0:26
About to go live right here.
0:28
I guess we are going live.
0:29
We're going to be reviewing a little review that took a little bit, but we're going to do it with the dog.
0:46
So are you ready to do a review of the review?
0:49
I was so ready that I thought it was time I trimmed my beard for it.
0:52
Dude, you got a baby beard now.
0:56
I just got to hit the reset on it.
0:57
You know, like, you know, baptism washes away your past sins.
1:00
You need that reset button.
1:01
You got to get re -bearded.
1:05
So what did you think about Aaron's eight hour review?
1:12
He holed up in an office for eight hours, dude.
1:16
I hope his family was on vacation.
1:19
That's a whole work shift.
1:20
I thought, you know, on one hand, I could see myself, Trey, I could see myself doing an eight hour
1:26
work shift reviewing a debate.
1:28
I think I would love that actually.
1:32
I'd lock myself in that dungeon.
1:34
I was driving back from Baton Rouge and I saw it and I started laughing when
1:42
And so I was just fast forwarding to what, you know, what he said.
1:47
And I was like, okay, yeah, we're going to have to review this because it's not good.
1:51
Some things that were said.
1:52
So I did want everybody to know that I did invite him to be on
2:01
Asked if he would want to join us so he could defend anything we said and
2:10
So I did my due diligence.
2:10
Maybe he'll do a review of our review of his debate.
2:18
I don't know why he's scared to debate you though.
2:20
We'll talk about that later.
2:23
Are you willing to do it?
2:29
I would do any format under the sun that he wants.
2:33
We'll get you on cultish.
2:34
Get both of y 'all on cultish to do it.
2:36
Trey, we should have Jerry and Andrew moderate a live in
2:42
-person debate for cultish episode with a debate with me and Gallagher.
2:48
I think maybe he would do that.
2:49
I think he would love it.
2:52
I'll take, I'll talk more about my discussions with him later when he mentions me in the debate or in his review
2:59
So we got some people watching, jump in there on the interview, the chat deal.
3:04
And if you have any questions as we go, put a cue beside your message and we'll bring it up on the screen.
3:09
We'll try to answer whatever questions you may have.
3:13
So you're ready to jump right into it.
3:14
You want to say anything else before we jump into this?
3:18
Shout out to Leanne Ferguson, just all of her support.
3:22
All of her labors for the kingdom of just trying to bring clarity on the gospel of grace.
3:27
Shout out to the turtles, the turtle book, the turtle club.
3:32
We're going to be doing a little.
3:34
Book review of that one pretty soon because again, I've reached out to him and others there and just
3:40
said, look, I want to ask questions.
3:41
I said, I don't even want to tell you what I think.
3:44
I just simply want to ask questions of some very apparent contradictions in this thing.
3:49
Just to, I said to God, anybody can be there.
3:53
Just want to ask questions and that's it.
4:00
So you ready to go into this?
4:02
Before we dive in, I want to also just tell people, I listened carefully to a lot of things that Aaron
4:09
And one thing kind I want to say is he was not afraid to tell people where he disagreed with Mike Hysall.
4:15
He disagrees on Mark 16, 16.
4:18
He disagrees with the core understanding of Acts 2 .38 about what it means to be baptized in the
4:25
And so what this showed me was there is so much diversity amongst the church of
4:31
Christ and their proof text and their theology at large.
4:36
However, what binds them together is that they believe your past sins are washed away
4:42
in the watery graves of baptism.
4:44
So I want to let everybody know, no matter which sect of the church of Christ you fall under,
4:50
if you believe that core tenet, then that is a gospel that cannot saved.
4:55
And if you tell me, well, I disagree with them on, I believe in salvation by faith alone.
5:00
Then I'm going to tell you, then you're not church of.
5:04
And that, when I don't, I did the cultures thing.
5:05
That's what I just stayed on.
5:07
They believe you're born perfect.
5:08
The vast majority of them.
5:10
I've not met one that doesn't, but so anyway, born perfect.
5:14
And then you have to be baptized to be saved and you can lose your salvation.
5:18
But, so baptismal regeneration, which he says is he doesn't believe in baptismal regeneration, but that's another point that
5:24
Mike Isall does believe in.
5:26
And Mike Isall said that you don't necessarily have to be baptized because if you
5:32
intended to get baptized and died, then you could be saved, which Aaron will show that
5:39
He gives about a 20 minute, you know, word Judo scripture salad, where you
5:44
almost forget what the question was because it took him so long to answer it to him to say, you're going to hell no matter what.
5:50
When y 'all had a debate, more of a discussion, he didn't like that y 'all's exchange was timed.
5:57
And he had, I got emails anyway
6:05
I should make public, should just throw them out there.
6:07
But, but in emails, he wanted to have 10 minute answers.
6:12
And I'm like, dude, 10 minute answers.
6:16
And he's like, no five minutes.
6:17
I'm like, man, if you can't give an answer in two minutes, like you need to find another answer.
6:21
But this is why they have to have so much time so they can just like start picking and pulling scripture everywhere, just
6:27
jumble it all up and everything, get everybody confused.
6:30
And that's why they have to have so much time to give their answers because it's just scripture
6:40
First of all, let's talk about this one right here, where you have to be consistent, Jeremiah.
6:46
And he's going to bring up second Kings chapter five, Naaman had a discussion with some, a church Christ
6:56
And he's bringing up second Kings five.
6:57
And I said, I wouldn't bring up second Kings five, if I were you.
7:00
I mean, I know you do, but I wouldn't, it's not a good one.
7:03
He's all not, I'm not, I'm not.
7:05
And then like 30 minutes later, he goes to try to use it.
7:08
There's only so many spots you can go to, but you know, this is one that Aaron goes to, to try to prove
7:16
And, um, we're going to show you why it's a bad move.
7:20
Let's see what he says here.
7:22
Hey, whatever this phrase means in Matthew 26, 28, you should be consistent and it should mean the same thing in acts two 38.
7:28
So did Jesus Christ shed his blood because sins are forgiven already?
7:32
Um, acts two 38, were they repenting and being baptized because sins have been forgiven already?
7:38
So, um, that's the argument some people make.
7:41
Um, anyway, so that's, that's one thing I like.
7:44
I really liked when Mike said this, he worded it this way, physical water cannot wash away spiritual guilt.
7:50
Uh, there is a teaching called baptismal regeneration that unfortunately people throw around that phrase
7:56
nowadays, not realizing historically what that meant.
7:59
Um, for instance, like in Charles Spurgeon, um, in the 1600s, he was a Baptist preacher in London at the
8:05
maybe Metropolitan Tabernacle.
8:07
I don't remember, but he was like the most famous.
8:10
Some people call him the Prince of Baptist preachers, right?
8:12
He's the most famous Baptist preacher probably ever.
8:15
Um, and he was talking about baptismal regeneration in one of his sermons.
8:19
And he talked about how the church of England, I think it was, was the only one that taught it.
8:23
So back then what they meant by that is they meant that water without faith would regenerate.
8:29
So like baptismal regeneration, who really teaches that is like Catholics or believe maybe Lutherans
8:35
where they say, Hey, um, you dip a baby in water and that water because the
8:41
it's Holy, um, God will forgive the sins, right?
8:44
Not the water's Holy, but they, they still think I teach that God forgives the sins when they're baptized, but that's not what we teach.
8:50
So when someone says, Aaron, you teach baptismal regeneration, I'm like, well, I know what you mean by that, but
8:56
don't conflate that with what baptismal regeneration is historically.
9:11
here's the thing is this whole idea.
9:14
And this is what's so sad.
9:16
So many people just trust people.
9:18
They trust them, whatever they say.
9:19
Like there's so many people who watched Aaron Gallagher that just trust him, right?
9:23
For instance, we did a video on talking about what it means to obey the gospel.
9:28
Hippie Kua, what that Greek word means.
9:31
They did a video saying how I was stupid line.
9:34
Didn't know what I was talking about.
9:36
Didn't know what lexicon I got that from.
9:38
So we brought up about 17 lexicons proven that it's, it's a heart thing.
9:43
It's, it's a looking at the gospel of Jesus Christ and being in awe with it and taking it to the heart,
9:50
showed all the definitions in every lexicon and just show that they were lying,
9:55
absolutely lying, you know?
9:58
And thank God someone called me up about a month ago and watch that.
10:02
So they had to watch it twice.
10:03
And now they're, they're gone just simply from seeing that like that was just a mind blower to them.
10:07
But here's this one right here that, that baptismal regeneration
10:13
is talking about just the water washing away original sin and babies, stuff like
10:20
Let's just see what it is.
10:23
Here's the glossary of theology right here.
10:26
Baptismal regeneration, the idea that baptism is the means by which original sin is washed away.
10:30
That is water baptism is how the Holy Spirit performs the regeneration of the believer, right?
10:37
Would he say that he agrees with that, that at baptism, that's when the Holy Spirit performs
10:43
regeneration of the believer?
10:45
So it's necessary part of salvation.
10:47
Would he say that that's the necessary part of salvation?
10:53
According to the church of Rome, regeneration includes not only spiritual renewal.
10:58
He would agree with that also justification or the forgiveness of sins and is affected by
11:05
Now that's what your whole debate was about, right?
11:08
Your whole debate was about that.
11:10
So yes, he would agree with that.
11:16
Roman Catholics, advocates of baptismal regeneration.
11:20
Roman Catholic church teaches, teaches it describing baptism as the lever of regeneration at the Council of Trent.
11:27
It anathematizes who disagree.
11:30
So if you disagree, you're going to hell.
11:32
If anyone saith that baptism is free, that is not necessary unto salvation, let him be anathema.
11:39
Now, Jeremiah, doesn't he think that we're anathema because we don't believe that?
11:47
Same thing with Eastern Orthodox.
11:52
Presbyterians, Congregationalists, Baptists, Methodists, Low Church, Episcopalians differ from that of the Roman and the
11:58
Greek churches and the high church of Anglicans in his rejection of the idea that baptism is the instrumental cause of
12:04
regeneration and that the grace of regeneration is effectually conveyed through the administration of the right
12:11
That's exactly what, that's what region, that's what baptismal regeneration is.
12:15
So as much as he wants to say, that's not what it is.
12:20
You want to say anything before we go back.
12:22
Into this, before he goes into 2 Kings chapter 5?
12:29
People mean different things by baptismal regeneration, but the question you have to ask that you brought out is, all
12:35
right, Gallagher, all right, Hysol, when is a person regenerated?
12:39
Is it about faith or is it at another point in time?
12:43
Oh, you're regenerated in the watery graves of baptism.
12:47
That's baptismal regeneration.
12:50
So this is the weird quandary that they're in.
12:52
Yeah, they believe in baptismal regeneration differently than the Anglicans, the Lutherans, and the Roman
12:58
Catholic and the Greek Orthodox.
13:00
Yes, but you still believe in baptismal regeneration.
13:04
Lutherans, Catholics, a lot will say, well, yeah, you got to baptize infants because in
13:10
baptism it washes away original sin.
13:14
Church of Christ, they don't mean that.
13:16
They don't believe in original sin.
13:18
So to me, it's like a waving of the hand for Gallagher to say, well, we don't really believe in baptismal
13:24
regeneration historically.
13:26
Well, you believe that you're regenerated in baptism.
13:31
Y 'all just reject infant baptism and they didn't get to say, well, then we
13:37
don't get to say we believe in baptismal regeneration because we don't baptize infants.
13:41
No, you believe adults, believers, or those that confess Christ, they get
13:49
So to me, this is a weird point.
13:51
This is why Mike Hysall openly says, of course, we believe in baptismal regeneration.
13:55
They had a debate review recently, actually really enjoyed a lot of the input that they said reflecting
14:03
And when Hysall was taking me to town on BDAG, which I hope we talk about this a little bit because I
14:09
don't know, if you've been looking on Facebook, we have a lot of questions out there and I've been letting people know I've been seeing
14:15
And to me, they crack me up.
14:17
But when they're doing their debate review and they were talking about,
14:23
you know, we're getting into, oh, Lutherans understand that the grace of justification
14:30
Number one, I don't think they do, actually.
14:32
They'd be more on our side when they say justification is by faith alone.
14:36
But every time in the debate where I would tell Mike and regeneration and regeneration, his debate
14:42
review was he said, of course, Jeremiah's acting like he's teaching me something.
14:46
And of course, we believe that you're regenerated in baptism.
14:50
And that wasn't what I was doing.
14:51
I was just saying like there's a full picture that I agree Mike and Lutherans are very
14:57
similar, that regeneration happens in baptism.
15:02
So this is just a point of inconsistency.
15:04
Now here's I think why there's an inconsistency with with Mike and
15:10
Gallagher is because Gallagher is a far right wing Church of Christ, which
15:18
The further you go back, like they're all going to sound the same, make similar Campbellite.
15:23
Now, Mike, I saw he's a right moderate leaning, so he doesn't make the same
15:29
kind of arguments that Gallagher makes.
15:31
And this is just to demonstrate to people, they're all not the same, the core tenants are there, but there's a lot of
15:37
disagreements amongst the CFC.
15:39
Like the Mark 1616, the hard, hard ones want it because it says that baptism, you know,
15:45
whoever believes in is baptized will be saved.
15:48
But again, they don't even really believe that had a guy reaching out to me this week from a local congregation.
15:54
Yep, he kept sending me all these memes.
15:57
And I messaged him, I said, look, Hey, if you want to meet and talk about, you know, scriptures, I would love to
16:03
do that, but don't send me memes.
16:04
I don't get my theology from memes.
16:06
So if you want to sit and talk, I would be more than happy to sit.
16:11
So he just kept sending me all these memes about how do you got to get baptized, be saved.
16:14
And so finally he sent me Mark 1616.
16:17
He said, you don't believe Mark 1616.
16:20
You don't, you know, I said, cause it says whoever believes in is baptized will be saved.
16:25
So you don't believe that you believe whoever believes in is baptized might be saved, could be saved, has the opportunity to be saved,
16:33
Because you believe they could lose their salvation.
16:34
So you really don't believe it.
16:36
So let's just go back to his deal about being consistent.
16:39
And he's about to bring up second Kings chapter five.
16:41
Let's see what you think.
16:43
So the reason I think that's important to mention is Mike said, let me get it.
16:46
He said, physical water cannot wash away spiritual guilt.
16:49
That's what we believe that the new Testament teaches.
16:51
It's also historically what all the early church writers, the apostolic and anti -Nicene fathers taught,
16:57
but that's a different point for a different day.
17:00
So physical water doesn't wash away spiritual guilt, but a good analogy is in the
17:07
Second Kings five, a man named Naaman has leprosy and Naaman wants his leprosy cleansed.
17:12
He goes to a prophet and the prophet basically gives him the instruction to dip in the Jordan seven times.
17:18
And he says, I don't want to dip in the Jordan.
17:19
I want to dip in these nice, clean rivers in Damascus.
17:22
And then his servant girl's like, just do what he says.
17:25
So Naaman goes and dips in the Jordan seven times and his leprosy is miraculously healed.
17:31
Now, if you could take a time machine back and say, Naaman, what healed your leprosy?
17:37
He would obviously say God did it, but when did God do it?
17:40
He did it whenever you obeyed.
17:46
It had nothing to do with his faith.
17:48
It had nothing to do with his faith.
17:50
It had everything about his action, him doing.
17:52
Now he would say, of course, God did it.
17:54
God healed me, of course.
17:56
But when, when you did, when you obeyed, had nothing to do with faith.
18:01
So he wants to, he wants to act like you do have to have faith, but you really don't.
18:06
But we'll talk more about that in a minute.
18:08
So Naaman, I'm just going to back up just a hair bit so you can.
18:11
Go back and hear that again.
18:13
And his leprosy is miraculously healed.
18:16
Now, if you could take a time machine back and say, Naaman, what healed your leprosy?
18:21
He would obviously say God did it, but when did God do it?
18:25
He did it whenever you obeyed the command, the promise, you got their promise blessing.
18:30
So Naaman, dip in the water seven times and what's going to happen?
18:34
Your physical infirmity, leprosy will be cleansed.
18:39
Otherwise there'd be leper colonies all over the Jordan river.
18:41
And it may be, it'd be cured to this day.
18:45
So obviously that's a good analogy and maybe a foreshadowing that the biblical writers intended, which is
18:51
whenever you're dipped or immersed fully.
18:54
I mean, when I mean dipped, I mean, go down to the water.
18:56
Like I dunk my Oreos, not like some people just half immersed.
19:01
Whenever you're buried, immersed, baptized, completely under the water, you're buried under the water
19:07
that is physical water, but you are being obedient to the promised, the promised blessing you'll receive, which is forgiveness of
19:13
So I liked that Mike said that.
19:15
So when you come up out of the water, if you said to somebody who was baptized, like they were in the new Testament, um, what saved
19:21
Did, did the water save you?
19:22
You'd say, no, God saved me.
19:24
Well, when did God save you when you did what he promised?
19:28
I thought baptism now saves you.
19:30
Well, see, here's, and this is the problem.
19:32
Like he said, like, this is a perfect picture of the old Testament, you know, the new Testament baptism.
19:38
Like he said, baptism doesn't mean naming, you know, if you ask name and who healed, how'd you get healed?
19:43
He'd say, well, God healed me.
19:44
How I have nothing to do with faith of believing God.
19:49
It was all about his obedience.
19:50
So look, here's, here's Naaman commander of the army of the King of Syria.
19:54
So he goes down, he has leprosy.
19:56
He goes to Elisha, the man of God or the King of Israel had torn his clothes.
19:59
So he goes see Elijah verse nine.
20:02
So Naaman came with his horses and chariots and stood at the door of Elisha's house.
20:05
Elisha sent a messenger to him saying, go and wash in the Jordan seven times and your flesh shall be restored
20:13
But Naaman went away angry.
20:16
He was angry and he went away, right?
20:18
Saying, behold, I thought he would surely come out to me and stand and call upon the name of the Lord and wave his hand
20:24
over the place and cure the leper or not a Bama and far par the rivers of Damascus better than all the waters of
20:30
Israel because they hated Israel.
20:32
Could I not wash in them and be clean?
20:37
He didn't believe in God.
20:38
He didn't believe the promise of God.
20:39
He did not believe the words of the prophet of God.
20:41
He didn't believe any of it.
20:42
He's like, this is ridiculous.
20:46
And he left in a rage, but his servants came near and said to him, my father, it is a
20:53
The prophet has spoken to you.
20:55
Has he actually said you wash and be clean?
20:57
Like, so it sounds like just do, just do it.
21:00
I mean, what's it going to hurt?
21:01
I mean, you got leprosy, just do it.
21:04
So Naaman didn't go down into the water because he trusted God and his word and his promises.
21:09
That's not why he went in the water.
21:11
He went in the water to save his own hide.
21:13
So if Aaron wants to say this is the, this is their understanding of baptism, I would agree.
21:19
You're getting into the water to save your own hide.
21:21
And we can look and see how that developed over church history.
21:25
But this is why a lot of people are doing it.
21:26
Just, hey, if it works, it works.
21:30
So he turned away, went and raised, so he did it.
21:32
So when he dipped himself seven times in the Jordan, according to the word of the man of God, his flesh was restored like the flesh of a
21:38
little child and was clean.
21:41
So don't think you want to use Naaman.
21:43
There was absolutely no faith, no trust in God in that whole.
21:49
Okay, so we got to be careful when you appeal to type and shadow and substance in the Old Testament about
21:55
what, what can we extrapolate and learn?
21:58
How can we discern what is written for our learning and to apply to us today?
22:03
Number one, I would say it's different in saying there's ceremonial rituals,
22:09
whether it be in Leviticus or numbers or in the Torah for people with
22:14
leprosy and things like that.
22:16
Okay, there's principles there.
22:18
And what principles can we glean from Naaman?
22:20
Well, for one, this ceremonial bath, this showing an act of humility,
22:26
did not justify him before God.
22:29
By the way, that's the whole point of my debate with Hysol.
22:33
So all you can glean from that is, yeah, God did say, do a command.
22:38
Would that be an act of humility?
22:42
Well, putting your faith in the perfect Savior and not trusting in your own works, not trusting in any of the ceremonies you
22:48
participate in, but putting your trust in Jesus Christ, that is the most humble thing you
22:54
could possibly do is say, I can't add any of my works on the
23:00
table to make myself right before God.
23:02
So I'm all for taking principles, Trey, but people want to look at Noah building the
23:08
ark and say, well, he had to do that or he wouldn't have been saved from the waters of judgment.
23:13
I'm like, that is living faith being active, but that's not what justified him
23:20
And so some of these are just far -reaching.
23:23
I'm all for it because when we look at a lot of the faithful in the Old Testament, the just shall live by faith.
23:29
We're going to talk about this later, but someone who is justified by faith then works out their faith in sanctification.
23:36
That's why, Trey, and you can tell me your thoughts on this.
23:38
I define six terms in my opening statement because I've listened to these types of objections
23:44
over and over and over again.
23:46
What do people like Gallagher assume?
23:49
Well, obedience always entails your works, and they would just say doing
23:57
obedience is the works of God, not works of man.
24:00
Okay, well, let's define works.
24:01
Let's talk about the context in which we see that.
24:05
As we're going to see, Hysal takes a lot of liberty with the word faith regardless of what the
24:13
Aaron does the same thing.
24:18
That account of him dipping in the water seven times, about the only thing you can take from that
24:24
is, yes, God requires humility.
24:27
Now, like you said, men can do that to save their own hide.
24:30
We're in a time during the Old Covenant.
24:34
You've got to be careful with saying this is a foreshadowing of X because Roman Catholics, they actually point to
24:40
the Ark of the Covenant as a type of Mary because she and her womb carry
24:46
Jesus, so she must be holy like the Ark of the Covenant.
24:50
Why can you Protestants not see that?
24:52
Oh, well, Church of Christ are going to do that with 2 Kings, anything to bolster their
24:58
Right, so there we're going.
25:02
Define your terms, Jeremiah, because you asked him to define terms.
25:07
You just kind of hit on it a little bit, but according to Aaron, you did not define your terms, so he's going to define some terms
25:13
I just want to know, you're going to go first on this one.
25:15
Let me know if you want me to pause it.
25:18
He talked about Mike's opening and said that Mike didn't define his terms and that Mike just begged the question.
25:24
You know, I got to say, I've watched a lot of debates, listened to a lot of debates, and I remember in the old debates,
25:30
what they would say is, you know, I'm going to define terms.
25:32
They'd say the Bible, and by the Bible, I mean the 66 books that we have in.
25:37
Okay, Jeremiah didn't define what Bible he was using, but come on, we all know what he means,
25:45
Okay, so I'm just going to go.
25:47
Ahead and jump the gun on this.
25:48
No, it is begging the question.
25:50
When you don't ground your case, and when you start making some types of assumptions, then the
25:56
interlocutor, your opponent, is allowed to call you on that.
26:00
Just because if Mike, I'm sure I made a lot of assumptions all over the place, right?
26:05
The ones that I thought most people would be in agreement with me as I assumed something, I don't have to
26:12
So me and Mike, we were assuming that one another knew we were going to be appealing to
26:18
the 66 books of the Protestant canon, right?
26:22
Yes, but we can high -five and say, that's fine.
26:25
Now, what Gallagher doesn't realize is, depending on the context, meaning who you're interacting
26:31
with, it is totally legitimate to call someone out on begging the question.
26:36
You cannot assume the 66 books of the Bible if you're debating a Roman
26:43
That's a time to make a case, because you both might say, the scripture says this, the scripture says that, but they might be
26:49
quoting from Sirach, like Mike Hysall did.
26:54
But my point is, depending on who you're talking to, when you're in a debate, Reformed Baptist, Church of Christ,
26:59
talking about baptism, obedience, and faith, guess what you don't get to do, Trey?
27:04
You don't get to beg the question.
27:05
You got to prove that one.
27:07
Well, here's the reason why,.
27:09
And this is why when I'm talking to them, I get them, well, we both do, get them to define terms.
27:13
What is the definition of faith?
27:15
What is the definition of justification?
27:16
What is the definition of baptism?
27:18
What do these words mean?
27:20
Because here's the deal, if we're supposed, we're both talking about faith, right?
27:24
I'm talking about faith, say Mike's talking about faith, or Aaron's talking about faith, you're talking about faith, we're talking about faith, but
27:30
we know they've changed the definition of faith.
27:33
They know they've changed the definition of faith, but the people who are listening to us talk, they don't know
27:40
that they've changed the definition of faith.
27:42
And this is why it says this right here, remind them of these things, this is 2 Timothy 2, 14,
27:49
and charge them before God not to quarrel about words, which does no good, but only ruins the
27:56
Because see, if the people don't know that somebody in here has changed the definition of words, they're going to get confused,
28:01
because they're going to hear the word faith, they're going to hear the word grace, but they don't know that the
28:07
terms have not been defined, right?
28:09
So do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a worker who is, no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth.
28:15
So that's why you're asking to define terms, but he says you didn't do it either.
28:19
Let's see what he says, you ready?
28:21
Let me tell you, what he's.
28:23
Going to do is, he did not like how I appealed and grounded faith, because it wouldn't be
28:29
the same way that he would.
28:30
And to me, you're welcome to object, but to say that I didn't define faith either,
28:37
even Gallagher, he wouldn't have said that in a debate, because obviously I took time to go
28:44
He's going to want to go to a different definition of faith, as we're going to see.
28:47
But I did more than just that.
28:49
I actually went to verses like Hebrews 11, 1, which gives us the definition of faith.
28:54
And it continues to give us the definition of faith later in verse six that says, this is a faith that doesn't just
29:00
know facts, but seeks God in faith, meaning trusting him with your whole
29:06
heart in the just shall live by faith.
29:08
That's the same context that Hebrews uses faith and the book of Romans.
29:13
So yeah, play Gallagher, because he essentially says, I don't define faith either.
29:18
I just tell people, go back and listen to the debate.
29:20
I spent a long time defining it.
29:24
I'll say everyone, 99 of the people watching this understand when they start talking about the Bible and scripture, that they
29:31
mean the 66 books of the new Testament, excluding the Apocrypha, right?
29:35
So, you know, whenever you say, well, he didn't, you know, Mike didn't define his terms properly.
29:40
And I think the ones he mentioned, I tried to type as fast as I could, faith works, justification, sanctification, obey, and maybe
29:47
Maybe those were the five, um, you know, not trying to be too critical, but like Jeremiah didn't really define it either.
29:52
For instance, Jeremiah brought up BDAG and said BDAG defines faith as trust.
29:58
And he only gave one definition.
29:59
He didn't give all the definitions that BDAG gives.
30:02
So I want to sort of show you something really quickly.
30:05
So this is how you use a lexicon, right?
30:08
So, you know, if I'm looking at my Bible, uh, and I believe you guys can see my screen.
30:13
So, you know, I'm looking up, uh, Hebrews 11, one in the new American standard.
30:16
Now faith is the substance.
30:19
Click on that English word and click on Bible word study.
30:22
And if I were to click on that, it would bring up this page, right?
30:25
So what this does is it gives me the root of the Greek word.
30:28
And then these circle things, this is the lima, the different uses of that, um, cognates, I believe would be the word that people would use.
30:34
So then you come down here to the lima, right?
30:37
It's the more specific form of the root.
30:39
So it's from the root, okay.
30:41
Which means to believe, but the lima here is, uh, pistis or pistis, right?
30:46
And let's see if my software will play it for me.
30:51
Now these are different lexicons that I have, right?
30:53
There's a whole bunch that I have.
30:55
Um, but anyway, this is, uh, we're going to click on BDAG.
30:58
It's when we're referencing and it gives a lot of different definitions, faithfulness, reliability, fidelity, commitment, assurance, oath, truth, proof,
31:04
pledge, trust, confidence, yada, yada, but listen, faith, the body of faith, the belief, or the teaching in Galatians
31:09
one 23, Paul uses the word faith.
31:11
He said, uh, I preach the faith that I once tried to destroy.
31:15
What was he trying to destroy the system of faith Christian.
31:18
So you see what he's, he wants to make faith always be the system of faith.
31:25
He's like, I'm just going to use the last definition of the word faith.
31:29
That means the whole system of faith and try to apply it everywhere.
31:33
It says faith that way I can get away from.
31:36
Firm trust, reliance upon God and Jesus Christ.
31:40
Did, did I see a comment where the church of Christ don't use dictionaries?
31:46
And what's Gallagher doing here then?
31:49
Um, that was, uh, Carl Henry.
31:51
Let me find him again here.
31:52
I think that's your best friend.
31:55
I don't even remember Carl, but he just texted me that you did something.
32:00
He didn't like, he didn't like it when I called BDAG the Lutheran BDAG.
32:05
So, uh, I'm doing this too.
32:11
Did you know I'm pausing for dramatic effect?
32:14
They have to poison the well best way they can.
32:17
Why are you being so dramatic Trey?
32:21
I don't mean to be, but yeah.
32:28
Trey's reading random definition, Aaron quotes from Spurgeon.
32:31
I don't even know what that even.
32:33
Means, but let's just keep going with Aaron's quoting a Baptist.
32:40
Uh, here we go on that English word and click on Bible word study.
32:44
And if I were to click on that, it would bring up this page, right?
32:47
So what this people would use.
32:49
So it's from the root Pistuo.
32:51
Which means to believe, but so is this Pistuo also mean baptized?
32:57
Because I have to go back and look at Pistis, but I don't remember that in.
33:06
So I'm going to hear is Pistis or Pistis, right.
33:10
And let's see if my software will play it for me.
33:15
Now these are different lexicons that I have, right?
33:17
There's a whole bunch that I have.
33:19
Um, but anyway, this is, uh, we're going to click on B dag.
33:22
It's when we're referencing and it gives a lot of different definitions, faithfulness, reliability, fidelity, commitment, assurance, oath, truth, proof,
33:27
pledge, trust, confidence, yada, yada, but listen, faith, the body of faith, the belief or.
33:32
In Galatians one 23, Paul uses the word faith.
33:35
He said, uh, I preached the faith that I once tried to destroy.
33:39
What was he trying to destroy the system of faith, Christianity, right?
33:42
So you have different uses.
33:45
The faith, the faith he was preaching the faith, right?
33:52
Carl's getting a lot of attention here.
33:56
Oh, Hey, how did we miss that?
33:58
That one was the attribute of faith and not the definition.
34:03
Well, cause here's Carl again.
34:07
Oh, don't expose us like that.
34:10
Hebrews six is the definition of faith.
34:14
I don't think that's accurate at all.
34:16
Please pull up Hebrews 11.
34:18
Let's show people what Carl's trying to do.
34:20
Cause remember I've had you on before and I try to tell people how the church guys slowly and ever
34:26
craft craftily tried to shoehorn in works.
34:30
They don't want to use the word works.
34:31
It usually works in the word obedience.
34:37
That's going to tell you what it is.
34:38
Faith is the assurance of things hoped for the conviction of things not seen for by it.
34:45
The people of old received their commendation, their approval.
34:50
Well spoken of to be approved of commendation.
34:53
How did they receive their approval by it?
34:57
The assurance of things hoped for conviction of things not seen by faith.
35:03
We understand that the universe was created by the word of God so that what is seen was not made out of things that are
35:09
So you see the universe, you know, the universe didn't create itself.
35:13
So you see that must be God who created this stuff.
35:17
So then it goes into this stuff of the things that they did.
35:20
And if you can see the things they did, you must know it came from something unseen, which would be faith.
35:25
Their faith produced this because saving faith produces obedience.
35:29
He says, verse six is the definition of faith without faith.
35:34
It is impossible to please him for whoever would draw near to God must believe that he exists and that he rewards those who
35:41
So that's the definition of that.
35:42
That's what he was saying.
35:44
That's the definition of faith according to Carl Henry.
35:50
Emphasize is the word assurance means firm trust.
35:56
And then that that's paralleled with conviction or evidence if you got the good old King James.
36:01
And this is an inward assurance that produces a changed life.
36:06
And so it's always inward.
36:07
It's always of the heart.
36:09
Verse six, without this inward, firm trust, it's impossible to please God for whoever would
36:17
You must believe, not just knowing facts, but you must believe that God
36:22
rewards those who seek him.
36:26
And then we get example after example.
36:28
The just shall live by faith.
36:29
By faith, those who are just demonstrate their lives to the glory of God in
36:45
Hey, Carl Henry, don't mean that.
36:49
This is this is this height, right?
36:51
This was actually for Carl Henry over here.
36:55
But I don't think he's going to believe it.
36:58
So what do you think about that?
37:03
We do have some questions.
37:04
I don't know if you want to backtrack a little bit.
37:06
I want to honor the side chats on both.
37:09
Casey Taylor's up in here and Nikki tight pants.
37:14
You may have to introduce me to some of these cats.
37:19
OK, so somebody said, I think it's Tracy Lewis on Facebook said, I got a question.
37:25
All right, Tracy, let's hear your question.
37:27
Why did you jump from passage to other passages instead of focusing on a passage
37:33
and exegesis of that passage?
37:41
This was on Facebook a little bit while back.
37:45
But Trey, I got I got rebuked for looking at multiple passages and not one.
37:56
That you went from passage to passage.
37:59
I think you went to passages to show that you're justified by faith and that works do not justify you.
38:05
You know, it's funny, too.
38:08
I think you went to Romans four.
38:10
I think you went to Luke 18.
38:13
But this is the thing I read.
38:15
I can't wait to share what he says about Luke 18.
38:18
I referenced Romans four because there's a few key phrases there that our works don't justify us
38:25
Then we see a contrast that we're justified by faith and not by works.
38:29
And he emphasizes that over and over that our justification is judicial, forensic, vertical, and it's by
38:36
That's why all I did was read Romans four because it speaks for itself.
38:41
But, Trey, what I exegeted, and I don't know if Tracy watched the debate or not, but I exegeted
38:46
Luke 18 with the parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector.
38:51
Oh, Jeremiah's not talking about baptism.
38:52
Well, what does baptism mean?
38:55
And I referenced three verses in a row of saying, if I grant that all these are the ceremonial right in the water, then it
39:01
signifies these spiritual realities.
39:04
And I'd like to encourage Tracy, go listen to my rebuttal because I only responded to the
39:10
verses that Hysal brought up in the debate.
39:13
I remember we went to the Great Commission.
39:14
He begged the question there.
39:15
He didn't define his terms.
39:18
And his assumptions I called out because nowhere in the Great Commission says when the point a person is justified,
39:24
you're just assuming what a disciple means.
39:25
And you're looking at the word go, baptize, and to teach them to.
39:29
Yeah, I agree with all that.
39:30
But you got to parse that out.
39:32
You got to explain what that means.
39:33
Mike didn't do that, but he did reference it.
39:36
His one string banjo was Acts 238.
39:39
So guess what the majority of my rebuttal time was?
39:43
And I even started when they were cut to the heart.
39:45
I went all the way down to verse where we read that they were added to the church.
39:51
They received the word, which that's verse 41, I believe, and they were baptized, which is indicative of
39:57
those that received the word.
39:58
And that's the whole point is works are indicative of someone.
40:03
Who is justified by faith.
40:08
So the next one is Galatians where he uses system of faith everywhere in
40:16
He reads Galatians 3 verse 1, but he doesn't want anybody to see the rest of that middle section of chapter three, where it
40:22
says you receive the Holy Spirit by faith, by hearing with faith, by hearing with faith, not the system of faith.
40:27
But anyway, that's like a nine minute clip.
40:28
We're going to skip that.
40:29
I want everybody to see this Luke 18.
40:34
Are you ready for this one?
40:37
Who's ready for a breakdown?
40:40
What up, Nicky Tightpants?
40:43
Where are you at, Josh Ham?
40:50
Josh Ham's in here somewhere.
40:55
This is a whole nother level.
40:59
Quickly, the Luke, Luke 18, the Pharisee and the tax collector. Both of those men were saved.
41:10
That dude said, wait, we're going to let everybody hear that again.
41:15
Quickly, the Luke, Luke 18, the Pharisee and the tax collector.
41:19
Both of those men were saved.
41:26
Sorry, this is a dramatic pause.
41:31
This is Nicky Tightpants.
41:35
Quickly, the Luke, Luke 18, the Pharisee and the tax collector.
41:39
Both of those men were saved.
41:43
So your point to the Pharisee and
41:50
the wretched sinful man who went away justified, what you didn't know is they were both
41:56
justified because they were both Jews.
42:00
You didn't know that, Jeremiah?
42:00
I totally misunderstood that parable.
42:02
Every Jew is a Christian.
42:04
Seriously, this is what he says.
42:07
You are in a right relationship with God.
42:10
They were both already in a relationship with God.
42:13
Now, the Pharisee, very possibly, I would assume he's a Jew.
42:18
So the old covenant, you were born into the relationship with God.
42:28
Did you really believe that for 18 years?
42:32
This is one that he is pulling it out of you know, where, because that is, I don't know any
42:38
church of Christ person who would ever even say that.
42:40
You know what I'm saying?
42:41
But like, this is what he will do.
42:43
He's got a lot of people following.
42:45
Hey, Haisal would not say that.
42:46
Haisal wouldn't say that.
42:48
Cause he, I think Haisal is a little bit more honest than, than this guy to say that.
42:52
I mean, he just knows people are going to believe whatever he says.
42:55
I mean, because that is ridiculous to say that they're both.
42:58
And if you were a Jew, you were born into a covenant relationship with God.
43:02
Let me tell you something, Aaron, I don't care if you're a Jew.
43:05
I don't care if you're a Gentile.
43:06
I don't care if you're a Martian.
43:07
If you're born, you are in a relationship with God.
43:11
You're either got a really good relationship with God.
43:13
You've got a really bad one.
43:15
Every person in the world has a relationship with God.
43:17
But to say that the Pharisee and they're saved.
43:30
Paul says that's what he was taught.
43:34
I was never, I will say this.
43:38
That was because I think that at least we think a little.
43:40
Bit, we'd be like, no, that's crazy.
43:42
Well, here, here's the problem.
43:45
Gallagher doesn't understand covenant theology.
43:47
He doesn't understand what a covenant means.
43:50
Were the children of Israel born in a kind of covenant with God?
43:55
It was not a covenant of salvation.
43:57
It was a covenant of works.
43:59
It was a covenant that was teaching them that they can't save themselves.
44:05
And so it's really unfortunate that Gallagher believes that if you're born, I mean, this is, this was
44:11
what the Pharisees and John eight were telling Jesus that we're born of
44:19
And according to Gallagher and the Jews of those Pharisees is we're saved by being of Abraham
44:25
and John, whether it was John the Baptist or in Jesus, but talking about how it doesn't matter for your sons of
44:31
Abraham by physical birth, God could raise up sons of Abraham from these stones.
44:38
Um, he says, uh, your father's the devil, you know,
44:45
Would say, well, actually no, they were saved under the old covenant.
44:50
Jesus said, if you were Abraham's children, you'd be doing the works Abraham did.
44:53
And they love that part, right?
44:56
But now you seek to kill me.
44:57
A man who's told you the truth.
44:58
I heard from God, this is not what Abraham did.
45:00
You were doing the works your father did.
45:02
And he says, we're not born of sexual morality.
45:04
We have one father, even God.
45:05
And Jesus said to them, if God were your father, you would love me for, I came from God and I'm, I'm here.
45:09
I came not of my own accord.
45:11
Why do you not understand what I say?
45:12
It's because you cannot bear to hear my words.
45:14
You were of your father, the devil and your will.
45:17
You want to hear what free will is your will is to do your father's desire.
45:22
And he was a murderer from the beginning.
45:23
He goes on to tell him that you were your father, the devil.
45:31
I want to see how far Carl is going to try to defend Gallagher.
45:34
You see right here where he says here, he says, you're not born a Jew.
45:38
So he either doesn't understand like Gallagher or he's going to try to defend Gallagher and it's going to be really, really
45:45
We're not saying you're not born a Jew, but listen, what Gallagher said, he said they were born in a
45:50
salvific relationship with God.
45:54
The second temple Jews, they taught that and believed it and were rebuked by John the Baptist, Jesus.
46:00
And I actually want to pull up what the apostle Paul said in Romans chapter two,.
46:05
If we can, the Nikki tight pants, his wife, Emily, she's 1 saved when she was born
46:15
Have you seen that SNL skit?
46:17
So if you could pull up Romans three or Romans two verses 28 and 29.
46:21
So I want Carl to pay careful attention.
46:25
People were born Jewish, but that doesn't mean they were born in a salvific relationship
46:32
Understand the new covenant is better than the old covenant in every
46:39
For no one is a Jew who is merely one outwardly.
46:43
Oh wait, unless you were born a Jew, according to Gallagher and Carl, no, no, born a Jew outwardly meant you're
46:49
saved and you're in a covenant with covenant relationship with God.
46:53
And as Trey said, yeah, you are in a covenant of condemnation with God as a rebel of God
47:00
But he goes on to say, nor is circumcision outward and physical.
47:04
Well, I thought that was what the Jews were commanded to do.
47:07
Trey, did they have to obey to circum to be circumcised?
47:10
They had to obey that commandment.
47:12
Uh, so they weren't saved when they did that?
47:15
No, that's not what saved them.
47:18
Verse 29, but a Jew is one inwardly.
47:21
That doesn't happen at birth.
47:24
The true Israel, true Israel, true Jew is one inwardly and circumcision
47:30
is a matter of the things you do, Trey, that your obedience, no,
47:36
the heart by the spirit, not by the letter, not by the law, but look at your praise
47:42
You want to know if he's.
47:43
Going to double down, right?
47:48
That's not the context Aaron was talking about.
47:52
Carl, defend Gallagher, defend your boy a little bit.
47:54
What was he talking about?
47:55
What was he talking about?
47:56
Hey, Carl, we asked Aaron to come on here as well.
47:59
So, because I would love to ask him, what in the world are you talking about here in Gallagher?
48:05
And I would like to send Gallagher a message that's saying, Hey, what are you going to debate.
48:11
He's not going to debate Jeremiah.
48:13
I can't wait to talk about mine with him here in a minute when he brings up, but Carl, please tell us what the context was.
48:18
Let's just hear again what he says.
48:21
Let's just make sure John six 44 and 40 quickly, the Luke, Luke 18, the Pharisee and the tax collector.
48:28
Um, both of those men were saved.
48:31
So they were both already in a relationship with God.
48:34
It sounds like the context of this that he's referring to is Luke 18.
48:40
They were both saved because they both went to the temple because they were both Jews
48:47
and you're born in that relationship with God as a Jew.
48:51
He spent thousands of hours with you, Trey.
48:57
No, he didn't spend thousands of hours.
49:06
Um, I would assume he's a Jew.
49:08
So the old covenant, you were born into the relationship with God.
49:14
Um, okay, here we go, Carl.
49:20
John six, 44 and 45 talks about.
49:24
I listened to a debate recently on this and I know it don't mean that it don't.
49:29
Mean that no one can come to me unless the father who sent me draws him and I will raise him up on the last day.
49:36
It is written in the prophets and they will all be taught by God.
49:39
So we got to ask ourselves, who's the, they, there will all be taught by God.
49:43
Everyone who has heard and learned from the father comes to me.
49:46
So that's John six, 44 and 45.
49:50
So is, is he saying that every Jew, because they've heard from God and some, you know, just,
49:56
just they heard it in their ear.
49:59
Therefore they all came to Jesus.
50:02
I think we can read right above this in the section that these Jewish people didn't come to Jesus.
50:07
You know who he's he's talking about?
50:10
All the father gives me, all the father gives me will come to me.
50:15
And the here's this part that the church Christ really don't like is that he came to do the father's will and the father's will
50:21
is he lose none that the father gave him that he raises them up on the last day.
50:26
One of them don't mean that.
50:28
Well, so that's, if that's, that's his context.
50:32
And according to him, John six, 44 and 45 explains that you
50:39
Carl said, we don't believe that.
50:42
Help us understand Gallagher.
50:44
The different new covenant's different.
50:45
The old covenant, you were born into the covenant.
50:49
The new covenant you're born spiritually.
50:51
You're born again of water and spirit.
50:53
That's John three, three through five.
50:54
You enter into the new covenant.
51:00
So gallery is saying that, and we agree you're born into the old covenant.
51:06
That doesn't mean you're saved.
51:08
This is a covenant of works.
51:09
This is a covenant of condemnation.
51:11
Paul calls it the ministry of death.
51:13
Gallagher means they are born in the covenant in a saving relationship with God.
51:20
Salvation has always been by grace through faith in the full
51:27
finished work of the savior to come for old Testament saints.
51:30
And we live in light of that.
51:31
And you know what that means that the new covenant has always been the covenant of
51:37
The old Testament saints were saved by the new covenant.
51:42
They were putting their faith in the covenant that was promised that was to come that has a
51:48
Mediator in Jesus Christ.
51:51
No, just a little to show you this, but it's not as though the word of God has failed for not all who are descended from
52:00
So not everybody who is born descended from Israel belongs to
52:18
He has some more defending of.
52:26
There's a lot of parallels that you can really put together and it's beautiful when you don't fight against the text.
52:32
Um, so you were born into the old covenant, right?
52:35
The new covenant, you're born spiritually.
52:37
Old Testament was physical.
52:38
New Testament was spiritual.
52:40
So the idea about Luke 18, uh, it almost is really like ad hominem because it's like argument against the man.
52:45
Essentially what Jeremiah is saying is if you think you have to be baptized to be saved, you're just like the Pharisee who
52:51
trusts in yourself, which is not really accurate.
52:54
Um, when I was baptized, um, I remember sitting on the baptistry steps.
52:59
Uh, I would like to know which time Aaron, cause you got baptized a couple of
53:05
times, which when I asked him in his debate or my discussion, his debate,
53:12
he said he only did it once, but then somebody sent me a video is a video of him saying that he was
53:19
So at what time, which one were you sitting on the steps like doing that?
53:26
Saying, Lord, I'm not, I know that I could never do anything good enough.
53:32
We got something here from Carl.
53:37
I don't know what exactly what he's.
53:39
Well, he's just quoting the new covenant promise in Jeremiah.
53:44
God will write his law on their hearts and he will know them the least to the greatest.
53:49
And check this out, Trey, that's a new covenant.
53:51
All of their sin, all of their sin will be forgiven.
53:57
So there it is getting closer.
54:01
And by the way, that's not the argument.
54:03
I will put my law within them and I will write it on their hearts and I will be their God.
54:07
No longer shall each teach his neighbor, his brother saying no, the Lord for they shall all know me from the least to the greatest declares the Lord for
54:14
I will forgive their iniquity and I will remember their sin.
54:20
That's let me explain something.
54:23
That is the only covenant that has saved.
54:26
That is the, the promise of the new covenant give being brought into a greater light.
54:32
That is a further explanation of Genesis 3 15.
54:37
That is the promise that saved old Testament saints.
54:40
The promise of the new covenant.
54:43
This is why Gallagher and Carl, please hear me.
54:45
This is why Gallagher is wrong.
54:48
Yes, you were born as a Jew under the old covenant and you were not in a saving
54:54
You were not born already justified before God.
54:58
No, you entered in to the promise of the new covenant by faith.
55:02
That's what Romans four is all about.
55:04
That's what the whole book of Galatians is all about.
55:08
Aaron explained physical and spiritual.
55:13
He's, he was very clear on what he said.
55:16
Now we can go back and show you again if you want,.
55:20
Is there anything left to receive the forgiveness of sins?
55:22
You know, Luke 17 10, that one that when we do all that, which we have been given to do, we're still unworthy
55:29
I'll pause that because Haisal brought this out.
55:33
And I just want to let everyone know, why is it that we are unprofitable servants?
55:37
Because of what we did in our works of obedience?
55:40
No, it's because the Jesha live by faith, right?
55:43
We're living our life to the glory of God.
55:46
We did not earn our justification.
55:49
We were justified by amazing grace.
55:51
And I want to let everybody know God's grace isn't just necessary.
55:55
That's Roman Catholicism.
55:57
Well, grace is necessary, right?
55:59
You need the grace of what Jesus on the cross.
56:01
You know what the apostle Paul said in second Corinthians 12?
56:04
No, God's grace is sufficient, right?
56:07
God's grace is not just sufficient in our sanctification, but it's sufficient.
56:11
God's grace alone is what ultimately is going to justify us because that grace tray
56:17
effectually gives us a heart of faith.
56:20
Don't take my word for it.
56:21
That's what Ephesians 2, 8, and 9, and then 10, right?
56:26
Unto good works, once again, in our sanctification.
56:35
You boys are playing like 90 seconds.
56:37
You know, if we would have played 18 minutes, oh, you didn't play the whole thing.
56:40
You took them out of context.
56:43
You didn't listen to the last.
56:45
Did you say Mike Haisal's on here?
56:49
My Facebook said that Haisal's watching, so I just let people know.
56:52
Just get Haisal to answer, because I guarantee you, Haisal would not say that the Pharisee was saved.
56:59
Haisal, please, please tell us.
57:05
And Carl was saying, just because Aaron, but what I said earlier, he knows that people are going to back him no matter what,
57:11
because it's defending the system.
57:13
You know what I'm saying?
57:15
It's defending the system.
57:16
That's all they care about.
57:17
You know, and he knows that there's going to be Carl's out there that would just agree.
57:29
Let's keep going with this.
57:33
Doing what we ought to do.
57:34
So it's really ad hominem.
57:36
Nobody that I know was baptized thinking I'm just, I'm going to be baptized.
57:40
I'm going to knock on the gates of heaven.
57:41
All right, Peter, let me in.
57:45
So I don't agree with that.
57:49
Of course they don't agree with that.
57:57
Nobody, nobody's going to actually say those words.
58:00
Everybody's going to honor them with his, with their lips.
58:03
And so nobody's going to say, yeah, you owe me salvation.
58:05
You can't say that you have to speak the Christian language.
58:07
You've got to say, oh no.
58:10
Well, of course God saved me, but when did he save me?
58:14
When I did X, Y, or Z had nothing to do with faith whatsoever.
58:20
Actually, I'm not going to teach you, Jeremiah.
58:23
You need to learn how to read the Bible.
58:26
So let's go through everything you said about Luke 18.
58:30
Everything you said about Acts 2, the argument is just being a picture.
58:41
This is one of the best ways you can tell if the doctrine is false.
58:44
So you basically, the more you study the Bible, you will basically see, oh, well, okay.
58:50
If it means what you say, it means in this verse, then you have a big problem over here because that won't work.
58:55
So the easiest thing that I would say is the biggest, the easiest way to show is many easy ways, but let me show you the easiest
59:02
If you look into, if you look into, if you look into, if you look into, if you show that Jeremiah's argument is wrong.
59:10
Jeremiah is saying is that you're saved before you're baptized.
59:14
I mean, that's essentially it, right?
59:16
So you're saved whenever you have faith.
59:19
Um, he's even saying, uh, you know, as soon as you believe in God, regeneration precedes faith, which is what
59:25
he hasn't said that in this debate, but I know that's what he believes.
59:28
Um, as soon as you believe that means you can only believe because God already regenerated you.
59:33
Well, let's say acts chapter two, you could explain that verse away.
59:37
You can't explain X 2216.
59:42
Cannot wait to do it again.
59:45
Let's just see if he says anything else.
59:47
And Jeremiah, uh, together.
59:49
On the same show, the cultist show, they tried to basically say the same thing.
59:54
I debated Trey, uh, on this, on multiple things, total depravity once saved, always
1:00:00
And we had four debates on baptism, salvation, faith alone, et cetera.
1:00:06
Tell everybody real quick, before we get any further in this, when Aaron called me, he called me up one day, he said, Hey, would you like to
1:00:13
do some debates or know some, have some conversations?
1:00:15
He said, would you like to have some conversations on some topics?
1:00:18
And I said, yeah, I'd love to have conversations on these things.
1:00:21
He said, yeah, I want, I said, what do you want to talk about?
1:00:23
He said, well, baptism, faith alone.
1:00:25
And then the five points of Calvinism, I said, yeah, I'll do that when you want to do it.
1:00:29
And he's like, well, would you like to know the things that I might say or bring up?
1:00:33
I said, no, I pretty much know him.
1:00:36
Well, I said, when do you want to do it?
1:00:38
He said, how about tomorrow?
1:00:40
And I said, but look, here's the deal.
1:00:41
I'm going to record it and I'll send you the footage after I record it.
1:00:45
Cause I don't, I don't believe that you're a Christian.
1:00:48
And so I don't know if I can trust you with that because a lot of people cut and slice my stuff up and they'll play 10 seconds TT
1:00:56
And so, and so I said, I'll send you the whole thing.
1:01:00
And our first one was a conversation.
1:01:02
And then after that it became, Hey, let's do, you know, debate style, five minutes and two minutes and opening statements, closing.
1:01:07
I was like, yeah, whatever.
1:01:09
Like total prepared zero for any of it.
1:01:12
I would just sit down many times.
1:01:14
I was out doing stuff and I'd have to run to the office and turn it on.
1:01:20
And I mean, he's like reading all this stuff.
1:01:21
I'm just like winging it, you know?
1:01:25
But the only thing is, so he calls a debate.
1:01:27
I call it, I was just having a conversation, could care less.
1:01:31
Secondly, though, he never finished it though, you know, and I even called him out on the second one.
1:01:34
I think the second conversation slash debate we had, I said, are you going to go the distance?
1:01:39
Are you really going to do total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, perseverance and saying, oh yeah,
1:01:49
I think I do know why, but he didn't want to go the distance.
1:01:53
It was more of a conversation from my end, but you can see him reading the whole time when he's doing it, you know, but I want
1:01:59
him to, cause see Jeremiah has a lot of time where he can prepare for like formal debates.
1:02:07
I'm more of a, hey, let's sit on the couch and study, but he's like a formal debater.
1:02:12
But, and I even told Aaron, I said, look, you want to debate Jeremiah?
1:02:17
And I said, no, he'll come to your, he'll come to your church.
1:02:19
I'm saying like, he'll come, like his game travels.
1:02:21
He's like a professional, he's like a professional golfer.
1:02:23
You know, he doesn't have to play his home course.
1:02:26
And he's like, I don't know.
1:02:28
Like he don't want none of the dog,.
1:02:30
Which hopefully we can schedule it.
1:02:32
We'll schedule it out whenever he wants.
1:02:35
I promise you, we'll get this thing on cultish.
1:02:38
We'll go to Arizona, whatever we got to do, or we'll go to the GBN, whatever network
1:02:45
And then you can prepare and get ready and do all that study and stuff that you do with it of how to ask.
1:02:52
He doesn't understand that.
1:02:53
I will lock myself in a dungeon and figure out how he thinks.
1:02:59
I'm like running here, running there.
1:03:10
Watch this for yourself and determine how you think, which position you agree with.
1:03:15
2216. I will say one of a close friend of his left the church of
1:03:21
Christ from those debates, which was awesome.
1:03:24
And we've had a lot of good stuff from all of our stuff, seven, eight.
1:03:30
I wanted to, you know, we mentioned old TT.
1:03:34
So Travis Thomas, I don't mind to us, you know, for us to drop his name to me, Travis is harmless and
1:03:40
he's pretty entertaining.
1:03:43
He is going to be interviewing.
1:03:45
Do you know who all TT is interviewing this coming Sunday night?
1:03:52
I wonder how old TT figured out that he left the
1:03:59
I wonder where he saw that.
1:04:01
Look what I get at Carl Henry's house.
1:04:06
Trey, you do tell the best stories, man.
1:04:08
I take that as a compliment.
1:04:11
From Carl, I take that as a thank you, Carl.
1:04:14
I live in your head rent free.
1:04:19
So, yeah, he's interviewing Derek Healy.
1:04:23
And I got a chance to talk with Derek, been praying for him and just saying, get ready to get on the
1:04:29
highlight reel afterwards.
1:04:30
And he's done it to the rest of us, wear it as a badge of honor, told him what questions, no doubt that
1:04:36
Travis will talk to him about.
1:04:38
So y 'all keep Derek in prayer, just that he would be kind, loving, even through some
1:04:44
of the nonsense that tends to happen on that platform.
1:04:48
But yeah, that's coming up this Sunday.
1:04:54
Does TT stand for Turtle Turtle?
1:04:59
We're gonna be doing a Turtle Book Club review later.
1:05:03
So let's go back to what he was saying here before Carl got me all at his dinner table
1:05:09
telling story times with Trey.
1:05:10
I don't know if you can read this next one, but he made me laugh.
1:05:18
We got a little, we got a lot.
1:05:21
Why did you stop drinking?
1:05:26
You had me laughing on that one.
1:05:30
So where, how do you read the Bible?
1:05:36
We don't have an explanation.
1:05:37
I think it's great because Paul is the one who writes most of these New Testament epistles.
1:05:40
1st and 2nd Corinthians, Galatians, Ephesians, Philippians, Colossians, 1st and 2nd Thessalonians, 1st and 2nd Timothy, Titus, and
1:05:49
I don't think he might have.
1:05:51
I don't have any proof of that.
1:05:52
All those epistles Paul wrote, Paul did not teach them to become a Christian in a different way than he did.
1:05:58
Unless you're, you know, a dispensational person, believes that there's a different gospel or different faith
1:06:05
than the Gentiles, which is wrong.
1:06:07
So anyway, I say that to say Paul, the way he taught people to become Christians is the same way he became a Christian.
1:06:13
And Paul in Acts 9 meets Jesus, asks Jesus, what must I do?
1:06:17
Jesus, ironically, didn't say nothing.
1:06:19
I paid it all on the cross.
1:06:21
He said, what he said, go to the city and be told what you must do, what you have to do.
1:06:26
Jeremiah says, nothing you have to do.
1:06:28
Jesus said something you must do.
1:06:35
He's fasting, not eating or drinking.
1:06:36
And he's praying for three days, right?
1:06:39
Finally, when Ananias comes to him, Ananias miraculously heals him to show that he's inspired.
1:06:44
And Ananias tells him in Acts 22, 16, why are you waiting?
1:06:46
Arise and be baptized and wash away your sins, calling on the name of the Lord.
1:06:53
Now, if Jeremiah is, if the shoe fits, right?
1:06:57
If the glass slipper fits and Jeremiah's doctrine is true, then you have a big problem in Acts 22,
1:07:03
because Paul has already believed he's already been repentant.
1:07:06
He's had a change of life.
1:07:07
He's been fasting and praying for three days.
1:07:09
And yet an inspired man, Ananias, and not only Ananias is inspired, in Acts 22,
1:07:15
Paul is retelling his own story.
1:07:17
So Paul, who's now inspired, he's been working.
1:07:19
So that's enough of that.
1:07:21
And we're going to break it down for you, but we're going to come back to True North's questions.
1:07:25
She says, I'm no longer in the church of Christ.
1:07:28
And she's wanting to know about, you know, because she's probably fearful of her sins, right?
1:07:31
All of her sins being forgiven.
1:07:33
And it's a fearful thing in the church of Christ.
1:07:35
That's why they don't know if I'm saving.
1:07:37
I get re -baptized and don't know enough to understand enough.
1:07:41
And it's a miserable thing.
1:07:42
So True North, we want to take care of that question for you.
1:07:45
But I want to answer Acts 22 real quick for Aaron again.
1:07:50
And when we did this in our talks, I had quite a bit of people reach out
1:07:57
of, they said, this is the one that really made them start questioning everything.
1:08:04
And so let's do it again, because the first time Aaron ever reached out to me, I was at a
1:08:11
And he said, this is the one verse he can't get around.
1:08:14
This one, rise and be baptized and wash away your sins, calling on his name.
1:08:18
Well, you know, he's going to say that calling on his name means, right,
1:08:24
that's talking about baptism.
1:08:28
That means get baptized, right?
1:08:30
So, but we know in Genesis 4, 26, right here, Seth, also a son was born and he called his name Enosh.
1:08:36
And at that time, people began to call upon the name of the Lord.
1:08:39
Does that mean they got baptized back then, all the way back in Genesis chapter 4, verse 26?
1:08:44
So just to break this down really quick, like you mentioned, it's in Acts 9, 22, 26,
1:08:50
Galatians 1, the conversions of Paul.
1:08:55
So here, I just want to go back to 9.
1:08:56
All right, let's go back to Acts 9.
1:08:59
I want everybody to see this and really pay attention, especially Carl, okay?
1:09:04
Saul, Saul, why are you persecuting me?
1:09:07
He said, who are you, Lord?
1:09:09
And he said, I'm Jesus of whom you're persecuting.
1:09:12
Rise and enter the city and you will be told what you were to do.
1:09:15
The men who were traveling, Mr. Speechless hearing the voice, but the Encino one, Saul rose from the ground, although his
1:09:21
eyes were open, he saw nothing.
1:09:22
So they led him by the hand and brought him to Damascus.
1:09:25
For three days he was without sight, neither ate nor drank.
1:09:28
Now there was a disciple of Damascus named Ananias.
1:09:31
And the Lord said to him in a vision, Ananias.
1:09:33
And he said, here I am, Lord.
1:09:35
The Lord said to him, rise and go to a street called Straight at the house of Judas.
1:09:39
Look for a man of Tarsus named Saul, for behold, he is praying.
1:09:42
And he has seen a vision of a man named Ananias come in and lay his hands on him, that he might regain his sight.
1:09:48
So here's a little note thing I have here.
1:09:50
So this is what I asked everybody here.
1:09:54
Is it fair to say that Jesus has already appeared to Paul?
1:10:00
And so Saul's his Hebrew name, Paul's his Greek name.
1:10:03
It's not that his name changed when he was converted.
1:10:05
It's Hebrew name and a Greek name.
1:10:08
But regardless, is it fair to say that Paul has already received this vision from Christ?
1:10:14
He's already manifested himself to him, right?
1:10:18
Is it fair to say by looking right here, where Jesus calls out to Ananias and says, rise and
1:10:24
go to the street called Straight.
1:10:26
He says, there's a man named Saul there.
1:10:30
And he's seen in a vision, you, Ananias, coming in and laying his hands on him, so he can regain his sight.
1:10:35
Is it fair to say that Saul or Paul, whatever you want to call him, is praying to Jesus Christ, who is God.
1:10:42
And Jesus Christ, who is God, is hearing his prayers and answering his prayers, letting him know that I'm going
1:10:48
to send someone to heal you.
1:10:50
Is it fair to say that's true?
1:10:53
And anybody who's reading the text would have to say yes.
1:10:55
But the question is this right here.
1:10:58
John 9 31 says, we know that God does not listen to sinners, but if anyone is a
1:11:04
worshiper of God and does his will, God listens to him.
1:11:07
Now, this doesn't mean that God doesn't hear people all over the world.
1:11:12
He's saying in this intimate way, does he, does he hear him like you hear your children over all the other chatter in the world?
1:11:19
This is what he's talking about.
1:11:20
So how does this guy say that?
1:11:23
That God doesn't listen to sinners, but if anyone's a worshiper of God and does his will, God does listen to him.
1:11:29
How does these Jewish people know that?
1:11:31
Well, I would say from the Old Testament, right?
1:11:34
So in Proverbs 15 8, it says this right here.
1:11:38
Let me just make this a little bit bigger for you, so you can see it.
1:11:42
The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord, but the prayer of the upright is
1:11:48
So he hears the prayer of the upright.
1:11:51
So is Paul upright in the eyes of God at this point, or is he not?
1:11:54
Is he still in his sins and still unregenerate away from him?
1:12:02
And John, these people said that we know that God doesn't listen but to worshipers of God.
1:12:07
He listens to them, those who love God, right?
1:12:10
The Lord is far from the wicked, but he hears the prayers of the righteous.
1:12:16
So does this contradict what is happening with Paul?
1:12:21
Is Paul seen as righteous or is he seen as wicked at this moment as he's praying to Jesus?
1:12:26
Jesus is hearing his prayers and answering his prayers.
1:12:30
And it says here, the Lord's far from the wicked, but he hears the prayers of the righteous.
1:12:34
I think you would have to say that he is viewed as righteous.
1:12:37
So here in Psalm 66, it says this right here in verses 18 and 19.
1:12:41
If I had a cherished iniquity in my heart, the Lord would not have listened.
1:12:47
But truly God has listened.
1:12:48
He has attended to the voice of my prayer.
1:12:50
So we see that Paul does not cherish iniquity in his heart.
1:12:55
God is hearing his prayers and answering his prayers.
1:12:58
Isaiah 59 .2 says, your iniquities have hidden, have made a separation between
1:13:04
you and your God, and your sins have hidden his face from you so that he does not hear you.
1:13:12
Is God hearing the prayers of Paul?
1:13:16
Therefore his sins have not created a space from him.
1:13:22
He is viewed as righteous with God.
1:13:25
He has faith in Jesus Christ.
1:13:29
And so now his sins have not hidden his face from him.
1:13:31
And now he hears his prayers.
1:13:38
Or you just reject it because you don't like it.
1:13:40
But then you can just break down the whole verse of 22 .16.
1:13:43
But I'll let you have some time here, Jeremiah.
1:13:46
Before we go back to Acts 22 .16, go to Hebrews 13 verse 15.
1:13:51
Because your best friend Carl says, calling on his name is not a mental thought or prayer.
1:13:58
Now, I don't know if he's calling mental thought prayer.
1:14:01
I would say prayer is not just having thoughts floating around your head.
1:14:05
Prayer is indicative of a heart of faith that is giving
1:14:11
praise to God, acknowledge him, extolling his name.
1:14:17
Jesus talks about hallowed be your name, giving God honor and glory.
1:14:22
And so when we talk about the word confessing or calling on his name, you rightly pointed out this is not new to the
1:14:30
The prophet Joel even talks about whoever calls upon the name of the Lord shall be saved.
1:14:34
And that is a further clarification of what Genesis chapter 4 was talking about.
1:14:39
And so I just want to tell people, Hebrews 13 .15, this is a really good verse that puts this
1:14:45
word confessing or acknowledging.
1:14:48
This is something so much deeper than just having certain thoughts floating around in your head or things like that
1:14:54
or doing external sacrifices.
1:14:55
No, this is talking about the heart, and then it's going to manifest with what you say and how you live your
1:15:02
So that verse right there in 15 says, through him, our perfect high priest, King Jesus, then let us
1:15:08
continually offer up a sacrifice, not of a lamb, not of a scapegoat, but of
1:15:15
That is the fruit of lips that acknowledge his name.
1:15:21
So this has to be coming from a changed heart.
1:15:24
That's the whole argument of Paul in Romans chapter 10, 9 through 13, I believe, for with the
1:15:30
heart, one that believes is justified.
1:15:33
Now, if a person were to see that happening to a person or if a person was recalling that experience,
1:15:39
well, they're going to call upon the name of the Lord.
1:15:41
They're going to cry out in prayer.
1:15:43
Prayer is not merely saying the right words.
1:15:47
Prayer is indicative of a heart of faith.
1:15:51
You can be a mute person, Trey.
1:15:53
And you can still pray to God.
1:15:55
When we read, confess with the mouth that Jesus is Lord, this isn't saying, well, if you're not able to
1:16:01
speak properly, then it don't mean that.
1:16:05
It's because confessing Jesus is Lord is a heart of faith.
1:16:09
So yeah, maybe now with that going to Acts 22, 16 is a good place.
1:16:18
So just this sentence right here, you know, it has to be spiritual.
1:16:25
Plus right here, this is in the middle voice, meaning that the grammatical voice that signifies the subject of the verb
1:16:31
is being affected by its own action or is acting upon itself.
1:16:35
So is Paul, rise and be baptized and wash your sins away, calling on his name.
1:16:41
He's causing the sins to wash away.
1:16:42
He's calling the baptism.
1:16:45
Like you would have to say no.
1:16:46
Aaron would say no to that, but he'd have to argue with the, just the way the structure of the sentence is written.
1:16:51
And, but still again, middle voice here, wash away sins.
1:16:56
It is something away, washing away something from oneself, wash oneself, used an imagery of purification.
1:17:02
It's again, it's a visual.
1:17:06
It gives, it's a, it's a picture of the true spiritual reality that's happening.
1:17:11
So you can see visually what is truly taking place spiritually.
1:17:16
Troy, you're just begging the question, man.
1:17:18
That's what Gallagher would tell you.
1:17:20
And this right here is so important to why you must define what
1:17:27
Now, if we can agree that it's a ceremony, if we can agree that it's a purification, right.
1:17:33
And you know, it's, I've even thought about this tray.
1:17:35
If someone said, well, I don't see anywhere in the baptism that uses the word ceremony.
1:17:39
If we were to go to John three, we don't have to.
1:17:42
But later it talks about the baptism of John, which caused many people to dispute and talk about
1:17:47
purification laws or purification rights.
1:17:50
And all of that means is there is a rich old Testament history of what it means to be fully
1:17:56
bathed as rights that are given to have spiritual cleansing.
1:18:03
So this is why we have to define our terms.
1:18:05
This is why in the context of a reformed Baptist and a church of Christ, you can't beg the
1:18:11
You have to make a case what you, and this is to Mike's credit in my debate.
1:18:17
I mean, he spent 25 minutes on Baptizo and then the word ice for the forgiveness of sins.
1:18:23
I think if he, I think more church Christ would have been thankful for him doing that.
1:18:28
If he would have spent about five minutes, not 25 minutes, you know what I mean?
1:18:33
Because his whole case is this literally means your past sins are washed away.
1:18:40
My whole opening was when you rightly understand them, Baptizo, when you have the Jewish background
1:18:46
of that, the signifies spiritual realities.
1:18:49
Well, then this is a representation, not the reality.
1:18:53
And I think this is the core of why the church of Christ teaching, um, or a cult, we don't say that mean, but it perverts the
1:18:59
gospel of grace is because they've replaced the representation with the reality itself.
1:19:04
When you think in the watery graves of baptism, then your past sins are being washed away.
1:19:10
You have to own the fact that you are participating.
1:19:13
You are the one being obedient.
1:19:15
You are the one in your works, obtaining justification before God.
1:19:20
And that distorts the only gospel that is ever saved, which is to be received by faith apart from
1:19:26
anything you accomplished.
1:19:27
And you know what the best accomplishment a person could do, Trey, it would be the works of law.
1:19:31
And that ain't going to get you there.
1:19:32
And that's the thing too, when they say, well, it's not the works of law.
1:19:35
I'm like, well, you can't name a law greater than the works of the law of God.
1:19:39
That is the greatest works you could possibly do is the works of the law.
1:19:42
And if you're saying that some other work, it's lesser than the works of the law.
1:19:45
So it can't, if it is, if it's not the works of the law, which is the greatest of all works you could do, why
1:19:51
would you say, oh, no, and it's not that it's, it's, it's a lesser work you got to do.
1:19:56
So is there anything else you want to say on Acts.
1:20:02
Cause, uh, Gavin James asked a good question on Facebook, but I do want us to kind of just briefly touch on Acts 22,
1:20:08
So when we understand that baptism is a ceremony, you have to agree you're participating.
1:20:14
You, no one can now say you're only merely passive.
1:20:18
If you're participating and you agree that it's an act of faith, there is a moment within the ceremony that
1:20:24
you're passive, but it's an act of faith.
1:20:28
You are demonstrating repentance and people cannot deny that fact.
1:20:32
So even Lutherans that are listening, I want to say, listen, baptism is not faith.
1:20:37
It's an expression of faith.
1:20:39
It's a work of faith and you have to be consistent with these terms.
1:20:43
So that's going to help us in Acts 22, 16, Ananias is speaking to Paul.
1:20:49
Saul of Tarsus, rise and be baptized and wash, right?
1:20:53
These important terms that signify spiritual realities, wash your, wash away your sins,
1:21:00
Well, I just tell people, how would the apostle Paul understood what, what he said here?
1:21:04
Well, he tells us in Romans 10, right?
1:21:06
This means, um, but the heart one believes and is justified.
1:21:10
And I just like to sprinkle in here.
1:21:12
He already called upon the name of Jesus earlier in the context.
1:21:17
He says he understands he he's looking at the risen Lord.
1:21:20
He even says that this is Jesus of Nazareth, Paul, whom you're crucifying, persecuting.
1:21:26
And then he says, what shall I do?
1:21:31
And so this is the moment of faith where he calls upon the name of the Lord from a heart that trusts that this is, uh, Yahweh in
1:21:37
the Shekinah glory and identifies as the resurrected Jesus.
1:21:40
This is the moment that I believe in.
1:21:42
Galatians one says, look, I received the gospel, the good news, that the power of God unto salvation
1:21:49
from Jesus himself, uh, from God, right?
1:21:52
He met me when I wasn't seeking God.
1:21:54
I was actually going my own way, persecuting the church.
1:21:57
That's a picture of all Christians.
1:22:00
At one point we were not seeking after God, but he sought us.
1:22:04
And so then it is true that Ananias later after Paul
1:22:10
in faith confessed that Jesus is Lord and was justified.
1:22:14
It is true that Ananias preached the gospel here, but it wasn't the first time
1:22:20
that Paul had heard the gospel, right?
1:22:22
Tell me, tell me if your baptisms look like this.
1:22:25
When I baptize somebody at 12, five, guess what I'm talking about?
1:22:29
The picture of what he's done, who he is, what he's done in this person's life.
1:22:33
Because if, if everybody was silent and you just got in the water and it was just dead quiet and
1:22:39
no, and people were confused what was going on, I would argue that's not a proper baptism.
1:22:44
You need to contextualize this ceremony.
1:22:45
You should see the early church and what they did.
1:22:48
Talk about the early church in a minute.
1:22:50
Aaron wants to get in the early church.
1:22:51
We're going to get in the early church.
1:22:53
I promise you it don't work out.
1:22:55
But so to answer, um, Gavin's question real quick, right?
1:23:01
So the question I have left over for the debate, and I want to get back to true north cause that's a, that's a one I really want to answer is true north question.
1:23:08
But Gavin says, question I have left over from the debate is baptism of the Holy.
1:23:14
So let's go to true north.
1:23:18
Um, I just want to add, um, baptism of the Holy Spirit is not a ceremony made with human
1:23:25
God says, I will take out that heart of flesh.
1:23:28
I'll give you a heart, a new living heart of flesh, and I will cleanse you with my spirit.
1:23:34
It's not talking about your participation.
1:23:36
God says that I will do these things.
1:23:39
This is what Paul talking about is the powerful working of God.
1:23:43
And, uh, what Jesus said to John the Baptist is you must be born from above.
1:23:48
It has to be a work of God.
1:23:51
Um, so let's go, I'm going to go back up here and try to find these comments from true north because this is
1:23:58
so here, let's put these up right here.
1:24:03
This is the stuff I like.
1:24:07
I don't even know where true north is.
1:24:13
So she says, train your mom track, um, tracking with him, but I still don't completely understand since the
1:24:19
scripture talks about being forgiven for past sins.
1:24:22
The new Testament talks about past sins.
1:24:25
I get that Jesus ultimately forgives all my sins, but why does the new Testament talk about forgiveness from past sins?
1:24:37
So I'm curious, maybe true north, you can bring some clarity.
1:24:40
We are not the one saying that only your past sins are forgiven.
1:24:45
No, I think, I think for, I'm just going to take a stab at this.
1:24:50
Uh, she's came out of the church of Christ.
1:24:52
So the church of Christ teaches heavily that only your past sins are forgiven, right?
1:24:58
Which they have a huge problem with.
1:25:01
Now they'll jump to first John, you know, and say, well, if we confess our sins by, you know, like Aaron does all the time.
1:25:06
But the problem with that is in Hebrews, it says without the blood, without blood, there is no forgiveness of sins.
1:25:10
And so if you're saying that you contact the blood of Jesus in baptism, that's where you contact that
1:25:17
You can say, I'm sorry, all you want from here on out.
1:25:21
But if there's no blood to wash away those sins, you, you commit after you got baptized, you're going to have to go back into the water
1:25:27
and contact the blood of again, because without blood, there is no forgiveness of sins.
1:25:33
So that's a big theological problem they have.
1:25:36
But this is, I would say, this is what she's struggling with because in the church of Christ, they teach that your past sins are forgiven.
1:25:43
And from here on moving forward, pull up yourself by your bootstraps and work yourself hard and prove yourself, right?
1:25:49
True North, am I right on that?
1:25:52
Before we start answering.
1:25:54
Yeah, because our position is when you receive forgiveness of sins, and we don't have to go here, but Romans 4
1:26:00
talks about that your sins are when they're no longer imputed on your
1:26:06
behalf, they can never be imputed on your behalf.
1:26:10
Because when you put your faith in Jesus, this is the instrument of our justification.
1:26:15
All your sins, past, present, and future goes back to the cross of Calvary, and it gets better, Trey.
1:26:21
I know you preach this at your church, but we get the perfect righteousness
1:26:27
of Christ imputed on our account, and if that's a perfect righteousness and it's imputed on our
1:26:33
account, then we can't lose our justification because of a perfect Savior, a perfect
1:26:39
mediator, and a perfect intercessor in the new covenant.
1:26:44
Like 1 John says, if you say you don't, then you're a liar.
1:26:47
Yes, but a believer has relationship now, and we confess and we
1:26:53
repent relationally, because we know positionally we're already declared right before God.
1:26:59
Yeah, so this right here, blessed is the man.
1:27:02
So right here, look, to the one who does not work, wow, but
1:27:08
believes in him, God, who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness,
1:27:14
the one who does not work.
1:27:16
You know, Aaron says we bring out really hard verses that are hard to understand.
1:27:19
That's what Reformed theology does.
1:27:21
I know that's pretty difficult to understand, the one who does not work, but believes in him, who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as
1:27:28
Just as David also speaks of the blessing to the one whom God counts righteousness apart from works, anything you do,
1:27:34
blessed are those whose lawless needs are forgiven, whose sins are covered, blessed is the man against whom the Lord will not count sin.
1:27:43
What sin is he not going to count?
1:27:45
Well, he's not going to count all the sins in which he died for.
1:27:48
He died for all of our sins.
1:27:51
And here is 2 Corinthians 5, right?
1:27:58
It says that for our sake, he made him to be sin who knew no sin, so that in him we might become the
1:28:05
So that's that great exchange that Jeremiah is talking about, True North.
1:28:10
We exchanged our sinfulness on him, and he in place, he imparted his righteousness to us, all of it,
1:28:17
not some of it, all of it, because we imparted all of our nasty sinfulness on him, and he
1:28:23
died in our place, and we actually died with him there in the eyes of God.
1:28:26
We'll talk about that here in a minute.
1:28:28
That's what Colossians 2 would be talking about.
1:28:29
But here, yeah, I know, True North says that she believes in faith
1:28:37
But Gavin, look at this here.
1:28:42
He got us to admit that the baptism of the Holy Spirit is not a ceremony.
1:28:46
I'm like, you heard it here first, ladies and gentlemen.
1:28:49
Baptism doesn't always mean ceremony.
1:28:52
I don't know if this is groundbreaking for Gavin, like if he didn't know this, or if he's just trying to show people.
1:28:58
He didn't have to try to trick us out.
1:29:00
Was he trying to trick us with the question, is Holy Spirit baptism a ceremony?
1:29:05
I'm like, well, I could have told you that baptism, you just said, look, do you think that baptism always.
1:29:13
Now, I will say baptism into water is always a ceremony.
1:29:17
That's always been our case.
1:29:18
So I don't know if this was groundbreaking for Gavin.
1:29:19
But just the word baptism is not always a ceremony.
1:29:22
I would always say, well, I've preached on this.
1:29:25
I've explained this on my podcast, YouTube channel, Trey, that baptizo just
1:29:32
You can be immersed into water, ceremonial, right?
1:29:36
You can be immersed into suffering.
1:29:38
Jesus talks about a baptism under suffering.
1:29:40
Or you can be immersed into one's authority, like in 1 Corinthians chapter 10.
1:29:45
I've always said, baptizo, it has to be understood in context.
1:29:49
But if that context involves water, where you're being immersed, that definitionally
1:29:55
is a ceremony, a purification, right?
1:30:00
Everett Young in the building.
1:30:08
Dalton Chalice is in the YouTube channel.
1:30:11
Look, Carl Henry picked up on that, too, now, what Gavin said.
1:30:18
They had a high -five moment.
1:30:24
So, I'm rambling and digressing.
1:30:26
But essentially, what Calvinism and Reformed Theology does is they go to the difficult passages that a
1:30:32
lot of people haven't studied, like Romans 9.
1:30:41
We go to these difficult passages, like, I don't know, John 3, 16, whoever believes.
1:30:48
I mean, like, that's a tough one.
1:30:51
I just want to play it again.
1:30:53
Is they go to the difficult passages that a lot of people haven't studied, like Romans 9, John 6, 37,
1:31:02
They go to these passages, Ezekiel 36, passages a lot of people haven't studied before.
1:31:07
Now, how do you know that, Aaron?
1:31:10
Jeremiah, how does he know that a lot of people hadn't studied this?
1:31:13
I found that a little insulting for people.
1:31:15
Does he tell them that they, look, y 'all, now, you might have read it, you don't understand it.
1:31:22
Trust me, it don't mean that, right?
1:31:26
When it says, the one who does not work, but believes in him, who justifies the ungodly, his faith is kind and righteous.
1:31:32
That's a very hard thing to understand, because what you don't understand is that word faith is a root of pisteuo,
1:31:38
which is believe, which also means you have to be baptized.
1:31:41
And see, that's not in there.
1:31:42
So, I have to explain it to you, that that actually means you have to be baptized.
1:31:46
Now, that seems confusing, but just reading it for what it says, it doesn't seem confusing to me.
1:31:50
But according to him, we use very hard passages to confuse him.
1:31:56
And they misteach them, they misapply them.
1:31:58
But if you've never studied it before, you're like, oh, wow, I don't, I don't, I didn't even know that text said that.
1:32:03
And so, then they take the hard passages to...
1:32:07
Like, don't work, but believe in Jesus Christ and put your trust and faith in him.
1:32:11
Like when Jesus says, whoever looks upon me and believes, be saved.
1:32:15
Like, that's a very tough passage.
1:32:16
We take those passages and we misapply them.
1:32:21
Therefore, we've been justified by faith and now at peace with God.
1:32:25
That's a really tough passage.
1:32:26
Okay, let's look at this.
1:32:27
You know, let's look at that.
1:32:31
Oh, Mack Slick had a good one on this one, right?
1:32:34
So, when it says, therefore, we have been justified, saved, right, by
1:32:42
Now, faith doesn't mean baptism, and nobody thinks that.
1:32:44
Like, when you tell your kids, have faith in me, you don't mean to go get baptized.
1:32:48
Are you telling your kids to go get baptized when you say, hey, look, son, just have faith in me?
1:32:54
What are you telling them?
1:32:55
Well, I'm telling my kid to get baptized in me.
1:32:57
That's what I'm telling them.
1:32:58
Like, no, it's not hard to understand.
1:33:00
I need to get my second cup of coffee.
1:33:03
We've been justified by faith.
1:33:06
Do I have peace with God?
1:33:07
When I have faith, or do I not have peace with God when I have faith?
1:33:11
That's a simple question.
1:33:14
Like, bottom shelf Christianity all over the world knows that it's a religion that says that you're saved by
1:33:20
faith in God, in Christ Jesus.
1:33:25
So, we're the ones making it complicated.
1:33:27
Like, when you start changing the definitions of words, things get a little complicated for people.
1:33:34
But let's just go back to this and how we make things hard.
1:33:39
To formulate their doctrine.
1:33:40
And they come to very easy passages.
1:33:42
And they basically say, nope, that's not what it means because Romans 9.
1:33:45
That's not what it means because Ezekiel 36, right?
1:33:48
Which is sort of the opposite of good Bible study.
1:33:50
Logical good Bible study is you take the very simple, easy, clear passages, and you say,
1:33:56
okay, what does this clear passage say?
1:33:58
Okay, that I know is true.
1:34:00
So, how do I reconcile a difficult passage?
1:34:07
And you basically interpret the difficult passages in light of the plethora of easy verses.
1:34:13
That's like the opposite of what Calvinism does.
1:34:17
Okay, so that's the opposite.
1:34:18
So, let me just put this up here and we'll wait on, we got Carl here again.
1:34:23
He's going to tell us what Romans 5 means.
1:34:25
Romans 5, justified by the same kind of faith Abraham had.
1:34:29
Romans is a point to the next point book, okay?
1:34:39
Therefore, when you see the word, therefore, Carl, you ask yourself, what's the word, therefore, therefore?
1:34:45
What is it right above this?
1:34:50
For the promise to Abraham and his offspring that he would be an heir of the world did not come through the law, but through righteousness of faith.
1:34:55
Look, you got to see Carl's statement here.
1:34:58
He's telling us what Romans 5 .1 means, okay?
1:35:03
For if the adherence of the law, who are to be the heirs, faith is null and promise is void.
1:35:07
For the law brings wrath, but where there's no law, there's no transgression.
1:35:10
That's why it depends on faith.
1:35:12
In order the promise may rest on grace, be guaranteed to all the offspring.
1:35:15
Not only is the adherent of the law, but also to the one who shares the faith of Abraham, who is the father of us all.
1:35:22
All right, stay with me here, Carl.
1:35:24
As it's written, I have made you the father of many nations in the presence of God in whom you believed, in whom he believed, who
1:35:30
gives life to the dead and calls into existence the things that do not exist.
1:35:33
In hope he believed against hope, and he should become the father of many nations, as he had been told.
1:35:38
So shall your offspring be.
1:35:40
He did not weaken in faith when he considered his own body, which is good as dead, since he was about 100 years old, or
1:35:46
when he considered the barrenness of Sarah's womb.
1:35:48
No unbelief made him waver.
1:35:50
Now listen, Carl, point by point, remember?
1:35:53
No unbelief made him waver concerning the promise of God, but he grew strong in his faith and he gave glory to God,
1:35:59
fully convinced that God was able to do what he'd promised.
1:36:01
That is why his faith was counted as righteousness.
1:36:06
But now, Carl says, no, no, no, Trey.
1:36:09
You got to take the whole...
1:36:11
I'll stay with you, Carl.
1:36:12
We can do it all night long.
1:36:15
My wife and kids are out of town, so we can do this all night long.
1:36:18
The whole chapter four, Trey.
1:36:24
So is Carl trying to redefine faith in the faithfulness?
1:36:28
The faith in Romans 5, one is the faith of Abraham, and Abraham's faith was doing, right?
1:36:37
If Abraham was justified by works, he has something to boast about, but not before God.
1:36:41
For what does the scripture say?
1:36:43
Abraham believed God, and that doesn't mean baptized or did anything.
1:36:47
Believed, trusted God, and it was counted to him as righteousness.
1:36:51
Now to the one who works, Carl, his wages are not counted as a gift, but as a due.
1:36:56
And to the one who does not work, but believes in him, who justifies the ungodly,
1:37:02
his faith is counted as righteousness.
1:37:05
Now to say that we take hard passages and make them difficult, like, and mix them up and everything,
1:37:14
You have to be brainwashed in this.
1:37:17
You really have to be brainwashed in this to see it.
1:37:20
Because if I just brought this to anybody, and you gave them your side, and I just read them what it said, they would say, what are you
1:37:27
You know, it just is what it is.
1:37:29
To the one who does not work, does nothing, but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his
1:37:35
faith is counted as righteousness.
1:37:40
Can I comment on that real quick?
1:37:42
Hopefully nobody saw that I was wearing shorts.
1:37:47
So, you know how you said the person that does nothing?
1:37:50
The Church of Christ, a lot of times hear that and say, oh, they just contradicted Acts 2 .37.
1:37:57
And the Calvinist says we don't do it.
1:37:58
And I want to tell people, you don't do anything by your works.
1:38:02
That doesn't mean you don't have a response of repentant faith, a love in Christ
1:38:10
And by us saying you don't do anything by your works, that doesn't mean that you are denying yourself
1:38:16
and your self -righteousness or whatever facade that you're wearing.
1:38:21
But Gallagher has either done this in the videos we've already looked at or the ones to come, but he's
1:38:26
mischaracterizing our position when we say, well, the Calvinist says you don't have to do anything.
1:38:32
We're saying by your works, by your works, that doesn't negate that you must respond in
1:38:39
We are arguing, but that's not of your works.
1:38:41
That is a gracious gift from above.
1:38:45
That is something that God works in you, grants to you.
1:38:50
Does that make sense, Trey?
1:38:51
What does believe in Him mean?
1:38:54
Okay, so this is a good question.
1:38:57
This is a good question if it's meant sincerely.
1:38:59
Obviously, he thinks it's a gotcha.
1:39:00
And he, I mean, I just don't think he understands.
1:39:02
But believing in Jesus means to put your faith in Christ apart
1:39:09
from your accomplishments.
1:39:11
It does not mean, now you gotta look at the context because there are people, I mean, even the demons believe in God.
1:39:17
And there's even an effect that produces from their knowing the right facts.
1:39:21
They tremble knowing that Jesus is the Holy One of God.
1:39:23
And that's still not enough to save you.
1:39:25
Because the demons cannot trust from a heart of faith.
1:39:29
They can acknowledge facts, but that is not enough to save a person.
1:39:34
What does it mean to savingly believe in Him?
1:39:38
To trust that Jesus is a perfect Savior, trusting in His finished work,
1:39:44
trusting that He is the Savior, and you cannot add any of your sin -tainted works
1:39:50
of obedience to what Jesus accomplished at Calvary.
1:39:54
That's the beauty of the new covenant is that Jesus saves to the uttermost by His work of
1:39:59
intercession, not a joint participation of, well, He did about 95%, and you still gotta
1:40:05
do five more percents, meaning a five -step formula, right?
1:40:10
Here's what BDAC would say regarding that verse.
1:40:12
It's with the person to whom one gives credence or whom one believes in, right,
1:40:18
which falls under the definition of to consider something to be true and therefore worthy of one's
1:40:25
Like you trust them and you believe in them.
1:40:29
I mean, like you might believe,.
1:40:32
You know, some character exists and puts presents under the tree.
1:40:37
So again, one body, which is the body, His body, which is His church, the church
1:40:45
I mean, man, if you just had some little bit of common sense, you think He drove by these denominations where it says grandma's church,
1:40:51
Baptist church, Methodist church, live church.
1:40:54
I mean, He drove an hour, 20 minutes here,.
1:40:57
And they act like they give God the glory.
1:40:59
And Jesus, I mean, grandma's church, Baptist church, Presbyterian church, church of Christ,
1:41:06
Again, they deny redemption.
1:41:09
Man, if you just had some little bit of common sense.