The Economy or Saving Lives - Take Your Pick!

AD Robles

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Shelter -in -place order day three My Vienna sausage rations were running low and so I had to go to the store today.

00:06

It was chaos There were old people everywhere and I don't know

00:12

I just something fell off now.

00:19

I just kidding It was a pleasant trip to the grocery store this morning. I went early there was hardly anybody in the store There were some old people there for sure and the store is pretty well stocked.

00:27

They didn't have any toilet paper They didn't have any canned goods, but besides that I mean pretty much everything else was there

00:33

I was only there for perishables to be honest because when it comes to canned goods and things that you could store

00:38

I probably have three months worth of stuff anyway but Interesting side note to this story.

00:46

There's a there's a person that I'm friends with on social media Who's normally a very level -headed person, but he's been freaking out about this whole thing doom and gloom every single day very angry about young bucks like me that Don't necessarily take this as seriously as he does and I do take it seriously

01:04

I'm just on a little perspective a little balance here because at the end of the day as bad as this thing is

01:11

You know people die every day And I knew that before that this happened people die every flu season the other the other flu season

01:17

We had like 80 ,000 deaths because of the flu and so I'm not saying this is the flu so before you get in the comments

01:23

It's not the flu. I get it, but Let's not lose our heads here of anyway this guy who's talking about how all these guys are just walking around business as usual I was warning people for weeks and months to stock up on food

01:35

Which good for you by the way because when this guy was warning people to stock up on food I I pretty much stock up already

01:41

But I did actually take his advice because I was like you know this is a probably good idea to re -up my stock

01:46

I probably had a month or two's worth of food and through this guy's advice I got about four months worth of food.

01:53

You know maybe not I don't know. It's hard. It's hard to really know, but when you stretch it out. It could probably last a while anyway

01:59

Three months let's just say but anyway the point is though that so good for this guy for warning people that very good

02:06

But the doom and gloom is a little much. He's very mad about people walking around business as usual They're not wearing gloves.

02:12

They're not wearing masks, and then this guy has the audacity This guy has the audacity to say well.

02:17

I'm gonna go to the grocery store today to get some perishables We need some eggs We need some vegetables and stuff like that, and I'm saying to and I'm thinking like where's the line here?

02:25

So you're you're all angry because people are going out going to Home Depot getting stuff that they need for their house and stuff like That you're angry that it's business as usual But yet you have stored food in your house

02:36

And you are going out exposing you and others to this potential killer virus all to get some eggs because you prefer to have eggs

02:43

In the morning why not just eat some Vienna sausages for breakfast instead of eggs like you're used to why?

02:49

And then he said then he bemoaned the fact that people were limiting the amount of eggs you could buy because he said well What the problem is if you limit to per customer then people are just gonna go to multiple stores to get what they want

02:59

They're gonna spread the virus even more, and I'm thinking to myself like Dude, if this is really the black death like you claim, then why don't you seriously hunker down forget the eggs?

03:10

Maybe you don't have an omelet, but you see that's the question here. I'm not mad at him for this I didn't comment on it because because I'm gonna get eggs too if I want some eggs

03:18

You know what I mean, but the thing is where's the line right like he's all pissed off at people Because they're going to Home Depot because they might need a hammer or something and he's going to get

03:29

Let's just face it a luxury item when you have months of stored food in your item in your pantry eggs

03:36

Vegetables things of that nature look these are not luxury items in general I'm just saying if this really is the black death maybe hold off on eggs for a month

03:43

Yeah, I mean, it's not gonna kill you that's the point though There's there's no line here like I asked a question on on on Twitter the yesterday

03:51

I was like where's the line right so that this is a bigger death rate than the flu virus okay granted Let's just say it's 20 times 30 times 50 times more dead deadly than the flu okay, so the question

04:02

What is the cutoff point when do you have to cancel church? When do you have to obey these shelter -in -place?

04:07

Orders from the government and stuff like that and when is it out of line? There is no answer to that question that and that's what

04:13

I said that's my video was about yesterday. It's fine There's so much There's so much out there of people saying you have to go with my standard of what's what's acceptable

04:23

What's essential and things like that, and I'm thinking to myself well who gets to decide? What's essential we cancel essential businesses yet the liquor stores are open the pot stores are open the abortion clinics are open

04:33

You know the sex toy stores are open, and it's like Has the church really bought into that like like we decide if we're essential or not based on what daddy government says like we have

04:43

We really bought into that now again in my video yesterday I said there are good reasons to cancel church, but it's got to be your call

04:51

It's got to be in your hands not daddy government. That's the point, but anyway this video is not supposed to be about that I made a point yesterday about this problem with trying to pit the economy versus saving lives because my argument was that the economy is

05:05

Critical to life. It's critical to human flourishing. It's critical to loving your neighbor and so tanking the economy

05:12

Intentionally, which is what's happening here? I'm not saying that that's their goal although I have a suspicion that for many it is their goal to tank the economy

05:21

Tanking the economy intentionally is a problem. It's it's it's it's showing a disregard for human life

05:27

Let's watch this video together. We'll watch what I said yesterday, and then we'll receive the response Which I think is quite classic so seriously guys the take that That if you care about the stock market and the economy in general that what you're saying is you really don't care that much?

05:42

About life that is one of the stupidest takes Ever and I do mean ever

05:48

I realize that that's a strong statement But it really is it just shows you there's like a disconnect here

05:54

Economics and the economy itself is a part of life when God saves souls for eternity

06:01

He's saving the whole person including that person involved in economic activity

06:06

I think that there will be economic activity in the new heavens and new earth It's not like this dirty thing.

06:12

That's somehow outside of us. No no that we are an economic creature That's right.

06:18

That's that simple and if you need evidence of this There's so much in God's Word not just the law of God, but also the

06:25

New Testament as well How often does God say to the rich don't hold back the workers wages don't?

06:32

Don't don't defraud people don't don't use your power to steal from those who are less fortunate than you

06:39

That's all laws regulating economic activity and God says if you do that You'll be guilty of sin the poor will cry out to him, and he will hold you accountable for that This is just one of the many many many laws

06:51

I could have Quoted here, this is the King James version of the Bible. This is

06:56

Deuteronomy 24 15 each day you shall give him his wages and not let the sun go down in it for he is poor and has his

07:04

Heart on has set his heart on it lest he cry against you to the Lord. He needs it to live

07:09

He needs his wages to live he needs to be able to engage in commerce to live This is part of being human.

07:17

This is part of life Economics and the economy in the state of the economy being open for business so to speak is a matter of human flourishing

07:25

I'm serious though that this is a stupid take Sipping on a working man's beer just because I'm talking about the working man.

07:32

We need to go back to work It's just that simple so so many of us who don't normally work from home or can't work from home

07:39

This virus is serious, but canceling the economy for months is Serious and probably more serious

07:48

I think that's a very level -headed very winsome take and a very obvious take like I I don't get the disconnect between Understanding that the economy being able to earn an income being able to earn a wage

08:01

And provide for your family is not part and parcel of human flourishing. It's it's critical to human life critical being able to exchange labor for goods being able to exchange labor for Housing being able to exchange and the free exchange of that and being open for business in that way

08:19

You can't live without that. That's why there's so much in the Bible about Economics if you notice there are so many parables about economics

08:29

There are so many laws about economics when God comes in judgment against a nation Oftentimes he cites economic sins that they were engaged in Economics is not this dirty disconnected thing from human life and human flourishing and loving your neighbor

08:45

No, it's part and parcel of it. It has to be it just has to be and so yes

08:50

The virus is serious and will cost lives But canceling the economy is serious and probably more serious and probably will cost more lives

08:59

It's just it's really just that simple And so here's here's the guy who comes in and instantly proves my point that there's this weird disconnect

09:08

Is I think this guy's a Christian? I don't know who he is But he's on my Facebook and he took he took offense at what

09:14

I said Which I I can't believe some random person on the internet Thinks I'm stupid or doesn't like me

09:20

He quotes me says this virus is serious, but cancelling the economy is serious and probably more serious There you have it people money is more important than people's lives

09:29

Did I say money is more important than people's lives? You know,

09:34

I could have said it and forgot it's only like a two -minute video Did I say money is more important than people's lives?

09:41

No, I said money is is critical for people's lives Like if you're gonna live you have to be able to have a medium of exchange

09:49

You have to be able to exchange your labor for the goods that you need to survive to provide for your family

09:54

So it's not that money is more important than people's lives Money is critical to people's lives.

10:00

It's part of people's lives So this guy just doesn't understand there's a disconnect in this guy's brain

10:06

Between earning a wage and economics and earning an income and living as a human being

10:12

And that's that's not the biblical view. That's not the biblical view The biblical view is that the economic situation that that you find yourselves in is critical to your life

10:21

It's critical to your life. I think most people understand this, but I just I don't understand this

10:28

Okay, let's continue. He says let's do some math Let's say no matter what 20 % of Americans will be infected by COVID -19.

10:34

That's definitely within the realm of possibility 20 % of 33 333 million is 65 million.

10:41

If we don't cancel non -essential labor, then the virus will spread quickly too quickly It will overload our medical infrastructure like in Italy The death rate there is eight to ten percent if eight percent about the 65 million

10:51

Americans who contract COVID die That's five million people However, we do cancel if we do cancel non -essential labor

10:56

Then the virus will spread slower and our medical infrastructure won't be overrun For countries whose health care systems remain functional the fatality rate is about two percent

11:04

If the same 65 million still get sick in this scenario over a longer period of time and only two percent of them die That's only about one million people who die

11:11

Put simply if we don't cancel anything five million people will probably die at least But at least our economy does better and this is all over within a year.

11:19

We cancel whatever we can Second option we cancel whatever we can and only one million people die our economy tanks and this may last up to two years

11:26

Take your pick five million people dead or more money in your pocket or one million people dead and less money in your pocket

11:31

I think we all know what the Christian answer should be Child, please because this is not the this is not the it's not a zero -sum game here.

11:42

It's not either or it's not either You want five million people to die or you want uh money in your pocket more money in your pocket.

11:49

That's not it Josh, that's not it. So I know that you're you know, you you for some reason this is disconnected in your brain

11:56

But let's think like a big boy here Okay, because the point of this video and the whole point of this thing is is that there is a cost in lives

12:06

Associated with tanking the economy canceling the economy for months and months and months. There's a life cost associated with that as well

12:13

So it's not five million people on this side or one million people and a few extra bucks in your pocket and stuff

12:18

Like that's not the that's not the option And and josh, let me just say this. This is this is the view of an elitist

12:25

This is the view of an elitist i'm not saying I don't know your economic situation But you're thinking like a rich person because people who are really vulnerable right now people that are really vulnerable right now

12:35

Oftentimes have service jobs. That's definitely been canceled office time have service jobs Oftentimes have have jobs that are live paycheck to paycheck and things like that.

12:44

And so a few months of not working for them is brutal Rich people middle class people can probably get by a few months not working

12:53

They could probably figure something out they have people that have a lot of connections or a big network They can probably figure something out

12:59

Like if I get into dire straits, I can talk to my parents I can talk to my grandparents about loans or help and stuff like that and and it's okay for me

13:06

But not everyone's in my situation Some people are isolated. Some people don't have that kind of a network

13:12

Some people don't have the savings to get through months and months of their their job being banned

13:17

I'm not talking about just a few extra bucks in my pocket. I'm talking about entire sectors of the economy banned

13:25

Overnight with just the stroke of a pen you're banned from work guys

13:31

Men are supposed to work Being able to earn an income and provide for your family is critical for a human being

13:38

And entire sectors of this economy have been banned and told to stay home So it's not you just not not just that you can't go to work or your or your or your business has been banned

13:47

It's also you got to stay home You you can't you can't do what you got to do This is this is a really simplistic childish way to view this it's childish josh you're being childish

14:01

The way you put it's not you say put simply it's not simple like this It's not five million deaths or a few extra bucks in your pocket.

14:08

It's five million deaths Okay, let's just say that that happened, right? And then if you cancel the economy

14:16

You can add to that number. I don't know how to calculate the addition to that number But not only are people going to be you know unable to feed their families and again

14:24

I'm, not just even talking about the united states You know how many economies count on the on the on the economic strength of the united states?

14:32

How many countries economies count on the economic strength of the united states that have poor people that have?

14:39

hardly anything Live on less than a dollar a day and stuff like that. They count on our generosity and stuff like that Look if I have a good economy here

14:48

There's a lot more money to give to ethiopia to somalia stuff like that If we don't have an economy here less money goes there.

14:55

It's just it's just a matter of mathematics And so again josh, this is childish and it's elitist

15:01

The economy needs to be strong in order for humans to flourish. It's just that simple.

15:07

It's just that simple You can't cancel the economy and expect there to be No death toll associated with it

15:14

We gotta be able to think this is one thing that i've been thinking a lot about lately We've got to be able to think Like at least two steps ahead

15:21

Oftentimes we only think about the immediate consequence the immediate thing and what it looks like we're doing

15:27

Instead of thinking two steps ahead. I'll give you a perfect example. This is something I mentioned earlier Let's just say all of a sudden you shorten the hours of a grocery store and you say you know what seniors?

15:36

Come to the grocery store between 6 and 8 a .m. And everyone else come between 8 and 6 p .m Right. We're going to close early.

15:44

We're going to open late for regular people and all the old people come at the same time now let's just That sounds like a pretty good idea, you know on the surface, right?

15:52

Let's think two steps ahead here. Let's think two steps ahead here Let's say one of these old people is sick with covid

16:00

And now all the old people are shopping at the same time and so now one old person can

16:06

Can make all the rest of the old people sick and now you've got a you've got a tragedy on your hands because they're all

16:12

Shopping during the same designated hours because you didn't think two steps ahead of what could happen Let's talk about the shortened, uh business hours

16:20

Listen businesses could do whatever they want but insisting that they shorten hours. For example Now all of a sudden you've got a bedlam

16:27

You've got people that normally would shop later now all trying to cram into a few hours Now they're all there's people everywhere and everyone's coughing on each other and stuff like that You gotta be able to think at least two steps ahead.

16:38

Josh you've thought About this about a millimeter of depth here. Josh. This is this is this is pathetic

16:44

It really is to think in this way. Well, I guess you just want a few extra bucks in your pocket No It's about everyone on the chain the more money that I have in my pocket

16:55

The more I can provide for my family the more money the more I can provide for my family the more I can give away

17:00

The more we can give away the more they can give away the less Deaths that we have all the way down the chain all the way to the poor person in the slums of uh, mumbai you know what

17:09

I mean, and it's just it's just so It's it's very stupid to think of this way.

17:15

It's very stupid to think of this way There are certainly greedy people out there. Josh. There are certainly greedy people out there that just want money

17:22

But you know what the ones that are greedy and just want money They'll figure out a way to make money in a down economy The thing is like that this is not about a few extra bucks in our pocket.

17:30

This is about literally Saving lives there are countless verses in the bible that talk about, you know, allowing the worker to get his wages

17:41

There's nothing in the bible about banning entire segments of the economy the legitimate economy nothing

17:48

The governor doesn't have that authority. The church doesn't have that authority The individual doesn't have that authority. The family doesn't have that authority

17:54

And it's just that simple And so josh, i'm sorry to break it to you, but you're speaking like an idiot here

18:01

This is not the choice. This is not what I was saying What I was saying was that the economy tanking for a year or two years will be deadly deadly

18:11

Probably more deadly than the virus Anyway, I hope you found this video helpful