Aldo Leon Dissects Doug Wilson (Part 2)

No Compromise Radio

Subscribe

Download

Share

00

00:02

Welcome to No Compromise Radio, a ministry coming to you from Bethlehem Bible Church in West Boylston.

00:08

No Compromise Radio is a program dedicated to the ongoing proclamation of Jesus Christ, based on the theme in Galatians 2, verse 5, where the

00:16

Apostle Paul said, �But we did not yield in subjection to them for even an hour, so that the truth of the gospel would remain with you.�

00:24

In short, if you like smooth, watered -down words to make you simply feel good, this show isn�t for you.

00:30

By purpose, we are first biblical, but we can also be controversial. Stay tuned for the next 25 minutes as we�re called by the

00:37

Divine Trumpet to summon the troops for the honor and glory of her King. Here�s our host, Pastor Mike Avendroth.

00:44

Welcome to No Compromise Radio, a ministry. My name is Mike Avendroth, and today is part two of an extended interview

00:50

I had with Pastor Aldo Leon to talk about Doug Wilson�s federal vision and things of Moscow Canon Press.

00:59

So if you haven�t listened to today�s show, go ahead and listen to yesterday�s show, and I think that it�ll flow better.

01:05

We didn�t do two complete shows, but one show, and then now with a second introduction. Don�t forget

01:11

Gospel Assurance, the new book that I compiled, is out on Amazon. I think it�ll really encourage you.

01:16

Stay tuned for Aldo Leon. About this soteriological subject, because the plagiarism, it�s bad.

01:25

The cases there, the legal scandals, bad. The husband, how do you talk about women and the words he uses, bad.

01:33

And those could go on and on and on, but that to me isn�t the main issue. The main issue is, this is, you know, the standing or falling issue, and how hard would it be for him to say something like this?

01:45

Because this is what I believe. I personally, Mike Cabendroth, believe in the act of obedience of Christ, the covenant of works of grace, of covenant of redemption.

01:56

I believe in a law gospel paradigm. I believe in all these things as taught by the

02:02

Reformation and the Reformed Confessions. Calva, Besa, Olivianus, Senator DeWart, defined by those terms.

02:10

How hard would that be to say? But you�ll never hear him say that, because he�s going to be wishy -washy. Aldo, tell me about this.

02:15

You said something really good on your show. You think that the Wilson movement is kind of the opposite of woke.

02:21

What do you mean by that? Yeah. Go ahead. Yeah. So, if you listen to the woke folks and the anti -woke folks, which is the

02:39

Moscow folks, they both have a social view of the Trinity. The woke folks will say this differently, but in Moscow, the eternal functional subordination thing.

02:56

So, Doug believes that the Son eternally subordinates to the

03:03

Father. Now, why does he say that? He says that because he sees everything in the universe in light of this hierarchy position, like submission and submitted to.

03:17

So, he has this view of society, of patriarchy, this kind of vision for society, and he reads back that patriarchal vision of society into the

03:30

Trinity. And so, he has a socialized view of the

03:35

Trinity that you'll see. If you want to see someone unpack this really well, it's

03:41

Matthew Barrett and his books on the Trinity and the Sonship of Christ.

03:47

And so, that socialized view of God filters into the way they see creation, covenant, fall, redemption, and sacraments.

03:57

And that's kind of like how the dominoes flow. So, you have this view of human society that you want.

04:08

So, in the woke world, it's the egalitarian utopia, everyone being the same, economically the same, gender the same.

04:18

There's this oneness and sameness that is like the paradigm for society.

04:24

And then you go back to the gospel, and you see the gospel through the grid of this egalitarian utopia.

04:31

And then you go back to the doctrine of God, and you see the doctrine of God in this egalitarian utopia. And somehow, you begin to talk about the

04:37

Trinity in these egalitarian terms. Doug has this patriarchal utopia, right?

04:44

The reason why he's always talking about men submitting, it's not because he's, like me, looking at Ephesians 5, and looking at 1

04:53

Timothy 2, and looking at Genesis 2, and just exegeting that and saying that. He has a utopic view of society built on this hierarchy, okay?

05:06

And so, he sees the gospel through that social grid, and he sees the

05:12

Trinity through that social grid. And so, here's how it gets flushed out. The woke person says, we're going to transform society in this egalitarian, neo -Marxist oneness.

05:30

And as we transform and take over society with this egalitarian ideology, then we're going to see transformation.

05:40

The Wilsonite says, we're going to transform society with this patriarchal, hierarchical, conservative ideology, right?

05:52

And as we transform society and take over society, we will then transform people.

05:59

So, they both, you know, Tim Keller, he's going to transform the city to bring about the gospel, right?

06:07

But he's going to change the city by this egalitarian, you know, progressive ideology, right?

06:16

The Moscow guy, we're going to take over Idaho, you know, we're going to take over Moscow, not through the ideologies that are humanistic of Keller, but through the ideologies of, you know, other things, right?

06:33

Like the patriarchal utopia, you know, the conservatism, kind of like, you know,

06:40

Christian nationalism, collapsing, confusing civil and sacred sphere. But they're both social transformationists seeking to bring about God's purposes through sociological, political, spatial, human, institutional meaning.

07:00

They simply do so with different paradigms. And that's why they hate each other so much, because they're the same person competing for that same stage of, you know, social transformationalism.

07:15

But, you know, to be fair, like, the reason why a lot of our audience likes

07:21

Doug is because a lot of his values in his, you know, patriarchal utopia have some correspondence with our values.

07:34

But, I mean, if you want to think through that a little bit more deeply, well,

07:41

Jesus did share a lot of values with the Pharisees, okay?

07:47

More so than the Sadducees. But Jesus did not take kindly to their aberrant worldviews and corruptionist sociology simply because there was more of a correlation to ethics.

08:06

It's another... One of the things I was saying is that wokeism is not a strand of Christianity.

08:14

It's another religion. It's another religion. And I'll go to the other side.

08:22

Wilson -Moscow spirituality is not a strand of Christianity.

08:30

It's another religion. Just because you can find more correlations in ethics...

08:36

I mean, I can listen to Ben Shapiro and find a whole lot of things that I would agree with, but we're not on the same team.

08:43

We're not talking about the same God and same redemption and same Christology, you know? But I think, let's just be honest, brother, a lot of these folks have a

08:55

Judaistic view of Christianity. What I mean by that is Christianity can be reduced to homeschooling.

09:02

It can be reduced to male headship. It can be reduced to being anti -woke.

09:07

It can be reduced to believing in a limited government.

09:14

And when Christianity can be comprehensively reduced to those things, then I guess you don't really care to know too much about all the other things that Doug would believe, you know?

09:25

That is so true. Thank you for that. Have you gotten a lot of pushback on your show so far? People after you, they write you emails.

09:32

What's the response been so far on those monster shows in length? Well, I've gotten a ton of positive feedback.

09:43

A ton of positive feedback from a lot of people. A lot of them are like, yes,

09:49

I've been seeing this. I've been saying this. Thank you. I've gotten some. I was on the

09:55

Moscow train and I'm off the train.

10:02

And some people were like, hey man, why are you going so hard on Doug?

10:12

So there was a few of that. I had some people like, it's funny how one of the things that it motivated me to do this content is

10:24

I realized, I don't really want to go too deep into this, but Doug has a bunch of fans of his that have like fake accounts on Twitter and Facebook.

10:35

They're like kind of like promoted stuff that you can tell when someone's doing a fake account and stuff. And so there's a lot of those people that were telling me, if you're a

10:45

PCA guy and if you're about what you're about, you can't oppose someone like Doug because Doug, he's doing things that the

10:53

PCA is not doing and he's speaking in ways that other people aren't speaking.

11:01

So I've gotten a lot of good responses. Some like, hey, why are you being so mean to that guy?

11:06

Is he really that bad? And others like, how dare you? But at the end of the day, it hasn't been excruciatingly complicated.

11:20

It's just stuff like that. Okay, good. Well, let's see. What else do I have here? The rest of Canon Press, do you see a lot of,

11:28

I think it's Doug's daughter, Rachel's influence in churches? How would you assess that? Well, in light of the whole system, it's an integrated system, and in light of it being a whole integrated system with this counter -Christian worldview posing as Christianity, I see

11:56

Canon Press not as a good thing. You know, it's funny, I watched this with my family, and one of the things

12:06

I saw in that Eve's Hope documentary, I was watching with my family, and I was like, let's watch this.

12:12

Is that they said that the women's suffrage movement was a

12:17

Trojan horse in order to bring about all this anti -God, you know, egalitarian, you know, feminism and stuff.

12:28

So like, the genuine concern in society was simply a

12:34

Trojan horse for all of these Jezebel anti -God people to bring their ideology.

12:41

And at the end of that podcast, at the end of that documentary, I told my wife, I said, it's interesting they say that because I see this exactly the same.

12:51

This recapturing, you know, the biblical woman. This championing the traditional household.

12:59

It is a Trojan horse. It is capturing people. But on the inside of this

13:06

Trojan horse, there is a rot, there is a toxicity of aberrant doctrine that will destroy the whole city of that accepts the horse.

13:21

And I feel like it's the gateway drug. It's the gateway drug. Hey, I'll get you with this. And then

13:27

I'll, you know, I'll switch you with that. So I believe that, look, here's what's important to understand.

13:36

I'm not telling Christians that you can't learn from unbelievers.

13:43

You can't learn from like a Jordan Peterson. You can't learn something from, you know, you know, some person who is not like, like say, like,

13:52

I'm not like some Anabaptist, you know, no common grace. You can't learn anything from anyone.

14:00

However, the issue with someone saying, I like Eve's Hope and Canon Press and all this stuff, is that this person at the head of this movement is presenting himself to you as one of you, and he's not one of you.

14:19

So I don't have a problem saying, hey, watch Ben Shapiro, you know, say this about, you know, about, you know, the

14:26

Ukraine and, you know, watch this person talk about, you know, you know, like federal overreach or whatever, because he's not presenting himself as a confessionally

14:39

Reformed Christian. But when you have this guy who is telling everyone that I am a confessionally

14:46

Reformed Christian, and by the way, you know, all those guys who are in the PCA and the OPC, they're not actually confessionally

14:53

Reformed. They lost the Reformed faith. And then you're listening to their Christian ethics.

15:00

To me, it becomes more of a problem. And again, like, I would challenge a person who says to me, well,

15:09

I don't buy into his theology, but I do buy into, you know,

15:16

I do buy into, like, his view of, like, family. I'm like, where on earth do you read in the

15:23

Bible that you can separate Ephesians 1 and 3 from 4, 5, and 6? You can't unhinge those

15:30

Christological Orthodox doctrines in Ephesians 1 and 3 with God's view for the family.

15:40

Like, you can't unhinge. If you get the gospel wrong, then your view of family is wrong. And if you listen very closely, if you listen very closely to Doug, I would make a case that he's not right on soteriology, and he's also not right on ethics either.

15:58

He's not. When I hear Doug talk about families and women, what

16:05

I don't hear is a working out of the gospel into the paradigm of marriage.

16:15

What I hear is the categories of submission being understood in a legalistic, tyrannical, sociological system of, you know, the works righteous as Christian.

16:32

That's what I hear. And I think, here's one of the things that I said to people, is that when a society is really unraveled, an overcompensating, exaggerated hero who gets things done is always going to grip you in a way you probably don't realize.

16:53

So Castro comes in in the midst of Bautista. So we have a lot of,

16:59

I genuinely believe we have a lot of egalitarian, soft egalitarian, or hard egalitarian, you know, weak, impotent guys, spiritually speaking, in the church world.

17:14

And I think we have a lot of softness about biblical categories and masculinity in the church world.

17:20

And it's left this vacuum for someone like Doug to swoop in and be the kind of overcompensating hero that people cling to inappropriately.

17:34

So like, whenever, like, you know, things are complicated and crazy, we immediately gravitate towards an oversimplified, overly extensive kind of solution.

17:46

So my long answer is that the acceptance of all of the programs and things,

17:55

I believe, is a chosen horse to get you to buy into the whole system.

18:02

And the very fact that you are having difficulty with me saying he has heretical theology, based upon what you like about what he says about these things, proves that you're already hooked by the chosen horse, right?

18:22

It's hard for you to hear me even say this, you know? And it's because the very thing that I'm saying has already done its work on you.

18:33

Although, thank you for that. As you were talking, I thought to myself, I feel like I'm at the gym listening to your podcast, and I just am enjoying it so, and then

18:40

I realized, oh, I have to ask another question. Let me give you a few quotes from Doug Wilson, and you can see how slippery this is.

18:50

These are all quotes. Life and obedience are essential characteristics of the instrumentality of faith.

18:59

Here's another one. It is indisputable that works is the animating principle of faith.

19:06

Thirdly, I am treating obedient faith and living faith as synonymous. It is obedient in its life, and in that condition, it is the instrument of our justification.

19:19

Lastly, does obedience, he's talking about justifying faith, mean works or does it mean life?

19:25

If the former, then mixing it into justifying faith is death warmed over. If the latter, then leaving it out is death stone cold.

19:36

And all this instrumentality, you don't hear typical reform language, knowledge, assent, and trust.

19:42

You don't hear resting and receiving. You don't hear any of that. The OPC report on justification said this, though not ordinarily challenging the terminology of justification by faith alone, they, federal visionists, have changed the definition of faith and have therefore changed the meaning of faith alone.

20:03

Yep. Yep. That's another area where he takes a category and he impregnates it with all of his federal vision baggage.

20:18

So when he says living faith, working faith, someone says, oh yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

20:25

That's like the whole concept of like, it is not alone, but it works.

20:37

Like all true faith works. So he takes the fact that the reformers say that faith works, and then he says living faith, working faith, covenant faith on it, to basically take the category that the reform says that saving faith always causes work.

20:59

The instrument of faith causes work. And then he takes those two concepts and he morphs them into one.

21:06

And he says, basically the instrument is a faith that is obeyed.

21:12

And that's, I don't know how you feel about this, but that's where sometimes MacArthur muddles the instrumentality of faith where it's not faith that receives and rests

21:22

Christ alone for righteousness, sanctification, and redemption. But it's faith and obedience are kind of like the instrument.

21:29

You know, Piper does faith and affection as the instrument. And the good thing about Piper and MacArthur is they're not consistent with like, you know, kind of like confusing these categories.

21:40

But when Doug says living faith, he's basically echoing the new perspective covenant faithfulness concept, which says the means by which you are justified is through the instrument of your worked out righteousness.

22:01

So God is justifying you through the instrument of how you, in a contingent sense, live your life.

22:11

So basically it's the instrument of your action through faith, not the instrument of faith alone.

22:24

See the thing with, the reason why Doug says that, Doug literally has said in a podcast or a

22:30

YouTube video that, that Rome has not apostatized from the solar yet.

22:38

Okay. Doug in that, on a video of Peter Lightheart, the other

22:44

Romanist, you know, guy in the CREC, he's in the CREC with Doug Stokes. He says that, that Catholics are a part of the new covenant.

22:57

They're a part of the new covenant. They're brothers in Christ. He's quoting somebody from church history, they're brothers in Christ.

23:03

So Catholics are not full of faith. They say it through faith and affection, right?

23:09

The instrumentality of God working love in my heart, you know, Doug says that Rome has not apostatized from the solar.

23:18

Doug says Rome is not a part, is a part of the new covenant community. Doug says they're brothers in Christ.

23:25

Doug has a Roman Catholic view of faith. I mean, it's like, it's not complicated, you know?

23:32

And that's not what the Christian has. But you know, again, like, I think, again,

23:39

I think all these things that people don't seem to understand, I think they say more about how moralized and diluted the reform world broadly really is, because we don't even know what sola fide sounds like anymore.

23:58

We don't know what sola gratia actually sounds like anymore. You know, everything sounds, when everything sounds the same, that is,

24:07

Roman and Westminsterian, if that's even a word, when it all sounds exactly the same, it's very likely that we just don't have our, we don't know what we're talking about anymore if you can't, if you can't tell the difference, you know?

24:22

So true. I tell people all the time, Aldo, that we need to make sure we understand justification properly, and so every person, lay people as well,

24:31

I suggest that they read Calvin on justification, Turretin, Buchanan, Fesco, and Horton.

24:38

And if you get that down, you'll easily be able to hear things like Doug Wilson saying, quote,

24:44

I believe that a man is justified by faith, through faith, to faith, under faith, and over faith.

24:51

And I'm thinking, what is he doing there? But if you understand what the Bible teaches, it'll be very, very clear.

24:58

And so, I guess in summary, A, thanks for coming on and standing up for the truth. I really appreciate what you're doing, because most people are shying away from Moscow and Canon Press and critiquing

25:10

Doug Wilson, because I don't know what the reasons are. Secondly, if the folks want, go ahead, do you want to say something?

25:18

Well, I think, I think, again, might not sound repetitive, but one of the things that, one of the things that I believe is the reason why people have issues with doing this with Doug is there's not enough people like me and you that are speaking about Doug this way.

25:45

I read, I saw the things that were said about Doug throughout the years. I read the blogs that were critiquing him, and it's a lot of, apart, with the exception of Scott.

25:58

Scott was, you know, one person that was, I think, it was like, this is wrong, but let me pat him on the back.

26:05

This is incorrect, but not like false teacher, heretic, damnation, you know, like none of that stuff.

26:14

There's been like this, I don't know, kind of like, yeah, he's wrong about this, and yeah, I don't agree with this. I don't think we've, we have enough people that have given like a very precise, clear definition of how aberrant he is.

26:30

There's been, let's put it this way, in the evangelical world, right now, we have a real issue with confrontation, clarity, conviction, and boldness to people that are dangerous.

26:47

Look, I know this is hard for people to hear, but people like Tim Keller and the things they say are very dangerous.

26:56

Now, I wouldn't put Keller in a listening conversation, okay, but, you know, people that are well -known are saying very dangerous things, some on the spectrum of heretical and some on the spectrum of progressive, and we just have this tendency, we have this piety, this false piety of linsomeness and understanding, and I don't know, like,

27:23

I think that there just needs to be more people that, when they see things like this, they will love people enough to say what it really is, you know, and what

27:36

Doug's issue really is, is not that he is a post -millennial. I'm a post -millennial.

27:42

We're gonna have to stop this, we have to stop the show right now. It's not that he, you know, believes in male headship, it's the guy is a false teacher, and he has to be addressed as such, and the more you call the guy, the more you gaze at the guy, the more you kind of, like, softly give him a spanking,

28:08

I feel like it's hard for the sheep to really understand, like, how to respond, you know, so my hope is that I would just be one of a few people like yourself that would be very clear about how someone like this is supposed to be seen, you know.

28:33

But anyway. Well, what happens is, you look at R .C. Sproul and his life, I just read Nate Pikowitz's theological biography of Sproul, and it hurt

28:43

Sproul so much, but he had to do it to confront his friends Chuck Colson and J .I.

28:48

Packer, and I'm not equating J .I. Packer with Wilson, but he had to confront them and say, this is wrong, we can't do this, you can't snuggle up to Roman Catholics.

28:59

Now, how much more, essentially what Doug is teaching, it's got that same flavor of Roman Catholicism, and it just blends everything, and so we need to have folks that'll stand up and say, this is not good, if you want good culture warrior stuff or analysis of America, listen to Victor Davis Hansen or something like that, but once you, and I think you're right, once people start saying,

29:23

I love all the stuff he does about culture, then into the church he comes with his aberrant view of sola fide.

29:29

He does not teach justification by faith alone in any way, shape, or form from Westminster 1689,

29:36

Savoy, etc., and so we have to reject that, and if you don't teach salvation correctly, you're a false teacher.

29:43

So if you're good in other areas... Yeah, go ahead. Yeah, yeah, and here's,

29:50

I know we gotta end, but here's just something. When you get that wrong, you know,

29:59

Paul says, if we're just about at worth in Christ's side for nothing, and you're falling from grace, but like, listen to this for a second.

30:09

Listen to this. Look what Doug says about women over here.

30:19

Let's see. Okay, listen to this. In other words, how do we try?

30:26

The sexual act cannot be made into an egalitarian pleasuring party. A man penetrates, conquers, colonizes, plants.

30:37

A woman receives, surrenders, accepts. True authority and true submission are therefore the erotic necessity.

30:47

Listen to that for a second, and then listen to this. This is Doug describing slavery in his book with Steve Wilson.

30:54

Slavery as it existed in the South was not an adversary relationship with pervasive racial animosity because of its dominant patriarchal character.

31:01

It was a relationship based upon mutual affection and compassion. There was never a multi -racial society which has existed with such mutual intimacy and harmony in the history of the world.

31:13

So, owning somebody as property is loving and effectual because though you own them and dehumanize them, you're nice to them, and they like you.

31:26

He talked about sex with a woman. I've been in jail a lot of times, and I do jail ministry.

31:34

He talked about sex with a woman like a rapist in jail. So, if you listen to Doug's ethics very closely, it's not like the leadership of Christ and the way he lays himself down for the bride and the way he leads her, the way he gives to her, the way he provides for her, the way she nurtures her, that paradigm that informs the way a man is ahead over his wife.

32:00

He doesn't have that. He talks about these paradigms in the home in a way that is nothing at all of the gospel, and why is that?

32:11

Because he doesn't know the gospel. So, to all these folks that want Doug to help them out to be healthy families and healthy homes and healthy marriages, you need to have the paradigm of the true gospel of grace to know what it looks like for a family to be in order with a husband at the head, because that guy, what he's talking about, that's talking about brute power and force and cold dominance, which is—that's what you get when you think of God, not in light of the worldview of grace that we believe in, right?

32:48

That's so true. And you think about, okay, husbands love your wives like Christ loved the church. And in the federal vision view,

32:55

Christ loves the church initially through baptism, and they get all the benefits of being the bride of the husband as long as they're obedient in the covenant, and if they're not, then they're out.

33:08

And so, even that, I think, this is wrong. It's wrong at the core, right? This is not the love of Christ.

33:14

And so, I think that's a good tie -in. Probably we should end here, Aldo, the tie -in to Christ and his selfless, sacrificial love for his bride.

33:22

I hope men are not interested in Moscow because somehow they want to be dominating their lives.

33:28

I hope that's not the case. But nonetheless, I'm thankful for your ministry, thankful for your stand for truth.

33:35

If they want to go to Gospel on Tap, they can. Are the other shows called Kingdom...what's

33:41

it called again? Kingdom Polemic. So, Gospel on Tap and Kingdom Polemic are the same thing.

33:48

I'm just rebranding it Kingdom Polemic. So, Gospel on Tap is where you go, and if you don't see

33:53

Gospel on Tap, it's because it's Kingdom Polemic. So, just search both of those. It's the same podcast.

33:59

Thanks for being on the show, Aldo. I appreciate it. My pleasure. My pleasure. No Compromise Radio with Pastor Mike Abendroth is a production of Bethlehem Bible Church in West Boylston.

34:10

Bethlehem Bible Church is a Bible -teaching church firmly committed to unleashing the life -transforming power of God's Word through verse -by -verse exposition of the sacred text.

34:19

Please come and join us. Our service times are Sunday morning at 1015 and in the evening at 6. We're right on Route 110 in West Boylston.

34:26

You can check us out online at bbchurch .org or by phone at 508 -835 -3400.