Saturday Special: When I Got the Attention of Catholic Answers

WWUTT Podcast

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Welcome to a Saturday special edition of When We Understand the Text. Looking at current events and responding to them with a solid understanding of scripture.

00:10

Visit our website at www .utt .com. Here once again is

00:15

Pastor Gabe. When I got the attention of Catholic answers over their tradition,

00:21

Pastor Gabe's blog for June 4th, 2024. The comments I've been making on social media about Roman Catholicism has attracted the attention of some higher profile

00:32

Roman Catholics, including former White House speech writer Joshua Charles, pro -life advocate

00:39

Abby Johnson, and Catholic Answers, the world's largest database of answers about the beliefs and practices of the

00:46

Catholic faith. Last week on May 28th, I posted the following, The Apostle, stand firm and hold to the traditions you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or our letter, 2

00:58

Thessalonians 2 15. Roman Catholics, guys, you hear that? We can make stuff up and call it tradition and shame all who won't go along with it.

01:08

Let's worship Mary. Catholic Answers responded to my caricature and we had a brief exchange.

01:14

I'm not sure who it was at Catholic Answers I interacted with, but they did not score the point they may have thought they did.

01:20

I'm not even sure what they were attempting to refute or why they commented in the first place.

01:27

First, a little explainer. In case you're unaware, Roman Catholicism claims their tradition is just as authoritative as God's word, and 2

01:37

Thessalonians 2 15 is one of those verses they use to justify it. In fact, they will place their tradition above God's word because only the

01:47

Roman Catholic Church has the true understanding of Scripture since they gave us the Bible.

01:52

This is all according to Roman Catholics. So praying to Mary and other dead saints is perfectly acceptable, even though God never permitted this, nor is there one example of it in Scripture.

02:02

The only instance in the Bible that someone appeared to have succeeded in communicating with the spirit of a deceased saint, he died the next day as a result, 1

02:13

Samuel 28. God has said that one who inquires of the dead is an abomination to the

02:19

Lord. Deuteronomy 18 11 to 12 Isaiah 8 19 to 20 says, When they say to you inquire of the mediums and the necromancers who chirp and mutter, should not a people inquire of their

02:32

God? Should they inquire of the dead on behalf of the living to the teaching and to the testimony?

02:39

If they will not speak according to this word, it is because they have no dawn.

02:45

But because Scripture is insufficient to the Roman Catholic, they invalidate the command of God praying to departed saints, including

02:54

Mary, the mother of Jesus, the apostles of Jesus, Mother Teresa, Pope John Paul II, various Roman Catholic figures over the centuries and pretty much anyone they want to.

03:05

The canonization process whereby the Roman Catholic Church declares a departed

03:10

Catholic to be a saint requires that one pray to that saint for a miracle.

03:16

It takes two miracles verified by the Roman Catholic Church for one to be declared a saint.

03:23

Take the case of a deceased Italian boy named Carlo Acutis who died at the age of 15 on October 12, 2006 of leukemia.

03:31

At least two healing miracles have already been attributed to Acutis, including the healing of a boy named

03:38

Matthias in Brazil and a girl named Valeria in Florence, Italy who had fallen off her bicycle.

03:44

Valeria's mother, Liliana, said she went to Carlo Acutis' tomb and prayed to him for healing.

03:51

And the Roman Catholic Church has verified that Acutis granted her request. It's possible that Acutis could be the first millennial to be canonized as a saint as early as next year.

04:03

What is the difference between this and a medium conducting a seance? This is abject paganism.

04:10

A Christian has a direct connection to the God who created the universe, but they would settle for praying to the dead instead?

04:19

Then they do not have the light of God. Exactly the word of Isaiah 820. Departed saints are not listening to these prayers.

04:27

As 1 Timothy 2 .5 says, there is one God and there is one mediator between God and men, the man

04:35

Christ Jesus. In Mark 7 .9, Jesus rebuked the Pharisees.

04:41

You have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to establish your tradition. And that is

04:47

Roman Catholic dogma in a nutshell. Deliberately ignoring God's commands in favor of their man -made traditions.

04:55

For the cult of Mary and the saints, God's word is only good for twisting to justify their traditions.

05:03

Thus, my post mocking Roman Catholic traditionalism. Catholic Answers answered, sort of.

05:11

Catholic Answers responded to me and said, from actual Roman Catholics who aren't made of straw.

05:17

And then they posted an image from an article on their website about scripture and tradition. The article begins.

05:24

Protestants claim the Bible is the only rule of faith, meaning that it contains all of the material one needs for theology, and that this material is sufficiently clear that one does not need apostolic tradition or the church's magisterium, teaching authority, to help one understand it.

05:42

In the Protestant view, the whole of Christian truth is found within the Bible's pages. Anything extraneous to the

05:48

Bible is simply non -authoritative, unnecessary, or wrong. For the most part,

05:54

I agree with a minor correction. Now, I cannot speak for all Protestants, as Protestantism is not a monolith.

06:01

But Reformed Baptists believe, as our Statement of Faith says, the Holy Scripture is the only sufficient, certain, and infallible rule of all saving knowledge, faith, and obedience.

06:11

This is in submission to 2 Timothy 3, 16 -17, which says, "...all

06:17

scripture is breathed out by God, and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work."

06:31

Scripture is clear. God has made it understandable for anyone by the illumination of His Holy Spirit.

06:37

See also 1 Corinthians 2, 6 -16, 2 Peter 1, 16 -21, and 1

06:43

John 5, 6 -12. The Roman Catholic Magisterium Teaching Authority, as they so arrogantly call themselves, says no.

06:52

According to the Council of Trent, Session 4, "...no one, relying on his own skill, shall, in matters of faith and of morals pertaining to the edification of Christian doctrine, resting the sacred

07:05

Scripture to his own senses, presume to interpret the said Scripture contrary to that sense which

07:12

Holy Mother Church, whose it is to judge of the true sense and interpretation of the

07:18

Holy Scriptures." So in other words, I am not allowed to read

07:23

Deuteronomy 18 as meaning that we cannot pray to the dead because the Roman Catholic Church has determined that's not its meaning.

07:30

I cannot say that 1 Timothy 2, 5 means that there is one mediator between God and man and Mary ain't her because the

07:38

Roman Catholic Church has determined that's not its meaning. This is quite the scam they have going on, and no one can understand the

07:45

Bible without the Mary cult. Roman Catholicism has a long history of wanting to keep the

07:51

Bible out of the hands of just anyone. They were murdering Christians who translated the Bible into languages that people could read, including

07:58

William Tyndale and Thomas Cranmer. Now when Catholic Answers says that Protestants don't need apostolic tradition to understand the

08:06

Bible, that's wrong. In fact, I rely heavily on apostolic tradition. And to the pastors

08:12

I have trained in expository preaching, I have told them that they need the apostolic tradition to understand

08:17

Scripture. The apostolic tradition is in the Bible. We use Scripture to interpret

08:23

Scripture. Of course, that's not what Catholic Answers means when they say apostolic tradition. They're talking about themselves.

08:30

They believe Roman Catholicism is the apostolic tradition and that only they have the true understanding of the

08:36

Bible. The Pharisees taught the same thing. Weightier are the words of the elders than the words of the prophets they taught.

08:45

From John Gill's commentary on Matthew 15. The main point of the article that Catholic Answers wanted me to see was this line from the

08:53

Second Vatican Council's document on divine revelation, De Verbum, Latin for The Word of God, quote,

09:00

It is not from Scripture alone that the church draws her certainty about everything which has been revealed.

09:07

Therefore both sacred tradition and sacred Scripture are to be accepted and venerated with the same devotion and reverence, unquote.

09:16

Now that might be what they say, but that's not what they mean. As I quoted earlier from the

09:21

Council of Trent, and Vatican II would affirm, what the Scripture says is held in reverence according to how their tradition interprets it.

09:29

So though they might say Roman Catholicism regards tradition as equal with Scripture, tradition is over the

09:36

Scripture, or to say it as Jesus would, you leave the commandment of God and hold to the tradition of men,

09:42

Mark 7, 8. I responded to Catholic Answers with this, but you believe

09:47

Roman Catholic tradition has authority over the Scripture, correct? Then I shared a clip of Priest Martin Diaz, rector of the

09:54

Cathedral of the Madeline in Salt Lake City, Utah, and according to Roman Catholic so -called magisterium, he holds more authority than Catholic Answers.

10:03

When asked, what is the Roman Catholic view of Scripture, Diaz said the following.

10:09

So I think one of the things for Roman Catholics is that we are not a church of the book.

10:18

So, for us, the church is first, the book is second.

10:23

Catholic Answers responded simply by pointing to the line from Vatican II. Read the screenshot again, they said, especially the last sentence.

10:31

Therefore, both sacred tradition and sacred Scripture are to be accepted and venerated with the same devotion and reverence, unquote.

10:39

I asked how that fits with what Martin Diaz said, and if tradition and Scripture are to be venerated with the same devotion and reverence, how does that negate my post?

10:50

To this, Catholic Answers never responded. And again, I'm not sure why they commented in the first place.

10:56

They never showed that what I said was wrong. In fact, it seems they agree with it.

11:01

They just did not like the way I framed it. Again, my caricature of their doctrine was this, guys, you hear that?

11:08

We can make stuff up and call it tradition and shame all who won't go along with it. Let's worship

11:14

Mary. Were they not attempting to shame me for not going along with it? Many of the comments from other

11:20

Roman Catholics certainly were. Follow -up comments from other Roman Catholics.

11:26

Said an anonymous Romanist named Regina, he's exactly correct. The church came before the

11:32

Bible. The Bible came from the church, not the other way around. Anyone with even a smidgen of knowledge of church and biblical history knows this.

11:41

Your engagement farming and ignorance of Christianity is embarrassing.

11:47

Unquote. No, I believe I heard the priest and Regina didn't. The very first part of his answer was, we are not a church of the book.

11:55

The church has authority over the book. And of course, Roman Catholics believe this because they believe they gave us the

12:02

Bible. A guy by the name of Jacko said, quote, sacred tradition isn't just made up.

12:08

Stop acting like a two -year -old. If you seriously don't know the history of sacred tradition within Christianity, you should resign immediately.

12:17

I know you have no formal theological training, but you're just making yourself look foolish. Unquote. If it's not made up, then show me where in the

12:26

Bible God permits Christians to pray to Mary or any other departed saint. Where does

12:32

God permit making statues of them and bowing to them? Where does it say Mary was without sin or that she was bodily assumed into heaven?

12:41

Where is the doctrine of papal infallibility? Where is any doctrine of the pope for that matter?

12:47

Where is purgatory in the Bible? Where is the treasury of merit? These doctrines are all man -made traditions.

12:54

They are not biblical. But Jacko can't give a reasoned response. So he name calls.

13:00

That's all he has. Jared called me a false witness. Stephen said, what unrepentant sin is keeping you from the one true church,

13:09

Gabriel? Matthew said, not how it works there, Mr. Heretic. Scott said, Gabe is starting pride month early.

13:16

Darian from Canada said, Gabe, why are you court ordered to have no contact with persons under the age of 16?

13:23

This is the slander that they resort to. Again, it's all they have. I also had various threats that my criticisms were going to result in my judgment.

13:33

Said Nenora, my only consolation is that if you fail to repent for that post, you will on judgment day have to answer for it.

13:41

Ronald from Pittsburgh said, welcome to another edition of Pastor Gabe's false witness. Today's episode is brought to you by the smell of sulfur.

13:50

Another anonymous Romanist said, tradition informs scripture because scripture doesn't interpret itself.

13:58

See, he gets it. He's wrong, but at least he interprets his own church's doctrine correctly.

14:04

Another anonymous Romanist said, Gabe, if I were you, I wouldn't read First Timothy three 15.

14:10

Yes, I just taught on that passage earlier this year as First Timothy three 14 to 15 says,

14:15

I hope to come to you soon, but I am writing these things to you so that if I delay, you may know how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living

14:25

God, a pillar and buttress of the truth. The church is the instrument

14:31

God has chosen to proclaim the truth to the world pillar and defend it from those who wish to malign it buttress.

14:39

But what is First Timothy three 15 scripture? And what's

14:44

Timothy to do? Follow it. That verse actually says the church is subject to the writings of the apostles, not the other way around.

14:52

The verse, this anonymous Romanist used to shame me actually puts his doctrine to shame.

14:59

John from California said, hold on. Where is the canon of scripture explicit in the

15:04

Bible? It's also a tradition, isn't it? So whose tradition are you relying on?

15:09

If the Bible preceded the Reformation by over a thousand years and hundreds of books were purported to be scripture unquote.

15:16

Well, first of all, hundreds of books were not purported to be scripture. That's a lie. The list of 66 books that we call the

15:23

Bible is not listed in scripture. That's true. It is tradition, a tradition which precedes

15:28

Roman Catholicism. Incidentally, the 39 books of the Old Testament were already compiled as the word of God even before Jesus was born.

15:36

The 27 books that make up the New Testament were already upheld and taught in the church before the

15:41

Council of Hippo in 393 agreed that these books were the New Testament. Canon is a tradition that is subject to scripture, not over it.

15:51

If all scripture is breathed out by God, then how can it be that the church gave us scripture?

15:57

Isn't it God who gave us scripture? The church doesn't define what scripture is.

16:03

Scripture defines what the church is, and so the church did not decide canon. The church discovered canon.

16:11

Scripture being the authoritative word of God is self -authenticating. As said in 2

16:17

Peter 1 19 -21, we have the prophetic word more fully confirmed, to which you will do well to pay attention, as to a lamp shining in a dark place until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts.

16:31

Knowing this, first of all, that no prophecy of scripture comes from someone's own interpretation, for no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the

16:47

Holy Spirit. As Psalm 138 -2 says, I bow down toward your holy temple and give thanks to your name for your steadfast love and your faithfulness, for you have exalted above all things your name and your word.

17:04

And Jesus said, My sheep hear my voice, and I know them and they follow me.

17:12

John 10 -27 In conclusion, when Paul wrote in 2

17:17

Thessalonians 2 -15, Stand firm and hold to the traditions you were taught by us, either by our spoken word or our letter.

17:24

This was not a license to grab whatever tradition you want, no matter how historic it may be and attributed as apostolic.

17:32

How do we know what the apostles said? Because it's also what they wrote, which we have in the

17:38

Bible. But Catholic answers will twist this scripture and others to justify their unbiblical man -made traditions.

17:45

And the gospel of Jesus Christ gets hidden beneath false doctrines of Roman Catholicism.

17:52

Jesus died on the cross for our sins and rose again from the dead for our justification.

17:57

Romans 4 -25 By faith in him, we are forgiven our sins and have everlasting life with God.

18:04

That's not a message you will hear very often from the Mary cult, who place their man -made traditions and works -based righteousness over scripture.

18:13

Tradition is not a bad thing. I have my traditions, as I'm sure you have yours. The very fact that I'm a

18:19

Baptist is a tradition. But all of our religious traditions must be subject to scripture, not equal to scripture, and certainly not over scripture.

18:29

For it is the very word of God. As the apostle wrote, Learn by us not to go beyond what is written, that none of you may be puffed up in favor of one against another.

18:41

1 Corinthians 4 -6 That's one rebuke the magisterium teaching authority of the self -proclaimed one true church cannot stand.