Just War

Have You Not Read

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:11

Welcome to Have You Not Read, a podcast seeking to answer questions from the text of Scripture for the honor of Christ and the edification of the

00:19

Saints. Before we dig into our topic, we humbly ask you to rate, review, and share the podcast.

00:25

Thank you. I'm Dylan Hamilton and with me are Michael Durham, David Kassin, and Andrew Hudson.

00:31

We are happy to answer another question that came in from one of our listeners. The question reads, and it's a two -parter, are

00:38

Christians supposed to be involved in earthly wars? Are Christians to be involved in military combat of any kind?

00:44

And I think we would like to start by delineating between just war and holy war as two separate categories.

00:51

Michael, would you like to tackle that real fast? Yes, so when we read, for instance, in the

00:57

Old Testament that God commissioned Israel to be his instrument of judgment against the nations of Canaan with whom he was patient for hundreds of years, having given them effective and robust witness through the lives of the patriarchs

01:12

Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, yet they did not turn from their evil and idolatrous ways. He strove with them and was patient with them for hundreds of years, and then when he brought his people into the land he used

01:24

Israel as an instrument of judgment. And he instructed them that anything that was placed under the ban was to be utterly destroyed.

01:31

It was holy to the Lord for destruction. So we see that all of Jericho, except for Rahab and her family, was placed under the ban.

01:39

All of it was to be burned and destroyed. Achan sinned and did not follow through on that, so his family came under the ban.

01:47

But that's a classic example. This is holy war because God, in his holiness, sent his people as his instrument of judgment to destroy these nations and obliterate them.

01:58

And then on other occasions he would tell them, okay, with this region or this city you may take spoils, but the rest of these things must be destroyed.

02:07

And it was all according to the righteous and holy judgment of God.

02:13

When people read these stories in the Old Testament, they want to find fault with God for his holiness, when we should be learning lessons about how holy

02:23

God is and our need for a mediator, for a Savior. They want to find fault with Israel for being party to this supposed genocide.

02:31

This is a man -shaped word being imported over onto God. No, God was actually bringing about judgment.

02:40

It's not genocide. So holy war in the Scriptures is different than perhaps holy wars that we have read about in history.

02:52

Again, they're similar in that they're saying we have a divine right to go take this land or kill these people, but the only case we actually see that in the

03:01

Scriptures is when God authorizes his servant to bring about his judgment in his way.

03:08

Now, God did that with Abram when he went to war with his trained servants against Cheddar -Laramore and those who had raided and came into the land of Canaan.

03:21

And Abram responded properly and he gave tithes of the spoils to the

03:26

Lord and would take nothing from the king of Sodom. So we see that was a holy war. We see the holy war in the life of Israel, how

03:33

God told them to treat the Canaanites and it was holy in the sense that, you know, they're not going to be falling into idolatry and compromising themselves and so on.

03:43

When we see how the Old Covenant is fulfilled by Christ in the

03:51

New Covenant, we do not have the end of all holy war. We have the consolidation of all these shadows unto the person and work of Jesus Christ.

04:01

And when we see Jesus Christ as the fulfillment of Israel and we see him as Psalm 2 pictures him as God's anointed upon his holy hill, we see that Christ has a rod of iron in his hand and the nations are given to him as an inheritance.

04:17

And he smashes the nations that rebel against him with a rod of iron against like clay pots.

04:23

And therefore the kings and judges of the earth are called and said you should be very considerate of the authority of the

04:33

God's anointed God's Son and you should bow the knee to him and take refuge in him that you may be blessed.

04:39

So we also see this image throughout the rest of Scripture how Jesus Christ is the judge of all and that Jesus brings ultimate judgment against all those nations, all those peoples who would rage and rebel against God.

04:57

In this sense the shadows of holy war have been fulfilled by the substance which is in Christ.

05:05

Now what about what does that mean for Christians? Are we involved in holy war? You know that belongs to the servant, that belongs to Jesus.

05:12

Okay now the question is what is just war then? What is just war? In this sense what kind of war would be right in God's sight?

05:20

What kind of war would be, I mean all the war is just terrible, but what kind of war would be justified for Christians to be involved in given the standards of God's character as expressed in God's Word?

05:33

Okay and in this sense there might be some sort of overlap in which

05:38

Christians defending their homeland against evil oppressors who are coming to take their children and so on that God may empower them to successfully defend their land and defeat an enemy.

05:51

We would not be saying I am conducting holy war, I would be saying I'm conducting just war, but it may very well be that God is using the situation in his providence, in his sovereignty for Christ to bring about holy judgment against this nation.

06:08

Okay so I think it's important to make those distinctions but I'm already beginning to answer is it okay for Christians to be involved in military action of any kind?

06:16

And this is a good question right? Because what are some of the passages in the Bible that immediately confront the

06:21

Christian about getting involved with you know violent war -like action? Well the modern pacifist movement, say the the

06:31

Quakers, Amish, they take Matthew 5 38 42 which talks about if someone offends you, slaps your cheek, you should you know turn the other cheek also.

06:41

Someone you know takes your cloak, you know give them your shirt also. I mean there's and once you walk a mile walk you know walk to that there's no place for any kind of violence whatsoever and that's you know their view and they take that to to an extreme.

06:58

I think that Romans 12 and 13 talk about who properly bears the sword.

07:04

So the government bears the sword and it doesn't bear the sword in vain. And in that same vein of not avenging yourself

07:13

Romans 12 19 says beloved do not avenge yourselves leave it to the wrath of God for it is written vengeance is mine

07:19

I will repay says the Lord and that is taken right out of Deuteronomy. And then into Romans 13 it talks about the authorities and not bearing and then the the authorities bear that sword in vain.

07:31

So there is a place for proper justice. There's a place for proper physical violence.

07:37

It is in the context of justice, in the context of restoring that that peace.

07:44

So we don't take our own personal vengeance, we leave room for the wrath of God, but there is a place for that and it is in the

07:53

God -ordained state. The role of the state is to punish the guilty and defend the innocent.

07:59

In that same vein you have nations protecting their own.

08:06

They defend their borders, they defend the innocent, they protect against those invasions or people that are coming to hurt them.

08:17

And just like a man would protect his family, a government is raised up to protect the the nation or the nation -state.

08:25

So personal vengeance I think that is really is the local context for Matthew 5 and it's still true.

08:32

I mean you don't want to take personal personal vengeance. You know then you get into the historical blood feuds and that has quite literally lasted centuries.

08:43

One person makes one offense, you take personal revenge, then the other people have to take that revenge on that revenge and it just compounds upon each other to have families fighting each other, villages fighting each other, cities fighting each other, nations fighting each other and they historically hate one another and I can't remember what started it.

09:00

Probably just a stolen goat. And we see that God put a mark on Cain to stem that kind of violence right away.

09:07

The violence continues and the earth was filled with violence which is what the reason why God sent the flood to fill the earth with water.

09:15

And just after the flood when God declares that the heart of man is fundamentally unchanged despite this you know global disaster that the heart of man is still evil from his youth.

09:28

He then says in Genesis 9 he says verse 5 surely for your lifeblood

09:36

I will demand a reckoning from the hand of every beast I will require it from the hand of man from the hand of every man's brother

09:41

I will require the life of man whoever sheds man's blood by man his blood shall be shed for in the image of God he made man and as for you be fruitful multiply and bring forth abundantly in the earth and multiply in it.

09:54

So in other words unless you have some form of civil government enforcing the death penalty good luck you know following the creation mandate.

10:03

How are you going to be fruitful and prosper? How are you going to exercise dominion in the name of God unless you have a proper in -place civil a government where if a man goes out and murders you know one two three people and he finally gets caught who puts him to death?

10:20

God -fearing people put him to death right? How has that been done you know in the

10:26

Bible there was a group stoning him who knows what the final stone was that actually ended the man's life but it was the group.

10:33

Same thing with a firing squad so on and so forth who knows what actually killed him but you know everybody was involved fearing

10:40

God rather than man bringing this to an end. But when what happens when you have a group a group of people running around killing a whole bunch of people what happens if you have you know cartels on your border slipping in and out of you know your national borders what do you do?

10:57

Well you know the civil governments need to get involved and they send in I would hope

11:03

God -fearing men with the necessary tools to bring about the execution of those who have been involved in murdering and pillaging and raping and so on and so forth all of these crimes worthy of capital punishment.

11:17

In this case we're talking about military action we're talking about something that is larger than okay someone murdered somebody was proved by you know two or three witnesses the evidence is clear and then the community brings forward this rather orderly death sentence for the one who's been detained but that is not fundamentally principally different in the

11:39

Bible than a group sent by the civil government who bears the sword as the minister of God sending forth armed agents to go take out evildoers.

11:49

Now there's nothing different between one and the other except for the experience of it how that actually comes to pass is going to be one's very orderly and the other one has an order but it's a far more chaotic and there's a lot more going on there okay but the question is should

12:05

Christians be involved in any military action of any kind? Well in that regard yes in that regard if being

12:12

God -fearing people who believe you know who ascribed to the to the creation mandate and we want to see be fruitful multiply you know we want to be living out the you know the image of God and so forth it's fine to be involved in the civil government as a civil magistrate who would order the execution of a murderer is that fine?

12:28

Yes as a civil magistrate who would order a group of soldiers to go carry out that execution order right what if it's a nation attacking a nation right we're just scaling up a principle that is set firmly in the scriptures so there is such a concept of you know just war a good reason for it this would be the right thing to do you know and it comes even back down to self -defense and defending your family if you're not gonna look at from the from the sphere of the civil government what about the sphere of family government aren't you gonna defend your family aren't you gonna be involved in military violent action if your family was threatened

13:08

I would hope that you would defend your family be very Christlike for you to defend your bride very

13:13

Christlike you know we see that in the scriptures Christ defends his bride he comes against it takes vengeance against those who assault her so however we look at it there is a space for that but I think that very often the concerns that you know sincere

13:30

Christians have is just how corrupt and messy and disastrous wars are it's hard to it's hard to read our own history and find a really clear -cut case of just war right it's really hard I think there needs to be liberty of conscience in these issues about how to think about what if you know what do you do if you live you know a few decades ago and there's a draft and they're saying you have to go to Vietnam and kill these

14:05

Vietnamese because the government tells you to when the whole thing was one of the worst corrupt scandalous types of things we've ever seen despite the bravery and the courage and the integrity of many who were involved it's a mess the whole concept of like the war could be just you know this is a

14:26

Western idea there's reasons to go to war than this conduct within war that's it's the difference between the just odd Bellum and and just in bellow is it is there's reasons to go to war and then once you're within it how do you conduct yourself properly right so really

14:42

I think we're focusing on the reasons to go to war Calvin actually discussed you know some of these things and he cites

14:50

Luke when John the Baptist is addressing some of the soldiers here we first he talks about tax collectors he says in verse 12 so 312 tax collectors also came to be baptized and said teacher what shall we do and he said to them collect no more than you are authorized to do soldiers also asked him and we what shall we do and he said to them do not extort money from anyone by threats or by false accusation and be content with your wages so the way

15:19

Calvin took that and Luther and Augustine as well and some of those before him was he didn't tell them to get out of the military exactly he said be content with your wages and perform your duties properly but okay so you can be can be in the in the military there's this whole just war tradition within the

15:39

Roman community though it dates back to Cicero you know says it actually predates you know Augustine and Aquinas and Luther and Calvin and this whole

15:47

Western tradition so there were reasons to go to war but what if it's a war of conquest what if it's a war if you're just gonna go and rape and pillage for resources you just knew we're gonna go and we're gonna to increase the glory and honor of our state well okay versus well we are being invaded by an opposing force who wants to rape and pillage and take all of our resources you know so there's is a defensive war so there's yeah it gets starts to get you know messier it's it's usually not good versus evil black versus white yeah so I'm in a very short order in the

16:19

Gospel of Luke Jesus moves from and making sure his disciples are armed telling them not to swing the sword and you know what's the difference well you know in the one context

16:30

Jesus is reminds them remember when I sent you out two by two and I told you don't get a bunch of supplies to prepare yourself but you know trust in the

16:37

Lord okay you learn that lesson you know but because of the days that are coming because I'm about to be executed and all of you are gonna be declared outlaws you're gonna need to be well prepared for living a life where you know you're gonna be marked men and you have any swords with you you know this is gonna be a natural thing that you're going to need to protect yourselves against bandits along the way on the roads and so on and so forth especially if you have to sleep outside of towns if you have to sleep in you know exposed areas you're gonna have to have swords to defend yourself that's the that's the basic idea but then when

17:10

Jesus and his disciples are in the Garden of Gethsemane he's getting arrested which he told them was the will of God and that was supposed to be

17:18

Peter lashes out offensively right none of the disciples are being put to the sword right he just swings out the sword and starts going hack attack and Jesus says stop heals the man you those who live by the sword shall die by it so what does

17:37

Jesus do in a very short order in the gospel of Luke he affirms using weapons for defense he condemns using weapons for attack right and I think that's the fundamental germ of just war theory that obviously there's been a lot of doctrinal development of it over the generations but you go back to the way that Jesus handled it and I think that you have a lot of wisdom right there so what you're saying is if you're in a financial bind don't start swinging a sword right like that's not a reason to become a mercenary to go to war right yeah now there's a lot of money in that so you just talk to you guys have you know

18:16

Blackrock yeah so don't go make a living as a mercenary right that's not

18:22

Jesus would say that that's not consistent with hit following him right but he he is saying there is a consistency in owning weapons for the purpose of defense and following him as well and so that's where I mean

18:36

Jesus sets that balance I think just perfectly and Christians have been like all over the place one side of the other on and it should extend the nation's to right you should not be a mercenary nation going to solve all your financial problems by starting a new war here that would make you an evildoer and some other nation as a minister of God is going to end you mm -hmm the

18:57

Bible says that as much as it depends upon you be at peace with all men you should you could even make an argument that if somebody is attacking you you have the option of not retaliating but when it's you are given the role of protector of your family someone attacks your family you don't get to retreat into pacifism you that is a violation of your role as a protector and provider and yet that's it's worse than an unbeliever well being struck on the right the one cheek and then turning the other also is not the same thing as someone trying to kill your family right and I think that just reading the

19:36

Bible out loud might help solve some of that sure yeah very true also it doesn't preclude believers once they're let's say they they join up they've been conscripted they see unjust things happening in the war and they say

19:53

I'm not gonna participate in this any longer you're not constrained to to stay under contract to do evil don't do evil you know if it's not just then depart from evil you're gonna have to give an account for that so there could be a situation where you're treated like a deserter and shot and killed but that's better than entering into unjust war and being a mercenary a warrant warmonger but imagine you know imagine platoon and battalion and regiment numbers of Christians all saying no this is a not busy these are unlawful orders that you're you know we're all gonna stand down it's like you know one brother speaks out than another than another than another and like yeah no you're doing this we're not doing this this is unjust by every code of you know military conduct this is unjust you know and so you're gonna have to kill us all for disobeying this order and then you got to find other people to do the job what what a wonderful influence on an army

20:55

Christians are so I would say why would we leave this realm of government bereft or devoid of believers of Christians there's no no reason to give that we shouldn't have believers in this aspect of government do we want unbelievers in this and only unbelievers no no no we don't yeah we want

21:18

Roman centurions as Christians we want Christians in Caesar's household yeah we want Christians as you know running the tax offices we want you to everywhere everywhere that's right everywhere but the pagan temples

21:28

Justin Martyr said this goes back to the you know the doctrine the lesser magistrate now you have a as a

21:34

Christian in uniform whether it's a military whether you're a county sheriff whether you are in Congress well if you're in some kind of government service you have a responsibility to you know who is who is your king

21:47

I'll give an example you know you talk about you know there's been a lot of concern about corruption and amongst police and are they really doing what's right and just or are they just trying to keep their job or so on and so forth but you think about the the group of police officers where they called the the constitutional there's a special name that they both keep both keepers yeah so we know we're gonna follow the

22:12

Constitution more than any other policy but you know what's better than that if you have a whole bunch of Christian police officers who know that their true master sits at the right hand of God and that how they conduct themselves they must conduct themselves in the fear of the

22:29

Lord as they interact with all the citizens as peacekeepers as peace officers how much better to have them then then mere oath keepers to the

22:38

Constitution yeah cuz at the end of that you have Judgment Day exactly like the Constitution doesn't have a

22:43

Judgment Day right and our politicians prove that all the time yes there's no judgment for them according to the

22:50

Constitution but and it goes back to the same principle of the Christian masters and Christian slaves in the churches in the first century where the

22:59

Christian masters were told to treat their Christian slaves and their non -christian slaves even in a certain way always remembering

23:06

I have a master in heaven I have a master in heaven and I'm a master in heaven well that changes things what would you how would you counsel somebody like say we're talking about disobeying obvious direct evil orders there are these situations that you hear about where these guys are coming back and they're recounting some of the stuff that went on and realizing coming to the knowledge of hey maybe what

23:32

I was doing in this situation it wasn't it was evil yeah it was evil and I didn't know it at the time there are those issues of conscience that are gonna come up especially for men who have been out there but when you have a young man looking to join up and he knows of these situations that are going on that seem to be more frequent than they have been in the past or at least you have more knowledge of them now because of the way that social media or media works how would you counsel somebody now in a certain time period like say your son wants to join up how are you gonna counsel him with that decision just biblically even as David has already talked about there is the why to go to war and then there's the how to conduct the war there's a why to join up and then there's the how to serve and I think that that kind of discipleship needs to happen why would you want to join up you know because it looks cool you to blow stuff up so let's think a bit more biblically about why you would serve in this way giving glory to Christ why you would serve this way and then let's talk about how you serve because it doesn't matter if it's a new for their military or you're in the business world okay there's all manner of temptations of doing things a corrupt way a pagan way rather than a

24:49

Christlike way so there needs to be some discipleship along those regards and to be thinking about these things before they even come up I have somebody in our one of our former churches in Arizona who is considering joining the militias act actively pursuing it and I have talked to him at length about the different pressures that are going to be on him that will violate his

25:14

Christian principles and I just want him to know eyes wide open to discuss those things before they happen because you're gonna be faced with it and whether you are in uniform in the

25:30

Department of Defense or in uniform in local law enforcement or in uniform in organization

25:36

X you will be faced with those choices how are you going to handle them think through them now and we as husbands and fathers and me maybe a spiritual father to some of us are in my case

25:50

I'm mentoring someone you have to talk through them talk through these things with them so that they're prepared yeah and if your daughter comes to you nasty about it you say no a men good amen a man and men not a woman that's for sure well

26:09

I think we have wrapped up that discussion for today so what are we thankful for Michael I'm thankful we're back to the podcast

26:14

I'm just I'm rejoicing that we have this back as part of our routine and just thankful for each one of you men here that give of your time and your talents and I really enjoy the process and just praise the

26:27

Lord for it I am thankful for I'm not trying to be flippant but I'm thankful for my bed

26:33

I spent a lot of time in different hotels and I spent time at somebody else's house and there's no there's nothing like coming home and being in your own bed and I I slept so well last night

26:48

I've slept better last night than I haven't last about six seven nights and just I was

26:53

I was flipping through this morning I landed on a Hebrews 4 and it reminded me that so then there remains a

27:00

Sabbath rest for the people of God and whoever has entered God's rest has also rested from his works as God did from from his and of course

27:10

Christ is our Sabbath rest but that time that physical rest reminds me it says you know there is a there's a rest that that awaits and it's better than any bed that we've ever had hmm

27:23

Andrew I'm thankful to God for the different giftings of the people of his body that bring them together to further the gospel locally and abroad it is amazing

27:37

I earlier it was remarked about you know being part of this family and it really is you get to know people in ways that challenge you to continue to be led by the

27:50

Spirit to use your talents in ways that edify the body and also bear with others it's it's amazing thing and if you're if you're not involved with a local body and you're a believer you're doing it wrong you have you have to get into the body of Christ be with other believers and you know

28:12

I don't want to call it a movement but I feel like a long history of the

28:19

Saints prior up until this point that we have a mission to continue that commission that we've been given and this is how it's done it's done together amen to that I am thankful for weddings weddings in the local church and weddings done to honor

28:38

Christ specifically Joel and Nicole we were thankful to attend to work on their wedding with them and when you're doing photography you get to go to some of the best and some of the absolute worst forms of weddings you can think of and anytime you get to shoot one that is a brother and a sister in Christ a fellow church member one where they are specifically trying to honor your

29:02

Lord it is so refreshing it is so it's so joyous because it's there for the right reasons and it's an adornment on that that institution it's a jewel and you get to go back and look at it and say they they did it to the honor of their