This Week in Witchcraft (S1 E20)

Have You Not Read

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Welcome to this week in witchcraft The elements have been conquered with intense heat and witchcraft has become more cosmopolitan.

00:09

Can you spot it out in the wild? I'm dylan hamilton and with me are michael.

00:15

Durham and andrew hudson Our fellow podcaster who could not be here tonight David caston has sent in his his own witchcraft that he has found out in the wild Actually, it's not really in the wild.

00:26

It's within the church this time. So michael i'd like you to take it away for us right, so our listeners may be familiar with the name andy stanley a pastor of a church out in atlanta, georgia

00:40

And he has said many Things in the past. Are you sure he wants to be known as pastor?

00:46

I don't know. Maybe he's a ceo Sorry perhaps he's a life coach for Personality driven.

00:54

Did he say he doesn't really like to be called pastor? Well, I yeah, I can't keep up with what he says um

01:00

But he did say something about unhitching ourselves from the old testament. Oh, yeah, I remember that Um said some other things as well.

01:07

Now. His latest thing is saying that he it doesn't want to say Following phrases in his sermons anymore.

01:14

He doesn't want to say the bible says he doesn't want to say the scripture says He doesn't want to in his preaching give a sense that Christian life or christian living or christian understanding is to be tied

01:29

To a text Okay For appealing for his change in his his direction moving forward.

01:37

He appeals to What was like in the early church? We want to do things the way That the early church did it now

01:43

This is a spell that has been used many many times in the beginning of divergent false teaching false churches and so on This is a spell like well we're we're most we're gonna be like the early church and when when someone says that there are all sorts of problems that come with That that I think you know needs to be very carefully thought through But in this case he says concerning the early church.

02:09

He says obviously there was scripture I mean, he knows that there was there was an old testament.

02:14

He knows that even in the early church Some of the books of the new testament are being written and disseminated.

02:21

Okay, he says this however But they did not especially in the first century build the christian faith on the back of a text

02:29

Nobody could read Nobody owned one meaning I guess owned a bible what drove the first century christians was an event

02:39

Okay. Now there are so many problems with This expression that it's difficult to untangle.

02:47

This is a bit of soothsaying that just Makes everything so amorphous and confusing that it's hard to penetrate.

02:55

However when we first of all um when we read the bible when we read the new testament

03:04

The more we read the new testament and the old testament together the more we realize how much old testament is in the new testament how amen, how many allusions and quotes and The patterns and the themes of the old testament

03:17

Having been fulfilled in christ are being declared in the preaching of the gospel throughout the whole new testament we are told that all scripture is inspired and profitable for For doctrine for reproof for correction for training and righteousness that the man of god would be adequate equipped for every good work

03:32

This is paul writing in the first century to a first century pastor about old testament scripture

03:38

Being profitable in all these different ways And this is how people are discipled and brought up to fruition and to maturity in christian faith

03:45

This is paul first century apostle writing to a first century pastor about the use of scripture in the life of the church

03:54

Nobody could read a lot of people could read All sorts of people could read and and if they didn't have a copy it was read to them

04:02

The culture of the rabbinical culture of the synagogue was very strong Wherever there was 10 men you'd have a rabbi and there'd be a reading of the scripture on a regular basis

04:12

Young people like timothy were brought up at their mother's knee learning the psalms learning this learning the scriptures learning the shema teaching the scriptures

04:22

Nobody owned one. There was a eunuch You know that came up from ethiopia and bought a copy of isaiah and was reading it on the way back

04:30

You know and philip was able to get in there and philip get this Philip got into the chariot with this.

04:37

Uh this eunuch And they read they could read Right, they could read the bible and this guy even owned a portion of the bible and they read it together

04:47

And he led him to christ through isaiah Which was you know a text a bible text and what's going on here?

04:54

Why the desire to say I don't want to say The bible says or the scripture says anymore in my preaching.

05:02

That's not how they did it in the early church You know, it was all about the event. It wasn't about text.

05:08

What's going on here? Is it the claim that the word of god is not authoritative? It almost seems like a form of projection to me maybe andy stanley

05:17

Can't read it as well as he would like to And he he's projecting that back onto everybody

05:23

And that rich rabbinical culture as if if I can't read it. It's a closed book to him, right?

05:29

I mean, that's the only thing i'm i'm coming to when i'm hearing this as well as is He's not making the connections that he needs to so He just comes up with his own answer

05:38

I think it's a very difficult book for andy stanley and I say that because of the way that he expresses himself

05:44

I had to take extra homiletics courses in my seminary degree because of some accreditation issues where I lost whole classes and it was an interesting thing but in my second go -around on homiletics my professor had us watch a

06:03

Sermon given by andy stanley and this was Is it about 2012 maybe? It was about 10 years ago and In addition to this sermon there was an interview

06:16

That was written out in text form so we could read it ourselves, you know, and it was just Transcripted out for us to read and this in the sermon

06:25

He begins to tell the story of A couple who had a hard time and the husband and wife

06:33

Split up and began to live in separate quarters. Okay, and it was you know it was very rough and And they had received some help from some people in the church who prayed for them and loved on them and those

06:44

So on and so forth where the man who left his wife behind Began a homosexual relationship with a with a man with another man and they began to live together

06:53

And this woman still raising the kids, you know took up with a boyfriend

06:59

Okay, and then her daughter, of course She ended up with a boyfriend as well Uh, and there was extended family, you know that was involved

07:08

And so this story continues on and this homosexual couple wanted to go to a different campus of this church of andy stanley's church because they didn't want to go to the same campus they were before because of the

07:20

Estranged marriage and this homosexual couple wanted to um Volunteer to minister in the church, you know greeters, you know greeting everybody comes in shaking their hands giving them programs, whatever and this of course was not

07:37

Possible because of the situation right and he explains the problem was Not that the men were in a homosexual relationship

07:46

That wasn't the problem. The problem was the man had not yet divorced his wife And there wasn't a clean break

07:53

And that was the issue So counseling them so that he would go ahead and properly divorce his wife so that he could live

08:01

With his homosexual partner in freedom Then they were able to be brought on as ushers and volunteers at this other campus and the story gets even better in the reconciliation of the whole group because On a christmas special they all decided to come together and they sat on the front row or near the front

08:20

Here is the homosexual couple The ex -wife with her new boyfriend the daughter and his and her new boyfriend and all the various extended appendages

08:31

And andy stanley wraps it all up by saying ha here is the modern christian family

08:37

A play on the sitcom the modern family the modern christian family He says look at all the love and acceptance and reconciliation that has occurred here

08:47

That was his sermon That was his sermon and that was 2012 -ish that was 2012 Now paul says that false teachers proceed from bad to worse

08:56

Now back at this time. He's also he was being consulted about his preaching style. He had 24 000 people on the rolls

09:03

How could he be wrong? Okay, so people were consulting him about preaching because he was an obvious expert and he said that This fad of preaching expositionally passage by passage through books of the bible he said it's cheating

09:18

That was his word cheating. It's too easy He says he says the real job of the pastor is to exposit his congregation to exposit his audience

09:29

That's who he needs to exegete He needs to exegete them and then the bible comes in as helpful analogy and illustration

09:36

To help us on to how we're supposed to all follow jesus Now he kept to his principle of exegeting his audience because he saw who was in his congregation who was in his audience

09:46

He saw this family he exegeted their experiences He had some bible verses that he shared but they were only illustrative of their experience to support them in what they were experiencing

09:59

To then make their experience and the way he interpreted it as normative for the kind of loving supportive

10:06

Reconciliation that should be happening in everybody else's families as well Now this is back in 2012 okay, and now

10:14

You know, he says they all want to unhitch the old testament from the new testament. He said I want to say The bible says or the scripture says anymore in my preaching

10:22

Well that that's consistent with what he said 10 years ago. He's not expositing the text

10:28

Anyway, he's not preaching the bible. He's he says that's cheating He's exegeting his audience

10:35

And it's about their experiences and he wants to tie their experience with the experience or the event of the resurrection

10:43

And he wants to call that christianity But in so doing you have vacated the meaning of the resurrection you have vacated the meaning of the event

10:53

You have vacated any opportunity for the people that you're preaching to To be confronted with the truth of the one true god in jesus christ whom he has sent so that may have eternal life

11:05

Because he refuses to proclaim the message of god inerrantly infallibly eternally afforded us in the holy scriptures

11:16

I can't help but think of false prophets tickling the ears. Oh, yeah, that's smooth things club.

11:22

Yeah and the the irony of it is You're going to have so many people with these false gods coming into your congregation that they're eventually going to war against each other

11:32

And you won't know which ears to tickle anymore Yeah This sounds shocking that he would say

11:38

I don't you know, it's not about a text. Nobody could read We shouldn't be using the bible. It's about an event.

11:44

Yeah, that sounds very shocking, you know Unhitching the old testament sounds very shocking, but he's been working towards this for a very long time

11:52

This has been his trajectory And his his motivation has he has he laid that out?

11:57

Like why he's moving this way or is it just something that we can just see this is about reaching people

12:05

Right. This is all about reaching people and showing love and compassion and helping people. I was listening to one of the sweater vest dialogues between uh, doug wilson and uh

12:16

James white and they made the comment and probably quoting somebody, you know, but made the comment that god manifesting himself to man and Revealing who he is to man

12:32

Is a far different thing far different thing than man

12:38

Declaring to god what he should be Right how he should be to them That the orientation of the bible is about god revealing himself to us he's the standard he's the authority rather than man

12:55

Declaring into god. This is what we would prefer It's completely different and in this case trying to Present god in a way that is appealing

13:08

To the tastes of men Well, you really can't do that if you stick with the bible So it's an unfortunate thing.

13:15

I mean, but it's a matter of authority. It's a matter of authority is human experience authoritative Is human experience authoritative or is the word of god authoritative?

13:24

in isaiah 26 verses 1 through 11, which I Had the pleasure of reading in church this past sunday verse nine reads

13:35

At night my soul longs for you indeed my spirit within me seeks you diligently for when the earth experiences your judgments

13:42

The inhabitants of the world will learn righteousness their experiences of judgment should teach of his righteousness

13:53

And I think we may be able to tie that in to what you just said right there about their experiences

14:00

Not having the authority But their experiences and judgment will teach them who is in authority and they will learn that Do you have anything else to add andrew?

14:10

The name of andy stanley will perish In the name of christ will reign forever.

14:17

Amen. Amen. Amen to that. Well, I think that wraps it up today for witchcraft

14:22

What do we have to suggest to counter it? Yeah, I recommend a um series of interviews and Kind of a documentary style but it's put out by ad robles who is a um youtube channel

14:37

And he has a new series kind of a long form format called the rise and fall of the gospel coalition and Just talking about you know this

14:48

This component of modern evangelicalism Where did it come from? You know, how does it operate?

14:54

What is the trajectory? And why is it part of it's kind of a mystery, you know, too because I mean you can go on there and you can

14:59

Find helpful articles. There's been helpful media that they have produced There's been conferences that they've put on that have helped people before and there are names that are attached to this loose you know coalition that uh

15:12

These authors and pastors who have published books that have been beneficial to the saints and at the same time

15:19

There is so much other things that are just unhelpful And unbiblical and subversive that flow through the whole thing ad is

15:30

Trying to You know parse that and show in the mess. What is what? And so it's an interesting interesting set of interviews and some some background and some history and some context that I think is helpful

15:43

I tend to be someone who looks for evidence truth

15:49

So this discussion about where does truth arise from experience or god's word

15:55

It makes me think about some of the obfuscations that are also happening in current american economic discussion and some of the

16:07

Attempts for politicians to paint the picture to be something different than it is and i'm going to cover a or suggest

16:15

A podcast named the wolf street report where he tends to focus upon What is actually happening with the numbers with a economy housing market?

16:25

Monetary inflation those types of things to help counteract

16:32

The lies with the truth of the numbers Does he come from a specific school of economics or is he just kind of a general macro guy?

16:39

He's a general macro guy, but he leans towards What the austrians teach with sound monetary theory and also just not being convinced with the lies of hedonic quality adjustments with Huh what they treat the cpi or quote -unquote inflation with Sugar coating might we might we call it?

17:01

Yes Okay, well my suggestion is uh, go figure it's a it's another

17:07

It's tendential to fiction, but it is uh will in the world how shakespeare became shakespeare

17:12

It's a biography of william shakespeare and little is really known about shakespeare But there's a lot of documentation that we can use to piece together

17:21

Some of his background some of his business dealings which are quite impressive But it's by stephen greenblatt and I just started it recently, but i've listened to a podcast or two

17:31

About shakespeare and a couple of the biographies that i've i've just bought and i'm i'm interested in shakespeare as a businessman personally because that's where I think most

17:40

Content creators have the toughest place of launching from because they tend to be creative minds and They struggle to know how to market to find the audience that they need

17:51

But also to attract that audience to stick with them and become loyal patrons of their work.

17:56

So will in the world by stephen greenblatt And that wraps it up for today

18:02

We are always very thankful for our listeners tuning in every week and for supporting us by rating