June 7, 2016 Show with E. Calvin Beisner on “Debunking Global Warming Hysteria”

Live from the historic parsonage of 19th century gospel minister George Norcross in downtown

Carlisle, Pennsylvania It's iron sharpens iron Radio platform on which pastors

Christian scholars and theologians address the burning issues facing the church and the world today

Proverbs 27 verse 17 tells us iron sharpens iron so one man sharpens another

Matthew Henry said that in this passage quote we are cautioned to take heed whom we converse with and Directed to have in view in conversation to make one another wiser and better It is our hope that this goal will be accomplished over the next hour

And we hope to hear from you the listener with your own questions

Now here's our host Chris Arnton Good afternoon,

Cumberland County, Pennsylvania And the rest of humanity who are living on the planet

Earth listening via live streaming This is Chris Arntz and your host of iron sharpens iron wishing you all a happy Tuesday on this 7th day of June 2016

I'm so delighted to have back on the program dr. E Calvin Beisner Many of you may know the last two times we attempted to interview dr.

Beisner We were unfortunately having technical problems but the Lord is in our favor today and everything seems to be running smoothly thus far and Dr.

E Calvin Beisner many of you may remember him from years ago on the John Ankerberg program

But he is also a prolific writer and he is a conference speaker an ordained

Orthodox Presbyterian minister and Founder and national spokesman for the

Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation today We're going to be discussing debunking global warming hysteria, and we're also going to be letting you know about a documentary

That you can purchase where the grass is greener biblical stewardship Versus climate alarmism and it's my honor and privilege to welcome you back to iron sharpens iron radio.

Dr. E Calvin Beisner It's great to be back with you and I appreciate very much the the kind introduction

I I do need to clarify one thing. I was ordained as a ruling elder Okay, and well

That still is a position of high esteem in my regard. Anyway, so we thank you for being on the program

I have many friends in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, and I hope that my dear friend pastor

Bill Shishko in Franklin Square, New York is listening to Yes, I've known

Bill for about 30 years at least and he was one of the First pastors other than my own after I became a born -again believer in Christ.

He was a visiting Conference speaker at my church where I was a member grace reform

Baptist Church on Long Island which actually was originally named Calvary Baptist Church of Amityville Long Island and Bill has been not only a dear friend, but an enormous supporter and Encouragement regarding iron sharpens iron radio.

Well, we've since we've already done this before but for our listeners who are tuning in and Hearing you for the first time tell our listeners about the organization

You represent the Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation. I Am delighted to do that because I think the

Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation has Tremendous ministry on behalf of the poor around the world as well as ordinary folks and and also especially in terms of the gospel

We are a network of a little over 60 scholars sprinkled around North America and a few other continents

About a third of us are natural scientists such as climate scientists geologists oceanographers physicists mathematicians, etc and about a third are economists specializing many of them in either environmental economics or developmental economics so that we have men with us who really have expertise on how societies grow out of poverty what are the

Conditions absolutely necessary for doing that and how to create those conditions in societies and then another third

Our theologians ethicists and pastors who can bring the biblical worldview and biblical ethics and theology to bear on these issues and We seek through a variety of different educational channels our website

Cornwall Alliance dot org as well as published articles in online publications and print as well and We provide expert witness testimony for congressional committees and Speakers for churches conferences schools colleges and the like we seek to promote three things

Simultaneously and really interwoven with each other First biblical earth stewardship or what we also call godly dominion

This is this is men and women created in God's image laboring together laboring lovingly together to enhance

The fruitfulness the beauty and the safety of the earth to the glory of God and the benefit of our neighbors

So we're really really addressing there the two great commandment to love God and to love neighbor

The second major area of our emphasis is economic development for the very poor around the world think in terms of places like Sub -saharan

Africa and parts of Asia and Latin America and this we see as We find historically that economic development out of poverty rising out of poverty for an entire society not for a few isolated individuals here and there requires two

Primary conditions one is a set of social institutions such as private property rights

Entrepreneurship free trade limited government and the rule of law The other is access to abundant affordable reliable energy

And this is both both of these are completely indispensable to any society rising out of poverty.

You must have both Without one or the other you cannot see a society really rise out of poverty and then the third and most important Goal that we have is to promote and defend the gospel of Jesus Christ that That man is sinful man is justified and reconciled to the

Holy God by grace alone through faith alone in Christ alone who died for our sins according to the

Scriptures was buried and rose again on the third day according to the Scriptures that being the

Apostle Paul's summary of the gospel in 1st Corinthians 15 and All of this we do in a world that is permeated by an environmental movement whose worldview theology and ethics overwhelmingly anti -christian whose science and economics are typically pretty poorly done and Whose policies therefore often are not particularly helpful to the natural environment?

But are very harmful to the poor around the world by depriving them of the very conditions

Absolutely essential to their rising out of poverty those social institutions of private property

Entrepreneurship free trade limited government the rule of law and that material condition

Access to abundant affordable and reliable energy, especially in the form of electricity

And this means that the environmental movement by and large whether intentionally or unintentionally harms the poor even while it fails to do much good for the natural environment and That community has its own doctrines of God creation humanity sin and salvation

And these are definitely not the Christian doctrines of God creation humanity sin and salvation

It tends to be either atheistic or pantheistic or animistic It tends to think that that man exists to serve the earth rather than To to subdue and rule the earth as God told us to do in Genesis 128

And it tends to think that that sin is well certainly not cataloged in the

Ten Commandments but more like having a big footprint a big carbon footprint on the earth and it sees our salvation as coming from from repenting of our environmental abuse and Becoming good stewards of the earth now we as Christians believe that we should be good stewards of the earth

That's why our group is called Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation

But that is not the gospel. That is not the way of salvation. Amen. So we address all of these issues together

Yes, it appears that your organization is very holistic And I mean that in the best sense because you are very concerned with not only the souls of men

But the very physical well -being of men and just as the the book of James Mandates that Christians be concerned about those things to be obedient to Christ and Let me also make sure

I introduce you to my co -host. Once again, the Reverend Buzz Taylor Say hello to our it's good to be back on the air with you

Great I was good to be back on the air with you too. I enjoyed the last time Let me announce our email address for those of you listening who would like to ask questions of our guest.

Dr E Calvin Beisner, our email address is chris arnzen at gmail .com chris ar n ze n at gmail .com

and There is also I want to make sure our listeners know about a really fascinating Documentary that I viewed in fact,

I know that the Reverend Buzz Taylor my co -host viewed it as well where the grass is greener

Fascinating documentary that is just chock -full of valuable information that debunks a lot of myths that the leftists and And Environmental extremists are

Basically duping society with Where the grass is greener the movie .com

is the website I see but tell us something about this very valuable documentary

But we're very excited about the usefulness of this because as you say it does refute a lot of the various different Myths about climate change and of course the reason that's so important is that climate change or dangerous man -made global warming has become really the primary rationale for Depriving people of those things that lift and keep them out of poverty things like private property rights

Entrepreneurship limited government free trade the rule of law and so on and access to abundant affordable reliable energy

The the fears of dangerous man -made global warming are now the primary reasons given why we need to forfeit those things

In order to prevent this dangerous man -made warming and some of the myths about that that we address in this documentary

Where the grass is greener? Are things like the idea that there is an overwhelming scientific consensus that man -made warming is indeed

So dangerous that it warrants are spending trillions of dollars literally about two trillion dollars a year above the regular cost of providing energy around the world to Change our global energy systems from being primarily fossil fuel driven

About 87 % of all energy used in the world right now comes from fossil fuels primarily wind and solar trip, which would be far more expensive and Not nearly so reliable because wind and solar are intermittent

The the real fact is that among climate scientists climatologists meteorologists atmospheric physicists atmospheric chemists and so on among climate scientists

There is not any Consensus whatsoever for the idea that man -made warming is dangerous

Certainly to that extent Instead the real consensus is that you know, global average temperature is probably risen by a

Little under a degree Celsius since about 1850 Human activity in the way of putting greenhouse gases, especially carbon dioxide into the atmosphere has probably contributed

Significantly to that warming and that's it. That's all there is to it. There's nothing about the idea in Consensus there's nothing about the idea that human activity has been the primary driver of it

There's nothing in support of the idea that it is dangerous net dangerous

Certainly not anything any consensus over the idea that it is so dangerous as to warrants spending trillions of dollars

To mitigate it. Mm -hmm. So that's one of the many different myths that we treat. Yeah, right. There seems to be three major Categories during the documentary that I hope to cover everything under these subheadings

The first would be science is not settled the second would be catastrophic warming from unvalidated models and the third being not a single example of Carbon dioxide being a pollutant and we'll get to each of those main

Categories in a moment, but I do want to go to a listener in Wyoming Who has questions,

I usually don't take more than one question from a listener at the same time, but this this gentleman

Trevor in Laramie Wyoming has Provided this three excellent questions that I thought

I'd get to right away because they kind of set The stage for a lot of what we're gonna be discussing. Let me go to his first Question Trevor in Laramie Wyoming s if global warming is true and such a danger to the planet

Why are countries such as China and India given exemption exemption from polluting?

Well the the primary reason for that in terms of I assume that he's referring to the negotiations that led to the global Treaty in Paris in December the primary reason for that is

Precisely that the people behind this recognize that Fossil fuels coal oil and natural gas

Continue to be far and away the most affordable abundant and reliable source of the energy that is absolutely necessary for any

Society to climb out of poverty and India and China Are not only very poor societies compared with the

United States and Western Europe and the rest of the OECD but also very very large societies each of them over a billion people and Their leaders are not about to commit those countries to an energy policy

That would lock their people into their extreme poverty And so they made it clear that there was no way that they were going to sign on to any kind of a climate treaty

That would have that effect Now what they have done is instead they've they've announced their intention to to essentially

Begin to think about capping their carbon dioxide emissions sometime after around 2030 or 2032

But there's no solid commitment there and frankly their energy ministries their their energy

Departments in their governments already have made it clear that that's not going to happen

It's not going to happen precisely because their their leaders are committed to raising their people up out of poverty

So that's why they got a pass at this stage. But the fact is that the organizers of this treaty driven primarily by the

United Nations are Determined to try to Rope them in over the long haul and we'll have to see

How well the leaders of those countries are able to stand against the pressure to come and Trevor's second question is how much danger?

Are scientists and other professional careers in if they speak in dissent?

against global warming Well, that's a very good question

If there have been actually death threats against Wow question the reality of dangerous man -made global warming

Those are fairly rare and so far. Nobody has actually been killed over this however here in the

United States Attorney General Loretta Lynch has told

Congress that she has asked the FBI to look into the possibility of evidence that fossil fuel companies have

Intentionally suppressed evidence of dangerous man -made global warming in an effort to shield themselves

From the kinds of policies that would undermine the value of their product in the marketplace

Now the idea behind this is to do something similar to what was done with tobacco companies back in the 1980s and 90s

When the federal government used the Rico racketeer influenced and corrupt organizations act to to prosecute those companies winding up with a

Settlement not a court verdict, but a settlement In which the companies agreed to pay the federal government many billions of dollars

And to stop whatever they had been doing to resist the message that smoking was

Hazardous to your health now Frankly, I think that the tobacco companies were quite wrong to do that.

And obviously the the Situation there was one of a fairly obvious connection scientifically.

We knew full well the tobacco smoking caused much increased risk of lung cancer and heart disease

The problem with the comparison is that that connection was scientifically really pretty simple

There was no real debate over that among any medical doctors

Scientists physiologists and so on The case with global warming is much much much more complex

It involves thousands of climate feedbacks the climate system is probably the most complex physical system

We've ever studied except for the human brain There are thousands of feedbacks in it Most of which we do not understand very well at all some of which we don't even know whether they increase or decrease original warming the result is huge disagreements over Many many different issues of the climate change debate among perfectly well -qualified scientists, so in order for government to say

That there's a fraudulent activity going on here. And that's what they're what they're wanting to do

In order for them to say that there's a fraudulent activity. They have to prove that these companies have knowingly conveyed false information information contrary to Substantial factual information with the intent of getting people to take actions that would harm them and Help those who gave the false information and that the people took those actions and in fact suffered the harm from them

Now that is simply not going to happen And in fact, I've even read one email from a major proponent of this kind of prosecution who acknowledges that that's not going to happen, but the threat of the prosecution by the attorneys general

United for Clean Power Which started back in March? the threat by Loretta Lynch the federal attorney general

That threat is itself a major intimidation factor and it will silence many critics

And the ironic thing of course is that you know United States Code 18 section

I'm sorry 180 section 241 Actually says that it is a federal crime a felony in fact for two or more persons to conspire together to injure intimidate or otherwise harm anyone in the

Exercise of his rights guaranteed by the Constitution or laws in the United States Well, the

First Amendment guarantees our right to free speech and freedom of the press and these attorneys general by threatening

Prosecution whether civil or criminal Against those who question the reality or the extent or the proper the best responses to man -made global warming

That is indeed to intimidate the exercise of constitutionally guaranteed rights and we have one last

Trevor question Trevor from Larry me Larry me Wyoming and I better not accept any more questions from him.

Otherwise, I'll have to start paying him but Trevor s What drives global warming money?

Power or something else? Are we seeing a trending down in solar activity on the

Sun? Well, there are actually two questions Yeah The first one is, you know, what really drives the whole global warming alarmist?

Message and the movement is it money is it power? What is it? Well, I think it's a number of different things for some people.

I think it's a genuine Sincere belief that human emissions of carbon dioxide initially methane

Are going to cause dangerous global warming and these people sincerely believe that we need to Reduce our emissions of those gases in order to prevent that harm

And I have no, you know, no qualms as to their motivation

I do have the qualms as to the accuracy of the understanding of Scientific data

Related to the relationship between co2 and global average temperature and we can talk about that later in the program if you like some people

Are in this especially those in businesses that are related to renewable energy sources like wind and solar

Some are into it because they have a major business interest if they can get governments to Adopt policies requiring reduced use of fossil fuels

Well, we're going to have to get our energy from other sources and much of that will come from the wind and solar industry that of course means

Big profits for these players and they have in fact been major funders of climate alarmist scientists

Some also are in this for the sake of promoting power not energy power not you know electricity, but political power and frankly

The idea that we're going to fight global warming by reducing our for our use of fossil fuels Is going to require governments to take control of more and more of our energy industries

Because the market certainly will not make that choice The market will always try to find the least expensive way to provide the goods and services that Consumers want well wind and solar are far more expensive than fossil fuels for providing the energy that we need and So the only way that we're going to make that switch is for governments to take control of more of our energy systems

That control is an extremely powerful Control over our own lives because as you think about it

Everything we do takes energy whether it's the energy that we take into our mouths

Food to fuel our bodies or the energy that runs the electricity That provides for the telephone that I'm using right now to speak to you

And the broadcast for your radio program at the internet and all of these other things or the energy for your refrigerator that keeps your food

Spoiling or your air conditioner your heater that keeps your house comfortable or the assembly line that turns out cars and trucks

And I know iPads and things like everything takes energy And so if you're going to control energy, essentially, you're going to control every aspect of people's lives

So that's the political power Motivation behind it and a part of that is particularly people who believe that they can ride this horse

To global government and the establishment of socialism as our global economic system

And you have for instance Christina Figueres who is the recently retired?

Chairman of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change who said about a year ago that the climate negotiations in the

Conferences of the parties of which Paris last December was the 21st annual one

These climate negotiations were the best opportunity we have to replace the

Global economic order that we've had for the last century and a half, which is basically

Capitalism and free trade with a new global economic order and that would be socialism

Our Eden Hofer an economist a German economist a co -chairman of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Said in the lead -up to the

Cancun climate conference in 2010 that we must not mistake these conferences for Environmental conferences.

They are in fact the biggest economic conferences in the world and we by adopting climate change

Agreements we de facto Redistribute the world's wealth. So this is the you know, the underlying motivation for a lot of the folks

Involved in the political activity now when we come back from our break, we'll have you address the last question that Trevor Asked that I already read to you

Are we seeing a trending down in solar activity and the Sun will be right back after these messages with more of?

Dr. E Calvin Beisner, so we hope you join us with questions of your own and we'll be right back after these messages

Hi, I'm Chris Arnzen host of iron sharpens iron radio here to tell you about an exciting offer from world magazine

My trusted source for news from a Christian perspective Try world at no charge for 90 days and get a free copy of RC Sproul's book relationship between church and state

I Rely on world because I trust the reporting I gain insight from the analysis and world provides clarity to the news stories

That really matter. I believe you'll also find world to be an invaluable resource to better understand critical topics with a depth

That's simply not found in other media outlets Armed with this coverage world can help you to be a voice of wisdom in your family and your community

This trial includes bi -weekly issues of world magazine on -scene reporting from world radio and the fully shareable content of world digital simply visit

WNG org Forward slash iron sharpens to get your world trial and dr.

Sproul's book all free No obligation with no credit card required visit world news group at WNG dot org forward slash iron sharpens today

Charles Haddon Spurgeon once said give yourself unto reading the man who never reads will never be read

He who never quotes will never be quoted He will not use the thoughts of other men's brains proves

He has no brains of his own you need to read Solid ground Christian books is a publisher and book distributor who takes these words of the

Prince of creatures to heart The mission of solid ground Christian books is to bring back Treasures of the past to minister to Christians in the present and future and to publish new titles that address burning issues in the church and the world

Since its beginning in 2001 solid ground has been committed to publish God -centered

Christ exalting books for all ages We invite you to go treasure hunting at solid ground books .com

That's solid ground books .com and see what priceless Literary gems from the past or present you can unearth from solid ground

Solid ground Christian books is honored to be a weekly sponsor of iron sharpens iron radio

Iron sharpens iron radio is sponsored by Harvey Cedars a year -round Bible conference and retreat center nestled on the

Jersey Shore Harvey Cedars offers a wide range of accommodations to suit groups up to 400 for generations

Christians have enjoyed gathering and growing at Harvey Cedars each year thousands of high school and college students come and learn more about God's Word an

Additional 9 ,000 come annually to Harvey Cedars as families couples singles men women pastors seniors and missionaries 90 miles from New York City 70 miles from Philly and 95 miles from Wilmington and easily accessible scores of notable

Christian groups frequently planned conferences at Harvey Cedars like the navigators

InterVarsity Christian Fellowship campus crusade and the alliance of confessing evangelicals

Find Harvey Cedars on Facebook or at hcbible .org hcbible .org

Call 609 494 5689 609 494 5689

Harvey Cedars where Christ finds people and changes lives Welcome back.

This is Chris Arnzen. If you just tuned us in to iron sharpens iron, we are interviewing today

Dr E Calvin Beisner founder and national spokesman for the Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation

And our theme today is debunking global warming hysteria we're also talking about a documentary that is available called the grass is greener and we're going to hear more about that documentary as The interview progresses if you'd like to join us on the air with a question of your own for dr

Beisner our email address is Chris Arnzen at gmail .com Chris Arnzen at gmail .com

And to go to Trevor's last question our listener in Laramie, Wyoming Are we seeing a trending down in solar activity on the

Sun? Whether the trending down is continuing, I'm not sure but we do know that solar cycle 24 was was one of the coolest that we've seen in quite a while and It appears likely and there are various different solar physicists who've been studying this especially a number of them in the in Russia have been

Predicting that cycle 25 Follow it are going to be quieter solar cycles than usual.

We could actually see something that would be That would be comparable to the

Maunder minimum back a couple of centuries ago Which brought on severe cold temperatures throughout throughout the earth, especially in the northern hemisphere

We we saw the medieval warm period for roughly 900 to 1200

AD a period of significantly greater warmth was accompanied by and caused by a warmer period of solar activity more sunspots more solar irradiance emitted

And more solar magnetic wind emitted from the Sun That was followed by what is termed the

Little Ice Age running from about 1300 to about 1850 Which had several different periods of especially cold weather during various different Sunspot minimum the

Maunder minimum the Dalton minimum and things of that sort during this period For instance the

Thames froze over in the winter there were actual ice parties on the

Thames around Christmastime during this period the particularly in the late 1600s 1693 and following Scotland experienced some of the coldest temperatures that ever did

This was the period of the bubonic plague and the Black Plague in Europe which probably wiped out almost a third of the people

Cold is a far greater risk for human beings. That is war various studies indicate that During cold snaps about ten times as many people die per day as die during heat waves

So cold is a very major problem and the likelihood that we're seeing some cooling in the

Sun makes it particularly ironic that we're being asked to to reduce the activity that might actually help to offset a little bit of that by Adding a little bit of warming the co2 in the atmosphere before Reverend buzz has some questions that he's itching to ask you

I Wanted to just have you comment on something that it's I know that I've said this before on this broadcast, but there seems to be a real obvious charade going on with leftism the leftist totalitarianists who

Constantly beat the drum that they are the ones who are most concerned over the poor and the less fortunate on the planet and All of these insane environmental schemes that they are trying to mandate legally

Are really robbing those very people the the least among us if you will those who are

Living in the depths of poverty and starvation levels. They are robbing them of their livelihoods all over the world, aren't they?

Yes, that is that is so And in fact, there's one of the easiest ways of seeing that the left's constant

Talking about the poor and caring about the poor is not matched by its actual actions

Is by reading a book called who really cares the surprising truth about compassionate?

Conservatism by Arthur Brooks who is a major scholar with the American Enterprise Institute Brooks looks into the data and he shows that people who identify toward the liberal end of the political spectrum

Voluntarily give far less of their income to help the poor than people on the more

Conservative end of the political spectrum and that's the same thing that we see when we go to the global warming issue for instance

We the United Nations intergovernmental panel on climate change, which is a global warmest organization

It is dominated by political appointees from governments around the world Yes There are some real climate scientists who work with it

But the summary for policymakers that comes out with each of its major assessment reports

Which come along about every five years? The summary for policymakers is really written primarily by the politicians and After it's been written then the underlying scientific reports have to be edited to agree with it

Which really puts the cart before the horse. You should have the scientific reports Finalized and then the summary power for policymakers should fit those

So unfortunately that doesn't happen. But at any rate the UN IPCC Actually Finds in what is called working group three which deals with adaptation and mitigation working group three projects that the societies that are poorest today

Will be far better off under warmer scenarios a century and two centuries from now

Cooler scenarios That is they find that we keep people poorer

Longer by fighting global warming than by not fighting global warming and the more we fight global warming the longer and the poorer

We keep them now. There's the reason for that is pretty simple the warmth

Predicted by the IPCC is driven by the amount of energy used and that is determined Primarily by how much fossil fuel we use and so If we reduce our use of fossil fuels to fight global warming

We are going to prolong and deepen the poverty of the poorer parts of the world Now they say that they want to prevent global warming for the sake of the poor

But poverty is a far greater risk than anything climate related if you if you have

If you are as prosperous as say the lower middle class of the

United States You can thrive in any climate from the Arctic Circle to the

Sahara Desert to the Brazilian rainforest if you're poor if you're like the people of the vast majority of the people of sub -saharan

Africa or of India of China of Southeast Asia of major parts of Latin America if you're poor like that You can't thrive in the very best climate the very best habitat in the world

And and these people know this and yet they still say oh, but we need to prevent global warming

Well that that shows that they really don't care about the poor

Which is not terribly surprising granted that the environmental movement

Which is the real driving force behind the UN intergovernmental panel on climate change the environmental movement is overwhelmingly dominated by wealthy elites in the

Western world Who frankly have never known poverty and have never known the fear of whether they would be able to put food on the table at?

the next meal Yeah, they basically are valuing God's creation in The realm of plant life, especially and the animal kingdom

They are placing that at a much higher level of importance than human beings but there's a tremendous irony about that Chris and that is that that Increasing co2 in the atmosphere doesn't only raise temperatures a little bit

But also improves life a whole lot For every doubling of co2 concentration of the atmosphere you get an average 35 % increase in plant growth efficiency

Plants grow better in warmer and cooler temperatures. They grow better in wetter and drier soils

They can survive droughts and floods better They resist diseases and pests better.

They increase their fruit to fiber ratio They expand their ranges that is they will grow at higher altitudes and lower altitudes

They'll grow in higher latitudes and lower latitudes so plants anyway love

Co2 and in fact at the 280 parts per million of the of the atmosphere that were to co2

Before the Industrial Revolution Plants were very near the bottom end of their survival chemistry in the atmosphere

Right now we've raised it to about 400 parts per million, but that's still so to speak suck an air

Plants they need far more co2 and as we increase co2 in the atmosphere we increase plant growth

We're greening the earth We're making more food available for everything that eats plants and everything that eats things that eat plants

That benefits the poor more than anybody else because it makes crop yields around the world

Higher which makes food less expensive and that's a critically important thing and it's another thing that shows the the hypocrisy of These global warming alarmists who say that they are in it for the sake of the poor if they really were thinking about the poor

They would want to increase co2 to increase plant growth to increase food supplies to decrease food prices

To make the poor better off. Yeah, basically then everybody is really losing out under their regime including the plants and Right and Reverend buzz.

Yes. Well, of course, we're we're talking about the video where the grass is greener and as Chris mentioned to you at the beginning of the program we both watched the video and I was just blown away by it really and I came up with I believe you had nine major points that I've every single one of them is important and I'm hoping that somehow within the time we have left that we can at least address briefly each of those nine points, but Before we even start.

Well, you already did point one. The science is not settled But before we even discuss point two

Could you tell a little bit about who's involved in the video? Well, we've interviewed over 30 world -class scholars in climate science and economics and theology philosophy ethics and the like For instance, some of them are actual senior fellows of the

Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation Dr. Roy W Spencer is a principal research scientist at the

University of Alabama in Huntsville He is the u .s. Science team leader on NASA's aqua satellite remote sensing program this uses satellites to Sense all kinds of different things about the atmosphere at all altitudes all latitudes and longitudes around the earth 24 -7 365 it is the source of what we call our satellite global temperature data

These are the most important the most reliable the most objective the most complete data on global Atmospheric temperature in the world and dr.

Spencer along with his partner. Dr. John Christie Who is a good friend of ours, though?

He's not a senior fellow of the Cornwall Alliance those to run that program.

So we've interviewed. Dr. Spencer in this in this Documentary where the grass is greener biblical stewardship versus climate alarmism

Dr. David Legates, who's a professor of climatology and geography at the University of Delaware former

Delaware State climatologist author of many Refereed journal articles on climate change is another of our senior fellows.

We've interviewed him we've interviewed people with Expertise in Scientific subjects that are crucial to the doing of climate research such as such as physics one of those is the highly regarded emeritus professor of physics at Princeton Dr.

Will Happer and he brings with him many years of experience in studying atmospheric physics

What are the underlying causes of changes in global climate, so those are a few of the scientists

Interviewed economists such as dr. David Kreutzer of the Heritage Foundation Who along with co -authors has done some of the most important studies ever done on?

The economic impact of climate policies such as the Clean Power Plan under the Obama administration

That would require 32 % reduction in co2 emissions from American power plants by 2030 at the cost of hundreds of billions of dollars and at hundreds of thousands of jobs

And the result of it would be less than zero point zero seven degrees

Celsius Reduction in global average temperature in the year 2100 all pain no gain

We've interviewed theologians and philosophers as well such as dr.

J Richards He's at Catholic University of America Dr. Richards is a specialist in the philosophy of science and we talked with him about The the common claim that the

Christian faith and science are somehow Contrary to each other and that the fact that many of the

Critics of global warming alarmism are Christians means that their scientific testimony can't be trusted

He did a tremendous job of answering that sort of thing. So those are a few examples

Well, I'll hand you one more as well one aspect of this controversy that many people do not are not aware of is

That the call to fight global warming by reducing our use of fossil fuels to reduce co2 emissions is actually driving surprisingly enough an increase in In prostitution and in human sex trafficking around the world

What? Can that be? Well a very important part of how the global warming alarmists want us to reduce our energy use is by controlling human population growth reducing human population growth and ultimately reducing human population

One of the most important steps toward that is government run family planning programs around the world

Similar to China's one child policy, which by the way Christiana Figueres the former chairman of the

UN Framework Convention on Climate Change lauded as a good policy

China has boasted that by Preventing hundreds of millions of births through that one -child policy.

It has already contributed heavily to fighting global warming well government family planning programs around the world almost invariably include

Heavily incentivized sterilization and abortion When people choose to use abortion to Limit their family size.

They tend to do what's called sex selection abortions If you live in a very poor society

The birth of a male male child is the promise of economic support for you and your spouse

When you reach old age like it like it is rampant in China, correct? Exactly China India almost all of the countries in Asia experience this

Africa experiences this to some extent Latin America has experienced it, but especially

Asia and Africa so when you are being Told by your government you cannot have more than one child or more than two children or you're told

We're going to tax you at a higher rate if you had to have more children than this If you're being shamed for having more children then when you use abortion to Reduce the number of children you have you're going to Abort the female children, but not the male children.

The result has been for instance in China that you have about a hundred and nine male births for every hundred female births and Over the long haul that has led to the situation in China right now.

I'm sorry It was a hundred and nineteen male births for every hundred female birth The situation in China right now is that there are about a hundred and twenty adult males

For every hundred adult females now that means that there are not potential marriage partners

For many many millions of Chinese males and that is the case in All the

Asian countries that is the case in many African countries Where they have done government -run family planning programs the result of that of course since those unmarried males

Still have testosterone trunk coursing through their bodies is an increased demand for pornography and prostitution

And you know what? Most women don't want to get into prostitution or pornography voluntarily, and so that results in kidnapping and Forcing them into sexual slavery and sex trafficking around the world and the ironic thing is that Pope Francis Who when he came into office?

Told his bishops around the world that he wanted sex fighting sex trafficking to be one of their top priorities

Was advised in preparing his encyclical in which he repeated the claim of dangerous man -made global warming

By two of the most outspoken advocates of government -run family planning programs to control population

UN Secretary General Ban Ki -moon and UN Millennium Development Goals leader

Economist Jeffrey Sachs from Columbia University The sad thing is that what he's doing on the one hand trying to fight global warming is

Causing the very thing he wants to fight on the other hand human sex trafficking. We interviewed one of the world's leading activists and scholars on this

Elizabeth your she is an attorney and has been fighting sex trafficking and especially child sex trafficking around the world

For over 20 years, so here you have another area of the leftist agenda that seems to be backfiring because feminists have

Always been In agreement with Bible -believing Christians over their opposition to prostitution and sex trafficking.

So here you have another Backfire of a leftist agenda in global warming very ironic

Yeah, and Reverend buzz, oh by the way, I just want a quick Announce that website again.

I'm gonna try to do this as often as I can during the program But where the grass is greener the movie .com

is The website where you can find out more information about this documentary. We are discussing the

Reverend buzz yet another question. Well, yes I have technically I have nine questions because it's the nine

Video You answered number one very well and number two is natural processes dominate climate change.

Could you talk on that a little bit? Yeah It's very very clear that Climate has changed throughout

Earth's history We know for instance just going back a little bit We know that the medieval warm period was warmer than the present

We know that the Roman warm period was probably comparable before that the Minoan warm period and back around 11 ,000 years or so ago

What most geologists refer to as the Holocene climate optimism was much warmer much warmer

Then not just the present but the medieval warm period as well. And by the way, those were all periods in which

Life thrived around the world far more than it does today So those things obviously were not caused by our driving

SUVs They were not caused by our generating electricity from coal and natural gas fired power plants

We were not using electricity in those days. We were not driving SUVs So natural processes have driven climate change through all the history of the earth

And it has resulted in climate in global average temperature fluctuating by in ranges measured to close to 10 degrees

Celsius from colder to warmer Well, you know even the

UN intergovernmental panel on climate change claims that the

Doubling the co2 content of the atmosphere would raise global average temperature by No more than four and a half degrees

Celsius and that is at the upper end of their estimates Frankly, they're more recent estimates indicate that that it's more likely to be somewhere down in the range of one and a half to two degrees

Celsius that is a small part of The warming caused the warming and cooling caused by natural processes we also know that Out of the roughly eight tenths of a degree to one degree

Celsius increase in global average temperature Since about 1850 Roughly half of that perhaps a little bit more of that happened before 1960 but it's only after 1960 that the

UN climate intergovernmental panel on climate changes models Indicate that co2 increased enough to have much effect on global average temperature

So that means that natural processes dominated the last hundred and fifty years worth of temperature increases well so What we what we know is that human contribution to climate change is probably real

But it's it's probably also too small to measure Well, that's very similar to well that leads naturally to point number three

Which is man -made co2 appears to be muted or very little. In fact, if you could dr

Bosner answer that question when we return from a station break and we'll have buzz repeat We'll have buzz repeat the question also when we return and if you'd also like to join us on the air the questions of your own

Our email address is Chris Ornson at gmail .com Chris Ornson at gmail .com. I thank you who are patiently waiting to have your questions read and Answered on the air by dr.

Bison er, and so we'll get to your questions as soon as we can But don't go away. We're gonna be right back with dr.

E Calvin Bison er on Debunking global warming hysteria

Paul wrote to the church at Galatia for am I now seeking the approval of man or of God?

Who am I trying to please man? If I were still trying to please man, I would not be a servant of Christ Hi, I'm Mark Lukins pastor of Providence Baptist Church We are a reformed

Baptist Church and we hold to the London Baptist Confession of Faith of 1689 We are in Norfolk, Massachusetts We strive to reflect

Paul's mindset to be much more concerned with how God views what we say and what we do

Than how men view these things? That's not the best recipe for popularity, but since that wasn't the

Apostles priority It must not be ours either we believe by God's grace that we are called to demonstrate love and compassion to our fellow man and to be vessels of Christ's mercy to A lost and hurting community around us and to build up the body of Christ in truth and love

If you live near Norfolk, Massachusetts or plan to visit our area, please come and join us for worship and fellowship

You can call us at 508 -528 -5750 That's 508 -528 -5750

Or go to our website to email us listen to past sermons worship songs or watch our TV program entitled resting in grace

You can find us at Providence Baptist Church ma .org That's Providence Baptist Church ma .org

or even on sermon audio .com Providence Baptist Church is delighted to sponsor iron sharpens iron radio

I'm James white of Alpha Omega ministries The New American Standard Bible is perfect for daily reading or in -depth study used by pastors scholars and everyday readers

The NASB is widely embraced and trusted as a literal and readable Bible translation The NASB offers clarity and readability while maintaining high accuracy to the original languages

Which the NASB is known for the NASB is available in many editions like a topical reference

Bible Researched and prepared by biblical scholars devoted to accuracy. The new topical reference

Bible includes contemporary topics relevant to today's issues From compact to giant print

Bibles find an NASB that fits your needs very affordably at NASBible .com

Trust discover and enjoy the NASB for yourself today. Go to NASBible .com.

That's NASBible .com Tired of box -store Christianity of doing church in a warehouse with all the trappings of a rock concert

Do you long for a more traditional and reverent style of worship? And how about the preaching perhaps you've begun to think that in -depth biblical exposition has vanished from Long Island Well, there's good news

Wedding River Baptist Church exists to provide believers with a meaningful and reverent worship experience

Featuring the systematic exposition of God's Word and this loving congregation looks forward to meeting you

Call them at six three one nine two nine thirty five twelve for service times six three one nine two nine

Thirty five twelve or check out their website at WRBC .us

That's WRBC .us Welcome back

This is Chris Arnsin your host of Iron Sharpens Iron If you just tuned us in for the last hour and the hour to come

We have been and will continue to be interviewing. Dr. E. Calvin Beisner on debunking global warming hysteria, and we are also

Promoting a documentary that dr. Beisner Helped to create where the grass is greener the movie .com

Where the grass is greener the movie .com And if you'd like to join us on the air with a question of your own

Our email address is Chris Arnsin at gmail .com Chris Arnsin at gmail .com

before I have the Reverend buzz repeat a question He asked before the break. I want to give out give a shout out to Laura in Toronto Ontario Canada and Thank her for spreading the word about today's broadcast

She says there is much work each of us can do in our local communities to get the message out to our

Neighbors, so thank you very much Laura in Toronto and Toronto Ontario Canada for listening and for spreading the word about the program and Reverend buzz

Taylor if you could repeat your question that we that you asked before the station break well, we were covering the points of the video and We were talking about number two natural processes

Dominate climate change which naturally led to a number three, which is man -made co2 appears to be

Muted or very little you pretty much already covered that when you were answering number two

Yeah, I can add a little bit about that though a group of engineers many of them former former

NASA Space program engineers who worked on the Apollo and space shuttle programs these engineers put to work their understanding of heat exchange physics and engineering and Did a new analysis of just how much would global average atmospheric temperature rise?

In response to co2 added to the atmosphere and they came up with a much lower estimate than what the

UN Intergovernmental panel on climate change has come up with Their estimate puts it in the neighborhood of half a degree

Celsius perhaps as much as one degree Celsius for a doubling of co2 in The atmosphere, but then they also asked this question

Just how much could we raise? Co2 concentration in the atmosphere if we were to burn all the fossil fuels in the earth and their answer was

Not enough to raise global average temperature by more than 1 .2

degrees Celsius No matter how long it takes and what that means is that if they're right

And I think that they have very very solid physics and engineering principles behind this if they're right the contribution of co2 to Atmospheric temperature is extremely small

And I think that's not surprising because frankly the computer models used by the

UN IPCC to predict future temperatures based on various scenarios about how much co2 we add to the atmosphere those models have

Predicted two to three times as much warming as actually observed so far over the relevant period

Running from 1979 the beginning of the satellite data period to the present

They have predicted 95 % of the time they've predicted more warming than actually observed and that means that their errors are not random but biased

By bias if they were random they would have often predict less warming than observed as more and by equal amounts instead 95 % of the time they predict more warming so the bias must be there whether it's a dishonest bias or an accident

Oh honest bias, we don't know but it's there and then third None of those models predicted the complete absence of statistically significant global warming from February 1997 to October 2015 a period of 18 years and nine months now

What that what that means is that? Despite the steady increase throughout that entire period of co2

Concentration in the atmosphere we had no warming that means in turn that co2

Cannot be the primary driver of the recent global warming that we've seen it has to be largely natural

So there you go co2 plays a bit part a real one, but a bit part

Let me just before buzz goes on with another question. I wanted to squeeze in a listener question here we have

Christopher in Suffolk County, Long Island, New York who says or asks

Why haven't we heard a peep for a very long time? from the king of global warming hysteria

Al Gore Well actually we have two months ago

What a group calling itself a terror itself attorneys general united for clean power

Launched itself publicly Al Gore was there with them on the stage

Standing right alongside and he was champion championing their cause it continues to speak around the world 150 thousand dollars

Honorarium each time he speaks and it costs massive amounts of money to take him around the world because he still gets

Yeah He still gets the protection of secret service when he travels as former vice president

He still continues to make huge amounts of money not only as a speaker, but also from his activity on the boards of various different Renewable energy corporations, so yeah, he's still active

But but he's not quite getting the same kind of press that he used to get and perhaps that's because So many of his predictions about great disasters that would happen that would occur by 2010 or 2012

Turned out false. I believe it was 2012, but he predicted back in 2006 or 7

But by 2012 we would see the Arctic ice free in the summer

That didn't happen. And as a matter of fact Arctic sea ice extent has pretty much recovered to what it was before 1979 and it looks like the fluctuations in Arctic sea ice extent have been largely natural not driven by I might also be because be because I'm sort of talking about his

Relative absence from the media the DNC knows very well as bad blood between him and the

Clintons So by the way, it should be said that he must have a jet that that doesn't burn fossil fuels, right?

I was wondering if launching of the space shuttle might also burn some fossil fuel with anyway

You you really answered Number nine in that when you said the 1 .2

degrees Celsius if we were to burn all of our fossil fuel And you know when you think about that, it would raise the the average temperature of 1 .2

degrees Celsius You know, I myself have lived in you know, the look coldest I remember being in was minus 45 and the most

I remember being in was 107 So we're talking about 152 range that I have lived in and you know,

I'm doing quite well with it With one or two degrees Celsius really make that much of a difference

Considering the rains that other in fact, in fact, one of the world's most respected climatologists is

He's at MIT and he's actually a friend of mine Richard Linsen Richard Linsen He responds to this stuff

Dick does by saying look in any given locale around the world the daily range between Cold and you know between low and high temperature is anywhere from 10 to 20 times the amount that being told global average temperature could rise in response to double co2 and The annual range between summer high and winter low can run anywhere even even as much as a hundred degrees difference between the two or a hundred and twenty hundred and thirty hundred and forty degrees difference between the two so in short a

Global average temperature increase of one point two one point five even three degrees

Celsius Dicks responses Yeah, well, that's that's what point number four

I believe is addressing that real evidence does not support catastrophic warning

Yeah, that's correct. Yeah, the only way that you get the predictions of of net

Harmful effects out of the global warming expected from rising co2 by the

IPCC is from their models None of that comes from empirical observation and we know that the models are

Invalidated as I said a little while ago on average they predict two to four two to three times the actual observed warming over the relevant period 95 % predict more warming than observed and none predicted the absence of warming for a period of 18 years and nine months

That means the models are invalidated for prediction in predicting future temperature and that in turn means

That any predictions about harms to come from that predicted temperature are themselves unjustified

Right. Let me just squeeze another listener question in Tyler and mastic

Beach Long Island, New York What is your response to President Obama saying that global warming is the greatest challenge facing the

United States? And the world in fact, that would also be one of the biggest Drumbeats of Bernie Sanders the socialist running for president right now

Yeah, and by the way, Hillary Clinton agrees with them This is this is the dominant position among Democrats It's simply absurd

It is absolutely absurd What we know is that poverty kills

Millions of people prematurely every year around the world We don't know that anybody has been killed by global warming ever

We don't know that anybody is going to be killed by global warming ever and in fact working group three of the

UN IPCC and it's treatment of mitigation and adaptation says that people at risk from various different factors that are climate related whether it's droughts or floods the lack of purified drinking water lack of sewage sanitation lack of adequate nutrition

Anything else that has any link to climate? IPCC itself tells us

That those people are at less risk from all of those things in the warmest scenarios for the future

Than in the coolest scenarios for the future the reason for that is the wealth that is created as We use the energy that puts co2 into the atmosphere

Enables people to deal with all the various different climate related Risks if you're wealthy enough, you can get clean purified drinking water anywhere in the world

If you're wealthy enough, you can do sewage sanitation anywhere in the world if you're wealthy enough

You can have irrigation systems that that Reduce the harmful effects of drought you can have flood control systems that reduce the harmful effects of floods

You can have heating and air conditioning that protect you from extreme cold or extreme heat

If you're wealthy enough, you can do those things and that wealth is driven by abundant affordable energy reliable energy derived overwhelmingly from fossil fuels

So the IPCC itself Tells us that people are at greater risk when we try hard to fight global warming than when we don't

So the notion that global warming is the greatest risk threatening mankind is simply absurd

And buzz you have another question well, actually he's covered most of them very well except for seven and eight and I'll just list those and Because they sort of go together and then we've covered all the main points of the video except for of course

Information on getting the video but number seven was climate models contain assumptions of Earth's Sensitivity to co2 that are far too high and linked with that is number eight

There is not a single example of co2 being a pollutant Yeah, well, we've already discussed the failure of the climate models and the reason that the reason why they fail so miserably is that they assume

That the net effect of all the various different feedbacks in the climate system how various different Parts of the climate system respond to added co2 in the atmosphere and to whatever temperature changes that might bring about The models assume that the the net effect of all of those feedbacks is positive

That is that they increase the initial warming that you get from added co2 in the atmosphere

Now we we have I think we've got good reason from pretty basic physics what is called the

Stefan Boltzmann equation black body radiation we have pretty good reason from physics to think that if we if we double the

Concentration of co2 in the atmosphere By itself that will raise global average temperature up by about one or perhaps up to one point two degrees

Celsius The only way the IPCC comes up with its estimates in the range of Two two and a half three four even four and a half degrees

Celsius is by assuming that the feedbacks are net Positive For instance, they assume that clouds respond to a little bit of warming at the surface

By changing in ways that actually increase that warming Well, we now know from empirical studies done by Cornwall Alliance senior fellow

Dr. Roy Spencer of the University of Alabama and whom I mentioned earlier as being in charge

With his partner John Christie of NASA's Aqua satellite Temperature measuring program.

We know that clouds in fact are a negative feedback that is as the surface warms a little bit clouds respond by cooling it as it cools a little bit clouds respond by warming it

That's just one of a variety of different ways in which the models Assume that feedbacks are the opposite of what they are or that they're much stronger than what they are and the

Empirical studies of what's called climate sensitivity the amount of warming that you get from doubled co2 in the atmosphere after all the various feedback mechanisms have been accounted for The empirical studies of that are now yielding much lower estimates of climate sensitivity in the range of zero point three to Perhaps two degrees

And I happen to think that probably the best estimate is going to turn out to be around half a degree

So there's just simply no danger in that the issue of Co2 not being a pollutant

This is one of the slipperiest and most deceptive Rhetorical devices that the other side uses on this they will speak of carbon pollution

When what's really in mind is carbon dioxide now Carbon really can be a pollutant in the form of very fine particles dust particles

Right and in the air total suspended particulates Carbon that way can cause upper respiratory diseases and eye infections and the like and those are

Significant health risks they can actually shorten people's lives in the form of and there are other emissions from using coal and natural gas in In power plants or gasoline or diesel in vehicles in the terms of sulfur oxides

Carbon monoxide of course is a poisonous gas those things. We know how to Strip out of the emissions and control so that in developed countries

The only thing that comes out of these so -called smokestacks is not smoke at all. It's water vapor and carbon dioxide carbon dioxide far from being like carbon which may be in the form of a dangerous pollutant carbon dioxide is a colorless odorless non -toxic gas

Plants absolutely have to have it for photosynthesis and the more they have the better they grow

You and I right now are breathing about 400 parts per million carbon dioxide when we inhale

When we exhale we're exhaling about 40 ,000 parts per million carbon dioxide

In other words A hundred times as much as we breathe in and it is not toxic

It doesn't become a problem for human beings Until we are subjected to upwards of 8 ,000 parts per million for months at a time in America's submarine forces

We have we have standards for CO2 concentration in the air in Submarines in the thousands of parts per million and men

Do tours of duty that lasts as much as a year without coming out of that and it doesn't harm them so co2 is not a pollutant by any stretch of the imagination and Unfortunately, the other side gets away with Depicting it that way by talking of carbon pollution when what they really mean is carbon dioxide

Which is not a pollutant and you know, all of us learned in third grade when we studied basic science that plants need

CO2 to grow and That's what we're doing is we're adding CO2 to the atmosphere

Which is a very good thing to do for the sake of plants and everything that beats them and that means Everything alive.

In fact, I think someone in your documentary described CO2 as a miracle elixir of life or something to that effect.

Yes the elixir of life. That was dr. Robert Carter a geophysicist from Australia a brother in Christ who

Who went to be with the Lord about three months ago? It's very saddened by his death.

That's a tremendous loss to the whole world of science he he published many very fine articles in referee journals and I'm sad to lose him.

We do have an anonymous listener in Greenville, South Carolina Who asks what does this discussion have to do with Christianity?

It seems to be more about politics than the Christian faith Okay a fair question.

Although I disagree with his his view of what we're talking about, but if you could

Absolutely fair question and I would answer it in a couple of different ways

First of all, the Bible does tell us that we as Christians should be

Concerned to protect the most vulnerable Vulnerable around us from various different harms including oppression including disease including poverty and the like and so we should be concerned about these things as Christians if we're going to be salt and light to the world if we're going to Remember the poor as Paul said in Galatians chapter 2 verse 10

The Jerusalem Council had asked him to do and he said that's the very thing that I was intent on doing

We should be remembering the poor the book of James tells us much about the importance of taking care of the poor

Doing so is a part of the the works that demonstrate the reality of the faith that we tell

That we claim to have in Jesus Christ the Bible says a great deal about helping the poor and protecting them from harm and My reason my entire reason for being involved in this battle for the last 10 years of my life going on 11 is

Precisely to protect the poor around the world from the harmful effects of climate policy

The second way that I would approach this is is that the biblical worldview tells us that The the earth and its climate system are the product of an infinitely wise

Designer an infinitely powerful creator and an infinitely faithful sustainer

She the scriptures tell tell us in Genesis 131 that after God had made everything

He saw that it was very good in Genesis 8 22

God made a covenant with himself That as long as the earth endured seed time and harvest cold and heat summer and winter day and night

Would not cease he was using a poetic device there in Hebrew called merism in which these opposites in the spectrum

Mean basically and everything else too. This was a promise by God to himself to sustain all of the

Cycles on which human and other animal life and plant life on earth depend as long as the earth endures

Now think about this for a minute I'm I'm sitting in my house right now talking with you on the telephone on this program and an architect designed this house

If he had designed it so that if I leaned against one wall all of the response mechanisms all of the feedbacks of the house

Magnified the stress of my weight until eventually it became so great that the house

Collapsed would we consider that that architect was brilliant or foolish?

We'd consider that he was foolish Well, the global warming alarmist message is that an increase in carbon dioxide concentration of the atmosphere from 28 ,000 of 1 % to 56 ,000 of 1 %

Is going to cause catastrophic? Collapse of the climate system so that it all goes into chaos and it could wipe out life on the earth

That's the same sort of notion as the architect who makes a building collapse because somebody leans against a wall

That's an insult to God. It doesn't Consist well with the biblical understanding of the wisdom of God the power of God the faithfulness of God So there's one part of it.

There are other parts as well in terms of the Christian roots of science the very doing of science depends on your belief that the world is a

Ordered system designed by a rational God to be understood by rational human beings created in his image

But a major part of the the climate alarmist global warming alarmist movement is what's called post -normal science

Post -normal scientists take the ideas of post -modernism of deconstruction into science

Deconstruction in literature tells us that language doesn't exist to convey truth but to project power to force other people into our

Meta -narrative of who should be in control over their lives

Well post -normal science says scientists the science doesn't exist to discover truth and to properly

Manipulate subdue rule the earth as God told us to do in Genesis 128

But rather to project power you go through the motions of science in order to justify a political agenda that you already have that's the basic idea of post -normal science and Perhaps not surprisingly a number of the most important figures in climate alarmist science are

Self -professed Post -normalist in science one is dr.

Mike Hume Who is former director of the climatic research unit at the

University of East Anglia and professor of climate change? There he's now gone to another university, but in his position there at the

University of East Anglia He trained many of the scientists who are at the very center of the

UN Intergovernmental panel on climate change and he has written Articles co -authored articles with dr.

Jerome rabbits a philosopher of science at Oxford on Post -normal science and advocating its use and for instance in his book why we disagree about global warming

Hume wrote that We He put it something like this

We need to ask not what we can do about climate change, but what climate change can do for us

He said that in a world that's dominated by capitalism Dangerous man -made global warming climate change is a handy thing to come about because it can help us to provide a rationale for the political agendas that we already have and Hume by the way

Was a socialist at that time. I understand that there is some indication that he's beginning to change his thinking about that But there you go.

There's you know Christianity provides the worldview basis for science and Post -normal science is undermining that and post -normal science is a very important part of the global warming alarmist message

And we're gonna be going to our final break right now If you'd like to join us on the air With a question of your own whether you agree with what's being said whether you radically oppose what's being said or do you just don't?

know our Email address is Chris Arnzen at gmail .com Chris Arnzen at gmail .com.

We do have a couple of people patiently waiting online To have their questions asked and answered and we also welcome your questions whether you are a

Christian Whether you are an atheist whether you are a Muslim a Jew or a Swedenborg enist

We welcome your questions at Chris Arnzen at gmail .com Chris Arnzen at gmail .com.

Don't go away. We're gonna be right back with dr. E Calvin Beisner and debunking global warming hysteria

Hi, I'm Chris Arnzen host of iron sharpens iron radio here to tell you about an exciting offer from world magazine

My trusted source for news from a Christian perspective Try world at no charge for 90 days and get a free copy of r .c.

Sproul's book Relationship between church and state I rely on world because I trust the reporting

I gain insight from the analysis and world provides clarity to the news stories that really matter

I believe you'll also find world to be an invaluable resource to better understand critical topics with a depth

That's simply not found in other media outlets Armed with this coverage world can help you to be a voice of wisdom in your family and your community

This trial includes bi -weekly issues of world magazine on -scene reporting from world radio and the fully shareable content of world digital simply visit wng .org

Forward slash iron sharpens to get your world trial and dr. Sproul's book all free

No obligation with no credit card required visit world news group at wng .org

Forward slash iron sharpens today Lindbergh Baptist Church on 225

Earl Avenue in Lindbergh Long Island is teaching God's timeless truths in the 21st century

Our church is far more than a Sunday worship service It's a place of learning where the scriptures are studied and the preaching of the gospel is clear and relevant

It's like a gym where one can exercise their faith through community involvement It's like a hospital for wounded souls where one can find compassionate people in healing.

We're a diverse family of all ages Enthusiastically serving our Lord Jesus Christ in fellowship play and together.

Hi, I'm pastor Bob Walderman I invite you to come and join us here at Lindbergh Baptist Church and see all that a church can be call in Brook Baptist at 5 1 6 5 9 9 9 4 0 2 that's 5 1 6 5 9 9 9 4 0 2 or visit

Lindbergh Baptist org, that's Lindbergh Baptist org Iron sharpens iron radio is sponsored by Harvey Cedars a year -round

Bible conference and retreat center nestled on the Jersey Shore Harvey Cedars offers a wide range of accommodations to suit groups up to 400 for generations

Christians have enjoyed gathering and growing at Harvey Cedars each year thousands of high school and college students come and learn more about God's Word an

Additional 9 ,000 come annually to Harvey Cedars as families couples singles men women pastors seniors and missionaries 90 miles from New York City 70 miles from Philly and 95 miles from Wilmington and easily accessible

Scores of notable Christian groups frequently planned conferences at Harvey Cedars like the navigators

InterVarsity Christian Fellowship Campus Crusade and the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals Find Harvey Cedars on Facebook or at hcbible .org

hcbible .org Call 609 494 5689 609 494 5689

Harvey Cedars where Christ finds people and changes lives Thriving financial is not your typical financial services provider as a membership organization

We help Christians be wise with money and live generously every day And for the fourth year in a row, we were named one of the world's most ethical companies by the ethosphere

Institute a leading international think -tank dedicated to the creation advancement and sharing of best practices in business ethics

Contact me Mike Gallagher financial consultant at 7 1 7 2 5 4 6 4 3 3

Again, 7 1 7 2 5 4 6 4 3 3 to learn more about the thriving difference

Lending faith finances and generosity. That's the private story

We were made to thrive Attention coin collectors and investors

Long Island galleries of Wading River, New York has brilliant uncirculated 19th century

Morgan silver dollars for only $54 per coin with free shipping and handling for a limited time

There's a 40 coin limit. So order now while supplies last call eight eight eight two six zero eight one one one

Eight eight eight two six zero eight one one one visa MasterCard discover and American Express Welcome price is subject to change.

So call now at eight eight eight two six zero eight one one one Eight eight eight two six zero eight one one one if you prefer ordering your brilliant uncirculated 19th -century

Morgan silver dollars by check mail it today to Long Island galleries nine

Susan Drive Wading River, New York 1 -1 -7 -9 -2. That's Long Island galleries 9

Susan Drive Wading River, New York 1 -1 -7 -9 -2 Remember, they're only fifty four dollars per coin with free shipping and handling and a 40 coin limit

New York State residents must add sales tax Long Island galleries is honored to sponsor iron sharpens iron radio

See the Long Island galleries display ad at iron sharpens iron radio calm

Welcome back. This is Chris Arnzen. If you just tuned us in for the last 90 minutes, we have been interviewing.

Dr E Calvin Beisner And we have been discussing Debunking global warming hysteria.

We've also been promoting a very valuable Documentary that you should get a hold of as quickly as possible

Where the grass is greener and the website for that is where the grass is greener the movie calm where the grass is greener the movie calm before I return to our

Discussion our friends at grace Bible Church in New Jersey and Allenwood, New Jersey to be specific

They are having dr. Vodie Bacom world -renowned author and conference speaker

He is going to be speaking there in New Jersey this Friday and Saturday at a conference that They hope you attend.

In fact, the reverend buzz Taylor and I will be there God willing Friday and Saturday for the conference

The ever -loving truth conference equipping believers to stand for the truth.

That will be Friday, June 10th 7 to 9 30 p .m. And Saturday June 11th from 9 a .m.

To 12 30 p .m. This is at grace Bible Church 4041

Squonkum Allenwood Road, that's s -q -u -a -n -k -u -m squonkum

Allen Road Allenwood Road in Allenwood, New Jersey The website is

Jersey Grace dot o -r -g Jersey Grace dot o -r -g and the phone number is area code 7 3 2 9 3 8 3 1 1 1 7 3 2 9 3 8 3 1 1 1 and We hope that you attend this conference because dr.

Vodie Balcom is Truly a phenomenal brother in Christ a very gifted speaker very very dedicated to The inerrancy of the scriptures he is a reformed

Baptist he has a very high regard for the family and I think that it will be well worth your while to go see him in,

New Jersey and we hope to see you there as Reverend buzz Taylor and I as I said hope to be there ourselves this weekend

And once again, the website is Jersey Grace dot o -r -g Jersey Grace dot o -r -g and Jumping on that question before I go to any of our other listener questions jumping on that question

From our anonymous listener in South Carolina who was being a bit critical isn't another big reason why this has everything to do with Christianity is that a global warming is a enormous lie

That is dominating in many ways the media at this point and many many many

Christians are being sucked into this deception Yeah, that's true

And we are supposed to be people of truth Jesus tells us you will know the truth and the truth will set you free now of course the most important thing is knowing he

Jesus Christ himself who is the way the truth and the life But you know falsehood always leads to a diminishing a diminution of our freedom

Falsehood is is the primary thing that tyrants and dictators have used all through the centuries to subject people to themselves

We see that in every single instance whether it's communist or fascist or or anything else

Tyrants use falsehood Christians need to test all things hold fast.

What is good first Thessalonians 521 and As we test this global alarmist message, we find that it is not good

I would like to address our anonymous listener also on that and simply to remind him and anybody else who might have

I'm sure many people would be asking the same question and Understand that even at the beginning of every one of iron sharpens iron programs

You do mention that we are discussing the burning issues of the day that affect us

Church and the world the church and the world but everything we look at is from a

Christian world and life view and so we do break out of theology, but in a sense we don't because When you are talking about massive starvation and death

That is a church issue. That's it almost be like saying. Why are you discussing abortion?

That is nothing to do with Christian, right? Definite and even even as as we heard at the beginning of the program

Your ministry Calvin Beisner's ministry is the Cornwall Alliance the Cornwall Alliance See you use the word godly dominion

I don't think a lot of Christians have an understanding of what that really means.

Why don't you re -explain that dr. Bosner? Yeah, well building on our understanding of Genesis 128

We define godly dominion as men and women creating God's image laboring lovingly together to enhance the fruitfulness the beauty and the safety of the earth to the glory of God and the benefit of our neighbors so that really we're addressing the two great commandments to love

God and to love neighbor and The whole global warming issue comes into this precisely because what we're being asked to do will make the earth less

Abundant less fruitful and less safe for human beings by depriving human beings of that abundant affordable reliable energy that is absolutely necessary for Lifting and keeping whole societies out of poverty, you know

It all really comes down to love for our neighbors the two great commandments

You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart soul mind and strength and you shall love your neighbor as yourself

We're not loving our neighbors if we stand idly by while a deceptive message traps them in extreme poverty for generation after generation

When instead they could rise out of poverty with access to the energy that they need to do so This this dominion that we're supposed to exercise is not abusive

We're not supposed to go out and abuse the earth Rather to where to be good stewards of the earth increasing its fruitfulness its beauty and its safety and it's really characterized by what

God himself did in The creation week as we read through the earlier part of Genesis chapter 1 we see that God Brought something out of nothing.

He brought order out of chaos He brought light out of darkness. He brought greater order out of lesser order.

He brought life out of non -life He brought a huge variety of life and he told all of the different forms of life that he had created

To be fruitful and multiply and fill the various missions Mitch's in the earth and then he finally tells mankind to be fruitful and multiply and fill the whole earth

So we should be reflecting God's creativity and productivity in how we steward the earth

We should be enhancing life. We should be enhancing fruitfulness. We should be enhancing variety and diversity of life we should be enhancing the safety of the earth and we should be

Enhancing its beauty as well because beauty itself reflects the image of God We're told that that God himself is beautiful This is why beauty is not a totally subjective relativistic notion

There is objectivity to beauty beauty should reflect God in terms of his his truth

His his holiness his orderliness and so on So all these things need to come into our understanding of Dominion and that's why frankly all of this really is very much related to our

Christian faith scriptures are God -breathed and profitable for reproof rebuke correction and righteousness

So that the man of God may be thoroughly equipped for every good work whether that good work is preaching the gospel from a pulpit at a church or writing a newspaper article or Practicing astrophysics so that we can understand better the impact of the

Sun on the Earth's Climate system and so that we can predict when solar flares are going to put electric systems at risk and Be able to protect against that Everything we do we should do better because we have studied

God's creation and God's Word and understood him Yes, and in fact one of the importance

What were one of the important reasons that this subject should be addressed in a

Christian? Talk program In my opinion is that the Christian community the conservative

Bible believing? Christian community has been long vilified and slandered and caricatured by the elitist left the pseudo pseudo intellectuals who mock and laugh and scoff as They listen to those opposed to the global warming hysteria

Coming very often from those in our camp the opposition that is to it and we are painted in the eyes of the public as morons as Neanderthals Chris Matthews very well -known and highly respected

Media journalist Host of the hardball program. He can't even restrain laughter when he discusses a conservative politician being

An unbeliever when it comes to abortion. I mean, I'm evolution he thinks this this is hilarious that any thinking person in the 21st century would be

Opposed to the theory of evolution the Darwinian theory of evolution and this goes hand in hand with that people who are

Basically sounding the alarm that global warming is a hoax to a large degree they are being viewed as morons and if people are to take seriously

Everything else we believe about the Bible and about life and about the gospel

They should know that it is not our best and brightest who are morons

It's those who are perpetrating this hoax. Would that be a fair thing to say? I think

In many respects. Yes, they're not all morons. As I said, some of them really are I think

Sincerely persuaded on this scientific evidence and better persuasion but the fact is that the

Apostle Paul tells us in 2nd Corinthians 10 that we are supposed to To be using spiritual weapons now spiritual weapons are not only prayer.

They're also Arguments arguments are important parts of spiritual weapons.

We should be using spiritual weapons to tear down The strongholds of darkness the demonic strongholds and we should be taking every thought captive to the obedience of Christ and when we see people attacking

Christianity as anti -science because we have the temerity to Exercise proper sky in a scientific skepticism toward global warming alarmism

We have to have good solid answers for that very thing we have to show that that Christianity is the real root of science and Christians have the far better understanding of current science than have non -christians and that's clear enough from the simple simple fact that for non -christians, especially those who are metaphysical materialist

There is no Ground in that worldview for belief in reason itself, you know

If matter and energy are all that exist Then there's no such thing as reason when to give when two billiard balls meet on a table

They don't exactly stop and have a discussion about which one's going to go where next at what speed it's a simple exchange of energy well, if that's all that's happens in the human brain if there's just simply the

Electrochemical events in the brain then there is no such thing as reason and if there's no such thing as reason that there's no such

Thing as persuasion and argument. Well, that's the logical conclusion of the metaphysical materialist naturalist worldview underlying an awful lot of the so -called science

Behind global warming alarmism and it's really not science That is what's anti -science and we

Christians are able to respond to that. That's part of what we do in the movie greener on the other side

I'm sorry for the grass is greener biblical stewardship versus climate alarmism where the grass is greener biblical stewardship versus climate alarmism

Available online at where the grass is greener the movie .com

Where the grass is greener the movie .com and when I speak to young people who claim to be atheists

That is their Usually their first charge against Christianity I don't even seriously consider

Christianity as an option in my life because of the moronic

Understanding of modern science modern science is basically disproven in their minds many things that Christians hold near and dear and Obviously that is not true at all.

And unfortunately the masses are being duped into believing that so once again By the way, by the way, too

You know, we saw how Darwinism came to dominate science education in our public schools

Now under what's called the next generation science standards being adopted by public schools all over the country climate alarmism is going is being put up right alongside

Darwinism and Students are being told if you don't believe in this then you are anti science

You're essentially as you're putting it a moron the parents

Christian parents need to understand that they need to recognize that their children's minds are at stake in our

Public schools and they need to get them out of there into good solid private schools or into homeschooling to to prevent that problem

I would also like by the way to Recommend to your listeners that they go to our website

Cornwall Alliance dot o -r -g and Find there the spot where they're invited to sign a petition

Forget climate change energy empowers the poor Thousands of people have signed this petition already.

We're looking to see it signed by many thousands more Forget climate change energy empowers the poor

They can find that at Cornwall Alliance dot o -r -g, that's Cornwall Alliance dot o -r -g

It's an opportunity for them to tell their public officials where they stand on this issue

C -o -r -n -w -a -l -l Alliance dot o -r -g and we do have

Arnie in Perry County, Pennsylvania asking Have you been able to confront in public such as in a debate forum?

the leading spokespersons who are promoting global warming hysteria

Including politicians and if not yet, are there any debates planned in the future that we can know about?

Some debates have happened about this unfortunately, just as most

Darwinists refused to debate creationists on the grounds that to hold the debate is

Itself to acknowledge that there's legitimacy in the other side Now the actual reason is every time they do debate they lose and the listeners

Hold in advance and then pulled again afterwards show that you know They may answer that they have been persuaded much more by the creationist side

Well, I think the same thing lies behind the refusal of most global warming alarmist to debate the skeptics about this

Now we have had some debates for instance early last year the two colleagues of mine and I doctor

Dr. John Christie of the University of Alabama private principal research scientist in climatology there and dr

Ross McKittrick an environmental economist at the University of Guelph in Ontario and I teamed up to debate

Let's see It's oh Here's the founder and head of three fifty dot org

His team is escaping me at the moment, but he and two others an economist rusty

Pritchard and a former emergency room physician Who has turned an evangelical?

environmentalist Matthew Sleaf Those two were joined by the founder of three fifty dot org and the six of us debated this issue at New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary under a

Program that they have going there to provide point and counterpoint on major public issues

And the result of that debate was pretty clear by the way Our side had far more scientific facts

Mastered and far more economic analysis mastered and far better theology and ethics as well

So we do that now also the Cornwall Alliance has repeatedly make it made public

Challenge and I would do so again right now on this program public challenge to evangelicals who embraced global warming alarmism we will provide a

Scientist and economist and a theologian for our perspective if they will provide a scientist and economist and a theologian for their

Perspective and we will debate this issue with them at any Christian college of their choice

And we will cover the cost of bringing all of the debaters there and we do have

Harrison in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania Who asked didn't the one of the founders of Greenpeace actually stepped down from the organization?

He helped to found because he realized that global warming was a lie

Yeah, that's dr. Patrick Moore. He was the only founder of Greenpeace with an actual

PhD in an environmental science and Really the only serious scientist among them all he was president of Greenpeace for a while early on and He stepped out of Greenpeace in the mid -1980s as he watched

Greenpeace become increasingly a left -wing socialist organization rather than a true environmental stewardship organization

And yes, indeed. He's one of the more outspoken critics of global warming alarmism

Yeah, I just saw him once I think on Fox News. It is interesting how the

Majority of the media seems to be keeping that a secret His resignation from the actual organization he founded

Well in about a minute if you could just close with a summary of what you most want etched in the hearts and minds of our listeners

Well, I think what we at the Cornwall Alliance for the stewardship of creation really want our listeners to grasp most of all

Most importantly is the gospel of Jesus Christ, you know, you and I Chris are our sinners

We fall short every day of Conformity with the law of God and we need forgiveness of our sins.

We need justification. We need Reconciliation with the Holy God and that is available to any who come to him through by faith and the

Lord Jesus Christ who Died for our sins according to the scriptures who was buried and who rose again from the dead according to the scriptures

And when we come to him and are reconciled to him then we begin to Study his word in the

Bible and that word Transforms our mind we are not to be conformed to this world

But transformed by the renewing of our minds so that we can know what is the good and acceptable will of God That is what we need to know to fulfill our function as citizens in this world

Exercising the command to love our neighbors and when we do that we can understand better and better his word and his world then

Act as salt and light in the world and we're out of time brother and we look forward to having you back and it's

Cornwall Alliance dot org Cornwall Alliance dot o -r -g And you just want you all to always remember for the rest of your lives that Jesus Christ is a far greater