent a lot of mental energy worrying that someone might copy and profit from what

01:58

I had created But such fears in hindsight were very irrational Later on I had this idea of using my programming skills for the sake of the gospel

02:08

And I came up with a website for comparing the Gospels to more easily see where they overlap

02:14

These days you can easily find a variety of tools for comparing the Gospels But back then they were pretty much non -existent

02:21

Little did I know this endeavor would be my first introduction to the complexities of Bible copyright

02:28

I was excited about the project and I worked tirelessly on it However, at some point along the way it hit me

02:35

Copyright might pose a problem So I decided to dig into the licensing terms printed at the front of my

02:41

Bible hoping to find some clarity Well, let's just say it was a bit of a reality check

02:47

It turned out that I wouldn't be able to make or publish my idea after all

02:52

Feeling a bit disheartened I reached out to a Christian lecturer at my university Seeking advice on the copyright matter and what steps

03:00

I should take Unfortunately, their guidance didn't provide any practical solutions At that time as someone unfamiliar with copyright and the publishing industry in general

03:11

I had no idea that seeking permission was even an option I was clueless about the process and honestly, even if I managed to figure it out

03:20

I highly doubted that anyone would pay attention to a university student like me So in the end

03:26

I had to let go of the project It wasn't because I couldn't technically make it happen

03:31

But the legal hurdles made it clear that pursuing it wasn't worth it A while later

03:36

I did actually have a project that took off to some extent It was an exciting time for me because it was my first project to take off I created a plugin for a text editor and it gained quite a bit of popularity

03:48

During that period I had delved deep into the world of Linux, the open source operating system

03:54

I fully embraced the open source software culture and transitioned away from Windows My computer ran solely on open source software and it was great

04:04

The beauty of it was that it was completely free A gift from people all around the world who generously donated their time, efforts and talents to create something valuable without asking for anything in return

04:17

The alignment between this open source ethos and the principles of the gospel deeply inspired me

04:24

So when it came to releasing my plugin I made the conscious decision to offer it for free as well

04:30

In the Linux software community there is this culture and expectation that you should share your creations freely, openly licensing them

04:38

Embracing that culture brought me great joy I released my plugin as open source and soon enough hundreds of people started using it

04:46

When I shared this with my friends they thought I was crazy They couldn't quite understand why

04:52

I had created something that was gaining traction without seeking any financial gain from it

04:57

For them it just didn't make sense But for me it was a source of joy Seeing people benefit from something

05:03

I had made without any expectation of payment was very satisfying Even though it wasn't even a

05:09

Christian project Around that time I discovered some great open source Bible apps that were free to use and free to improve as well

05:17

However I soon realized that none of the popular Bible translations were available Particularly the

05:23

NIV which I had grown up using and was the default translation for most churches around me

05:29

Interestingly the ESV was an option for a while But as of the last few years even that has ceased to be the case

05:37

I began diving into forums and reading the comments of developers who were trying to gain access to these

05:44

Bible translations It was during this process that I learned about the challenges they faced due to licensing restrictions

05:50

I found it strange to think that the very organizations entrusted with spreading

05:56

God's word were the ones hindering its accessibility At the time I didn't possess a strong theological foundation to question their practices

06:05

But deep within me I felt something was amiss It seemed contrary to the spirit of the gospel

06:12

Unfortunately I lacked a solid understanding of how to address this issue and could only hope that one day they would have a change of heart

06:20

I held on to the belief that things would eventually change I believed in the future of open source

06:26

And as it turns out I was right in many ways Nowadays open source software is running on almost everyone's phones and computers

06:35

Often without them even realizing it Commercial software still exists of course But open source has achieved incredible success and has become virtually ubiquitous across all devices

06:46

With that in mind I couldn't fathom that this state of affairs would persist indefinitely

06:53

I assumed that these Bible organizations would eventually come to their senses and recognize the futility of restricting

07:01

God's word Especially when used in non -commercial apps However I gradually relinquished any hopes of creating something myself

07:10

Mainly because I was just a lone individual without much experience in such matters at that time

07:16

Many years later while serving on the mission field I initially considered leaving my IT experience behind me

07:23

However when sharing the gospel with different friends I met I came up with the idea of creating an app to more easily share scripture with them

07:30

In the environment I was working in people had no Christian background whatsoever They had little knowledge of the

07:37

Bible or Jesus And simply handing them an entire Bible would be overwhelming for them

07:42

They didn't know where to start or how to find Jesus within its pages To address this

07:47

I believed it would be more helpful to collect key passages that individuals could read without getting lost

07:55

This approach would gradually build their knowledge and encourage them to explore more passages

08:01

Eventually leading them to read the entire Bible However I was determined not to include my own commentary

08:08

As a missionary I had developed a skepticism towards resources created by others

08:13

As it was a lot of work to discern the quality and accuracy of materials written in a language

08:20

I was still learning myself Instead I figured that quoting plain scripture would be the most valuable approach

08:27

Fellow workers would immediately recognize and trust the words of the Bible Eliminating any potential concerns

08:34

I assumed there wouldn't be any licensing issues Since I'd be using a relatively small amount of scripture

08:40

Usually 10 to 15 small passages at a time Well below the typical 500 verse limit

08:47

However I soon discovered that I hadn't fully grasped the intricacies of Bible licensing terms

08:55

Almost all Bibles include a clause stating that you can quote scripture up to 500 verses

09:02

As long as you don't share a complete book And as long as the quoted verses don't exceed 25 % of the total text in which they are used

09:13

Many people misinterpret this as limiting the quoted verses to 25 % of a book in the

09:20

Bible When actually it refers to the work in which the verses are quoted

09:26

This means that sharing plain scripture is forbidden Scripture could only make up a quarter of the content of a given page

09:35

And the rest had to be filled with personal commentary This restriction directly contradicted my intentions for the app

09:44

I didn't want to add my own commentary or paraphrase scripture I wanted other ministry workers to use it with confidence

09:53

Trusting it was the Bible and nothing else The more I learnt the more I realised that the licensing terms

09:59

Would effectively kill the concept of my app At the time I had never approached a publisher for permission

10:05

And I had no idea how to go about that process I attempted to research online and it seemed complex

10:12

And required establishing my own organisation I contemplated approaching the publisher under the umbrella of the organisation

10:20

I was a part of But it wouldn't be scalable Even if I obtained permission for myself

10:26

Others would still lack permission to use the app for their own purposes This directly contradicted the fundamental goal of the project

10:34

To create a tool that allowed customising the content shared Allowing others to choose their own sets of passages

10:41

Considering all these factors it became clear that asking for permission Wouldn't be a viable solution

10:46

The very essence of my project relied on enabling others To create their own story sets as well

10:53

Without that possibility the scope of what I was trying to achieve would be severely limited I brainstormed various techniques

11:00

Such as combining different translations to ensure no single translation Exceeded a quarter of the work

11:06

However none of these approaches proved suitable And I was unwilling to exploit any loopholes

11:13

I wanted to operate in good faith After much effort and working on the project for over a year

11:18

It became stuck due to those legal barriers And never ended up getting properly launched

11:24

Later on I established my own organisation dedicated to creating apps for mission work

11:30

After many years of ministry experience I had many ideas for projects Particularly ones involving the bible and different ways of engaging with scripture

11:39

However as I sat down to evaluate these ideas And consider the roadblocks that might arise

11:44

I realised that all the bible related projects faced legal hurdles I pondered whether these projects would be feasible at all

11:52

Technically I had the skills to create them And I knew I could overcome any technical obstacles

11:58

However if I encountered a legal barrier It could bring everything to a halt

12:04

This was especially true considering that most Christians Rely on only one or two bible translations

12:11

If my app didn't include the translations people trusted It would be rendered useless to a significant amount of Christians Not just in English but in other languages as well

12:23

It didn't matter how innovative or feature rich the app was Without the right translations it wouldn't gain traction

12:32

This realisation made me think Even if I approached publishers for permission

12:37

I would likely need to present them with a prototype to demonstrate the app's value This meant doing a substantial amount of work up front

12:45

Only for them to potentially reject the idea If they did it would be a dead end for the project

12:51

Rather than taking that uncertain path I opted to focus on other app ideas that would prove valuable to missionaries and others

12:59

As a result my organisation's first major app Was secure newsletter software which gained popularity

13:07

Today there are hundreds of users Finding it helpful to safely connect with their supporters

13:12

But my passion has always been to create apps that engage with scripture After successfully launching the newsletter app

13:20

I turned my attention back to bible focused apps I had in mind I knew I had to find a way to make it work

13:27

So I started researching bible APIs Which are platforms that power bible apps

13:33

By providing access to various translations However I soon discovered that even these platforms

13:40

Had their own set of terms and conditions They imposed request limits and cache limits

13:46

And while some were quite generous They still presented rigid boundaries If I exceeded those limits

13:54

I would have to enter into an agreement With the organisation behind the platform Which brought uncertainties

14:00

Would I have to pay? What would be the cost of it all? And even if I reached an agreement

14:06

Would I obtain the necessary permissions? Or would I hit a roadblock? This added another layer of legal complexity

14:13

On top of dealing with the licenses of bible translations Not only that but some platforms required collecting data from users

14:21

Which goes against my organisation's value of being privacy focused They require such measures out of fear

14:29

That translations will be abused in some way The reality however is that such measures are nonsensical

14:37

As copying scripture is incredibly easy Even an amateur programmer could write a script

14:43

To rip off entire translations from biblegateway or bible .com

14:49

They could do it in a day I decided none of these APIs were suitable For the kind of projects

14:55

I wanted to create So I realised I'd have to create my own bible platform from scratch

15:01

I developed it as an open source project Allowing anyone to contribute to it and create their own version

15:08

They could customise it according to their needs And use it however they saw fit It has so far turned out to be far more efficient

15:15

Than the other platforms available It is faster, cheaper to run And doesn't burden users with authentication requirements

15:23

Or locked content In order to get permission to use bible translations I needed access to a digital rights system

15:31

Which the majority of the world's bible translations use Naively I thought that by gaining access to this system

15:38

It would be easy to obtain permission for using various bible translations worldwide

15:44

From a technological standpoint It's incredibly simple to incorporate multiple languages into an app

15:50

So I wanted to ensure that my app catered to users across the globe Not just a single country or a specific language group

15:57

When I gained access to the platform I quickly realised that it only granted me permission to request permission

16:06

After spending over a decade getting to this point By starting my own organisation, registering it as a non -profit

16:14

Dealing with finances and business matters And establishing a reputation through app launches

16:20

And collaborations with mission agencies In the end all I could do in the system

16:26

Was ask permission I discovered that there were hundreds of rights holders

16:32

And thousands of translations within the system Forming individual agreements for each translation

16:38

Proved to be a very tedious process It meant having to connect with numerous rights holders

16:44

Explain my use case And try to convince them of its value In return they would present their own conditions

16:52

Including reporting requirements on the number of users And in some cases demand royalties and payment

16:58

Or even collect personal data from users Obtaining permissions for all the world's translations

17:06

Would be an incredibly expensive endeavour Due to the royalty payments alone

17:11

Moreover it would take decades to navigate and finalise agreements

17:16

For such a large number of translations The average back and forth email exchange

17:21

When seeking permission can take months As a result there are only a handful of organisations in the world

17:29

That have managed to include a substantial number of translations in their apps

17:34

Bible .com in particular stands out as the platform That has the largest collection of translations

17:41

Because they've been active since the early days of the iPhone They've had the time to establish those agreements

17:48

And have grown to such prominence That new translations often approach them for inclusion

17:55

For any other developer starting from scratch It's a difficult task As they lack the recognition and legal status

18:03

Necessary to easily secure such permissions So it was actually when

18:08

I had reached the point of Starting to secure access to translations myself That I decided

18:14

I didn't want to I didn't want to be part of the commercialisation And restricting of access to scripture

18:20

And so I had a decision to make Should I invest many more years In attempting to secure translations for my apps?

18:29

Likely facing numerous rejections And demanding reporting requirements That conflicted with privacy concerns

18:36

It would only make my apps less efficient and more complex Consuming an enormous amount of time

18:42

It seemed like a complete waste of my efforts Instead I pondered whether I should spend my time

18:49

Advocating for change And promoting the free sharing of scripture As Jesus commanded

18:54

For me the choice was clear Rather than getting entangled in contractual obligations

19:00

With various bible societies I resolved to devote my time to advocating for change

19:05

And that's when I started the website Let's Copy Church Which you can find at copy .church

19:11

One of my first initiatives Was a page that explains the restrictive nature of these licenses

19:18

I delved into the licenses Of the most popular modern English translations And compared them

19:24

Coming up with an objective scoring system Based on their legal text This scoring system offered a clear depiction

19:32

Of what you could and couldn't do With these translations Contrasting them with openly licensed

19:38

Or public domain translations By doing so People could understand the stark differences

19:45

Between commercial translations And those freely available During the creation of this website

19:51

And while discussing these matters in my newsletters A friend of mine mentioned a book called

19:57

The Dorian Principle By Conley Owens The subtitle immediately caught my attention

20:02

A biblical response To the commercialization of Christianity It aligned perfectly with the topics

20:09

I had begun addressing myself Around the same time My church was considering using a paid platform

20:15

For discipleship courses And we were discussing its potential usefulness After a brief evaluation of its content

20:23

I noticed its high price And more strikingly The language used to market it

20:30

The slogans and marketing tactics Mirrored those employed By profit -driven businesses

20:37

Phrases like Pricing made simple And unlimited means unlimited

20:42

And choose the best plan for your needs And they even featured discounts

20:47

Like 50 % off It was disturbing To see how similar These marketing strategies were

20:54

To those of any other commercial venture Solely focused on making money

20:59

It was at that point I began speaking out Not only about licensing issues But also about how ministry itself

21:07

Has become commercialized Throughout my endeavors I worked tirelessly To make my works freely accessible

21:14

Removing barriers whenever possible Meanwhile Other organizations erected paywalls

21:20

And sought to extract money from people I knew it was wrong But I couldn't quite articulate why

21:26

I would look to scripture Finding passages like Don't muzzle the ox while it treads out the grain

21:32

And a worker deserves their wages So financing ministry Was certainly a biblical thing

21:37

But I also knew Trying to profit from ministry Was inconsistent

21:42

With the spirit of the gospel And with what Paul was trying to convey Both Paul and Jesus Had demonstrated a willingness to give freely

21:51

Yet these websites and services Were priced and marketed In ways that were unnecessary

21:58

So reading the Dorian principle Was a breath of fresh air Suddenly everything fell into place

22:04

It connected all the pieces of the puzzle I had been grappling with for years deep inside This principle helped me articulate

22:12

What I had been sensing all along While I am concerned about How various forms of ministry

22:18

Have been commercialized My primary focus remains on scripture I believe that the commercialization

22:25

And restriction of God's word Poses the greatest challenge for the church Scripture, after all, belongs to God We even refer to it as the word of God Is it

22:38

God's or not? If it belongs to God Then it should be freely shared And no one has the right to commercialize