Was the Cross Cosmic Child Abuse? | Michael Horton
3 views
Are Progressive Christians correct when they claim that the cross of Christ was essentially a form of cosmic child abuse. To answer this question, I chatted with Dr. Michael Horton, who teaches Systematic Theology and Apologetics at Westminster Seminary. He's also one of the hosts of The White Horse Inn, which is a great podcast! Check out his response :)
Here's the full interview: https://youtu.be/fEkhXxF1Zfs
Check out our Wise Disciple merch: https://wisedisciple.store/
Want a BETTER way to communicate your Christian faith? Check out this video: https://youtu.be/OHC7Zpgvq6Q
Check out my website: www.wisedisciple.org
OR Book me as a speaker at your next event: https://wisedisciple.org/reserve/
Check out my latest Q&A where I take your questions: https://youtu.be/n_Hiq0GZOnA
Got a question in the area of theology, apologetics, or engaging the culture for Christ? Send them and I'll answer on an upcoming podcast: https://wisedisciple.org/ask/
- 00:00
- Again sort of anticipating what progressive Christians will say or progressive people who are taking a progressive theology will say
- 00:07
- One of the things that they really say a lot is that the cross was essentially a form of cosmic child abuse where a wrathful vengeful bloodthirsty
- 00:19
- God has Demanded I think you said this at the top of the the interview demanded his ounce of flesh, you know to satisfy his wrath
- 00:29
- Can you explain why exactly that is way off? Sure Nate, um, well it
- 00:38
- It's first of all, um a pretty faulty view of the Trinity You know you have
- 00:47
- God the Father God the Son and God the Holy Spirit all being equal three persons But one in essence they all have the same attributes of justice mercy love
- 00:58
- Holiness and so forth, but they they they are distinct persons and The Son is
- 01:08
- No lower than the Father in the you know that there there is no higher and lower in the
- 01:14
- Trinity. They are all equal And so the Son and the Father Agree together in the councils of eternity before the world was even created
- 01:27
- Knowing that we would fall into sin agreed to For the son to to have a bride be given a bride chosen from The foundation before the foundation of the world by the father as a gift to the son.
- 01:44
- Here is his bride Even as he's being given this bride by the father he knows
- 01:52
- What's going to happen to her and that he's going? To come and save her he doesn't have to he could he could he could say, you know,
- 02:02
- I The father and the son could could have decided not to say
- 02:08
- Father could have decided not to give a bride to the son But that all humanity would be judged and maybe start another human race but instead
- 02:19
- Instead the father gave the son a people and the son Voluntarily Accepted the burden as well as the delight that came with that Isaiah 53 again.
- 02:33
- He He will see his seed and be satisfied Because he poured out his life as a guilt offering for sin
- 02:42
- He will he will see the work he even from eternity. He he was looking forward
- 02:49
- To becoming flesh in order to save human beings people from every tribe and kindred and tongue and people and nation because he knew
- 03:01
- He knew what would be the result of his work. So You have to start start with the
- 03:09
- Trinity's idea of of God the father kind of beating up this this man Jesus or No, his his poor son
- 03:17
- Jesus said in John 10 No one Takes my life from me
- 03:23
- So let's get that straight. No one's no one's going to kill me. No one's going to you know
- 03:28
- I'm not gonna be I'm not gonna be a hapless victim here. I'm going to give my life
- 03:35
- Sure, I'll be arrested. I'll be handed over and so forth, but Jesus didn't say a word. He didn't defend himself
- 03:43
- And Is that powerlessness? No, that's power. That's Jesus being in control of his destiny and Saying I am going to the cross.
- 03:52
- I'm not going to fight this thing. This is why I've come into the world and So no one takes my life from me.
- 04:00
- I Have the authority to lay it down Mm -hmm, and I have the authority to take it back up again.
- 04:07
- So we're not talking here about any kind of You know whipping post any idea of a pound of flesh
- 04:18
- Furthermore the father so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son not the father was so angry
- 04:26
- He beat up his son But the father so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son.
- 04:34
- You don't have an angry dad right and a a Brutalized victimized son
- 04:41
- You have the father so loving the world that he's giving his only begotten son and his only begotten son
- 04:48
- Saying no one takes my life from me. I lay it down and I'll take it back up again
- 04:53
- Do you think also this kind of way of characterizing it? slips in the idea of Unitarianism, which is to suggest that God isn't the one going to the cross that it's actually
- 05:06
- God the father just punishing Somebody else. Yeah, just some dude
- 05:14
- Yeah No, exactly. It's it's God versus man here.
- 05:19
- No, it's it The person who died on the cross the person who bore our sins
- 05:26
- Is God right So, you know R .C. Sproul had that great line
- 05:31
- God God saved us from God Yeah, at least from his wrath from his justice
- 05:41
- But God's love is what? Moved him to save us. And so It's it's it's not that God the son saves us from God the father.