BREAKING: SBC Professor Threatened and Fired for Publishing Orthodox Views on Homosexuality

Conversations That Matter

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Welcome to the conversations that matter podcast. My name is John Harris, and I have with me today

00:05

Robert Oscar Lopez who? Robert are you are you still a professor technically at Southwestern or did that end?

00:13

Well, I think the letter that I received terminated me as of the end of the year, but Maybe interceding events

00:24

Earlier because it looks like I'm locked out of my email and all of my accounts there

00:30

So, okay. It sounds like you're not and I'm you're not employed there. You're gonna drop a Final paycheck and then that's it

00:38

Former professor at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in Texas and and Who's your son since he's on the camera there?

00:53

Yeah Yeah, we were talking for a minute before starting to record and as soon as I press record your son ran and Dane there

01:05

So it's cute though. I'm glad that he's keeping you company I want to talk about what's going on at Southwestern in regards to your situation a little bit and I have listened now to two recordings of meetings

01:21

That frankly, they're shocking There's transcripts available and you can go to the info section on this video.

01:28

You can find the recordings You can find the transcripts and more importantly you can find an article that we've put together the enemies within the church that Describes this whole situation and interprets it for you complete with sections from the transcripts, but People don't know what

01:46

I'm talking about yet, but we're gonna get into that a little bit So the long and short of it from what I can understand is

01:52

That it is like my 32nd like Summation you for a long time have been sharing your testimony how

02:00

God saved you out of a homosexual lifestyle You don't believe there's an innate fixed orientation you you believe that people can change and you've spread that message and You've been tapped many times by conservative publications, especially to talk on this issue and you kept doing it you kept writing about it and Southwestern After the new administration took over said we can't have this please, you know, stop you need to get approval

02:28

You tried to work with them and I heard that very clearly in the meetings and you eventually came to the conviction.

02:34

I cannot Be barred from sharing my testimony and what Christ has done in my life

02:40

And this is an important issue and and you were told that you are a bad guy at the URL see and that's a problem

02:46

You can't be saying the things that you're saying at Southwestern while supposedly

02:52

I guess representing them as a school If if you're running into conflict with the

02:57

ERL see on your positions here through the articles you've written on homosexuality you've been told to Stop making comments on Facebook I guess or there are troubling comments that you were called in the office for which

03:10

I'd like to hear what those were It sounds like they tried to censor you and then when they figured they couldn't they fired you and it seems that simple and the

03:18

Statement that was put out by Stinson I think his name is at Southwestern about this does not add up It seems honestly and I hate to say this about someone who's a professing believer, but it's a lie

03:29

It is an outright lie when I when I look at these transcripts and I hear these recordings and I see these emails

03:35

What they're saying about you is absolutely untrue and it is provable and you can go to the links in this info section to to show that so Robert I'm a little upset about this and you seem like you're in a better spirit than me

03:49

And I don't know why that is. Maybe you just you're tired and you're done with it, but I'd like to hear from you You know what what's going on is my assessment accurate?

03:59

Well, you know, there's a part of me that just wants to be very careful

04:05

So I'll I think you are, right? but I would say that they couched everything very carefully so that They tried to give themselves wiggle room.

04:18

So wasn't it didn't look like they were really censoring me They were just asking me to run things by The media communications office and then upon My questions and after many meetings it became clear that they wanted to say you can say certain things and you can't say other things

04:36

And the items that came under controversy that is to say the public statements and public writings that were subject to their

04:44

Objections in which they tried to steer me away from were all things that dealt with the LGBT issue

04:50

So, I think the official story that came from Southwestern which was that homosexuality had nothing to do with my dismissal

04:58

I Just don't know how you can twist Around the the record in terms of what they said at the meetings what they gave me in writing what they told me in person

05:07

It does seem to be that they wanted me to get away from my testimony they wanted me to get away from this subject matter and when

05:18

I Told them at a certain point that God had called me to my work and I could not

05:24

Abandon that for the sake of hanging on to my job Yes, they did basically asked me to resign and then when

05:31

I wouldn't resign they Terminated me and now they're claiming that the termination was because of a change in programming needs in the college and That seems not to add up because usually if you have a change in curriculum

05:47

Those things are known to people with a lot more lead time than I was given

05:52

The only time that I heard that my position was eliminated because of program needs was when on November 29th, you know a week ago

06:00

Which is after classes had already ended and you know, my job is over in a month basically at Christmastime.

06:07

So I think It is very troubling What happened and I think one of the reasons why

06:15

I'm in better spirits than you is because I lived through at least I would say nine months of this intense experience of working under people who say one thing and they're doing another and they live in behind a veil of obscurity and They not just in my case, but in the way that they run

06:39

The seminary they do seem to they rule with an iron fist You know The first thing that Adam Greenway did when he came in was he fired 25 26 professors in one day?

06:49

So that created an entirely different climate on campus relative to what

06:54

I had experienced prior to his coming to Southwestern people were all scared of their jobs.

07:02

And so there was a general feeling of distrust and uneasiness and They certainly did not work to tamp that down they were calling people in in a lot of these fashions where I don't know if you've got a sense of that when you

07:14

Look at the record of the emails and the audio tapes of the meetings But they would often call you into meetings and you didn't know who was going to be in the room

07:23

You didn't know what it was about They wouldn't set up meetings at a time that you knew people usually got fired at so they'll say you have to come on Thursday At 4 p .m.

07:32

And you know, that's when people usually get fired so that it's just a climate of fear and intimidation and It I think ultimately

07:42

What is scary is? That these are tactics that are worse than what

07:47

I saw in secular liberal academia Yeah, it seemed like I was listening to something that would have come from HR department at a secular job or secular academic, yeah

08:07

Here's the expectation of the administration They don't want that attention coming here, but it's something that Probably not going to want that kind of attention, that kind of involvement from you.

08:19

I would not want to see a situation where You force them to fire you.

08:28

I happen to be around some folks from the ERLC Where your reputation is not good there with those folks

08:39

So now there's a growing concern of mine in terms of a failure to relate constructively to Another major entity of the

08:50

SBC when you work at Southwestern Seminary You're not an independent actor

08:57

Everything that you do Represents the school in one way or another There are multiple factors that go into What might be acceptable or unacceptable and I'd like to know what that rubric is

09:13

Well, there's not I didn't say there was a rubric Well, there are multiple factors that we would consider in who the audience is the venue what's being said?

09:22

How is it being said? If it is going to be

09:29

Received poorly by the entity the honest truth. You know, what are we?

09:34

Okay, I'm There are ways to say things There are ways to do it.

09:40

It's just are you just putting out the truth unvarnished truth everywhere you go or Ways to have conversations or to make any decision.

09:48

I'm prepared to know I'm asking you You know ought to be at a man of integrity To make your own decision.

09:54

I've made my decision I've made my decision and you know what? I resent you to implying that I don't have integrity.

10:00

I'm Saying it on the 19th you met with Dean Stinson and you brought two pastors with you and he gives you a hard time for that in the audio file that I listened to which

10:11

I thought was interesting because You mentioned in the same transcript that you had Requested information about the meeting like who was gonna be there what it was about and he didn't respond to you

10:21

And so there's no specifics you get to the meeting and it's like a cat -and -mouse game for the next hour in which he does

10:28

Not give you any Not even verbal let alone written Instructions no rubric as far as how you could comply with whatever this supposed policy is.

10:37

It doesn't sound like there's any policy So, how do you know? I mean it is a Facebook post That's personal outside, you know, does that have to be approved by the the school?

10:46

I mean there are no specifics and that's one of the things that concern me about this So, I mean was there anything other than I mean

10:54

Just a verbal you need to get approval from us with all of your communication

11:00

Yeah, well, one of the hard things is I don't really have access to all of the other faculty's personnel files or their experiences, obviously, so I They claim that they put the same rules on everyone so I would have no way of really confirming that but it does not seem to me likely that everybody was asked to submit the level of Scrutiny to their work as I was being asked to what he drew a distinction in that meeting between academic work

11:27

Which he said did not need to be pre -approved and other kinds of commentary that did need to be pre -approved now the thing about it is that when

11:36

I do work on LGBT on sexuality a lot of that is peer -reviewed academic work, but he's not counting it that way so The their definitions are slippery there are not clear guidelines and the end result when you add it all up is

11:52

That there are certain subject areas that they are allowed carte blanche to regulate and one of those would be

11:58

LGBT because they just don't count that as academic work Even though that's an area of major theological discussion and a seminary needs to talk about it

12:06

That's one of the things that I try to bring up in that meeting When I brought the two pastors is that you know Those pastors can attest to how much work

12:14

I do in the ministries in churches The issue of LGBT is ripping apart the churches. Absolutely. It's it's tearing apart the pastoral landscape and but that's not counted as serious intellectual work as if I were, you know writing a

12:27

Biography, let's say of Martin Luther that would count as more academic and so I would have more freedom to write about that But on something like LGBT, it's so heavily

12:39

Scrutinized now. The other thing is at one point we asked her for a rubric. He did not want to give us a rubric as to what would be the like the reasons that I would be told that I shouldn't publish something or I should publish it and I think

12:54

What bothered me about that was the fact that I hadn't really written anything that went against the Baptist faith and message

13:00

Or that was against the gospel. I mean nothing at all it all So it was not clear to me why

13:07

You know some of the things were objectionable and And especially given all of the things that the

13:14

Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission is doing I mean they're having conferences on sex abuse

13:19

I was writing a lot on sex abuse but I was writing on same -sex sex abuse and sex abuse that happens in the gay community and for some reason that is

13:27

Every time I wrote anything on that that raised a lot of red flags Yeah, it's interesting to me the the double standard here

13:35

I mean does Malcolm Yarnel need to go to the Administration every time he puts a tweet out there on social justice or something because he puts a lot of tweets out there

13:43

I mean or is it just you that when you write something that has to do with this specific issue you have to get that approved and It it sounds like there's no actual policy.

13:57

There's they don't actually tell you what kinds of communication What what mediums and then as far as the content

14:05

They don't really give you any instructions other than you just need to abide by our moving standard that we don't define

14:11

I mean, that's frustrating Well, yeah what would happen is they would be building up a track record of you being a problem employee because They would give you a one rule and then they would call you in as if you violated

14:23

The rule that they had given you but that wasn't the rule that they gave you So the perfect example is when

14:28

I met with them in June, I met with the provost in June What they said was that we had to pass all of our media requests to Colby Adams because of the page

14:37

Patterson lawsuit That was underway on the seminary now From what

14:42

I understood nothing that I did had anything to do with the page Patterson lawsuit But they said well, it doesn't matter.

14:48

You still have to submit any media requests That means if somebody contacts you and says I'm a reporter and I want to interview you

14:55

That's what I understand media requests right? So I tried to go along with that They took objection because at one point somebody contacted me from the

15:03

Christian Union and I answered to the reporter and I copied Colby Adams so that the reporter and the chief of staff at Southwestern saw each other's names on it

15:13

They said that was inappropriate because that puts too much pressure on the chief of staff So they said instead you should do it in separate emails.

15:21

I was like, okay, whatever. I'll do that But then the next thing that happened was I submitted an essay to be published at American thinker and So I sent that to the editor at American thinker

15:35

I waited for him to get back and then in a separate email I emailed the chief of staff and they said that that was wrong

15:41

Because I needed to then submit that essay that idea To the chief of staff before I sent it to an editor and that's the point where I said

15:49

Nowhere at any point. Did you tell me that everything that I said including my testimony was subject to their prior?

15:57

Approval and that was just standard that was so expansive and I think the reason why there was no written standard is because I don't think that most

16:06

Institutions of higher learning would want to be caught with that as a written policy It would probably run them afoul of accreditation guidelines

16:15

That's what it sounds like to me and I mean I've been through in many academic institutions And I don't recall ever hearing anything remotely close to this kind of Policy, which is really a non policy where you have to get everything approved.

16:29

I mean professors typically do interviews and and have their own blogs that get sometimes populated on other websites and You're in a unique case in my experience at least and I know you've been around the block a little bit

16:43

Have you ever had trouble like this before? Well at Cal State Northridge there were gestures or innuendos

16:49

But generally no, I mean you couldn't have You would never be called in by the provost or by a dean at Cal State Northridge and told

17:00

That you have to have your commentary pre -screened by an administrator That's I would have never seen that this is the first place where that was even suggested let alone enforced

17:13

You know, and that's the thing is that this wasn't forced I mean, I mean it was I was called in for meeting after meeting and then, you know

17:20

Finally that there was one meeting where I just said I can't agree to meet with you because you haven't addressed any of the problems

17:26

I've raised with the prior meetings about nothing being in writing None of this has to do with my job description of teaching research or service that has nothing to do with his responsibilities as a provost

17:36

His demeanor very often was aggressive and threatening and yeah, you know Yeah, and so it you know

17:42

So and then at that point then they get you for not being willing to come into a meeting After I had already gone to seven meetings

17:49

So it it it's a really a run -around game I don't know I can't know what their motives are but it seems to me that the most plausible

17:57

Explanation is that they were looking for a reason to run certain people off and I was on the top of that list

18:05

That he brought up the Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, so yeah three times I was on his Three time you saw that.

18:12

Yeah. Yeah. I mean I listened the whole thing He brought up the ERLC by name I think twice and by right he referenced it another time

18:19

So there are three times that he referenced them and it was right out of the gate He's saying to you that we can't have someone who's making waves with the

18:28

ERLC that creates a problem here I'm like what? Well, I don't know well and it's it's

18:34

I see it as somewhat of a conflict of interest because his relationship to me is His relationship was that he was a provost and I was a professor.

18:43

So it was not the case that You know, he should be advancing the interests of his role as a research fellow at the

18:51

ERLC He is a research fellow at the ERLC But that should not be the what he's calling me in and using his position as a provost for a provost is supposed to be

19:00

Overseeing academics. Yeah. Well Robert. I I just want you to know I respect you

19:05

I know I've been praying for you and I'm sure many others are gonna be praying for you now is I'm sure you're gonna be looking for work in the months ahead and There's a lot of men

19:14

Teaching at these seminaries and I and I I know some of them personally who are in similar situations but they want to keep their jobs and and you were bold enough and brave enough to Take a stand here and I just want to thank you.

19:31

I really appreciate that. I know it honors the Lord You know your testimony is powerful

19:37

We don't we don't hear the kinds of things coming from revoice or living out or The ERLC that we should in regards to the issue of LGBT Q and you

19:50

I think have that the life -giving soul -changing message of the gospel that any Example because you were saved out of this and you can show people in that community in a gentle loving way

20:02

What the love of Christ can do for them and not just save their souls from eternal separation from God which is of course the main thing, but also from a lifestyle of death and so I just want you to know

20:14

I appreciate you and and I hope you don't stop putting that message out there that Christ can change lives and and We know what the

20:24

ERLC says it's interesting because I Tried to get away from it earlier this year

20:32

I pulled out of conferences and I I Didn't want it because I've been at this for a while and this just keeps on happening over and over again

20:40

And you know, I wanted to get away from it I just think that God if he calls you to something

20:46

You have to go where he calls you because every time I tried to get away from it You know,

20:51

I would be pulled back in and it's almost it's almost God's grace by saying like look if you had

20:57

Completely cut ties to all these people in all these ministries who had asked for your help and just decided that you were gonna write peer -reviewed articles about church history, you know or about You know

21:08

John Locke for the rest of your time studying that I probably would have felt an emptiness inside or at least

21:15

I think God would have done the Jonah punishment You know your

21:22

God more than men that's great. Yeah. Well, I think also, you know, I came from California And I did come from California Thinking that God had brought me here and I just don't think that God brought me here to shrink in fear from Southern Baptists and I Wish that more people in the

21:41

Southern Baptist Convention would break with this culture I don't even think it always has to do with right and left liberal or conservative

21:49

I think there's just a culture of going along to get along the old boys network. It's a corrupt culture

21:56

That keeps everybody in line And and people really distort the gospel.

22:02

They think that discretion is a biblical value They think that secrecy is a biblical value.

22:08

They think that Popularity or ingratiation with the people at the top is a biblical value.

22:14

These are not biblical values John No at all I mean, these are values that go contrary to the light and the salt that we're supposed to bring to the world with the gospel

22:26

So I hope that maybe if there's one or two people out there who could see my story and just think to themselves

22:34

You know, you don't have to do this You don't have to report to your cave in a Southern Baptist institution and keep your head down year after year

22:42

Clinging to something that ultimately is not really what God intended for you Robert I want to ask you one final question

22:51

I've heard that when Paige Patterson Was taken out for lack of a better term and Greenway was put in the faculty or at least most of them had to sign

23:03

NDAs and And You someone told me did not sign an

23:09

NDA and you may I don't know if you're the only one or one of the few Your resolution though to the

23:16

Southern Baptist Convention was specifically on NDAs. Yes I just wanted you to comment for a moment on that because I'm wondering if that also plays into this at all

23:27

Well, I it is a very good possibility that that was the beginning of the end I Submitted a resolution that wasn't really on LGBT necessarily it was on abuse sex abuse, but also other kinds of misconduct and that the resolution was on whistleblowers and trying to clean up the culture of corruption in the

23:45

SPC so that informants can come forward and bring problems to the public without four different things that I mentioned one of which was the

23:52

Eleventh Commandment one of which was Retaliation one of which were gentlemen's agreements, which I think are also very problematic and then the non -disclosure agreements

24:00

And I didn't mention that in there that resolution got killed and I was taken out to lunch

24:07

By the provost and it was clear that he was not happy with the fact that I had submitted that Resolution so that may have started the bad blood because that was back in May I don't know how many people signed on disclosure agreements because obviously

24:21

One of the conditions is that they can't tell you right? I did not sign one and I obviously paid a huge price because I am being cut off with no pay, you know,

24:35

I'm virtually no notice Whatsoever, but I do feel that God gave me that freedom

24:41

So I it would be a waste for me to stay quiet about things given the fact that I didn't sign one of those

24:48

I think non -disclosure agreements are a huge part of the sex abuse crisis They're a huge part of a lot of the abuse and misconduct in the

24:56

Southern Baptist Convention and we should not have them They are totally contrary to Christian faith No Christian organization should have people sign those because you're using the unbelieving world's legal institutions

25:07

To threaten and intimidate Christian brothers and sisters and I know of people not just at Southwestern but other places who are good

25:15

Christians who signed those things because they were worried about their family and putting food on the table or they had children with health insurance needs that were unique and quite onerous and so they had to sign those and it's just so wrong because They're they're very conflicted the people.

25:33

I know who do sign them They they feel that they need to show integrity to the fact that they signed those agreements

25:39

But those agreements are really inappropriate in the first place. And so it opens up that question

25:45

When we read Romans 13 when we read first Peter You know when we read a lot of those passages in the

25:51

Bible that talk about obeying the existing Authorities does that mean that we should obey everyone who happens to be in a position of authority even someone who?

26:00

Got there through ill -begotten means or who is not a good leader, you know so that's a question that we all have to wrestle with because there are other parts of the

26:08

Bible that tell us that we have To be wary of wolves and sheep's clothing. We have to protect the flock from the wolves.

26:14

We shouldn't be hirelings so It's a tough question But I do think that that's a big part of where we're at in the

26:23

Southern Baptist Convention I tend to feel from day to day that we're losing so many churches and so many people

26:29

Not always because of politics a lot of times because of this kind of corruption The retaliation is awful

26:36

But the fact that there are powerful people who will make a phone call to your church or to you like you're seeing that with Naples Right, you know who will make these phone calls behind the scenes and ruin your life because of a petty vendetta

26:48

And they're doing it all inside of what they say is Christ's house. It shouldn't be happening You should not have jelly

26:55

I wish I could say you're the only one I knew who had suffered from one of those phone calls, but You're not

27:03

You're you're willing to talk about About some of this corruption and for that you have my respect and I think the respect of probably a great

27:13

Majority once they find out of the pew sitters in the Southern Baptist Convention you probably don't know what's actually going on in the institutions like Southwestern, but Robert I'm gonna let you go and I know you know

27:26

You've been through a lot and I hope you just have a great weekend with your family a great Christmas season and and next year

27:33

I'll be praying for you that you hit the ground running and looking forward to seeing how the Lord uses you in your next phase