Transgenders and Violence

This is Apologetics Live, to answer your questions, your host, from Striving for Eternity Ministries, Andrew Rappaport.

We are live, Apologetics Live, here to answer your most challenging questions that you have about God and the Bible. We can answer every single one of them. Every question you have about God and the Bible, we can answer right here.

If you doubt such things, well, feel free to go to ApologeticsLive .com. From there, go to the StreamYard link. Just join where it says to participate. You ask me your hardest question. Just remember, when I say, I don't know, that's a perfectly good answer.

I didn't say it would be a satisfying answer for you. I just said I can answer any question. So for those who are watching live, sorry for the couple of seconds there of delay. We were having a technical problem.

In other words, I was trying to get something up on the computer that wasn't coming up right away. It had nothing to do with the co-host who was backstage. He was just going, yeah, okay, what was the delay there, Andrew?

Drew, how are you, sir?

I'm doing well, I'm doing well, and I'm in a different part of my house this evening.

So we don't get to hear the kids, or more importantly, we don't get to see your wife's arm.

Right, yeah. She's not trying to sneak behind and try to reach and grab something. But she was here just a minute ago.

Are you going to tell her that we were actually live when she came on and said hello? You really should.

I should, yeah. That would be great, yeah. I should really do that.

She'll go watch the video and go, you lied to me, liar!

I wasn't going to lie, it was a joke.

Yeah.

Well, let's start with something a little bit more somber instead of a joke. I got an email we want to read here from a regular viewer, many of you in the chat. And folks, if you're not watching live, you're missing out.

We have a lively chat. They like to not only discuss things that have nothing to do with what we're talking about that night. I think they try to just distract us, Drew. But one thing they do is our chat room is very good for praying for one another.

And Kathy Deming, one of the regulars, has sent me an email asking for prayer. She said, hi, Andrew, I was wondering if you can have prayer requests for me on the next show. I landed in the hospital January 30th, had emergency surgery on the 31st, and was unable to join the chat as I was very weak and tired.

I literally passed out. Came home February 8th. I am looking at eight weeks of recovery period. I tried to join the chat last week, but had a hard time. Appreciate your prayers and hope to get back to the chat soon.

Thank you, Kathy Deming. So if I'm just going to ask if all of you guys could lift her up in prayer when you're doing your prayer time. I've already prayed for her today as I just got that. So but if you guys could pray for her, that would be wonderful.

We would appreciate it. And Drew, I know we are both really not looking forward to this topic.

Yeah, it's not. It's not when you go, you know what? Let's get that one. And let's talk about that one tonight. Let that's going to be fun.

You know, we could we could.

Let's just distract ourselves. And D is saying, hey, Chris Honholds, I heard James White mentioned your response to he gets a Super Bowl ad. I'm not on X. Where can I read it? I think he wrote a blog article, but I'm sure I'm sure he'll post to where you can read it.

But but, yeah, it wasn't just James White who noticed it. Maybe, Chris, if you want to be so daring, you could you could let folks know who actually shared the article and blew up your phone.

Mm hmm.

And who is now following Mr. Honholds on X. And that's what it's called, by the way, Chris. It's called X.

Wait, who did this?

Mr. Honholds, Mr. Honholds, he has revealed the name. There it is. Yes.

Jenna Ellis not only retweeted it, but started following him and blew up his phone because she does when she. When she posts something, she gets a lot of notifications and people hate her.

Yeah.

So basically he he probably thought, oh, I'm going to have a nice quiet day. Go to work. No, my phone's blowing up with people telling me I'm a Pharisee. So we're going to be one of the few that won't deal with that.

He gets us Super Bowl ad because, well, folks, if you're watching or listening here, we're ahead of the curve. We dealt with that one like a year and a half ago.

Yeah, they said they did it last something similar last year or two years ago. So this is nothing new.

Yeah, we did it before they did their first Super Bowl ad. We we looked at their different videos and addressed the problems with them. So we warned you a long time ago. So those who are regular here, you weren't surprised.

All right.

So the topic tonight and folks, anyone can ask questions. I should mention that you could just go to Apologize Live dot com. That's the way to join. You just scroll down. That's you can watch the show there.

You can watch previous shows there. You can follow the podcast there. But you can also join the discussion there. You know, I don't think it's going to join, by the way.

Drew Chris Han holds.

Oh, well, he might he he would be more than happy to. But the couple of guys who made some really interesting comments about Calvinism and, you know, and and I said, well, why don't you come in and let's discuss it?

You hear those crickets?

Yeah.

Who was it that was talking about Calvinism?

Where was this on Facebook? We had and I actually grabbed a quote because it's going to go into my why Calvinism. Talk at the open air theology. This is what it said. This guy, Jeff, says, quote, Calvinism is not response.

Calvinists are not responsible for their own actions. God is. So is it no wonder that they reject that many reject the God of Calvinism? If God is responsible for what they do, then God is blamed for much of the evil that he does not do.

Unquote.

As he read about what Joseph said about basically that very thing, what you meant for evil, God meant for good. So there is an intention on the part of man that does things that are intended for evil.

But yet God in being sovereign does have a purpose. Right. So either evil happens and it has no purpose or there are things that God allows to take place and they serve a purpose.

That's a Calvinist view, by the way, that God allows.

Oh, yeah.

So we can also throw you can also tack on Providence in there, too, and how God works things out.

You know, we may have to do an in-depth show on the doctrine of Providence. I'm just looking up John Piper book that I was given on Providence.

I heard that was a very, very good book. I don't have it, but I've heard from a lot of people it is a very good book.

Yeah, it's not a thin book. It's about two inches, two and a half inches thick.

That is a serious situation to get into.

But I also have Charnock's Divine Providence, which would be a lot weightier to get through, but even though it's thinner. The thing is, how much of the doctrines we address here, whether we're discussing Calvinism or charismaticism with prophecy, it's really Providence that is misunderstood.

So much confusion there. So the topic we wanted to talk about tonight, in case folks did not hear, and we actually had an article that I sent Drew, I don't know how long ago. And I said I wanted to...

The plan was to do this a while ago, and then we kept putting other things in front of it.

Yeah. But after the shooting at Joelstein's church, or what did you call it? You didn't call it a church.

I called it the Joel Osteen Motivational Center.

Oh, I love it. You know, I wish you'd share what you really think about these things, because you keep holding back.

I do. You know, it's part of that having self-control. It's part of self-control and the spirit working and growing me that I just don't let loose.

And I wonder if tonight's show, we may trigger Mr. Honholz. I'm kind of expecting that we may see a Voice of Reason radio on tonight's episode. Oh, look at this. Chris Honholz said, Motivational Center sounds about right.

Oh, and we have someone saying, sup y 'all?

It's either Hax or it's Darren.

Yeah, because neither one of them want to bother doing... I mean, it's like, click a button. That's all that's involved. Go to pauljackslive .com. There's instructions to just click a button so that we can get your name.

And then we know who you are. Because we just keep confusing these Facebook users. The person says it's Hax, but do we know for sure until afterwards when we go on Facebook?

Video or it's not real.

Not anymore. Not anymore. I mean, now with the deep fakes. We are in for an election year of election years, because when you think about how much they hate Trump, they're willing to outright lie, say that he supports white supremacists because he says both sides have bad elements.

And they just skip where just before that he says he condemns white supremacy. I mean, if they're willing to completely flip what he says or make up what he says, say, oh, he's told people to drink bleach.

What do you think they're going to do with deep fakes? I mean, we're not going to be... The reality is with AI, you can't trust anything anymore.

Right. So how... Once this technology really gets perfected, the idea of how do you weigh in a court of law, how do you weigh evidences when someone says you did something? Because now they can mimic voices and you can have audio that sounds just like you, saying things you've never said.

They can do AI video and pictures. There's one guy who got, I think he got well known on TikTok or something like that. But he would have this AI overlay of Tom Cruise's face on his face, and it looked just like Tom Cruise.

And so it's like, now how do you trust anything like you said?

Yeah. I mean, after all, this was what Ben Shapiro might have said.

Many people have questions about God in the Bible with so many different views about God and how to interpret the Bible. Many people wonder where they can turn to get biblical answers. Well, have no fear.

Turn to my friend Andrew Rappaport and his friends on Apologetics Live. They can answer any question you have about God in the Bible. Check them out Thursday nights, 8 to 10 o 'clock PM, New York time at ApologeticsLive .com.

You can watch or join the discussion at ApologeticsLive .com and challenge him with anything. Please ask him your really hard questions and tell him Ben sent you.

I mean, that really could have been Ben Shapiro.

It could.

Or not.

Right. So the thing about this, right? When you have it slowed down, you can kind of hear the cuts, right? But Ben Shapiro speaks really fast. So all you got to do is speed that up and you can't tell the difference.

Yeah.

Actually, the reality is because the only clips I had of Ben Shapiro were chopped up. If I had a full dialogue, you wouldn't have heard it chopped up as much. In fact, I may have you saying some wonderful things about me by next week.

We'll see.

Then everyone would know it's a lie.

Yeah.

So there was an article in and I want to address the issue of what happened at Joel Steen's church as well. But there is an article that was in the Epoch Times. If you subscribe to that, you can go. Maybe it's there for free.

But the title of it is Growing Concerns Over Links Between Transgenderism and Violence. Subtitled, an increase in mass shootings by gender confused individuals is sparking worry over the vital cocktail of medical health issues and body altering chemicals.

And this is the thing. And I want to kind of want to go through this article because I do see a concerning thing. Look, we just had another shooting with the, who is it that won the Super Bowl? I don't even remember.

The Kansas City Chiefs.

The Kansas City Chiefs.

Okay.

Taylor Swift won the Super Bowl. Huh?

Taylor Swift won the Super Bowl.

Yeah.

At least I now know that she's a singer. So we do have this comment. Hi, this is Jody. Can you see my name? Yes, because it says Jody. But your account says you're just Facebook user. So I just go to ProjectsLive .com.

There's some instructions for Facebook. So here's what we end up seeing. This shooter in Kansas City. Notice we know nothing about the shooter. Okay. Two people. They have in custody. And we know nothing about them.

So what do you think I immediately think after what we've seen in recent days? I think that that person must be a leftist.

Right.

Why?

Because whenever they don't put out the information, it's usually someone that isn't going to carry the weight for the Marxists. I mean, their first thing every time is the gun, the gun, the gun, when a leftist uses a gun.

And if they think it's someone that's conservative, even if they're wrong, right, the first thing they did when there was the shooting in the gay bar, it was a Christian, evangelical Christian. Oh, sorry.

It was a Muslim.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Now, well,.

If you think about the shooting that took place in, I think it was Charlotte where the guy went into the church. Now he they were. Once everything took place, they were really quick to point out. He's got these type of flags in his his room.

He's got these types of posts. Right. They were really quick to give information as to who he was.

Until they get corrected. And that's I mean, we still don't know if you remember how the guy, a girl that thinks she's a guy that or thought she was a guy that went into the Christian school. They don't want to release that manifesto.

All the other manifestos, they're in a rush to do. And so what we end up seeing is they had, if you remember the shooter at the massage parlor. They were quick to say that he goes to church. They weren't so quick to say that he was a leftist.

Right.

Each one of these that they, they don't promote it as much. The shooting at Joel Steen's church. Drew, do you know what was written on his AR 15?

I do not.

It said free Palestine.

Well, there you go.

That sounds very conservative, right? Oh wait, no.

Yeah.

And, and guess what?

Yep.

That person who went into Joel Steen's church and shot people.

Yep.

That person was a transgender. Now here's, you don't have the most sickening thing is of that whole account. The guy who goes into a church thinking he's a girl and brought, I think it was a five-year-old child.

I think, I think it was their five-year-old child.

Yeah.

Brought their child with them.

And very tragic. The child got shot. And I think, I think the child's still in critical condition.

I have not heard the latest on the child. I am glad that there was not a lot of death and injury in that, but we don't hear the same rhetoric coming out from the media. When it's a transgender targeting Christians.

And just for the record, you don't see Christians playing the victim card, but if you were actually to look at the statistics throughout history and worldwide, Christians have always been the number one group.

I should say evangelical biblical Christians have been the number one targeted group for persecution everywhere throughout time.

Well,.

Last 2000 years, not throughout time.

Before that,.

It was a Christian. It was the Jewish people,.

Right?

But it has been for thousands of years, all over the world that Christians get targeted. And you see everyone going,.

Oh,.

We're a victim. We're a victim.

Well, it's,.

It's right now, the Marxist victimizing Christians. And that is something that you,.

You know,.

I think everyone in this audience gets and knows, but let's, I want to go through this article before we get to Joel Osteen.

Um,.

Drew,.

Maybe,.

Maybe you could just read a couple cause I figured not everyone. Actually, you know what I will do is I'm going to put it up on screen and you could.

Read,.

Read it and let,.

And then we'll,.

We'll engage with some of this article. If I could find it,.

Here we go.

Because I figured not everyone has this.

All right.

You want me to read it off of that screen?

Yeah,.

I can't read it off that screen,.

But I've got a little larger. I can do that.

I mean, I've got it pulled up so I can,.

Uh,.

I can read it.

Yeah,.

But I want to make sure the audience can read it too. So I got to make it, I got to make it large enough for folks is for folks who are watching. But for those who are not,.

I w. That's why I would like you to read.

Is that good size now on the screen?

Sure.

I mean, I've got it pulled up on mine, so I'm not really watching the screen.

Okay.

But,.

Uh,.

But here's what it, how it starts off. It says mental health issues that manifest in gender confusion, combined with potent cross-sex hormones can be a recipe for violence. Some experts have said since 2018, five people who identified as transgender or were gender confused, have gone on killing sprees at schools and businesses.

Authorities have been increasingly slow to confirm so-called gender identities and motives in cases such as these. My son's screaming for me.

Yeah.

So,.

So you, you, you,.

You want to keep reading or,.

Or yeah, I'll keep, I'll keep going.

Yeah.

I see mommy. Yeah. When shooters, gender, gender identities were revealed. Now he's trying.

Oh,.

Wait.

Now,.

Now we got, we got to see your wife's arm, but we got to see a little cute little boy there for a second.

That's Lawson.

And he is, he's, he's named after Steve Lawson.

But does Steve Lawson know that?

Yes. So he actually, so he actually met Steve Lawson when, when he, when my wife was eight. Yeah. Eight months pregnant.

Dr.

Lawson was preaching at praise mill. And we went up there and my wife was eight months pregnant and was talking to Dr. Lawson afterwards and said, well, this is a little Lawson that we're about to give birth to.

So.

So there you go.

All right.

So,.

So let,.

Let's deal with some of what you already read. Okay. The article is not saying I'll show this is, it is not saying that the cross-sex hormones are the cause. Okay. One of the things you see with the mass shootings that has been kind of universally known is that in every one of these cases, the gun gets blamed, which I don't know.

A gun doesn't do anything without a human doing something.

To it.

Along that lines, I mean, just look at what Jason cave says. He says the fork made me fat, right? The same lines. And then Chris Han holds pencils, misspell words,.

You know?

So, so we can, I mean, it's definitely the gun's fault. It's the pencils fault. It's, it's the fork's fault for why I'm overweight. It's not my fault.

Correct.

It's it's.

So,.

So if you don't have a human pulling the trigger that, that gun doesn't go off,.

It's,.

It's not magic. The gun doesn't have a mind of its own. But one thing we see when, in almost every one of these cases where you have these people who are doing these mass shootings and a mass shooting is,.

I think,.

Uh,.

It's four, four more,.

Three,.

Three more people, four more people.

Yeah.

They,.

They define it right here at the bottom. It says a mass shooting is defined by the crime prevention research center as the killing of four or more people in a single incident that's not gang or drug related.

So what you see is that you have a, you have four people, the one that's going to kill four people.

Um,.

We see this on the rise, but one thing we see consistently is that most often these are people who have been on mood altering drugs for a very long time and usually got off, took themselves off cold Turkey.

But there is in almost every case, mental health issues.

Yes. Correct.

Now let's be clear. The,.

Um,.

The issue we have here, this is,.

Um,.

You know,.

Transgenderism is a mental health issue. People are, you and your, their gender confused.

Well,.

They're confused because it's a mental health issue or nowadays I don't even think it's that. I think it's that they just want to fit in. And the way to fit in nowadays is to pretend you're the opposite gender.

And so that's a big one.

Or another way to fit in is because I see, I see everything has to do with mental health. And so I have a mental health issue. Therefore I need medication. In order to be, to deal with my mental health issues, because I'm just like everybody else.

Yeah.

So Mr. Han holds, says the argument basically boils down to quote, if there were no guns, then shooters can't kill so many people. Unquote. Then he says, except for bombs, pressure cookers,.

Cars,.

Fertilizers, and et cetera.

Yeah.

So this brings up a good point. That Chris makes. Okay. So if you look at Scotland, I've listened to a lot of people who have been to Scotland, like Jeff Rose, who is a open air preacher. He did a lot of ministry, lived in Scotland for a little while.

He'll tell you that guns are illegal in Scotland, but people carry around swords and they carry around knives.

Why?

Because guns are illegal. And so they need something to protect themselves with, or to cause crime with.

Correct.

And so the article here is not saying that these chemicals that are being put into people's bodies to make them, their hormones change and things like that. It's not that, we have a direct cause, but as it says, the numbers are starting to show a pattern.

You go,.

Well,.

The numbers, we're not talking about all that many people. I think, did they already mention the number? Five people since 2018.

And.

Though that sounds light, the question is, how many of the people did we not know were transgender?

Right. Because it says whenever the gender identities are revealed, and it's shown to be someone who is, who identifies as transgender or is gender confused or non-binary, whatever, they don't align with either one, then it's suppressed.

They kind of bury that.

And what you end up seeing is, with the case in Joelstein Church, they're very concerned about trying to figure out the proper gender to call this person. And as they've dug into the past,.

Found out,.

Oh,.

They were born a different gender, but they, they haven't mentioned anything about that.

And.

That's the thing that we'll see.

And.

When we,.

When we look at this,.

Well,.

We're going to see,.

You know,.

Some of these cases here. It's, it starts with,.

You know,.

Of the,.

Of the 37 public mass shootings from 2018. Now just stop right there. Does that number surprise you? I'm pausing for effect. I want people to think about it. If I was to tell you, ask you,.

How many.

Mass shootings have there been since 2018? Would you have thought it was as low as 37?

No,.

You would actually think it was much higher. And this was actually something that was pointed out I think in, it might've been 2018 or 2019, maybe even 2020 by someone like Ben Shapiro, where they were looking at, are there really as many mass shootings as people are saying?

And what they've actually looked at is they've counted things as mass shootings that weren't mass shootings.

So,.

So where someone, there was an incident where someone pulled into a school parking lot and shot themselves, right? Committed suicide. They counted that as a school shooting, which when you get into a school shooting, that counts then as a mass shooting.

You know,.

One of our podcasters, Jamal Bandy, has a podcast, Prescribed Truth.

And.

In there, this is back in 20, 2019, 2020. I forget when. He went through all the statistics, the statistics from the previous year where they were, the white cops killing blacks. I think he, I think he did it in 2020 about the statistics of 2019.

And he went through every one of them and looked at all of them. I think there were 19 of them. And he looked at the claims, like there was a time where a officer was being shot at. He shot an individual.

The bullet went through the individual, shot a black person behind him and killed him. That was counted.

Well,.

That was, should have been an accidental death. That was,.

He,.

It was not the intended target,.

But,.

But they counted that. So when he got all done, there was only one case out of the 19 that counted, that could be, he felt possibly a white cop killing a black person.

Right.

Now is that, is that a justified shooting? Or would we say that's, you know, a white cop killing a black cop just because he was black?

Well,.

See,.

And that was, that was the one case that he said there wasn't enough evidence to show whether the officer,.

I mean,.

The claim was the officer did it because the guy was black. It was the only one that was questionable on being a legitimate shooting. But all the others were clearly legitimate shootings or accidental shootings where the black person wasn't even the intended target.

Now I'm saying that to say this, first off, the way black lives matter sound, it sounded like there was way more than 19 in a year. It sounded like it's happening every day.

Yeah.

They make it sound like it's happening all the time in every city, every day.

Yeah.

And so you would think from 2018 to 2023 in that five year period that,.

Man,.

There's must've been a lot.

No,.

There were 37. So if we count the number of ones that we know are by transgenders, that's 13%. That's double their population. By the way, the claim is, is that they're 6 of the population. If that's true, then they do twice as much of the mass shootings for their population.

I don't know the, it would be an interesting thing to get all of the, these mass shootings and the date, the individuals and start to put some, some looking together of who is doing the mass shootings.

It may find some interesting things. This article is saying that the trend is going up in the number of transgenders. And remember, this is not, this is 2023. So this doesn't count the most recent one,.

Right? That would be another one.

So,.

And we don't know about the one in Kansas city yet. So they have not revealed that I know of. I haven't heard whether it was male or female, just two suspects. Makes me wonder,.