3. Keith Foskey | The Calvinism on Luther | Open Air Theology Conference 2024

Open Air Theology

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

4. Jeremiah Nortier | Calvinism in Tribulation | Open Air Theology Conference 2024

00:05

You have your copy of God's Word, I want to invite you to turn to Ephesians chapter 2 and hold your place at verse 1

00:14

Getting a little bit of feedback up here before we read

00:25

I want to Offer a few words of thanks. I want to thank the conference organizers particularly

00:33

Jeffrey and hats for And Braden, I'm sorry Not only am

00:42

I honored to speak alongside of them, but I have come to call them friends I met them last year at the conference and I'm very blessed to get to have gotten to know them

00:53

I want to thank the Lord for opening doors of ministry, especially in this last year much of which came through humor

01:01

I said, you know the bowtie has done a lot of things opened a lot of doors

01:07

They're funny videos and things like that, but I'm not clowning around today.

01:13

There may be a little humor, but it won't be a joke and I do want to explain the title of today's message before we read the title is the

01:23

Calvinism of Luther well Last year when we did the shadows to substance conference.

01:31

I wasn't a speaker last year I was just doing my podcast But I was talking to Jeffrey During one of the breaks and he mentioned that they were going to do a

01:40

Calvinism conference this year And he he just said what would you talk about if you wanted to come and speak and I said well

01:46

I want to talk about the Calvinism of Luther and as I sort of lit up and oh, well, that sounds interesting But I want to say off the bat that the title itself is a click bait

01:57

Title if you don't know what that is You're probably not into YouTube and all that stuff like me but you put things out there just to get people's attention and right before we started

02:07

I Hope I always post picture of my notes. I have these very colorful kind of odd -looking sermon notes and I post pictures of them online and the title by itself has already got a lot of people interested because their first a cow

02:21

Luther wasn't a Calvinist. I know But you clicked Right, like like like that was the purpose the entire title is anachronistic because when we talk about Luther, we're talking about someone who was born in 1483 and Calvin was not born until 1509

02:43

And I got to thinking about that in a sort of just comparative way. I was born in 1980

02:49

My daughter was born in 2011. Sorry 2012. My wife's gonna not be happy about that But my

02:59

Daughter and I are about the same difference in age as Luther was to Calvin and so to talk about the

03:07

Calvinism of Luther is is Anachronistic, but what I want to show today and what

03:13

I hope to convince you all of is That they shared an anthropology which in many ways

03:22

Was influenced by their spiritual ancestor Augustine now

03:28

Andrew has already talked about that some Earlier today and I'm going to seek to simply expand on some of what he has already said

03:36

But understand this my goal today is not necessarily to convince you of Calvinism There will be other men who come and do a wonderful job

03:45

But my goal is simply to convince you that there was a unity of Anthropology among our reformed

03:53

Ancestors that was actually shared by the church prior to the

03:58

Reformation and that we have a historic Anthropology of the nature of man in his fallen condition that we can look to and say this is what the church has taught about this subject and Therefore we can have confidence in What we believe as not just simply being some wild -eyed view from a 16th century

04:23

French Expositor but rather we are holding to the anthropology of the church which has been held

04:32

Now lo these many centuries. So with that being said I invite you to open your

04:37

Bibles again stamp Well, I'm not in church. I my church stands to read the word if you'd like to stand you're welcome

04:42

But I'm gonna read chapter 2 Verses 1 to 3 and this is reading from the

04:59

English Standard Version and You were dead in The trespasses and sins in which you once walked following the course of this world

05:13

Following the prince of the power of the air The spirit that is now at work in the sons of disobedience

05:20

Among whom we all once lived in the passions of our flesh carrying out the desires of the body and the mind and were by nature children of wrath like the rest of mankind

05:37

Our Father and our God we come to you in Jesus name and we ask now that even now you would give us

05:44

Your Holy Spirit to understand what we are about to hear For we know that apart from the

05:50

Spirit we can do nothing apart from the Spirit We can know nothing and apart from the Spirit. We will not be able to understand or apply

05:58

What we learn Lord we are completely dependent upon you

06:03

I Thank you for my brothers who have already preached for brother

06:08

Claude and for his passion for brother Andrew and his professorial presentation

06:17

And I pray now Lord that I would seek to simply dig a little deeper Into the history of this important subject.

06:24

I Pray that you would keep me from error as I preach your word And I pray that your people would be edified and Lord if there be even one here who has not yet Named the name of Christ who has not yet bowed the knee to the

06:39

Savior That you would do that work that only you can do and bring them the gift of regeneration which leads to life

06:47

We pray this in Christ's name Amen one person who

07:01

I did forget to thanks or to give thanks to as I was thanking perhaps and and Braden and Jeffrey, I want to thank dr.

07:09

White who is here with us dr. White has been very helpful over the years and being an instructor and Friend to me and I'm very grateful for The times that I have gotten to spend with him even the awkward times where I've sat and watched him eat

07:25

So if you don't know that story I'll be happy to tell you later

07:34

So I want to share with you some dates that are important I've already given you one and that was 1483 if you're familiar with the old tune about Columbus in 1492

07:46

Columbus sailed the ocean blue well about a decade before that Martin Luther was born in 1483 and then in 1505 as he was returning home from University he was caught in a storm and In that storm as many of you probably know who are somewhat familiar with Luther's life as he was caught in that storm he thought he was going to die and So in the moment where he thought his life was going to come to an end

08:16

He found himself afraid and so he called out not to God or to Jesus, but rather to st.

08:22

Anne and He said st. Anne if you save me, I will become a monk

08:30

Much to the chagrin of his father who had paid for him to go to university and get an education

08:39

Well, it was a few years later he did become a monk and in 1517 he published what became known as the 95 theses

08:50

Every year at our church we celebrate October 31st 1517 We celebrate it as Reformation Day not because that's really when the

08:59

Reformation began But it's a moment in time that we can look to and be thankful for it's a moment of time that we can say here's here's a watershed moment in the history of our faith and we can be thankful for what happened there and just remind you in 1517 when

09:15

Luther published the 95 theses He was 34 years old

09:22

Calvin was eight a Few years later in 1521 came the

09:31

Imperial diet of worms, which my children love to call the diet of worms and That is where Luther gave his speech in Different scholars have presented it in different ways.

09:47

Sometimes it's the very bold speech here. I stand and Some say he was more reserved here.

09:56

I stand I can do no other God help me Amen, and I would imagine that may be fairly accurate understanding that it was only as Andrew mentioned earlier only a century before that Jan hus at the

10:14

Council of Constance was condemned for some of the very things that Luther had taught and Was not given the safe passage that he was promised but rather was taken out and was burned

10:27

Luther knowing what could happen and potentially would happen still stood for truth and Luther said a lot of things that I disagree with and much of his theology

10:39

I would repudiate but on the core issues of the faith,

10:45

I believe we stand together and I will say this Luther is my hero

10:52

Not because he was perfect But because he took a stand for the Word of God Certainly many other dates could be mentioned in the life of Luther But I want to share with you just one more and that is

11:11

December of 1525 It was in December of that year that Luther published his response to the writings of a man named

11:20

Desiderius Erasmus Erasmus had written a work on the freedom of the will de libero arbitrio

11:29

Which means of free will? Luther responded with de servo arbitrio on the bondage of the will

11:40

This would become to Luther such an important work that later in his life when he was talking or rather Excuse me writing a letter to Wolfgang Capito he said he saw no other of his writings other than the bondage of the will and The catechism that was worthy to continue to be published

12:03

This is amazing considering the voluminous amount that Luther wrote

12:10

It's estimated that he published new writings every few weeks. I I had the opportunity to interview on my show a

12:18

Group of Lutheran pastors just a few weeks ago And one of them from the UK said it's estimated that that at one point in Luther's life.

12:27

He was publishing every two weeks Which is just an amazing amount of writing

12:33

Especially when you consider the fact that he did not have a MacBook but he was rather writing with a quill pen and ink and I want to say this because of Luther's prolific writing

12:47

It is sometimes hard to nail down exactly what his position is on certain issues

12:55

Because when speaking of an issue in one area, he may speak on it in another area and sound like he's contradicting himself

13:01

I don't know if you've ever had that problem Where you'll say something in one context and say something in another context and someone might think you're contradicting yourself

13:08

Well, imagine if you wrote all the time and you were constantly publishing things Therefore some of what

13:14

I say today about Luther. I'm I'm I know for certain someone's going to say well you misrepresented

13:19

Luther Well, I want you to know From the very bottom of my heart.

13:25

I have no intention of misrepresenting Luther at all I would hope that if he were sitting in the audience

13:31

Although he would be very confused. I Believed So why was the bondage of the will this work that Luther wrote so important to him?

13:52

Well, it was important because he understood what it meant in regard to theological accuracy a

14:00

Right understanding of God is essential to theology earlier we had

14:07

Brother Claude come and talk to us about that very thing We need to have a right understanding of God we all need to have our

14:16

Isaiah moment where we recognize that God is holy holy holy and I am

14:22

NOT NOT NOT and so a right theology begins with a right understanding of God, but it also includes a right understanding of man and Luther believed that to err in regard to the issue of human free will was dangerous to the soul

14:47

He said this he said a man cannot be thoroughly humbled till he knows that his salvation lies altogether beyond and out of his own strength counsels desires wills and works till he depends

15:03

Absolutely upon the counsel the will and the work of another and that other is

15:09

God One cannot read the works of Luther without coming to the conclusion that he was convinced of a monergistic view of salvation

15:23

Monergism simply means that there is one who works in Salvation we do not have a synergistic view where two or more work together to accomplish a particular task but we have a monergistic view where God alone is doing the work even as It were the work of giving us a gift of faith

15:50

Now having said all that it is important to understand that Luther did not hold to all of Calvin's views and Modern Lutheranism will be very quick to tell you that As I said,

16:09

I love Luther and I love Lutherans. I Know that sounds kind of a strange thing to say, but I sometimes think they don't like us.

16:23

I Make jokes about that with Hans Feeney. Who's the the guy from Lutheran satire?

16:28

He is a wonderful brother in the Lord But I tease I say

16:33

I say we like you guys, but y 'all don't like us So what

16:39

I want to do on on their behalf if I could take just a moment in the message is

16:44

I would like to simply address The issue that separates modern

16:49

Lutherans from Calvinists and where the issue really lies Before we get to the heart of Luther's theology

16:57

I want to on their behalf say well, this is what they would say is the dividing line between us and they would say

17:07

That the reason why they reject Calvinism is because of double predestination however, when

17:19

Describing it and I have listened to several of them describe it When describing it it seems as if they are defining double predestination as something called equal

17:31

Ultimacy which means that God does the same positive act in election that he does in reprobation that God expresses the same amount of power in Damning someone that he does in saving someone that's equal ultimacy.

17:50

And by the way, that is not What Calvinists should believe? And by the way, having just said that I paused

18:04

Because some of you may believe that and I'm Simply going to say that there is a debate in Calvinistic circles as to the method by which

18:17

God brings about reprobation But I am convinced that reprobation is an act of passing over or preterition not an act of Creating evil in the heart because the evil is already there

18:38

But it's important to recognize that while Luther and Calvin shared a monergistic view the resultant systems which arose from each man's theology

18:46

Do have distinctions especially in light of the fact that both of the men's systems were then Carried on by their followers and their followers had different ideas

18:54

Of course Calvin was succeeded by Theodore Beza and Luther by Melanchthon and both of them put their own thoughts into the systems

19:07

But if you were to ask a Lutheran and I and this is actually I'm going to quote now from the pastor of Holy Cross Lutheran Church He has his own

19:15

YouTube page. He does an ask the pastor Series on his

19:21

YouTube page and this is what he says in regard to the difference between Calvinism and Lutheranism in regard to election he says this and By the way,

19:32

I asked Hans if this was right and he said yes So if it's wrong y 'all get on to Hans and not me

19:39

I Hope it's okay that I told y 'all that No, I got with him beforehand

19:46

I said hey, I'm gonna say this is this right Does this does this rightly reflect what you believe and he said yes

19:55

God elects men to salvation in view of Christ's merits which are only received by faith God didn't elect anyone by an absolute decree

20:02

But he only elected people in view of Christ and his merits and Christ is only apprehended by faith

20:07

We don't add faith as a cause of election We add it because it's simply part of the order

20:13

God has established No one is considered in Christ in the scriptures unless by faith This does not answer the question of why some and not others because faith is a work of God in man's heart

20:24

Not of man. All this does is simply acknowledge that the scripture teaches and defends against the

20:30

Calvinism Or the Calvinian absolute decree That was a long sentence.

20:35

So let me see if I can help you make sense. They don't like the word decree They don't they don't like the idea of double predestination

20:46

But they have to admit that faith is a gift and they have to admit

20:51

That the faith that is a gift comes from God and that it's not wrought in the hearts of men

20:59

Because they share the anthropology that Calvin shared They recognize man's deadness and sin his inability to do anything good toward God and yet at the same time

21:09

They know that not all men have faith And so they have to leave it there and simply say we're not going to go any further

21:16

God has elected he has predestined but he is not predestined anyone to hell and therefore in my and This is gonna sound a little unfair.

21:25

I love them to death, but in my estimation They want to have their cake and eat it, too That's the meanest thing

21:33

I'm gonna say all day because I think they want to have their cake and eat it too They want to be able to say God elects but not

21:40

To hell God doesn't choose who's going to hell. He just choose who's going to heaven. Well That's having your cake and eating it too and sometimes we're accused of the other side we're accused of being overly logical

21:54

And there oftentimes they will appeal to mystery well, well these things are left to the mystery of God and that's their language not mine

22:00

That's a language that they use and therefore this is where the challenge comes in but again my only point in all of this is to simply say that both of us are starting at the same point and that's man has an

22:10

Absolute inability to do any of this on his own Even modern Lutherans will say man cannot come to faith

22:17

Apart from a work of the Spirit of God in his heart where the Spirit gives him that faith

22:26

You see that's the key that's what brings this together that's the unifying anthropological understanding

22:34

So again, even in affirming against the Calvinistic view of predestination they still affirm that faith is a work of God not something that is brought about by man and This is where Luther and Calvin's Anthropology converge

22:52

And the bondage of man in sin and the inability of man to believe apart from God's grace

23:00

Now with that being said I want to now share What three things

23:06

I believe are most consistent Between Calvin and Luther in regard to this teaching so if you're taking notes or you want to write something down this might be the point where you would pull out your pen because I'm going to give you three thoughts to consider

23:20

These are the consistencies in anthropology that we find between Luther and Calvin I'll give you the three if you want to write them down and then we'll go through each one of them.

23:32

Number one. They both affirmed emphatically the doctrine of original sin

23:38

Number two, they both rejected absolutely the concept of free will and number three they both affirmed

23:50

Salvation sola gratia, which is the Latin for by grace alone

23:57

Now with those three ideas I want to now lead you through a few thoughts that they have written and then

24:03

I'm going to read from Calvin's Institutes I'm going to read from the bondage of the will and Also, I'm going to read a short portion of a book that because what's interesting is

24:14

Luther and Erasmus had his Luther had his debate with Erasmus over the freedom of the will well

24:19

Calvin also had a writing which was a debate against a man Named Albert Piccius and Albert Piccius had written on this subject and Calvin wrote against him

24:30

And so it's interesting as we heard Andrew talk about earlier How often this subject comes up and every generation has their debaters.

24:40

You have Pelagius and Augustine you have Luther and you have Erasmus you have

24:45

Calvin and Pigius and then later Arminius and you have white and flowers

24:53

Every generation has their Has their debaters

25:01

So, let's look first at original sin When you say the word original sin in a church today

25:10

You might get looked at with some confusion because not everyone even understands what you mean Oftentimes when you say original sin people think you're talking simply about the sin of Adam in his original state

25:24

But that is not the doctrine of original sin That is simply Adam's sin the doctrine of original sin is that Adam sin has brought a corruption to all of his posterity

25:37

All of his posterity refers to all of his descendants And by the way that includes all of you

25:46

You are all born of Adam Backed in a couple of weeks.

25:51

I'm going to be doing another debate I'm going to be debating a young man named redeemed zoomer Y 'all know who that is on the subject of evolution

26:00

Because he's a Christian who believes in evolution and so we're going to have a debate on that subject and I believe one of the major Issues and I'm sure he's going to hear this so he'll be able to at least prepare himself

26:11

I believe one of the major issues is that in evolution if You join hands with your ancestor and he joins hands with his ancestor and he joins hands with his ancestor eventually

26:23

Someone is going to be holding hands with someone who's not human If evolution is true

26:30

At some point there's going to be a step back in the chain where you go from human to non -human

26:37

Well beloved that is not biblical anthropology Biblical anthropology is that man is a special creation of god created in his image

26:47

And that man in his fall represented all of humankind and what we call the

26:53

Federal headship of adam where he was the representative head of all mankind And in the same way where we have a federal government where if our federal government decides to go to war

27:02

Guess what? We all go to war if our federal government decides to do something We all do it because they represent us and when adam sinned

27:12

Against god he sinned in a federal sense. He sinned as our representative and now his sin has affected us all

27:24

That is the doctrine of original sin and and even further is how much it has affected it has affected us to the point that we now are morally unable

27:39

To do good toward god apart from a work of grace By the way, this is something interesting among lutherans if you ask lutherans about free will they will say we have free will beneath us

27:52

But not above us They will say we are free in those things that are

27:58

Choices like I was free to go to lunch today or go to the food truck or whatever I have freedom in those things that are beneath us.

28:05

But when it comes to the things that are above us I am bound I don't have freedom in that why because I have a moral inability which comes from what?

28:16

it comes from the Fall and I have inherited that inability

28:23

All right, so that's the doctrine of original sin. There's more to it. But for time's sake i'm hoping most of you understand it at least

28:31

And if you have questions, I'd be happy to talk with you later So Is it right to say that luther affirmed original sin?

28:38

Absolutely in the bondage of the will he said this he said seeing that we are All under sin and damnation through the one offense of the one man adam

28:46

How can we attempt anything which is not sin and which is not damnable?

28:52

So he addresses right there. We are in adam and in adam fallen

28:59

And in calvin's institutes He says this he says we thus see that the impurity of parents is transmitted to their children

29:05

So that all without exception are originally depraved The commencement of this depravity will not be found until we ascend to the first parent of all as the fountainhead

29:16

We must therefore hold it for certain that in regard to human nature adam was not merely a progenitor

29:23

But as it were a root in that according by his corruption the whole human race was deservedly

29:32

Vitiated and that word vitiated means spoiled or impaired Calvin writes a little longer

29:39

But you hear what he's saying through the one sin of adam all of humankind was spoiled or impaired

29:51

So did both of them affirm original sin absolutely And because of this they both rejected absolute free will

30:02

Or what might be referred to as libertarian free will and i'll seek in a moment to give an understanding of that Because if you read the bondage of the will

30:11

I mean the very title itself proves Luther did not believe in a free will the the the title of the book

30:18

But I do want to read a quote he said this he says original sin Does not allow free will to do anything except sin and be damned

30:28

Hear that again Which is original sin does not allow free will to do anything

30:35

But sin and be damned Now again, you may not agree with that You may not be a calvinist today and I may not be convincing you of that truth

30:44

But I hope that i'm showing you that's what luther believed Again, that's my purpose today

30:49

Is to say this is the anthropology of luther and it was the same anthropology of calvin Because when calvin wrote against pigeous and i'm not sure i'm saying that correctly

31:00

Albert's, uh, it's it's p -i -g -h -i -u -s And there's not a google translator alive that could give me a right answer as to how it's supposed to sound

31:09

So i'm just going with pigeous But pigeous

31:15

I want you to hear what he said Because There's possibility some of you never even heard of him

31:22

But I want you to hear the arguments he made against free will And I want you to think about some of the arguments.

31:28

Maybe you've heard against calvin. I'm sorry. He was arguing against calvinism, he was arguing against uh sovereign election and the the the he was arguing for free will listen what he says

31:42

He says that if we do not have free will It contradicts common sense it destroys all morality and discipline it turns men into animals and monsters

31:53

It makes god the author of sin. It perverts his justice into cruelty and his wisdom into folly

32:00

It sounds like a soteriology 101 post And hey Layton will be here in a little while I ain't trying to be ugly, but that sounds exactly what they're saying.

32:10

By the way, y 'all know he was coming Yeah, yeah layton flyers will be here he's coming to support the guy who's debating dr.

32:16

White be nice What's that?

32:27

Why well, yeah Calvin responded to pigeous's work

32:37

Much more eloquently than luther responded to erasmus Again, I like luther because luther liked to really have colorful language

32:49

And I like that. I like the fact that he didn't mince words. He said it like it was but calvin was the scholars scholar

33:01

And on this subject he wrote this and and I Excuse the use of latin um

33:08

You will understand the words, but I I just for a moment. I'm not going to read it all in latin

33:13

But there will be a latin portions In regard to this calvin said man has arbitrium spontaneum

33:21

So that he willingly and by choice does evil without compulsion from without and therefore he incurs guilt

33:27

But owing to native depravity his will is so graven to sin that it always chooses evil hence

33:34

Spontaneity or spontaneity and enslavement may exist together The voluntas is spontaneity

33:41

But not libera it is not co -octa yet serva translated. The will is self -directed, but it's not free

33:50

It can do what it pleases but the problem is what it pleases to do is sin So if someone asks you do you believe in free will you can say no

34:02

Well, I mean you can say whatever you want. I will say no But I will say this

34:07

I believe man makes choices And they are legitimate choices, but that they are choices that are bound by a will which is in bondage to sin

34:20

That was calvin's point Yes. Yes. Certainly man is self -directed.

34:26

The problem with that is the self part Is Yes, you're self -directed but yourself is bad

34:40

The will does what it wants But until it is liberated by the spirit of god

34:48

It will not want the things of god Isn't that very similar to what

34:54

I just said about lutherans today who say we can do we are free to things below us

35:00

But we are not free in things That are above us See there is more commonality between calvin and luther maybe than we like to admit

35:09

Yes, they differed on the table. Yes, they differed in many other areas, but on the issue of anthropology on the issue of the nature of man in sin

35:21

There was much agreement so both affirmed original sin both

35:30

Rejected absolute or libertarian free will And finally both affirmed salvation by grace alone luther and most modern lutherans affirm sola gratia

35:51

Calvin affirmed interestingly enough calvin affirmed What he would call prevenient grace

35:59

The problem is later The remonstrance who were the followers of arminius that andrew told us about they would take a different use of the word prevenient grace for the arminian

36:13

Oh, and by the way, here's something interesting Classical arminianism

36:20

Holds the same view of the will of man As calvin and luther

36:27

Because they all believe the will is bound Until god sets it free The only one who didn't believe the will was really bound is you have to go into pelagianism

36:40

And we're going to talk about that in a moment, but for now, let me simply say this arminians believe in the bondage of the will in the sense that they believe that god has to do something the difference is they believe god has done that for Everyone and he has preveniently graced everyone or as I think dr

36:58

White was the one who said peanut butter like he smears it on everything Maybe is that yes? Like like it just sort of goes on everybody and grace sort of goes everywhere and doesn't save anyone but rather makes men savable

37:12

That's not what calvin meant by prevenient grace Calvin's view of prevenient grace was much more in line with what we would talk about as effectual grace that the grace comes and Affects the heart the grace comes and changes the soul

37:38

Calvin said this Conversion Is the work of god alone?

37:49

Could that be the sixth sola? No, it's not necessary because it's already in there

37:55

Because if you affirm salvation sola gratia You are affirming that conversion

38:02

Is by god alone Because you're confirming you're affirming that it has to be by grace

38:09

It cannot be a cooperative thing it is by grace alone

38:16

Therefore if you affirm the five solas in their intention not in some odd Reinterpretation, but if you affirm the five solas in their intention, you will affirm a monergistic

38:31

Regeneration Calvin said this he said the will is prepared by the lord

38:42

The will is prepared by the lord. So this is the issue

38:51

We have these two men these ancestors in the faith luther and calvin a generation apart

39:02

They Came to some different conclusions about various things but on this issue they were in agreement

39:09

They were consistent and why? Why were luther and calvin consistent one is because they had a common scriptural commitment

39:20

They were both committed to scripture Both were masters of the languages

39:26

The heart that beat within them was the heart of sola scriptura They both applied similar hermeneutics and therefore came to similar conclusions

39:39

Even though they debated a little bit about what is means lord's table.

39:45

This is my body nobody A little bit of debate there.

39:54

Sorry, that was inside. That was inside baseball. Sorry It's like They had a common scriptural commitment, but they also had a common theological heritage

40:04

And I want to say this our opponents in this debate today will often

40:11

Look to what i'm about to say as the problem But I look to it not as the problem but as a positive thing

40:21

Because I am willing to say That yes luther and calvin had a tremendous theological influence from one who came a thousand years before them

40:29

And his name was augustus. I'm, sorry augustine Yes Augustine did influence calvin and luther if you read their writings you can come to no other conclusion

40:44

And the problem with that for some Is that they will argue that?

40:54

augustine himself Introduced many Theological novums many new theologies into the church

41:05

And they will say that no one before him believed in original sin. No one before him believed in The fallen nature of man to the point where he was unable to do these things

41:17

I was appreciative what andrew said earlier about the fact that the first three or 400 years of the church were more invested in the debate over christology than anthropology

41:25

That does not mean that they didn't discuss it or talk about it But certainly the major councils within the early church and the writings of the early church did deal a lot with the person and work of jesus christ

41:38

And it was those issues with philageus that brought about the systematization of augustine's theology

41:50

But again If we look historically History has sided the church has sided with augustine

42:01

Not out of fear Not out of having been coerced or not out of having been fooled

42:09

But because in the vast majority of instances when this subject has been has arose They have found his arguments to be most consistent with scripture

42:21

So, why do we look to augustine because augustine was looking to paul And making the very same arguments that he was making

42:32

In fact, it was after augustine and philageus

42:39

By the way philageus was condemned as a heretic But his teaching didn't go away as andrew mentioned earlier.

42:46

It moved into more of what was known as a semi philagianism And then what bb warfield would call a semi semi philagianism

42:56

In his book, by the way, we want the reference. So that's the book the plan of salvation by bb warfield But there was a council that took place this council took place in france in ad 529 so It was after the death of both augustine and philageus

43:20

And the council was known as the council of orange. It was actually the second council of orange And they established 25 canons of teaching now.

43:31

This was not an ecumenical council This was not a council that we would look to like the council of nicaea or calcedon or any of those

43:37

This was a more local council but yet at the same time they knew there was an important issue with which to deal and the issue was

43:43

How do we understand the nature of man? How do we understand our? Anthropology and understand this is a thousand years

43:53

Before luther wrote the bondage of the will There are 25 canons.

44:01

I don't have time to read them all to you. And i'm sure you wouldn't want me to if I did But I do want to read to you one of them

44:08

The first one And by the way, I don't agree with everything that the council of orange decided

44:14

So if you come to me later and say oh, well, they said this about baptism or this about this. Yes I'm, not saying it was perfect.

44:20

But what i'm showing here is a consistent anthropology through history, right? That's my point

44:26

And I want you to hear What was written? in 529 if anyone denies

44:37

That it is the whole man That is both body and soul That was changed for the worse through the offense of adam's sin

44:46

But believes that the freedom of the soul remains unimpaired and that only the body is subject to corruption

44:52

He is deceived by the error of pelagius and contradicts the scripture so again

45:04

Why? Did calvin and luther agree? Was it because they had been

45:11

Unfortunately influenced by the bad teaching of augustine Or was it because this teaching is what the scripture teaches?

45:19

and the People of god have recognized it down through the ages My argument is simple

45:28

I believe that history bears out what we believe about the nature of man

45:34

Does it raise questions? Absolutely. Do we have to wrestle with tensions about freedom and responsibility?

45:43

Absolutely But when we begin to give these things up When we begin to say well, maybe these things don't matter

45:53

We open ourselves up to so many other dangerous things so many other dangerous heresies

46:00

And so we should with calvin and with luther and with augustine affirm what the bible teaches

46:07

That you were dead In your trespasses and sins which you once walked in And you are by nature

46:20

Children of wrath but god who is rich in mercy

46:29

For the great love with which he loved us By grace, you have been saved through faith and that is not

46:38

Your doing But it is the gift of god Not a result of works lest any man should boast for we are his workmanship created in christ jesus for good works

46:52

That he prepared beforehand That we should walk in them

47:00

Beloved this is a biblical anthropology Proclaimed by our ancestors and one that I believe should be held by us all

47:09

Let us pray father, I thank you for your word And pray even now lord that we will see that The teachings of our ancestors have great value even to today and the battles that were fought before and continue to be fought now

47:28

Lord our battles over foundational issues And lord often we are accused of having an un

47:38

Balanced fascination with your sovereignty and yet lord we would say there are those with an unbalanced fascination with freedom of the will

47:46

Lord help us instead of both of those To have a right view of you

47:52

And a right view of god or a right view of man And lord forgive us where we err