Errors in the Book The Shack by William P Young

There is a famine in the land and Christian discernment is dying. The book, The Shack, is a feel-good fictional story about a man named Mack whose daughter is murdered. Mack subsequently has an encounter with God in a shack in the woods, and through this meeting he is healed emotionally and spiritually.

Sound good? Of course it does. The only problem is the many false doctrines laced throughout the book. Instead of describing God as the majestic supreme being that he is, The Shack dumps him down and reshapes him into a feel-good figure.

God the Father, who, according to the Bible, cannot be seen, John 6 .46, 1 Timothy 6 .16, appears in the form of an African-American woman named Papa. That's on page 86, and talk about gender confusion.

Anyway, Papa has scars on his wrists, page 95. Wrong. The Father was not crucified. Jesus was crucified. Furthermore, Jesus is presented as a Middle Easterner wearing a plaid shirt with rolled up sleeves on page 84.

The Holy Spirit appears as an Asian woman on page 85. The Shack's author, Mr. Young, justifies these false representations under the rubric of literary license and says it's only fiction. Okay, but does that mean it is alright to refer to God in a way that is in direct contradiction to Scripture?

No, it does not. God has chosen to reveal himself without gender confusion in the man Jesus in 1 Timothy 2 .5. But the Shack doesn't stop with flamboyant reconstructions of God. Within his pages you'll find other false doctrines.

Denying the Trinity and Teaching Humanist Philosophy

On page 124 you'll see a denial of the hierarchy within the Trinity. Remember, the Father sent the Son, not the other way around. On page 136, Young presents the humanist philosophy that good and evil, quote, do not have any actual existence, close quote.

Contrast this with Luke 18 .18 and John 17 .15 which speak to the contrary. On pages 145 and 146, God wants to be submitted to Mac so he can, quote, join us in our circle of relationship, close quote.

Sorry, but man is to be submitted to God, not the other way around. Page 206 tells us that God has never placed an expectation on anyone. Not so. In 1 Peter 1 .16, God expects us to be holy. And on page 225, the heresy of universalism is taught when we find the African American woman who was God the Father say, quote, In Jesus I have forgiven all humans for their sins against me, but only some choose relationship, close quote.

Universalism, Forgiveness, and the Call to Follow Christ

This contradicts verses such as Matthew 25 .46 and Mark 3 .29 which clearly teach us that all are not forgiven. In John 10 .27, Jesus said, My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me.

Real biblical Christians are supposed to follow the voice of Christ as found in the Bible, not the ear-tickling melodies of teachers who use feel-good stories and emotionally laden half-truths to lessen God's majesty, present humanist philosophy, and teach universalism.

Is this shack a good book? No, it isn't. Be warned.