July 28, 2009 Show: Harold Camping Debates Dr. James White (Part One)

Iron Sharpens Iron

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:00

Well, Mr. Camping, we could, for five minutes, give an opening presentation as to your view on the churchage.

00:06

We're not going to have any more commercials until the very end of the program. All right, I'll, uh, shall

00:13

I begin then? Yes. Yeah, well, you know, uh, the, uh, uh, it was exactly eight years and a few days ago

00:26

I had a group of people, uh, having dinner with me. I was celebrating my 80th birthday, and at that time,

00:36

I made a very solemn and sad statement. I said to them, you know,

00:44

I am, uh, this is the saddest birthday I've ever had.

00:50

It was my 80th birthday, but I, it was sad. I said it's sad beyond measure because I've really been studying the

00:58

Bible very, very carefully, and I've become totally convinced that the

01:03

Bible is teaching that we have come to the end of the church era.

01:09

Just like it was, uh, back in 33 AD, the era of national

01:16

Israel representing the kingdom of God, which had gone on for 14, uh, they had been a representative for, uh, ever since they left

01:26

Egypt, 1 ,480 years approximately before, and now after 550, uh, or excuse me, uh, now after 1 ,955 years, beginning at, in AD 33, when

01:43

God shifted from national Israel representing the kingdom of God to the church age, now

01:50

He has ended with this. And it was a, it was a dreadfully, dreadfully terrible thing to think about because I felt like I had been,

02:01

I was betraying all of the churches. I had been a church member all of my life.

02:08

Uh, for the 40 years previous, I had constantly told people to try to find a church that is reasonably true to the

02:16

Word of God, because this was God's plan. But the, but the fact is that I, I, recognizing the truth of the

02:27

Bible, I had to teach the way I was teaching. Well, uh, in fact, during these last few years, uh,

02:37

God has been opening my eyes and the eyes of others, uh, to a great many truths that we had never seen before.

02:47

And I wondered about that. But just a couple of years ago, I was reading

02:52

Daniel chapter 12, Daniel 12, and there God made a very, very profound statement.

02:59

And incidentally, the Bible, every word in the Bible comes from the mouth of God.

03:05

It is a very holy ground. We tremble before the Word of God. We, we don't ever look at it casually, or we should never look at it as, uh, uh, uh, something to, uh, bandy about or whatever.

03:21

It is something that is very serious business. And in, and Daniel had been receiving a great amount of information concerning the very end of time, and then, uh, and it made him very ill because of the sorrowful nature of it.

03:37

And then, uh, we read in Daniel chapter 12, verse 4, remember, this is

03:44

God speaking. Anything in the Bible, in the original languages, it is

03:49

God speaking. But now, O Daniel, shut up the words and seal the book.

03:56

Then, even to the time of the end, many shall run to and fro, and knowledge shall be increased.

04:05

And then it says further in verse 9, and he says, go thy way,

04:10

Daniel, for the words are closed up and sealed till the time of the end.

04:17

Well, you know, what is happening, what is happening here? And then when we go to Revelation chapter 5, we find that where God talks about the book being opened.

04:29

And as we see the book being opened, we begin to understand why, now that we're at the time of the end, and the

04:40

Bible shows us when that book, when the seven seals had been taken off, we can know that date very exactly, and when, now that the book has been opened, and that, of course, is the

04:55

Bible. Now, the Bible has never had anything added to it in the last 1900 years, but God has a lot of ways in which he has hidden truth until he wants it to be known.

05:11

And this is what God is doing now. He is giving us a lot of information that he has never given before, and it's all coming out of the

05:22

Bible. Well, okay. Yeah, that's the five minutes, Mr. Camping. And by the way, before James starts,

05:28

I want to let you both know, if you're free to stay till 4 .30, we can carry this on for the full hour now that everything's working.

05:35

I certainly am. That's up to Mr. Camping. Great. Well, if you can stay on till 4 .30,

05:41

that'd be great, Mr. Camping, because we could have this full hour of broadcast for day number one. Yeah. Great. All right.

05:46

Well, Mr. White, Dr. White, you have five minutes to give your opening presentation.

05:51

Thank you. The Scripture teaches that the triune God, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, did in eternity past covenant together to bring about the glory of the triune majesty by means of the creation of the universe and the redemption of a particular people.

06:06

In that council in eternity past, it was determined that the Father would decree the glory of the Trinity, the

06:11

Son would accomplish the means of redemption through the Incarnation, his cross work outside of Jerusalem, and his resurrection from the dead.

06:17

The Spirit would bring the eternally decreed salvation purchased by the Son to fruition in the hearts of undeserving rebels, raising them to spiritual life and making them sons of God by adoption through faith in Jesus Christ.

06:31

These redeemed sinners are united to Christ, placed in his body, the Church. The plain teaching of Scripture, believed and accepted by God's people down through the ages, is that the

06:40

Church is central to God's purpose in this world. Though many imposters have arisen calling themselves the

06:45

Church, Christ has in fact been busy in every generation building his Church so that the gates of Hades would not be able to withstand the onslaught of God's Spirit -led people.

06:54

The universal fellowship of true believers has been, by God's wise design, revealed to the world through the local fellowships led by elders and ministered to by deacons.

07:03

When Paul wrote to Timothy, he spoke of the local fellowships and referred to them as the Church, the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth.

07:10

And while individual local fellowships can cease to exist as God's blessings move to and fro across the earth, nations rise and fall in God's providence,

07:18

Christ's Church goes on, his redeemed people joining together for the preaching of the Word, the observance of the ordinances of baptism and Lord's Supper, and fellowship in the

07:27

Spirit of God. Today, I have the privilege of responding to the claims of Harold Camping of Family Radio, who has abandoned his former beliefs and is now promoting a whole host of novel doctrines.

07:38

The central assertion that brings us together is his insistence that the churches of Jesus Christ are now under the wrath of God.

07:44

The Spirit has withdrawn from all churches and no one can find salvation therein any longer. Mr. Camping has taken the amazing position of insisting that his interpretations of the

07:53

Bible, based upon allegory and numerology, are sufficient to allow him to claim that God is revealing new things today, never known to anyone in the history of the

08:02

Church. This claim is the foundation stone of all of Mr. Camping's idiosyncratic teachings, such as his assertion that Jesus died twice, that the death of Christ on the cross outside of Jerusalem was not relevant to the forgiveness of sins, his annihilationism, and his teaching that the world will end

08:16

May 21, 2011. Indeed, as I listened to Mr. Camping throughout the Doctrine of the Trinity just last week on his open forum radio program, identifying

08:24

Christ as the Father, resurrecting one of the earliest heresies of the Church, I was reminded yet again what happens when the sound exegesis of the text of inspired

08:33

Scripture gives way to personal revelation and spiritualization. This encounter is about rescuing the

08:39

Bible's trustworthiness. It is about demonstrating that the Bible is not the playground of any person who decides he has new spiritual insights no one else has ever had.

08:48

It is about defending Christ's Church, his Bride, and the local fellowships to which the Spirit of God joins all who are truly united with Christ.

08:56

As we will see, no matter what element of this teaching comes up, the fundamental issue will be this.

09:01

Harold Camping refuses to use any kind of meaningful, exegetical, or hermeneutical set of principles in his handling of the

09:08

Bible. There are no rules when Mr. Camping opens the Bible. He is the final authority when it comes to his system of interpretation, if that word can even be used as a complex system of allegory and numerology that he utilizes to make the

09:21

Bible speak. I believe firmly that the only way to profess that the Bible truly is God's Word, God speaking, is to expend every possible effort to avoid inserting my desires and my thoughts into the reading of the

09:34

Bible. That is why sound exegetes unanimously avoid all of the errors that Harold Camping's entire set of teachings illustrates in glowing colors.

09:42

Sound exegesis seeks to understand the meaning of the original writers in their original language, in their original context, first and foremost.

09:51

And that is the exact methodology rejected by Harold Camping. In fact, given that he says that no one has seen what he now sees, and given that he makes connections across all sorts of contradictory and differing contexts without the first thought of concern as to what the original authors actually intended, there is no way that Harold Camping can claim that what he is teaching is in any logical or rational way the teaching of the

10:16

Bible. It is the teaching of Harold Camping expressed in the words of Scripture wrongfully ripped from their proper and original context.

10:25

And so the issue that we need to address today is not just the individual teachings, saying that Christ died twice and things like this, and the allegation against the church, but it's the foundational issue.

10:37

How do we rightly handle the Word of God so that it remains the Word of God and not merely something that we are inserting our thoughts into?

10:45

How do you handle the Bible? That's what this discussion has to be about. Thank you very much, Dr. White.

10:51

And for those of you who just tuned us in, this is a two -day debate. This is day number one of a two -day debate between Harold Camping, the founder and president of Family Radio, and Dr.

11:02

James R. White of Alpha Omega Ministries, on the theme, Has the Church Age Ended? And now,

11:08

Mr. Camping, you have three minutes to continue your thought or to respond to Dr.

11:13

White in any way you choose to. You have three minutes. Well, you know, when we start talking about hermeneutics, the

11:22

Bible gives us the biblical hermeneutic, and I've never been able to find in the

11:28

Bible the historical grammatical method of hermeneutics. Where does that come from?

11:34

That's one question I'd like to have an answer. Where do you find that in the Bible? I'll tell you what the

11:40

Bible has to say. We read in Mark chapter 4, in Mark chapter 4, where God says that without a parable, verse 34, spake he not unto them,

11:53

Christ is speaking. In other words, Christ is saying he spoke in parables, and he did it for two reasons.

12:01

He said, in verse 12, that seeing they may see and not perceive, and hearing they may hear and not understand, lest at any time they should be converted, and their sins be forgiven them.

12:15

And on the other hand, for the true believers, the parable message is giving them a lot of new information.

12:22

In other words, God designed the Bible so that on the one hand it would remain impossible to understand by those who are not elect of God that it's spiritually understood, but on the other hand for the believers it would be.

12:41

Now, the fact is that God gave further rules that have to be followed.

12:48

The first rule is in 1 Corinthians chapter 2, verse 13, we are to compare spiritual things with spiritual.

12:58

In other words, any time we look at a verse and we are wondering what does it mean, even though it sounds like we know the meaning right now, until we compare that with everything else in the

13:13

Bible that might relate and find harmony, we have not found the truth.

13:20

We have to really compare everything with every idea with every possibility in the

13:27

Bible in order to find truth. And that's a terrific protection when

13:32

Christ spoke in parables. You just can't go out and say, well, the spiritual meaning is this or the spiritual meaning is that.

13:40

It has to be found in the Bible. The Bible has to always be the core of truth.

13:52

And never do we go out, that's why on my kind of programming I only quote the

13:57

Bible. But the fact is that, you know, the

14:04

God has given us all kinds of ideas, like a lamb can refer to Christ, the fields can refer to the world,

14:16

Christ is the way. So when we see the word way, we can think about Christ.

14:23

He is the truth. He is the light. There are just all kinds of emphases in the

14:35

Bible where God is given, like for example, Jerusalem.

14:40

I'm sorry, Mr. Camping, your three minutes are up and you can continue your thought after Dr. White who has now three minutes.

14:48

Thank you. Thank you very much. Just let me give an example of what happens when we do not go first to what the original authors meant in their original context, what they intended to communicate to their audiences.

15:01

Obviously we know that not all the Scripture is written in parables, only certain portions are. Jesus taught directly in a non -parabolic form, but Paul's letters are not written as parables.

15:13

We have to recognize the different kinds of literature we find in Scripture. But let me give you an example. I was listening to the open forum just this morning and a caller called in and asked about Hebrews chapter 10, verses 24 through 25, and let us consider how to stir up one another to love and good works, not neglecting to meet together as is the habit of some, but encouraging one another and all the more as you see the day drawing near.

15:34

Now, if we read the book of Hebrews in its original context, original language, this is talking about gathering together in the church and it is talking about stirring one another up.

15:44

The King James says provoking one another to do what? To do love and good works. So it is a positive thing.

15:50

So when we read this, it is talking about gathering together in the fellowship of the body of the church and provoking one another to doing godly things.

15:58

As soon as Mr. Camping started reading this, he got to the word provoke and he said, well this proves that this is actually talking about that period of time when the church age has ended because to provoke means to create dissension and so whenever you preach that the church has come to an end you bring about dissension and so this proves that this is about meeting outside of the church and no longer meeting in the church.

16:23

Now, the writer of the Hebrews never would have had that idea. His audience never would have had that idea. That ignores the context where the term itself is being used in a positive sense of stirring one another up, stimulating one another to love and good works and so the original words inspired under the direction of the

16:42

Holy Spirit of God, their meaning is completely lost and instead a completely foreign concept.

16:47

Now, there have been all sorts of folks down through the history of the church who have attacked the church who could have used this very same text in the same way that Harold Camping used it.

16:56

The Montanists could have done that and Joseph Smith could have done that. All sorts of people could have done that but does anyone seriously suggest that that was the actual intention of the

17:08

Spirit of God in penning these words? No, these words had a meaning to the person who wrote them.

17:13

They had a meaning to the persons who received them and we are first and foremost to discover that and then live in the light of the principles that are laid down by the

17:21

Word of God. If we don't do that then we cannot claim that our teaching of the

17:27

Scriptures is reflective of the Word of God itself. We simply cannot do it because we are not accurately representing what the original intention of those inspired writings actually was.

17:39

Thank you, Dr. White. And now, Mr. Camping, you have three minutes as well. Yeah, well, you know, the biblical rule is that the

17:50

Bible interprets itself. The Bible is not subject to private interpretation.

17:56

It is its own dictionary. We find words in the Bible that we are looking at and then we want to, if we want to understand it that's the wonder of the commentaries that we can find all the other words, all the places in the

18:16

Bible where that word is used. And if you go on in Hebrews 10 for example, the word provoke incidentally is only used in one place.

18:25

It was used in the book of Acts when there was heavy contention between Paul and Barnabas concerning taking

18:34

Mark with him on the next missionary journey. And so there was a provoking between them.

18:42

There was dissension. That is the only place it is used. And it is indicating there was contention.

18:50

Now when we go on in Hebrews 10 we find, it says that in verse 26, for if we sin willfully after we have received the knowledge of the truth there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins.

19:05

Well my, that's how do you understand that? The whole Bible is telling us that Christ is a very merciful

19:14

God and Israel came to him again and again and again for forgiveness and here it says however there will be no sacrifice for sins.

19:26

You're out. You're out. And the only time that could be in our day because in the churches there no longer is any sacrifice.

19:37

The Holy Spirit is not working there and that gives us the meaning now of Hebrews chapter 10.

19:45

But outside, outside wonderfully there is salvation going. Now when we look again when we talk about what did it mean to the local person when

19:56

Abraham for example back in Genesis chapter 13 he was told of God.

20:05

He was told in verse 14 lift up now thine eyes and look from the place where thou art northward and southward and eastward and northward for all the land which thou seest to thee will

20:19

I give it and to thy seed forever forever. Now how did

20:26

Abraham understand this and this has been emphasized in chapter 15 and in chapter 17 all the land from the river of Egypt to the river of to the

20:40

Euphrates River. Well we'll talk about that next. Thank you very much

20:45

Mr. Camping your three minutes are up and now Dr. White you have three minutes. Just a couple things to recognize in what was just said.

20:53

First of all the text from Peter I think was being misapplied when it says it is not of any private interpretation. If you'll look carefully at that text what

21:00

Peter is saying is that no prophecy of scripture ever came about by the prophets own interpretation.

21:06

It instead comes from God men spoke from God as they're carried along by the Holy Spirit. So that is a misapplication of that text but secondly

21:14

I hope everyone heard what was just said and that is we were just told that the actual meaning of Hebrews 10 24 -25 could not have been understood by anyone until a few years ago.

21:27

Every age of Christians whatever they thought that text meant they were in darkness.

21:33

They had no concept of what that was actually about. They must have been misled to do all sorts of things by this cryptic text that no one could understand until just a few years ago when

21:44

Mr. Camping determines that the book in Revelation is actually the Bible. There's no reason to believe that but that's what he asserts.

21:52

And so here you have the author doesn't know what he's writing. His recipients don't know what he's writing. The words in their own context he mentioned that word is only used twice.

22:01

It's actually used four times in the Bible. It's used twice in the Greek Septuagint. And yes it can mean dissension as it's used in Acts 15 39 but that's not what it means in Hebrews 10 24.

22:10

In Hebrews 10 24 it is a positive thing. It is to stir one another up to love and good deeds within the community of the faith which is the church.

22:21

And so to just simply say well it had this meaning over here that means it can have this meaning here.

22:27

What if we interpreted Harold Camping's books in that way? What if we took the words that he uses in the

22:32

English language and we could find any use anyplace else of the same word and import it into his.

22:38

His context doesn't matter anymore because what he's telling us is the context of the Bible writers doesn't matter.

22:44

We could turn him into someone who teaches anything that we want. We could read anything into his voluminous writings based upon ignoring the original context of the authors, the original context of those who initially received these epistles.

23:00

The epistle to the Hebrews was written to keep Christians who were being pressured to go back to the old ways.

23:08

And so when he says how can you understand there's no forgiveness Hebrews 10. He's talking about those people who would go back and offer sacrifice and therefore do disrespect the sacrifice of Jesus Christ.

23:21

He's talking about the same people first John talks about. And John says I do not even say that you should pray for such a one.

23:28

He's talking about those people who deny Jesus Christ and that was the issue in the early church and we need to understand that first and then make application to our day.

23:37

There is no reason to say that these words never had any meaning until our modern period.

23:43

None whatsoever. Thank you Dr. White and let me just make a quick announcement for those of you who are listening on MP3.

23:52

You may hear an MP3 cut short today because of the difficulties we had for the first half hour.

23:59

This program is being extended until 4 .30 p .m. Eastern Standard Time and the

24:07

MP3 of the full one hour exchange between Harold Kemping and Dr.

24:13

James White will be available at some point hopefully this evening or tomorrow but I just wanted to announce that for those who are listening on MP3 and also for those of you who tuned in late we are extending this program until 4 .30

24:28

p .m. I want to thank the management of WNYG and I want to thank Wayback Wally the evening drive disc jockey for allowing us to have a half hour of the evening drive segment.

24:40

I also want to thank the technicians and engineers for both WNYG and Family Radio for helping us to resolve the issue but Mr.

24:50

Kemping you now have three minutes. Well you know you still haven't answered my question where did the historical grammatical hermeneutic come from in so far as the

25:02

Bible is concerned. I can tell you what the Bible says it says that Christ spoke in parables and the

25:10

Bible says that we are to compare scripture with scripture and the Bible says that the

25:15

Holy Spirit will lead you in the truth because the Holy Spirit because the

25:21

Bible is a very spiritual book and we have to follow that very very carefully.

25:28

That's why I raised the issue just as an illustration and they're sprinkled all through the

25:33

Bible about Abraham. He was told that he would inherit all the land that he saw and he named it a little later as all the way from the river of Egypt to the

25:48

Euphrates River that that would be given to his seed forever are we to understand that the land over there adjacent to the

26:01

Mediterranean Sea is going to be there forever that's what the Bible says the

26:06

Bible says that and what did it really mean to Abraham?

26:13

Did he understand what he was being told? Incidentally we were arguing or discussing this matter of Hebrews 10 and I have tried to answer that question of how to handle that there remains no more sacrifice and every theologian has tried to answer that but it's in our day that now we find a very clear and concise answer and there are many verses like that that God kept under wraps so to speak he would not give us a clear and concise answer until today like Nicodemus for example was told nobody has ascended into heaven except the

27:00

Lord Jesus well now we understand and we always have had some kind of an answer but now we can understand it perfectly now when it comes to the church the gates of hell shall not prevail what happened to the church in the wilderness what happened to it?

27:22

that was Israel on Mount Sinai did it prevail?

27:29

it was the corporate or the external church when the reformers you know talked about the invisible church now it's true the invisible church is of every true believer but when it says that the gates of hell shall not prevail does that include the charismatic churches?

27:53

does that include the Roman Catholic Church? does that include the Methodist Church? what does it include?

28:00

in fact Mr. Campion your three minutes are up and we're going to just make a quick break for station identification and we will resume the debate with Dr.

28:13

White's next three minute segment right after station identification alright just for those of you who are tuning in very late or perhaps tuning in to hear the music of Way Back Wally on WNYG 1440

28:34

AM for the next half hour we have been given an additional half hour to conduct a radio debate between Harold Campion the founder and president of Family Radio and host of the

28:47

Open Forum broadcast which is heard around the world and Dr. James R. White of Alpha and Omega Ministries and also author of Dangerous Airwaves Harold Campion refuted and Christ Church defended we are discussing today or the debate

29:04

I should say is on the theme has the church age ended and we will now resume our debate with Dr.

29:12

James R. White and you have three minutes where did the historical grammatical hermeneutic come from?

29:20

well every time that Paul writes to for example the church of Corinth does he expect them to understand what he is saying?

29:28

does he expect them to interpret his letter in such a way that his words mean what his words mean in the context that his audience would have understood does he not hold people accountable for their behavior in light of what he has written to them in a historical and grammatical way the answer is of course he does and what if they had what if the

29:46

Judaizers in Galatia had decided to interpret the book of Galatians in the way that Mr. Campion interprets the text that say the church is going to continue and said well you know you need to understand

29:56

Paul is writing spiritual things here and what he really means when he says we are anathema is that we find this other use of this word over here in the

30:04

Old Testament and that actually means we should have the preeminence in the church now how would that work?

30:10

no his words had a meaning when they were written in the form they were written when the apostles and Jesus interpret the

30:17

Old Testament do they interpret it in the way that Mr. Campion is interpreting it where they say well you need to look at this word here and then we can connect it over here and there are 153 fishes and that is 3 times 3 times 17 and they took numerology apart and they connected things together is that how they use the

30:33

Old Testament? the answer is no it is not and so why should we follow that methodology because you can do anything with it

30:41

Mr. Campion has done much with the 153 fishes that are pulled out of the sea and I would just point out there are so many people being saved we can't get them into the church anymore and things like that why can't

30:53

I point out that those 153 fishes were dragged up on the shore and died and that this is therefore the end of the fishes

30:59

I can interpret anything any way I want to when the original intention of the authors and the original language and their original audiences is ignored you can't claim to be accurately representing

31:14

Harold Campion if you don't interpret Harold Campion in the context in which he intended to write his words the same thing is true with the word of God you cannot say you are accurately representing the word of God when you do that what

31:29

I said about Hebrews chapter 10 very clearly you have to know what the book of Hebrews is about and this pressure upon the people to go back to the old ways and there is no question about that when you come up against a difficulty of interpretation do you just simply throw out exegesis that is the easy way to do it to have this overarching system that you just force onto every text but that's not a way that honors

31:54

God's word and what is the result of all this even though Paul taught that God would be glorified in the church throughout all ages we are being told by Mr.

32:02

Campion flee the churches the Holy Spirit of God that forms the churches is no longer in the churches he is no longer saving people in those churches that's what happens when you ignore the original context thank you very much

32:15

Dr. White and for those of you who just tuned in to WNYG this is the day number one of the two day debate between Mr.

32:25

Harold Campion the founder and president of Family Radio and host of the Open Forum broadcast which was heard worldwide and also

32:34

Dr. James R. White of Alpha and Omega Ministries in Phoenix, Arizona who also hosts the program called

32:40

The Dividing Line heard over the internet and he is the author of Dangerous Airwaves Mr.

32:46

Harold Campion refuted and Christ Church defended and now we have three minutes for Mr.

32:52

Harold Campion to continue his thought or to respond to Dr. White you know

32:58

I've heard that many many times what did that statement by the prophet mean to the people of that day

33:08

I ask you the question what did what did the statement that God made to Abraham that he would be given all the land that he could see he was looking at physical land and it would be given to him forever what did that mean to him how could he understand that and as we look at Israel in the wilderness they were told again and again this and that and they were given all kinds of ceremonial laws to follow which were all incidentally like a parable to offer a blood sacrifice was a picture it was the earthly story pointing to the heavenly meaning which is what a parable is of the fact that it required the atoning blood of the

34:01

Lord Jesus Christ how much of this did they understand who is the Bible for the

34:08

Bible is for all of the nations not for those people that just happen to be living there and God has set up rules he spoke in parables and in fact he spoke in parables as I've read from Mark chapter 4 so that for those who are not elect of God they would not understand at all he wrote it in a way so they could not understand all the information that he had sealed in the book of Daniel when the book of Daniel excuse the book that is spoken of in the book of Daniel that was sealed was in the

34:52

Bible because nothing has ever been added to the Bible once it was completed about 2 ,000 years ago it was all here but God sealed it how did he seal it?

35:05

he sealed it by the way he wrote it and by putting in difficult verses very difficult verses the

35:16

Bible is not easy to understand at all for example right today we have always believed and this is a terrible thing that has happened but God has allowed it to happen namely that if we only believe on the

35:36

Lord Jesus Christ we will become saved and yet now we understand why did

35:42

God wait till now to tell us that faith which is the noun for the verb believe faith is the noun believe is the verb it's the same word and the

35:54

Bible says faith is work and we're not able to be saved and in fact your three minutes are up Mr.

36:02

Camping okay Mr. Camping thank you your three minutes are up and Dr. James R.

36:08

White you may now continue with three minutes there is no question that the Bible contains many different types of literature it also contains ceremonial laws it contains types and shadows in the

36:20

Old Testament but these are fulfilled in the New Testament and the problem is Mr. Camping does not see that distinction he blurs that and turns even the

36:28

New Testament writings into something that is but a type and a shadow that then allows him to fit it into his modern viewpoint of eschatology this ends up turning what is didactic teaching what is straight forward teaching that is not in any way shape or form expressed as future promises into the foundation of such things as saying that Jesus died twice or identifying

36:52

Christ as the Father or saying that the church by which God is going to be glorified can be destroyed completely that the church which is the body of Christ can experience the very wrath of God that's why you have this tremendous confusion is because you're not allowing the

37:10

Bible to speak for itself you come up with a system and then you force it upon the Bible he says who is the

37:16

Bible for anyways is it just for those people back then no it's for all believers through all times and yet it's

37:23

Mr. Camping who's saying otherwise when he says well no one has understood until now what the

37:28

Bible is actually saying in places like Hebrews 1024 or other texts where he assigns a new meaning that no one in all of church history has ever understood why should we believe that the book mentioned by Daniel is the

37:42

Bible what's the basis for that does the book of Revelation make that connection when it talks about the opening of the seals it does not so why make just because the term book is used there's all sorts of places where words are used the

37:56

Bible and again you have to make a meaningful argument that they should be taken that the original author intended for those things to be taken together because if you don't again you can do with Mr.

38:09

Camping's words what he's doing with the Bible and you can connect all sorts of things together that he never intended to be connected and make him contradict himself all over the place why is it that the

38:21

Bible is liable to this kind of treatment but Mr. Camping's material is not instead we go to the

38:27

New Testament we ask ourselves a simple question did any of the apostles of Jesus Christ teach that the

38:34

Christian church would cease to exist before Christ returned the answer is no they did not you have to claim modern day revelation you have to claim some type of spiritual insight that nobody else has ever had to be able to force these things upon the scriptures the

38:52

Jesus himself gave us the Lord's Supper and said that we are to do this until he returns

38:58

I asked Mr. Camping are you partaking in the Lord's Supper has Christ returned if he has not then clearly you're violating his own command in not doing well there yes you can you can begin

39:11

Mr. Camping Dr. White's three minutes were up you can begin your three minute segment Mr.

39:18

Camping you can resume you know you mentioned the

39:24

Lord's Supper it's very interesting that Israel they looked at the ceremonial laws and decided if they could keep them faithfully enough that was their salvation and we read in Romans 9 that they they came to an end because of unbelief now the fact is when

39:49

God introduced the New Testament era the next external evidence of the representation of the

39:57

Kingdom of God he gave two more ceremonial laws water baptism and Lord's Supper both activities that we perform and we put a lot of trust in that that assists us in our salvation or initiates salvation or is a means by which

40:17

God is helping us in our salvation we just put a lot of trust in it and yet their ceremonial laws and God warns and this is something that really hit me hard a few years ago that the seventh day

40:35

Sabbath day for example is a sign we read this in Exodus 31 that I the

40:44

Lord sanctify thee in other words even as you are not to do any work of any kind you're going to be under the wrath of God and then we go to number 15 and we find there a man that picked up some sticks on the seventh day

41:06

Sabbath and Moses asked God what should we do to him and God said execute him that is stone him to death and they did stone him to death why he had only picked up a few sticks on the

41:22

Sabbath day he hadn't made a fire he wasn't building a building or whatever he was a very slight thing now remember the

41:31

Lord said that you keep the seventh day

41:38

Sabbath because I the Lord sanctify thee and that means that you are not to do any work of any kind it was representing the fact you're not to do any work of any kind in becoming saved and then we find as we examine what the churches are doing every one of them have got work after work after work that they do in order to assure their people that you now are safe and secure in the arms of Christ and the fact is all the work was done by Christ and we simply have to wait upon him well thank you

42:17

Mr. Kipping your three minutes are up and now Dr. White you may resume

42:24

Harold Camping just said that every one of the churches say that they have works that you have to do to demonstrate you're safe in the arms of Christ that's just simply not true

42:32

I know my church is very clear in teaching that salvation is completely of the Lord that there is nothing we can do to save ourselves in any way shape or form what was just presented to us just simply

42:44

I'm sorry doesn't doesn't make any sense we were told that the Lord's Supper is a ceremonial law no it's not it is part and parcel of the new covenant in the blood of Jesus Christ and what we need to understand is there is no covenant beyond the new covenant the new covenant is the last covenant it is a perfect covenant the law is written upon the hearts of those who are in the new covenant and the

43:08

Lord's Supper is a part of that new covenant and Jesus said you do this in remembrance of me and we do this until he returns this is our proclamation as members of the new covenant that we have faith in the sacrifice of Jesus Christ and that it alone avails for our salvation there are many churches there are many people listening to that there are many pastors listening right now who are preaching that God alone can save in Jesus Christ and that he saved upon the cross of Calvary not some mythical pre -incarnational death but as the

43:45

Bible has always taught and as all Christians have always believed it is the blood of the cross of the

43:50

Lord Jesus Christ by which our sins are forgiven not something from before that period of time certainly the cross was certain from God's perspective but Jesus became incarnate in the person of Jesus of Bethlehem at a particular point in time he died under Pontius Pilate that is when the blood is shed and forgiveness of sins is wrought so that is the new covenant and so here you have

44:15

I don't know of anyone who's any sound biblical Christian who believes the Lord's Supper initiates or starts our salvation as was just alleged that's not what reformed churches believe that's not what we've been teaching those things are part of our proclamation of the death of Jesus Christ because we recognize that it is only by that single one -time sacrifice that any of us can have the perfect righteousness of Jesus Christ imputed to us that is why the cross is so central that is why the incarnation is so central as why the resurrection is so central and I would just like to point out that the doctrines of the deity of Christ the

44:56

Trinity the incarnation the cross the resurrection justification by faith were not hammered out and defended by Harold Camping's method of interpretation and it is that method of interpretation that has always been used by those who have undercut these beliefs that is why

45:13

I am I am so concerned about this because I believe that we must honor the

45:18

Bible for what it actually states thank you very much Dr.

45:24

White and I want to thank both of our participants for being so faithful to keeping to the three minutes and Mr.

45:30

Camping you have three minutes to continue or respond first of all the idea of that being a covenant really we have to read in Hebrews chapter 8 where God says now that he hath at verse 6 hath obtained a more excellent ministry by how much more he is a mediator of a better covenant which was established upon better promises for the first covenant had been if it had been faultless then should no place have been sought for the second and then he says and finding fault with them he finds fault with both of them and then he tells about a covenant the covenant that now is in action the law the word covenant is the word law in verse 10 for there is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days saith

46:24

Jehovah and after those days when we search that through the Bible we find it talking about our days after the end of the church age after those days saith

46:35

Jehovah I will put my laws into their mind and write them in their hearts and I will be to them a

46:42

God and they will be to me a people and they shall not teach every man his neighbor and every man his brother saying know the

46:50

Lord for all shall know me from the least to the greatest in other words there is this time when

46:57

God is saving directly not through a church not through elders and deacons and Bible pastors

47:08

I'm just directing people to show them in the Bible where to look but the fact is we've aborted the fact that we were looking at that there was another book that was open and we read about that in Revelation 5 and it was not open until the beginning of the great tribulation this final 23 year period and that is why we are understanding so many things but I don't know of a church that has ever considered at all what that little book or that book of Daniel that was sealed what all that has to do with as they have considered the import of that but until we do we don't have the truth and you know when

48:01

Christ came you were saying well what did it mean to them when Christ was preaching around the

48:07

Sea of Galilee those people none of them became saved virtually none of them became saved we have plenty of evidence in the

48:15

Bible and the church had started it was a dead church and what about I still want to know what church is still alive there is a church that is alive it's the invisible church

48:27

God is still building that church he will build that until the day of the rapture but it's an invisible church it has nothing to do with a local congregation the

48:41

Bible comes up very clear when we see that God with the nation of Israel and then with the church age thank you

48:49

Mr. Camping your three minutes are up and I just want to make a quick announcement for those of you who tuned in late this is a debate between Harold Camping of Family Radio and Dr.

49:00

James R. White of Alpha Omega Ministries this is day number one of a two day debate on the theme has the church age ended and Dr.

49:07

James R. White you now have three minutes I want to point out that Mr. Camping has just misrepresented Hebrews chapter 8 and this is a good example of what happens when you do not do exegesis of the text directly in verse 8 he said for he finds fault with them when he says he identified them as the covenants read what it says he goes on to quote

49:31

Jeremiah 31 he's finding fault with the people under the first covenant that's why you have the new covenant that is then enunciated in the verses that follow the them is not the two covenants there's not some third one or something that's coming that's not what

49:47

Hebrews chapter 8 is talking about in any way shape or form that does not follow the argument of the book of Hebrews that's again where you just he said well and we see elsewhere no you have to find out what the original text is saying before you run off to another text one is exegesis allowing the text to speak for itself the other is eisegesis reading into the text meanings that the original author in the original audiences would have had no idea of now there were many people who were saved in the outpouring of the

50:19

Holy Spirit of God I'm not sure what the the idea of well there weren't many people saved during Jesus's preaching well that may be true but there are 120 in the upper room and when the church began to expand there were thousands very quickly so when the spirit came and it was the spirits time to draw those people he drew them that's what the

50:36

Holy Spirit can do revelation chapter 5 talking about this book that is sealed the question is asked who's worthy to open it is

50:46

Harold Camping the one who's worthy to open it no it is of course the Lord Jesus is this the

50:51

Bible is that what anyone reading John's words would have understood again we need to understand if you take this perspective that is being presented by Mr.

51:01

Camping then John wrote this book and Christians read this book and Christians died protecting this book

51:08

Christians gave their blood protecting this book and preaching this book and they never had the slightest idea what it was talking about until 1900 years later when someone in Alameda California has the book open to them and then can begin teaching this

51:25

I'm sorry but the very teaching the scripture is that it's given to us for our edification it is given to us to build us up and that's why the scriptures were given to us and there have been many people down through the history of the church who have come along and said oh

51:39

I have the special insight I have the spiritual insight that no one else has ever had they've all come and they've all gone and the only thing left is the church of Jesus Christ and he asked what churches are still teaching

51:50

Mr. Camping there are faithful Christians sitting in prison cells in Muslim lands today who have never heard of you or your message but they stand firm for the name of Jesus Christ they will not give up their confession of faith in Jesus Christ and you cannot say that they are not true believers even though they don't believe what you are teaching.

52:10

Thank you Dr. White your three minutes are up and Mr. Camping you have three minutes yeah well you know you're saying

52:18

Mr. Camping this and Mr. Camping that and Mr. Camping the other thing and as if I am just poking along just with my own ideas

52:28

I'll tell you I have a very deep concern for the authority of the

52:36

Bible it's not the church that has any authority incidentally you quoted one place from 1st

52:41

Timothy 3 the church is the pillar of truth that absolutely is not true and it didn't say that either it's still the pillar and ground of truth and Christ is the foundation and the church can never never write her down the

52:59

Bible the Bible is God's word and the church was formed by the law of God it was not the law of God that formed the

53:07

Bible the Bible is and the Bible is not what John wrote or what Peter wrote the

53:13

Bible is what God said what God said holy men of old spoke as God the Holy Spirit moved them and in Jeremiah 36

53:21

God shows us He gives us a detail of how God dictated the book of Jeremiah to Jeremiah and then

53:32

Jeremiah's secretary wrote it down and put it in the role of the book and that is illustrating how

53:38

God has given us the Bible every word came from God and whether the apostles who wrote or the men who wrote understood that's beside the issue it's what

53:50

God wanted to give us and we as we read in Mark 4 he wrote it in a way that is very very conducive to unbelief in the lives of those who you know we have you ever preached a sermon on Mark chapter 4 let's look that again because that really when

54:13

I discovered that years ago I was shocked at what God was saying there as he says in Mark 4 he's saying in verse 11 unto you it is given he's talking to the apostles is given the word of God or excuse me unto you is given the mystery of the kingdom of God but unto them that are without all these things are done in parables that seeing they may see and not perceive and hearing they may hear and not understand lest they at any time be converted and their sins should be forgiven them now that's the word of God that came from the mouth of God and we have to deal with that and that shows that God's intention was that a lot of the

55:07

Bible was written in a way so it could not be understood but as we learn the rules and now wonderfully as we're talking now for example at the time of the end

55:19

May 21, 2011 God has given us marvelous proof right out of the

55:25

Bible that show us that we've done our homework okay Mr.

55:31

Camping your three minutes are up and now Dr. James R. White you may resume with three minutes

55:36

I would like to ask Mr. Camping to respond either today or tomorrow to one of the most key issues for me and that was a statement

55:45

I heard him make where he identified Christ as the Father I would very much like to find out if he has abandoned the historic doctrine of the

55:51

Trinity at that point and engaged and embraced a form of modalism I think that's extremely important but we just had a statement made that I somehow was misrepresenting 1st

56:00

Timothy 3 .15 let me read it to you but in case I am delayed Paul writing to Timothy I write so that you will know how one ought to conduct himself in the household of God which is the church of the living

56:11

God the pillar and support of the truth the pillar and the bulwark of the truth probably a better way of rendering hadrioma there so that is the statement that Paul makes and the context is right after he's been discussing the qualifications of elders and deacons so we're talking about the local church so he's writing to Timothy so that he might know how people must behave in the local church which is the church of living

56:41

God the pillar and foundation the truth it does not require us to believe that the church rules over Scripture Scripture is the speaking of God the church listens to the voice of her spouse speaking in Scripture there's no question about that I have defended sola scriptura against the leading

56:57

Roman Catholic apologists out there but it does not follow them that what is being said here should not be believed that it is

57:04

God's purpose that that which holds up that which protects the truth is the local body of believers with elders and deacons that was what

57:15

Paul wrote to Timothy now if you want to explain to me from the text not jumping to another text but looking at 1st

57:22

Timothy 3 .15 how do you understand that to teach anything other than that the local church is the pillar and foundation the pillar and support the pillar and bulwark of the truth that it is

57:35

God's purpose that in the ministry of the word of God in the gathering of the saints the instruction the word of God the worship that comes from that we enter into that place of worship and I have seen people save Mr.

57:47

Camping in the years since you started teaching this wonderfully changed in the fellowship of the church the

57:53

Holy Spirit of God has applied the word of God their hearts and lives and has changed their lives that has happened since you have been teaching that the

58:03

Holy Spirit is no longer in the church one of us can go to the word of God and explain why that is

58:09

I do not believe that you can simply stay in 1st Timothy 3 .15 and explain what is being said there in context in light of Paul's intention and what

58:18

Timothy would have understood and explain how your system of denying the church exists is consistent with that which is found in the inspired word of God well first of all you know

58:30

I spoke about terrors remember in Mark chapter 13 that the enemy sowed terrors and they were so much like the wheat and incidentally this is parabolic language again the terrors representing people who look so much like a true believer that you cannot distinguish them from the wheat the wheat representing there again parabolic language wheat representing those who are the true believers and God says don't try to throw out the terrors because you're going to be throwing out the wheat wait until the end and it's in our day that that separation is developing that's the whole purpose of the great tribulation one of the big purposes is a testing time where God is separating the wheat from the terrors but mankind can't see the heart you can't see the heart of any people that claim that they're saved and their life has really been changed and say now

59:38

I know they're a true believer nobody can see what about these terrors that come in that look exactly like true believers they love the

59:48

Lord they are very good Bible teachers and whatever and whatever and whatever and yet they are terrors

59:55

God knows who they are now insofar as 1st Timothy chapter 3 you know

01:00:00

God this is not untypical God wrote the Bible and put traps in the language in order to separate here this verse for example it says the church of the living

01:00:17

God the pillar and ground of the truth now the church being the pillar and ground of the truth that dramatically will work out that was true but also it will work out the living

01:00:30

God is the pillar and ground of truth this verse is written in such a way that you can look at it either way and we know without question

01:00:41

Christ is the ground of truth He is the foundation of truth and we're not going to try to figure any way in which the church is the ground of truth now you can do that but you're not doing it giving

01:00:59

God all the glory glory glory glory goes to God and incidentally insofar as the

01:01:06

Trinity is concerned the Bible is very clear there are three persons in the

01:01:11

Godhead the Father the Son and the Holy Spirit and yet the fullness of we we read that in Christ dwelleth all the fullness of the

01:01:22

Godhead bodily and we see this when he told the disciples in John 14 you have been with me you have seen the

01:01:32

Father and you have been with me you've seen the Holy Spirit. Three final minutes of this broadcast and then we will resume tomorrow.

01:01:43

Oh wait we will be able to go another three minutes? Yes. Oh okay well thank you very much again in answer to a number of the things that were just brought up the pillar and support of the truth is in apposition to the subject of the preceding phrase which is the church of the living

01:02:00

God. To make God the description of that is again to just completely miss the point that Paul is attempting to communicate there.

01:02:09

Next I wish I could maybe tomorrow we can understand this a little bit more fully but I don't understand

01:02:15

Mr. Camping's response just now. He has identified Christ as the Father. He has just used classical terms that modalist use.

01:02:23

Does he believe that the Son has existed as a divine person from eternity past or at least the second person of the

01:02:31

Trinity has he existed as a divine person from eternity past in communication with the

01:02:36

Father so there are three divine persons eternally existed. I realize he says that the

01:02:42

Son had a beginning at the resurrection or something like that but he actually uses the word

01:02:48

Christ for the pre -incarnate Jesus and it's very confusing but I would like to maybe tomorrow get some clarification on that because I think that is extremely extremely important but once again

01:02:57

I hope the people in the audience can hear I would like to offer to Mr.

01:03:03

Camping and the family radio that on May 22nd 2011 I will do the open forum broadcast for a month to explain to people how to do biblical interpretation to avoid what has happened because on May 12th 2011 when these things don't happen then there's going to be a lot of people who are going to need to have their trust in the

01:03:25

Bible reestablished because they've been told over and over again the Bible taught this the

01:03:30

Bible taught this and just like in 1975 when Jehovah's Witnesses predicted the end of the world and it didn't happen over a million people left the

01:03:38

Watchtower Bible and Tract Society over the next few years and the sad thing is studies have shown the vast majority of them didn't end up anywhere else they are the great religiously abused they no longer believe the

01:03:49

Bible they don't believe anything and so I would like to offer to on starting May 22nd 2011 to talk about how to do meaningful exegesis and hermeneutics so that you can again trust the

01:04:02

Bible and recognize that it has an unchanging message that is not dependent upon any one individual it is not dependent upon having a charismatic leader that claims to have a special insight and opening of seals and all the rest of those types of things

01:04:15

I would like to warn people and exhort people that the

01:04:21

Bible itself should not be blamed for incoherent teachings that are attributed to it by not allowing its own words to speak for itself don't blame the

01:04:32

Bible for what people do to the Bible recognize that you need to listen to what the

01:04:37

Bible said as it was originally written its original intention and to its original audience thank you very much for today thank you so much

01:04:45

Mr. Harold Camping of Family Radio and Dr. James R. White of Alpha Omega Ministries this has been day number one of a two day debate on the theme has the church age ended?

01:04:59

we are going to be continuing our program tomorrow I implore all of you listening to please pray for God to be glorified during that hour tomorrow

01:05:10

I want to thank the technicians from both WNYG and from Family Radio for making sure that today's broadcast was a success and keep in mind that on Thursday for those of you who have been itching to call in with questions we are not taking phone calls tomorrow on Thursday Dr.