RLL 27: Allan Wall on Immigration, William Saletan and Soros Evangelicals

ThornCrown Network

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:24

You're listening to Radio Luke's Lucid. I'm your host Steve Matthews. Thanks for joining me today for episode 27 today

00:30

I have a special guest with me Alan Wall Alan. Welcome to the program. Well, thank you very much

00:36

Steve It's a great opportunity to be on your show here and it's a great honor to have you here for me

00:41

You know Alan I've it's kind of funny. I'm talking to you here today for the first time But I followed your work for years I almost feel like I know you a little bit just from from having read so much of your work over the years

00:50

I've been reading you since you were doing the memo from Mexico column And oh, right.

00:56

Yeah, it goes back a ways. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, so that goes back a ways and you know I've long thought that you're one of the very finest writers out there on the subject of immigration and You wrote a piece a couple weeks ago that was posted on VDare .com

01:09

And we're gonna get and we're gonna want to talk about that in a minute that piece just really knocked me out And I said, well, I've got to get

01:15

Alan Wall on the line here So I really thank you so much for joining me here today But you know before we dive into talking about your article in particular

01:23

I wanted you to give a little sense of your background to the listeners because I think it's a very interesting background and I think it may be of some context to To why you're such a an effective writer on the subject of immigration.

01:36

Well, yes, I the main thing I guess I want to emphasize is that that I lived in Mexico for many years a

01:44

Decade and a half. I was working there as an English teacher And so I I lived in the society, you know,

01:51

I was not a tourist I lived there I I spoke the language I Followed the media and I you know,

01:58

I worked in Mexican schools I attended Mexican churches and I associated with you know, people of different social levels.

02:06

I Was able to visit different parts of the country and my wife is Mexican I met my wife there and we were married and and so, you know,

02:14

I also have Mexican in -laws so I Ten years ago. We had the opportunity to move to the

02:21

United States for a particular job opportunity that was convenient for us, so I brought my family here and But we frequently visit

02:31

Mexico. I like to go there Every year and I like to keep up with what's going on and I you know,

02:37

I love the people I love the society and I'm I'm very comfortable there Okay, sure here and and I know one of the features that you you write quite a bit is

02:46

I think it's called said in Spanish am I correct about that? Yes, exactly. Yeah, because of course being fluent in Spanish and you're familiar with the the

02:54

Mexican media Yeah I think that's a great service for people who are interested in in immigration because most of us don't have access to that the way

03:01

That you do and I think that's a very helpful service that you provide One thing

03:07

I did want to ask you to Alan is what is it that got you you interested in writing about immigration? Well, really the answer to that question is related to the first question

03:18

Living in Mexico. It was a real Education because I was able to see immigration from the other side

03:28

Now in the United States, there's this very romanticized vision of immigration

03:34

You know, it isn't it wonderful they all want to come here. They they're looking for freedom, you know, they want to become

03:41

Americans and Americans feel a sort of pride that people would want to live in their country and But when

03:49

I lived in Mexico, you know, it gradually dawned on me, you know, that's not how the people here see it in Mexico because Obviously many

03:59

Mexicans expressed the desire to move to the United States But I never heard them say they were looking for freedom and they did not say they were doing it to become

04:10

Americans They do it for the money. I you know, that's totally understandable.

04:16

They can make more money in the United States and But but here's what's amazing, too even when they become

04:24

American citizens, they are still regarded as Mexicans and Mexicans look at Mexican Americans and even

04:33

Mexican Americans who are born in the United States as Essentially Mexicans and and we're not talking about a small group of people we're talking about millions of people right and it and then

04:46

I saw how the whole society in Mexico supports illegal immigration and They and and I saw how the government is meddling in our political system

04:56

You know all this hysteria about Russian meddling. Let's suppose I don't really believe all that stuff

05:02

But let's suppose it's all true it is Almost nothing compared to what

05:07

Mexico is doing because what Mexico is doing is utilizing dual citizens to meddle in our politics

05:16

You know 2016 election they they did that. Yeah, it's just amazing. Yeah. Yeah, and you know

05:22

Alan I think that you're saying that that's probably the first time a lot of people are hearing this Exactly because used to be

05:29

Mexico did not permit dual citizenship. Yeah, if I'm a Mexican became an American citizen, he's not a

05:35

Mexican In the 1990s, they changed it Specifically to meddle in the

05:40

United States and yet none of our politicians seem to care about that. It's just amazing That is amazing.

05:47

You're absolutely right So yeah, I can definitely see why you know what you said and having lived in Mexico and seeing things from the other side you know that that would would certainly be a strong impetus to begin, you know, writing and maybe perhaps educating and correcting some of the

06:03

The fallacies that that many Americans have about about immigration and in particular, you know immigration from Mexico That's right.

06:13

And you know, and I think other Latin Americas other Latin American countries You have you have similar ideas to though, you know, and now we have it.

06:21

It's mostly Central America Is sending these immigrants but but I see in those countries kind of some similar dynamics in the society also as the government's are

06:33

You know tacitly encouraging their people to leave rather than solve the problems in their own country.

06:39

Sure. Sure. Okay Well Alan, yeah turning to the the article that you wrote

06:45

This was a an article is published back on just a couple weeks ago back on December 26th on Vidar and the title of your pieces memo from Middle America st

06:55

William Salatin says white evangelical Trump supporters are un -christian. How would he know and the the

07:03

Article that you wrote about is as the title of your critique suggests the article that you were writing about as a piece

07:09

By a gentleman named William Salatin, and I think I'm saying his name correctly as does that sound right to you

07:14

Salatin? I I've I believe I believe you're correct I've never really heard it pronounced, but I just assumed that that's how you pronounce it, right?

07:22

I tried to go with that Okay, because I tried to find something on the internet the other day and I couldn't find anything that gave me any guide to that Well, that sounds about right.

07:30

So I'm gonna go with Salatin, but when Salatin he is He's a writer for slate magazine and and in the title of his piece this was the petite the piece you critiqued is called

07:42

Trump's Christian apologists are un -christian and Maybe what I wanted to start out with Alan is just asking you, you know

07:49

Most evangelicals probably don't read William Salatin. Most evangelicals probably don't read slate

07:54

So why should evangelicals really care what slate and what William Salatin have to say?

08:02

well, yes from a a Spiritual standpoint we don't care. In other words, it's not a source we would go to for spiritual sustenance

08:11

But in order to be informed about what is out there that's why you know,

08:17

I thought it was worth Looking over the article because here this individual who is not even a

08:23

Christian of any sort, you know does not claim to be a Christian here he is holding forth and Explaining who is a good

08:31

Christian and who is not a good Christian Wow you know who appointed him the authority to do that and and what a coincidence to a

08:39

Good Christian for William Salatin is somebody who is against President Trump.

08:46

Wow, what a coincidence amazing, isn't it? Yeah, and you know,

08:51

I think you said in your critique of the article I mean you called it a fiery Article I believe and boy that's that certainly is true.

09:00

He really you know Salatin He really unloads on on evangelicals with both barrels as we would say.

09:06

Oh, yes. Yes Yeah, they call them wicked. Yeah and purveyors of wickedness, you know, yeah

09:12

I think he did that twice who called them wicked or something like that. I think he used that term Article is it was really pretty shocking.

09:19

You don't really expect to hear language like that Maybe out of slate so much, but I guess in this case, I guess on the subject of immigration.

09:26

It really really brings out the The hellfire and brimstone in them or something. I don't know

09:33

Now one of the things that you pointed out In your article, you know, you mentioned

09:39

Individuals you referred to as Soros evangelicals such as for instance Russell Moore. Could you expand on what you mean by that?

09:48

Well Russell Moore, he's one example of this type of person. He's a high -ranking bureaucrat in the

09:53

Southern Baptist Convention Head of the so -called

09:58

Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission, and of course, he's a big booster of amnesty for illegal aliens

10:06

And but but what is really okay. Some people are for that. I understand but what is really bothersome is he makes it a a

10:14

Christian doctrine issue in other words, he says if you're not for Illegal aliens, you're a bad

10:21

Christian, you know, if you're not for the demographic transformation of this country, etc You're a bad

10:27

Christian. So actually he's very you could call him Legalistic if you don't agree with him, you're not a good

10:34

Christian, you know, that's that's the way he presents it Yeah, it's it's pretty shocking to read some of the statements.

10:40

He's made over the year I did been doing a little bit of research on the the evangelical immigration table

10:47

For example, and of course, I know that he has been I don't know if he currently is but know that he has been

10:52

Associated with the evangelical immigration table and some of the statements that he makes You know if if you

10:59

I don't know if you cut and pasted his statements on to say, you know

11:04

The website of the Open Society found a foundation or something It wouldn't be out of place at all because he does sound just like George Soros or you know

11:15

Somebody that supports George Soros Exactly and and there's a reason you know as many have pointed out that Russell Moore and some of these other groups, they're getting

11:28

George Soros money, you know, it might pass through several different organizations, but this money is being funneled to elitist evangelicals supporting amnesty mass immigration

11:41

So and you got to ask yourself. Hey, why is George Soros, you know an atheist globalist billionaire?

11:47

He wants to erase borders and construct a sort of new global order like the Tower of Babel Hey, why is he giving money to these hundreds of thousands of dollars to evangelical

11:58

Christians who? Support open borders. It's kind of curious. You might want to ask that question.

12:05

Yeah. Yeah, exactly I think that's certainly cause to be wary of men, such as Russell Moore and Moving on in the in Salatin's article he

12:18

Actually quotes at some length a gentleman by the name of Ed Stetzer Who's identified as the director of the

12:24

Billy Graham Center at Wheaton College? And he uses the words of Ed Stetzer really to to castigate in particular white evangelicals for their support of Trump and in border control and you know apart from the influence of George Soros, why is it did you think that so many

12:42

Evangelical leaders are really so bad on the subject of immigration Well, you know that that's a good question.

12:51

I I got a few theories, but I'm it's probably a combination I guess part of it is our

12:56

You know, our whole society has moved to the left including You know the academic world the military and all our elite institutions and the church leaders to some of them

13:08

You know, they've been influenced by this left -wing soundbites and pop psychology and and all these these sort of emotional

13:16

You know answers and and little easy answers that when you break them down They really don't make that much sense and we might even speculate that they like the worldly acclaim that they receive from the mainstream media and Essentially what these people are doing

13:34

Ed Stetzer, for example He is bashing You know middle

13:40

American white evangelical middle -class Evangelical Protestants, he's bashing them, you know in in a secular venue

13:49

Right. Yeah, that's pretty amazing the way he does it. Yeah. Yeah, you said that in fact you you cited this in your article

13:55

You know You talked about the fact that he appeared on both NPR and on Vox and I think what one on the one on one day

14:02

One on the next day or within a very short time frame. Yeah, right Yeah, you know

14:07

Yeah, they find people like that yeah, yeah exactly and of course I know and maybe you mentioned this in your article to of course

14:15

Russell Moore, you know, he has written I believe several Editorials for the

14:22

New York Times. Oh, yes. He's their go -to evangelical, you know They don't really like evangelicals, but if they could find a guy like Russell Moore that they'll they'll play him up.

14:33

Yeah Yeah, he's he's useful to their cause Now what I wanted to ask you your opinion on this do you think that Evangelicals just I'm talking about the rank -and -file ordinary evangelicals in the pews

14:44

Do you think that they're aware of the extent to which their? Spokesmen are at odds with their own views on immigration.

14:52

I Would say that probably not, you know most Rank -and -file evangelicals they probably aren't even aware of most of this

15:02

Kind of elitist bureaucratic type stuff like like even it like the Southern Baptist Convention it's really

15:10

The churches are autonomous, you know, the individual congregations are autonomous, but they have this this overarching bureaucracy which is actually

15:19

Seems to be more liberal than the rank -and -file church members. I've suggested in a previous article

15:26

They ought to just disband the whole Denomination because the property of the local churches already belongs to the local churches.

15:34

They don't really need that bureaucracy Okay, sure. And if I may ask you this, are you do you belong to the

15:40

Southern Baptist Church? Are you with some other church? Yeah, I'm not actually in the Southern Baptist Church, but I've I've always respected them

15:48

I don't know. They're they're very active in you know, large parts of the country and But but I'm sorry to see people like Russell Moore representing them and in Denigrating, you know the rank -and -file members like he does.

16:01

Yeah. Yeah, that's you know, it's you know, it's it's sad how much the

16:07

Sort of the political situation if you can call it that in in in the Southern Baptist Church mirrors what goes on in in society

16:15

Broadly, unfortunately, I mean you would expect exactly you would yeah You you would hope that that people in a position of leadership in the churches

16:23

Would behave toward the people that support them in a more supportive way

16:30

But unfortunately, I just don't seem to be the case. Yeah No, no, it doesn't unfortunately

16:37

Now I want to move on to another point here that you brought up in your your article Salatin when he in his writing he he noted that surveys in surveys of religious voters that The numbers for evangelicals were quote bad and in by bad

16:54

He meant that evangelicals strongly supported Donald Trump. I just wanted to get your perspective on those poll numbers

17:00

I think it might be a little different than Salatin's Yeah, well Yeah, when he says it's bad

17:08

I would think well that sounds pretty good, you know, he said oh it's terrible 81 % Support Trump.

17:14

It's a wow. That's great. Well, maybe we could try to lift that up a little bit, but It's kind of funny, you know the way that works.

17:21

Yeah. Yeah. He yeah, I mean and of course the the assumptions that are contained in that, you know, the

17:29

It's almost a sort of a begging of the question, you know, he he says they're bad. Well, why is it bad?

17:34

He doesn't really explain why that's bad other than just to say I guess he disagrees with it Yeah, that's the bottom line.

17:41

That is really the bottom line. Yeah. Yeah now Another question here for you.

17:46

Do you think that as Salatin charges that? Well, he he when he's talking about Evangelicals, he calls them white evangelical

17:55

Protestants or weps, I guess and I think he invented that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So so when when

18:01

Salatin Charges that weps have compromised their moral principles by supporting

18:06

Trump and retreated from moral judgment of him What what would you say to that? Well, you know,

18:13

I I can only speak for myself, but I don't I don't approve

18:18

We know that Donald Trump is not perfect. I mean we knew that already I don't approve of anything that he's done that that is not that is not moral or not good

18:28

But that's not really the issue here is it I mean really in politics we have to choose between the imperfect

18:36

You know candidates and and think about in a 2016 election. Really? You got to look at the whole agenda and and how could you even compare the

18:45

Hillary agenda and the Trump agenda, right? And in religious freedom, which is a big issue for us, you know, wow, there's there's no contest there either

18:55

Right exactly and I have to admit, you know It took me a while to come around to supporting Donald Trump because I wrestled with some of those issues

19:03

And of course, yeah, there's a lot there. Yeah, there's a lot there to wrestle with Yeah, and you know, and I think sometimes when you know,

19:11

Salatin makes this blanket charge that you know Evangelicals have retreated from moral judgment of him somehow. He seems to say well.

19:16

Oh, yeah, you know evangelicals They approve of every single thing he's ever said or every single thing he's ever done And I think you and I would both say well

19:23

Yeah, there are some things that he said and done that you know, I wish he had not said or done And and I don't have to defend all those things, you know, we don't we don't have to defend all of those things

19:33

But I think on certain big issues for instance immigration since we're talking about that I think that he was a whole lot closer to to being where You know where as a

19:47

Christian I would want him to be as compared to any of the other candidates that were running oh Yes.

19:54

Yes And even you know the Libertarian candidate some people saw him as a viable alternative

20:02

Gary Johnson, I call him the so -called Libertarian candidate because he's against freedom of association

20:08

Yeah, he would punish cake bakers who didn't want to participate in gay weddings. What kind of a

20:14

Libertarian is that? Yeah, that's your status Libertarian That's not a

20:19

Libertarian at all Really? I don't see how you can reconcile that that type of thinking with Libertarianism at all

20:25

But apparently he he was able to square that circle somehow Yeah Yeah now you brought up I think a really a wonderful point here and I'm going to To just cite

20:40

Andrew Salatin, I want to hear your response to this at one point Salatin complained that these white evangelical

20:47

Protestants have abdicated social responsibility Because they lack charity toward poor people and you replied to to his comment and what you did is you drew an important distinction?

20:59

Between Christian charity on the one hand and government welfare on the other hand

21:04

I'd like you to explain the difference between these two concepts Yes, they are totally different because Christian charity is when a

21:15

Christian from the love of Christ Gives of his own resources freely gives a cheerful giver like the

21:23

Apostle Paul says freely gives to help somebody that is totally different from Government welfare, which is a system in which you know, the government takes money from one citizen

21:38

By force, you know, if you don't believe that don't pay your taxes next year and Gives it to another well citizen or maybe even a non -citizen in order to buy their votes and political support

21:50

I mean that is so cynical To identify the two they are not the same thing at all

21:56

Right in in you're absolutely right and I think that's an absolutely crucial distinction and thank you for making that I really appreciate the fact that you you brought that idea to the surface

22:05

You know, one of the things that I find that when I read immigration comments or columns or pieces by especially by Evangelicals they seem to confuse these two ideas

22:18

You know, they seem to think that somehow, you know, if if you don't want to to give the whole country away

22:25

Via, you know taxes and subsidies and welfare and such like that that somehow you're not being charitable

22:31

Well, as you said, that's not Christian charity. That's nothing to do with Christian charity Exactly, and in reality white evangelical

22:39

Protestants are very generous people They give a lot of money to help people here and abroad and it's just it's a slander to say that about them

22:49

I agree completely I think that that's and I really think that keeping that distinction between Christian charity and government welfare that overturns

22:58

So much of the bad thinking that we see both in the the secular presses as well as from You know religious writers on the subject of immigration

23:10

Exactly because they're they're trying to guilt -trip. This was what they're doing, right? Yeah, yeah, exactly

23:17

And let's see the yeah, you know that that's that that's exactly what it is. You know, they just just lay the guilt on it

23:22

It's it's amazing Moving on to another thought here in this probably would surprise no one if if someone has followed the

23:32

The discussions about immigration over the last number of years in the United States. He shouldn't be surprised to think that William Salatin says that racism is the reason that white evangelical

23:44

Protestants are concerned about immigration and what are your thoughts about that? well, yeah, that's the typical response and I You know the problem with the term racism is it's a word that is that is almost lost all its meaning

23:58

No one has ever really made a clear definition of the term and yet You could actually lose your career if you're accused of being a racist and yet look at the things that many minority activists say about white people and They're never called to account for that and yet, you know nowadays the term racism is generally used as a

24:23

As a slur against against white people or as some people have said, you know A definition of a racist is a liberal who's losing an argument with a conservative.

24:32

It's being used, you know in those ways, right? So we shouldn't really I really honestly don't it's hard to take the word seriously anymore.

24:41

Sure Yeah, and of course nobody likes to be called that it's a type of a word that I mean, it's an awful thing

24:46

I mean, we don't want to you know as Christians. We're called to love our neighbors as ourselves You know, we're not called to write them, you know, and and so that's not something, you know

24:56

It's terrible for for that to be said about anybody But maybe especially as a Christian and I think it maybe scares a lot of evangelicals and I think maybe that's one of the reasons

25:04

I'm just speculating here. See you would see what you think about that. I think it's perhaps one of the reasons why

25:10

Evangelicals have not given a clear unequivocal response to some of the

25:17

The immigration nonsense that's not only out there just in the secular press, but that's also put out by a lot of people as representative

25:25

Christian thought on immigration Oh no doubt about it, there's a great fear of being called a racist and And it's used so unfairly that you know, people are afraid to be called a racist, but really

25:39

They're probably gonna call us that anyway, so we just need to think about and do what's right, you know and not and not

25:46

Be driven by that fear anymore. Sure. Sure. Yeah Well Alan that really kind of covered all the the main points that I wanted to go over on your article

25:55

Did you have any other comments that that you're interested in making here today? Well, I mean,

26:01

I would just say we shouldn't Christians should not let people like William Salatin or Ed Stetzer Or Russell Moore, you know guilt trip us, you know

26:11

If we if I would say if you want to help poor folks in Latin America help them in their own country

26:17

You know, that's the Christian thing to do for one thing Your dollar goes further in those countries and you can help them in their own society in their own culture and their own communities

26:28

That's real Christian charity not trying to move, you know thousands of people Across thousands of miles, you know, like there's all this caravan stuff, you know, that that is not

26:38

Christian charity, right? Right, I concur completely Well Alan, where can listeners find your work on the

26:45

Internet? Well, I have a I have a website called Alan wall dot info now

26:51

My name is spelled a l l a n w a l l dot and it's kind of a it's not calm

26:58

Or it's not or it's info So out w w w dot

27:05

Alan wall dot info. Okay outstanding. Well Alan I wanted to thank you so much for coming on the program today.

27:12

It's been a real pleasure speaking with you On behalf of everyone at thorn crown ministries.

27:17

This is Steve Matthews saying thank you very much for listening I really hope that you join me again for our next podcast