TLP 555: The Truth and Lies of Developmental Stages

How do we know a child is strong enough to lift a 10-pound weight? We watch them do it. How do we know a child is old enough to learn 1 plus 1 is 2? We wait for the school system to tell us they're ready?

Parenting as Worship and the Purpose of Truth.Love.Parent.

Parenting isn't about us. In fact, parenting isn't even about our kids. Parenting is just one way Christian dads and moms are to worship God. So welcome to the Truth, Love, Parent podcast, where we train dads and moms to give God the preeminence in their parenting.

I'm so glad you're joining us today. My name is Aaron Brewster. I am married to Johanna, and we have two children. Our oldest is Micah, and our youngest is Ivy. The Brewster family is a testament to the fact that God is good in saving undeserving wretches, also that choices have consequences, and that God fixes broken things.

This podcast is nothing more nor less than our best effort to keep God's truth at the center of your family's experience by equipping parents to know God and worship Him in their.

Parenting.

That's all we're doing here. So thank you for joining us on this journey, and I pray that you will be sharpened in your walk with God. To that end, we have over 550 evergreen episodes that span so many amazing topics.

I strongly encourage you to at least scroll through our collection of series, but you can also look at the individual episodes or use our search function at truthlovefamily .com. We also love it when people email us directly at teamtlp at truthloveparent .com and ask which resources might be helpful for their current season of life, their questions, and or their needs, and we're always happy to respond and give you exactly where you need to go, what series and what episodes you need to look at.

Of course, I pray that every episode here will continue to minister to the spiritual needs of families for years and years to come. And in addition to the hundreds of episodes, we have free episode notes, transcripts, and additional resources included with each one.

And when you find a topic that interests you, be sure to work through the related resources in order to deepen your knowledge, understanding, and application of the material. Today we're talking about the truth and lies of developmental stages, and I think we should just jump right in.

The Reality of Developmental Change

Childhood developmental stages have absolutely taken control of every conversation that happens concerning parenting, education, psychology, maturity, health, and wellness. It's a huge conversation with a lot of observation and repetition and interpretation.

We clearly don't have the time to scratch even the surface, but I still believe this conversation is important and can be transformative in your family. But before we deal with our first truths and lies, I would like to remind you that this ministry is in tremendous need of donations.

God has been keeping us afloat graciously, and I praise Him for that, but we're struggling more than ever, and we really could use your help. Whether you download the free Evermind app and purchase my new book or online courses, or you sign up for weekly biblical counseling, or you commit to donating on a monthly basis, anything and everything can help.

We're having a difficult time paying our bills, and honestly, if only 85 people donated $50 a month, we would have more than we need at the moment. And if we had only 170 people donating $25 a month, it would be the same.

You know, that's how math works. The point is, not everyone can give the same amount, but whatever you can give will go a long way. I'm so thankful to all of our faithful donors, some of whom have been giving to this ministry for over seven years, and I'm inviting you to join our TLP friends.

Please visit truthloveparent .com forward slash donate or click the link in the description of this episode. Thank you so much for what you're going to do. Now, let's start by looking at number one, the truth of developmental stages.

Letter A, people change. If this truth weren't obvious from our physical changes as we age, the scriptures illustrate this point in various ways. The scriptures tell us in Luke 2, 52, that Jesus was advancing in wisdom and stature and in favor with God and men.

Here we see both physical and spiritual changes. The spiritual changes are also repeatedly taught all throughout the Bible via illustration as well as command. In 1 Corinthians 3, 1 -3, Paul wrote, I was not able to speak to you as spiritual men, but as to fleshly men, as to infants in Christ.

I gave you milk to drink, not solid food, for you are not yet able to receive it. Indeed, even now you are still not able, for you are still fleshly. But how many commands are there in the Bible that we grow in our sanctification, put off the flesh, and put on righteousness?

Later in 1 Corinthians 13, 11, Paul writes, when I was a child, I used to speak like a child, think like a child, reason like a child. When I became a man, I did away with childish things. The brain sciences have done their best to show us that the physical brain reaches full maturity in the mid to late 20s, when the prefrontal cortex finally catches up with the rest of the brain.

Therefore, it's reasonable and expected to assume that our children will change as they age and also as they mature spiritually. If you remember from our Expectational Education series, physical and spiritual, or mental maturity, do not happen simply because the other happens.

But this reality is what prompts people to try to understand what children are capable of learning. They recognize that an infant can't lift a 10-pound weight, and he can't solve arithmetic. So they assume that when they are strong enough to lift the weight, they also will be more likely capable of doing the arithmetic.

But when? We'll talk about that at the end of the episode. Now let's consider our second truth, B, maturity happens at different speeds. In the parable of the soils, Jesus says that some spiritually alive trees bore 30-fold, some 60-fold, and some 100-fold.

By the way, if you've never listened to the 4 Children series, I encourage you to take.

A listen.

That series is all about identifying how your children respond to truth and then how to parent them accordingly. And it's based off of this parable of the soils. The point is that not all 12-year-olds will be as physically mature or spiritually mature as all the other 12-year-olds.

The sciences have also concluded that. No surprise there. But here's a really important truth that most people don't like to address during a conversation concerning developmental stages. Letter C, the brain sciences are constantly updating.

Up until the 1900s, doctors believed that only children's brains had neuroplasticity. The adage, you can't teach old dogs new tricks, was an inappropriate assumption based off the fact that it was harder for adults to learn by forming new neural pathways than it was for children.

I'm constantly amazed when I hear people voice surprise that children born during the COVID lockdowns are now experiencing developmental delays. Listen, people, that one was obvious. At least it should have been.

Medical doctors and neuroscientists should have seen that one coming. Barring the government silencing people who stand up against them, Lord willing, the next time the government attempts to lock all the citizens inside, people will hopefully speak up, having finally learned that it was harmful for everyone to cut us off from each other.

Anyway, all sciences, including neuroscience, is not a perfect system. These people are observing, hypothesizing, and trying to find repetitions in order to solidify their conclusions. They are still learning, and if history teaches us anything, it's very possible that in 100 years, our modern-day neuroscience will seem just as lacking, or even backward, as scientists of the past now seem to us.

So yes, people change, and they don't change at even rates, but it's also important to recognize that just because someone in a white lab coat with a bunch of letters behind their name says it, that doesn't make it a fact.

Well, Aaron, doesn't that sound a little anti-intellectual of you? Yes, if you listened to our last episode, you might think that, but remember, I'm not questioning them simply because they're trying to teach me something and it contradicts my feelings.

I'm simply pointing out that a lot of quote-unquote experts have been wrong more than they've been right. We need to test the spirits and use wisdom and discernment to rightly judge information, regardless from whom it comes.

So that was the three truths we're going to talk about today. Now let's consider four lies. Number two, the lies of developmental stages. Letter A, scientists don't make mistakes. Now this may sound like a repeat from the last point, but it is different.

The observation that the neurosciences are changing doesn't necessitate that people aren't being hurt by their wrong conclusions. But the truth is that doctors and scientists do make mistakes and sometimes even lie, resulting in real harm.

A biblical example is the woman with the hemorrhage. In Mark 5, 25 -27, we read,. And a woman who had a hemorrhage for twelve years, and had endured much at the hands of the physicians, had spent all that she had, and was not helped at all, but rather had grown worse after hearing about Jesus.

She came up in the crowd behind him and touched his garment. And we know that she was miraculously healed because of God's power and her faith. Not only, though, was she not helped by the doctors, she was actually harmed.

According to Miller and Zois, attorneys at law, every year there are about 20 ,000 medical malpractice lawsuits filed in the United States. In 2022, 3 ,046 claimants won their wrongful death suits. They also said that,.

Quote,.

A new study indicates that nearly 800 ,000 Americans suffer permanent disability or lose their lives annually due to incorrect medical diagnoses, prompting researchers to declare such diagnostic mistakes as a public health crisis.

Unquote.

They also said that as of September 1, 2020, a medical diagnosis by an Australian doctor is incorrect one in seven times. Now, what does this have to do with developmental stages? Well, again, just because researchers make the claim, it doesn't mean it's true.

The neurosciences and the pseudoscientific therapeutic doctors have been trying to convince us that children aren't truly born male or female and should decide for themselves how they identify. These are the same people speaking into the commonly accepted developmental stages.

Okay. In fact, one huge mistake many of these scientists make is actually our next point. Letter B. People mature like they evolve. I don't think there's a medical field that is untouched by evolutionary thought.

Doctors will tell you that your body digests food differently because of how it evolved. Love doctors will hearken back to supposed cavemen mating rituals to substantiate their modern day advice. And some of the most influential thought leaders in a modern American education not only believed we evolved, but used those ideas to craft the school system as we know it.

In an abstract entitled The Influence of Evolution on Dewey's Educational and Philosophical Thoughts, we read, quote, Evolution has a great impact on Dewey's philosophical and educational thoughts. Many fundamental conceptions of Dewey's educational philosophy, such as continuity, growth, contingency, development, and genetic methodology could be traced back to Darwinian evolutionary theory.

Dewey reconstructs the ideas and methods of traditional philosophy based on evolution and introduces a lot of new scientific methods into educational theory and practices, end.

Quote.

By the way, that article in that abstract, they are praising this in Dewey. They're not saying it was a bad thing. And just in case you didn't know, Dewey had a huge lasting impact on a modern American educational system.

But here's the thing. We didn't evolve. It was quite the opposite. And my mother always taught me that if you do the math correctly, you can never come to the right answer when you start with the wrong numbers.

When it comes to neuroscience, researchers who attempt to identify how and why we change and mature based off the flawed presupposition that we evolved from lower life forms will always come to the wrong conclusions.

This is one of the reasons that abortion was originally made legal, because the assumption was it was just a creature of some type of organism evolving in the mother and wasn't fully human yet. Also, as an example, in 2023, research concludes that squid and human brains are tied by evolution because, quote, despite the 500 million years of evolution that separates squids and humans, our brains develop in a very similar way to the brains of these cephalopods, unquote.

By, quote, monitoring stem cells called neural progenitor cells in development, developing squid embryos, unquote, they found that, quote, to build a squid retina where most of the animal's neural tissue is found, the cells must first form a long, densely packed structure that can also be spotted during the neural development of vertebrates like us, unquote.

And they didn't just say, hey, these are similar. They said that they are tied together because we evolved from something similar. So people with a priori beliefs like this may observe factual occurrences, but they can't be trusted to make any applications based off of the findings when their ideas are so skewed by lies.

Now, the next lie we need to consider concerns the most influential belief system when it comes to developmental stages in our time. But this system grows not only from evolutionary thought, but also from many other flawed precepts.

Letter C, Eric Erickson's developmental stages are fact. This is the third lie of the day. I'm going to park on this one for a little bit, okay, because it's a big deal. It's important. It absolutely pervades everything in the developmental stages of life.

According to Eric Erickson, a psychologist who died in 1994, the human brain goes through eight psychosocial stages. Stage one is trust versus mistrust and supposedly lasts from infancy to eight months.

Stage two is called autonomy versus shame and doubt and is supposed to last from 18 months to three years. Stage three is initiative versus guilt and lasts from three to five. Stage four is industry versus inferiority and affects children from ages eight to 11.

Stage five is called identity versus confusion and covers the teen years from 12 to 18. Stage six is intimacy versus isolation and is supposed to affect people ages 18 to 40. I'm past that one. Stage seven is supposedly where I am.

It's called generativity versus stagnation.

Oh boy.

And lasts from 40 to 65. And stage eight refers to integrity versus despair in everyone older than 65. First of all, I want you to know that Erickson actually never received a formal degree in medicine or psychology, okay, while teaching in a progressive school created by a friend of Sigmund Freud's wife.

Our good buddy Ziggy saw Erickson's report with children and encouraged him to study psychoanalysis. Erickson's views were influenced heavily by Freud, but he did tweak them according to his own opinions.

Erickson believed that personality developed in stages when people faced a crisis that needed to be successfully resolved. And the majority of his observational research came from time studying the cultural life of two Native American populations.

With those observations out of the way, second, let's quickly consider his proposed developmental stages one at a time from a biblical perspective. Again, we don't have a ton of time. I'm going to do this in brief.

Stage one is trust versus mistrust. Let me say that at the outset that the question of whether we will trust or not trust something is seminal to every facet of humanity. Until the day we die, there is no more important discipline to exercise.

I talk all about this in the Mirrors Christianity series, which details why your kids do what they do. However, from Erickson's perspective, this was not necessarily a lifelong endeavor, but one from which we move on before we hit two years of age.

Of course, that doesn't mean Erickson thought it was unimportant. According to positivepsychology .com, quote, failure in stage one results in the development of fear, mistrust, suspicion, anxiety, and ultimately a belief that the world is unpredictable.

We may become anxious, believing we have no control or influence on our environment.

End quote.

Secular experts will have you believe that a child who didn't have a trustworthy caregiver during this stage of their lives are nearly incapable of developing healthy attachments with others later in life.

Unfortunately, not only does this instill a lot of fear in parents and motivate them to embrace parental determinism, but it also ignores the important dichotomy between not being able to do something and choosing to do something.

But since Erickson was a humanist who believed that everything is physiological in nature, then he saw cause and effect where the Bible sees interpretation and choice. Yes, teaching your child to trust is important both in practice as well as word, but it's not only important in the first two years of life.

Also, it's important for our children to recognize they don't have control. They have very little influence over their environment and that's okay. That's not something that should cause us to be afraid and anxious.

But you can only see it that way if you believe in God. Stage two is autonomy versus shame and doubt. The belief that is that children ages two to three are beginning to develop a heightened sense of their own control and desire for independence.

Which of course, the control aspect is just kind of a lie. Again, according to positivepsychology .com, during stage two, parents should expect and encourage their children to explore limits, gently stretching them while avoiding criticism when they fail.

The resulting feeling of security and confidence are crucial for our progress in subsequent stages and leads to the virtue of will. However, if we are overly criticized and controlled or prevented from asserting ourselves, we may feel unable to survive, lacking in self-esteem and excessively dependent on others.

Indeed, feeling a sense of shame over toilet accidents, as an example, can impact our sense of personal control and increase levels of doubt.". Now, first, this sounds an awful lot like John Gottman's Emotion Coaching, which I address in the Doctrine of Emotions on the Evermind app.

Those resources normally cost $25, but if you use the link in the description, you can access it for only $10. Needless to say, there are some very big issues with emotion coaching, especially from a biblical Christian perspective.

Other than that, your biblical mind should be registering some significant doubt yourself as you consider the necessity of shame and doubt in our lives. First, we absolutely need to doubt ourselves. We don't need to be encouraged in our autonomy.

In fact, the Biggest Parenting Challenges You Will Ever Face series, we talk about why the lie of autonomy is one of those categories, one of those challenges, I should say, and how you must parent through it.

We are dependent on God and we are commanded in the scriptures to be dependent on each.

Other.

Second, since we do need to doubt the non-existent control we have over our universe, it's appropriate to experience shame when we do wrong. In our Children and Shame series, we talk about the difference between good and bad shame and how to use good shame in our parenting.

Though Erickson rightly acknowledged that unsaved 2 and 3-year-olds struggle with this, of course they want control. Of course they're going to struggle with autonomy. He wrongly concluded that the best-case scenario is for the toddlers to avoid shame and doubt as they learn to control or whatever control they have over their own autonomy.

Stage 3 is Initiative vs. Guilt. PositivePsychology .com says, quote, To our parents, our behavior may seem vigorous. Overly assertive or even aggressive, and yet we are exploring our interpersonal skills.

If overly restricted from such exploration, either by parent control or through increased criticism, we can develop a sense of guilt. Similarly, while constant questioning in this stage can be tiring at times, if it is curtailed by caregivers, we may see ourselves as a nuisance, inhibiting our interactions with others.

Unquote.

I'm not going to waste too much of time on this one. We absolutely need to experience guilt when we do things we shouldn't. Yes, we should learn to direct our play and social interactions, but that doesn't mean that all of our choices will be Christ-honoring, especially at the age of five.

And we need people who will lovingly show us that the best initiative to take is in things that please the Lord. And if we take initiative in things which don't, we should experience the guilt and conviction of the Holy Spirit.

And that's true later in life as much as it is early on. In fact, if we rear children to think that they don't need accountability, they don't need people giving them constructive criticism and coming into their lives and saying, no, you shouldn't do that.

Then all you're going to get is adults who also think that people shouldn't be able to tell them that they're doing something wrong. Stage four is industry versus inferiority. These five to 12 year olds will likely find themselves in more and more instances of formal education.

And Erickson believes the tests of this season is the difference between being industrious in their work or shying away because of feeling inferior. Positivepsychology .com claims that, quote, if successful, development leads to the virtue of competence, while failure can result in a sense of inferiority, where we feel unable to perform specific skills.

Balance in stage four leads to a sense of accomplishment and competence, and we start to believe in our ability to handle existing and novel situations, unquote. Here's the thing, though. The world needs to recognize that our competence needs to be rooted in Christ because we aren't capable of doing anything good and pleasing apart from him.

And our failures need to produce a biblical inferiority where we recognize that we are incapable of apart from him. That drives us to him in justification. That drives us to him in sanctification. Of course, there are selfish versions of industry as well as inferiority, and both of those are a sin.

Industry isn't always good just because it's industry. The world will never understand this tension. They will never get it. But we as Christians need to realize that the right thing done in the right way isn't always Christ-honoring.

Now, remember, we're working through these stages identifying the commonly accepted lie that Eric Erickson's theory of developmental stages is not fact simply because he developed opinions while watching children mature.

He wasn't interpreting what he saw through the lens of Scripture. His entire worldview was humanistic and had no room for God. Therefore, any ideologies or philosophies or systems that are rooted in these eight stages are fundamentally flawed and shouldn't be prescriptive in the lives of our family.

Okay, there are four more stages. Stage five is identity versus role confusion. This is for the young adults in the teenage years. And yes, identity is a super huge issue with people of all ages. That's why we address it in the Biggest Parenting Challenges You Will Ever Face series.

But Christians will have to approach this discussion categorically different than the.

World.

Whereas the world believes that young people need to find slash create their own identity, the Bible teaches us exactly what our identity is. We don't need to search for it. God tells us everything we need to know.

And yes, I will say proudly that anyone trying to find or create their identity outside of God's will for their lives needs to be confused. They are confused. Lord willing, God will use that confusion to draw them to the understanding of what He was always making them to be.

Stage six is supposedly about intimacy versus isolation. Positivepsychology .com says, quote, in the sixth stage of Erickson's psychosocial developmental theory, young adulthood takes place between the ages of 18 and 40, which of course we know it takes place earlier than that.

Anyway, they say, during this time, major conflict can arise as we attempt to form longer term commitments outside of our family with varying degrees of success. And yet positive outcomes result in healthy, happy relationships that are secure and enduring, developing the virtue of love.

Erickson's view is that the ability to love marks the ultimate success of stage six when relationships are meaningful and lasting. Failure, whether beyond or within our control to form appropriate bonds or the avoidance of intimacy, may result in loneliness, a sense of isolation, and depression.

Those with a poor sense of self are typically emotionally isolated and less committed to relationships, end quote. Again, the scriptures are the only place where we can truly understand who we are, who others are, what it is to be a friend, and what it is to love and be loved.

Erickson's observations on this point were valid. Those who feel loved feel valued and those who don't feel depressed. You know, that makes sense. The issue again, though, is that Erickson and the systems built off of his theories cannot help an adult navigate the stage to their greatest benefit and greatest glory.

And again, it's not just adults who struggle with this. Children do as well. Stage seven is generativity versus stagnation. Positivepsychology .com, once again, explains it this way. Quote, during middle adulthood, we display our need for longevity, not necessarily in a physical sense, but as life's continuation in our children or the long-term impact we have on others.

We aim to make a mark on the world, nurture things that will outlive us. We may look for ways to be more productive and valuable to our society with an eye in the bigger picture. Success is exemplified by virtue of care, the feeling of being useful in life, accomplishing something, and contribution to society.

We are proud of who we are, what we have achieved, our children and who they have become, and the strong relationship we have with our partner. Failure looks quite different. We feel we have little impact on the world.

If so, we feel unproductive, uninvolved, disillusioned, and disconnected from the world in which we live.

Unquote.

What's interesting is that Erickson did a better job identifying the struggles in the older groups than he did the younger ones. Likely, this was due to the fact that he was able to carefully think through his own life stages, whereas remembering the details of his youth were much harder.

To that end, his observations were more on the nose for the later groups. But as I've already mentioned many times, though these developmental temptations may be real, the answer to them can only be found in God and his word, not by following his prescriptions.

And finally, stage six is integrity versus despair. The observation here is simple. Despair doesn't come from God. And yes, in our old age, God expects us to remain faithful to him in all things. However, our own perspective of our abilities and accomplishments shouldn't matter to us as much as the objective reality of our faithfulness to Christ.

So the very psychological bedrock of our modern understanding of psychosocial developmental stages and how they affect our children's ability to learn new skills and experience new events is fundamentally flawed because it doesn't interpret the seasons of life through God's eyes, nor does it seek to answer the challenges according to God's will.

Biblical Wisdom for Evaluating What Children Can Learn

Now, thank you for your patience today. As we go a little bit longer than usual, let's just quickly review the three truths and three lies and then apply them to the final lie. The truths are that number one, people change.

Two, people change at different rates. And three, the brain sciences are still being updated and changing themselves. And the lies that we are tempted to believe about how our kids develop are number one, scientists really know what they're talking about and don't make mistakes in their statements concerning the developmental stages.

Number two, we mature in life like our species has evolved over time. And three, Erickson's theories about human development are fact. So with a firm understanding of these truths and lies, we can answer the final lie.

Letter D, infants, children, and teens are incapable of, well, fill in the blank. Listen, your child is incapable of a lot of things and they will continue to be incapable of countless others as they age.

You personally are currently incapable of a lot of things that other people your age and even younger accomplish on a daily basis. But so what? Seriously, who cares? Those observations don't necessarily mean anything, nor should they be used to plot the trajectory of our growth.

Think of it this way. How do we know a child is strong enough to lift a 10-pound weight? Well, we watch them do it. We can conjecture all day long about whether they're strong enough to do so, but what's the harm in just letting them attempt it?

If they can't lift it, we'll know for sure. But if they can, they'll surprise us. And I think we should approach their spiritual maturity the same way. We shouldn't say, well, second graders aren't ready for such and such.

Why not? Why don't we let them try? For thousands of years, young people have been accomplishing amazing things, things that many modern-day adults haven't done. Let them try. How do we know a child is old enough to learn 1 plus 1 is 2?

Do we wait for the school system to tell us they're ready? Or do we try to teach them that 1 plus 1 is 2 and see if they get it? I say we teach them. Allow them to be as successful as they can. Remove the barriers for entry into their maturation.

Namely, the common misconceptions of what people at their age are capable of learning, understanding, believing, or doing. My friends, God has great and amazing things planned for your kids. I encourage you to listen to our God's Will for Your Child series that instead of telling you what your kids aren't capable of accomplishing, we open God's Word to see all the absolutely fantastic things God is doing in them now and has planned for their future.

There are a lot of lies when it comes to yours and your child's developmental stages. I only ask that you use biblical judgment and critical thinking to wade through the lies. Be theological. You have been tasked by God to rear your kids in His nurture and admonition.

He has created and commanded and capacitated them to rise to the level of His high biblical expectations, and He's called you to partner with Him in that process. See your kids the way God sees them and parent them accordingly.

Will you please share this episode on your favorite social media outlets so that more and more of God's people will learn to stop holding their kids back because the world tells them their kids are quote-unquote too young?

And never hesitate to email us at counselor at truthloveparent .com or leave a voicemail at 828 -423 -0894 if you need specialized biblical help in identifying what God has for your kids today. On our next episode, we're going to build on the past few episodes to identify the best version of your kids.

It's pretty exciting the vision God has for your children, and I want nothing more than for you to see them the way He does. And don't forget to please become a monthly donor to TLP. Even if it's only $5 a month, we really need your help to continue publishing this free evergreen content.

I'll see you next time. Truth Love Parent is part of the Evermind Ministries family and is dedicated to helping.

You worship God through your parenting.

So join us next time as we study God's word to learn how to parent our children for life.

And godliness.

And remember that TLP is a listener-supported ministry. You can visit truthloveparent .com forward slash donate to learn more.