Are Reformed People Too Hard on Topical Preaching?

Alright Tim, so the question for today is, are Reformed people too hard on topical preaching?

In some sense I think the answer is yes, and in other senses I think the answer is probably no.

Okay, so probably the vaguest answer possible. Yeah, I mean I want to say yes,

I want to say no, okay. So no, we'll start with a no. I mean I think in a lot of ways most of the topical preaching that most people are gonna do is just bad.

It's just, it's worse than bad, it's like the kind of stuff that you wouldn't want your dog to listen to, kind of bad.

And that's just true, I mean most of the time when you have, particularly when you have pastors who most of what they do is topical preaching, what's gonna happen is that most, they have some kind of topic in their mind.

In best case scenario they have a topic that they came to independently that they want to talk about.

Worst case scenario is some kind of charismatic experience has led to some sort of sermon, and then once they have their message then they go to the text and they basically find their passage that already confirms what they believe.

So it's like an eisegetical exercise at that point. And a lot of times if it's just on a practical topic it's gonna be mostly just them trying to pigeonhole the

Bible into some kind of psychological or sociological observation at that point. Reform people being hard on topical preaching if the only experience they have with topical preaching is that kind of thing,

I totally get it. And that's most of what's happening, particularly in your big churches, is you have a bunch of topical stuff and it's just bad.

So yeah, yes and amen, most of it's bad. Yeah, I remember I saw someone ask this question online,

I think this week actually, maybe you saw this too, but someone asked, do you know of any false teachers that preach eisegetically?

And I couldn't think of a single, maybe there's someone out there, but I couldn't think of a single person. Everyone I've ever heard is like the, you know,

I'm gonna pull from three to five different random verses and do the most sort of theological backflips

I can to try and make them mean exactly what I want them to mean, right?

Yeah, and that's the value of exposition at that point, is it forces a preacher to deal with what's actually in the text.

And it can be a very helpful and corrective thing if it's done well, to actually walk through the text.

And a lot of the bad theologies that are out there are the kind of theologies that could be corrected by a preacher committing himself to careful verse -by -verse exposition week in and week out.

And so I'm in favor of it, and most of what, you know, the teaching I've done has always been exposition, and I like it and I lean that direction.

But then at the same time, I think that there is a very important place for topical preaching to be found also, and I think

Reformed people, that maybe they're too hard on the concept of topical preaching in general because it's so abused.

So I do have a corrective I wish could happen in most churches as it relates to this.

I would say, yes, I think that on the one hand, it's impossible to be too hard on what's actually being done under the name of topical preaching.

Jared It's impossible to be too hard on that, but then like the idea itself, it's not a bad idea when done well.

Pete Careful, Tim, you might alienate our base audience. Jared That's fine. Well, we'll get them at one point or another, right?

I mean, they can't listen to us for long. They have to have thick enough skin to get it one way or the other.

But no, I think what topical preaching is designed to do is it's designed to answer the question, what does the whole

Bible say on a particular topic? And if you're the kind of individual who has a very thorough, comprehensive, not exhaustive knowledge of the

Scripture, but a comprehensive knowledge of the Scripture, you could do topical very well.

And doing topical very well is very helpful. It's a very helpful thing that I wish more preachers do, but then it is very hard.

If you're going to answer the question, what does the whole Bible say about marriage? What does the whole

Bible say about sex? What does the whole Bible say about parenting?

What does the whole Bible say about voting? Churches, they need to answer these questions that people have that are very practical in orientation.

And the problem is that it just takes a lot more work. Exegetical preaching is easy.

It really is. It's a lot easier than doing topical well. I mean, it's easy to do topical poorly, right?

Exposition is a lot harder than doing it poorly. But doing it well means that you're going to have to read the whole book multiple times, cover to cover, and requires you to have a pretty, not an exhaustive understanding of the

Scripture, but a pretty comprehensive understanding of the Scripture to be able to answer those questions. And I think that it does have a very important place in the life of the pulpit to where, you think about as you go through, like I don't want to wait 10 years to talk about marriage from the pulpit, right?

Because I finally get to Ephesians 5 or Colossians or whatever. I don't want to wait 10 years to do that.

I think that there's a lot of people that come and go in between 10 years, and it might be that you want to –

Pete Just teach through the book of Song of Solomon, man. Verse by verse. Jared I mean, the thing is most people who are doing exposition, they're only doing it in the

New Testament anyways, right? So there's that too. But I do think periodically taking a break from the normal exposition that you do as your steady dyke that keeps you honest, and just addressing certain topics like, what does the

Bible say about voting? I mean, I wish that there were churches that went there with it. What does the Bible say about voting?

Let's do a short topical series on this and try to cover the main points here. You don't have to cover everything, but let's cover the main points and inform people.

And I think that could be a very helpful thing. Now, I think a lot of churches, they have arbitrarily decided they're going to do that in small groups, and they're not going to do that in the

Sunday morning service. And I would just think, why not? Why not have a month series on voting?

And particularly if you're recording it, you can have it there for posterity and refer people back to it. I think that could be a good thing.

That could be a netifying thing, a helpful thing. Same thing for marriage, same thing for parenting. I mean,

I don't think you have to wait 20 years to talk about it one time. And part of the problem with doing it from an exposition sense is that you get to that passage in Ephesians, children obey your parents and the

Lord for this is right. Fathers do not provoke your children to wrath, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the

Lord. It's like, that's not everything the Bible has to say about parenting. And maybe at some point in like, you have two options at that point.

You get to that passage and then you're going to do a topical message in disguise, right? To where you're going to brought it in and out.

And I would just say, no, I mean, just do a series on parenting. Talk about the major features of parenting in the

Bible. And it might be something that you add that can scratch certain itches and answer certain questions that your church is going to have.

And there are some regular, normal, main things that you should address as a pastor.

And I wish we could just, I think the broader point is, I wish we could just do it well, put it in there in between the regular exposition, show all the charlatans and the frauds how to do it, how to really do it.

But I think we can do it better than them. I don't think we have to surrender that territory. I think we should do it better than them.

And yeah, keep on doing the exposition that keeps you honest, that keeps you focused, but then also do the topical stuff too.

And that's what systematic theology essentially is, is just doing something very similar to that. It's organizing the

Bible by means of topics. And I think it would be a nice part of what we're doing if we could make a bigger effort to include that in what we're doing.

Is there anything beneficial from saying, I know sort of your solution to it is say, hey, do probably mostly exegetical preaching and then periodically insert periods of time, several weeks at a time where you have a topical series that you're going through.

Is there any benefit from doing some sort of like, you know, probably 95 % of the time on a

Sunday, I'm going to preach exegetically, but then

I'm trying to purposefully supplement like on Wednesday nights or something, a lot more topical type things that don't necessarily have much to do with what's taught on Sunday, but are trying to more teach like the whole counsel of the

Bible. Yeah. I mean, I think if you, I would say that if you're devoted predominantly in the

Sunday morning to do exposition, then you really do need to make sure that you're doing topical in the midweek kind of stuff or the

Sunday night kind of stuff as a necessity. Do you think that that's like a good way to do it? Or that's just like, if you are doing it that way and that's really what you want to do?

Well, I don't know, there's no rules to this, you know, and I think some of the, you know, I think the

Reformed crowd has arbitrarily decided that exposition is the only way to do it.

And I would just say that, oh, I think you want to teach the whole counsel of God and, you know, that's one faithful way to do it.

And I think, I do think you need to get around to, you know, actually being helpful. So sometimes like, you know, you can do exposition poorly too, you know, just like you can do topical really poorly, you can do exposition really poorly.

And I think exposition is a safeguard, but then sometimes like it, like you can provoke a lot of questions in the normal exposition that you're not going to answer if you're going to be faithful to the intent of the passage.

And I think you need to have some way of answering those kinds of questions. So like, you know, you open up a can of worms with the submission stuff and the role stuff and, you know, there's a lot more to marriage than that.

And if that's the only time you ever really talk about marriage, you know, then you need to, I'm not saying that, like, there's a lot of passages that talk about marriage, you know, here and there, but it might be nice just to get a whole picture of what it looks like in one, you know, sitting to get your mind around the whole, instead of just like gazing at a part here and a part there and a part there, you know?

And so like, put it all together and help us see the whole thing, you know, and I think there has to be some place for that.

So yeah, I mean, if you say, hey, Sunday's always going to be exposition, you know, Wednesdays we'll do the topical stuff, that's fine, whatever.

I mean, but I just think it, you know, my opinion, my opinion, you know, non -sanctified opinion is that it, you know, it might be nice when, like, to, when most of your people are there, right?

Most of the people who are there on Sunday morning to put a little topical in there. And I wouldn't say 95 % of the time, because that means you do one topical sermon every two years, right?

But I would say, I mean, I would say make most, I would advise make most of it exposition, you know, but, you know, you do have to,

I would say it would be helpful, I think. Pete What I'm getting out of this is we need to do a series on Song of Solomon to counterbalance the submissions.

Jay Well, I think, yeah, just related to the topic of preaching in general,

I think we could do a better job of getting a lot more Old Testament in there too, right? Not be functionally

Marcionites in how we're preaching, you know, get some of the Old Testament stuff in there, it's written for our instruction too, so.

Pete I'm taking this as a personal sign from God that we need to do the, I'm just kidding.

No, okay, no, I think that makes sense, yeah. You know, probably do mostly exegetical preaching, but then we probably do need to do a better job with having some topical things because there is a benefit in terms of trying to teach more of the whole counsel of God and we get to stick it to all the false teachers by teaching topically the right way.

All right, fair enough. Fair enough. This has been another episode of Bible Bashed.

We hope you have been encouraged and blessed through our discussion. We thank you for all your support and ask you to continue to like and subscribe to Bible Bashed and share our podcast with your friends and on social media.

Please reach out to us with your questions, pushback, and potential topics for us to discuss in future episodes at BibleBashedPodcast at gmail .com

and consider supporting us through Patreon. If you would like to be Bible Bashed personally, then please know that we also offer free biblical counseling which you can take advantage of by emailing us.

Now, go boldly and obey the truth in the midst of a biblically illiterate world who will be perpetually offended by your every move.