Witnessing to Mormons part 9: Joseph Smith

Second Timothy 2 15 be diligent to present yourself approved to God a worker who does not need to be ashamed rightly dividing the word of truth

Alpha and Omega ministries presents the dividing line radio broadcast The Apostle Peter commanded all

Christians to be ready to give a defense for the hope that is within us Yet to give this answer with gentleness and reverence

Your host is dr. James White director of Alpha and Omega ministries and an elder at the Phoenix reformed to Baptist Church If you'd like to talk with dr.

White, you can call now by dialing 602 -274 -1360. That's 602 -274 -1360

Or if you're out of the Metro Phoenix dialing area, it's 1 -888 -550 -1360.

That's 1 -888 -550 -1360 And now with today's topic here's

James White and good afternoon Phoenix, my name is Rich Pierce sitting in for dr White today.

He is once again down in Tucson teaching for Golden Gate Theological Seminary and I'm gonna be sitting in for him kind of sort of picking up a little bit where he left off last week

Yes, we're going to be talking about Mormonism once again The last time

I was with you I was going through the book of Abraham and focusing on Joseph Smith's ability to translate reformed

Egyptian hieroglyphics now the one thing I want to do this day this particular show is a little bit different than what

I normally do when I Come in and sit in And I kind of want to throw it out to open phones for the subject of general

Mormonism general Mormonism questions discussion, etc I have some issues that I want to talk about and I will be kind of Introducing the show going into them regarding the person of Joseph Smith and who he was

What his origins were what his background was and well some shall we say interesting things in his checkered past as well as his checkered life and which is all in the past, but One of the things that I wish 2020 hindsight ladies and gentlemen,

I really wish that I would have done this week But circumstances didn't allow me to do that and I found out after the fact that I had missed it

PBS aired this week a television documentary as it were called the

American prophet the story of Joseph Smith and One of the things I would like to talk about with you today

Is if you had a chance to see that show because I didn't I did not get a chance to see that show

I did not get a chance to go through it I'm gonna be reading a little bit information from a gentleman

I respect a great deal who who did get to see it and wrote a shall we say an editorial on it and I will be reading that shortly, but today's

Today's show is going to depend a great deal on your participation I need to have you folks that have been following with us for years that are familiar with our

Mormonism ministry and Are familiar with this particular subject of Joseph Smith and hopefully got a chance to see the show call in and Shall you shall we say share with me your thoughts and share with?

Phoenix and the nation over the internet your thoughts on the show and how you think it was portrayed

I'll be honest with you. I've seen a number of different Secular programs done

Discussing Mormonism. I saw a movie a few years ago that I thought was fairly well done starring

Charles Bronson Where he was a newspaper investigator and got went through investigations of some

Mormon offshoot groups that were still performing blood atonement that were doing all kinds of interesting things to one another and he was investigating a murder that had taken place regarding one of the leaders of one of these groups and again, we believe talked about blood atonement in the past and the implications of that but to get into mr.

McIver's evaluation of this of this program I received fortunately in the mail yesterday his

His newsletter called Mormonism researched a little plug here for him because I think he deserves it

He is the head of Mormonism research ministry out of El Cajon, California If you want to look up their website, they are at www .mrm

.org And he goes on here some Some comments that I highlighted here in his commentary tracing the story back to the beginning

The film comments on the religious excitement that was taking place at the time of Smith's first vision

Only the 1838 official account is referenced he's speaking of a gentleman named

Alan Oaks who is one of the Apostles of the Mormon Church and Oaks goes on here.

Let me turn the page Let's see here States that the resistance

Smith faced by the religious leaders of his day was due to the fact that their motives were

Tainted says Oaks words like jealousy and envy and threat and resentment come quickly to mind

The possibility that this immediate resentment was based on the fact that Smith was making claims contrary to the

Bible is never given plausibility He later goes on to say that the film ignores the fact that this

Mormon scripture It has that Mormon scripture has undergone several revised revisions and that it does not teach the necessary Precepts modern

Mormons believe that they they must practice in order to achieve celestial glory

Condemnation against the Book of Mormon and even Smith himself comes through the mouths of Smith's enemies

None of the particular arguments that drew them to these conclusions are discussed so already he's kind of going into something that well oftentimes we hear and I think

PB PBS as I recall a few years ago did a program on the migration of the

Mormons from from the Midwest out into Utah and again the

Persecutions the opposition that the Mormons face Well, these folks are are bitter people.

They they're resenting they resent Joseph Smith. They resent The Mormon Church this new religion that started up they have jealousy they have envy they're threatening these kinds of terms are given to the motivations of the people who were

Contrary to the Mormon movement early on to Joseph Smith's claims early on In as he goes on here on the last page or next to the last page this one's lengthy but I think it's very telling in in what it does say and the things that are very much missing apparently missing if you're familiar with Joseph Smith's Genuine history the film dares not to venture into the relationship

Smith had with his wife Many Mormons have been led to believe that they had an ideal marriage

Van Wagner and he's speaking of Richard Van Wagner who wrote a book and this is what he's quoting from called

Sidney Rigdon Sidney Rigdon portrait of a religious excess where he's

Van Wagner's talking about this a multitude Van Wagner notes the following on page 293 of this book a multitude of Mormon records provides irrefutable evidence for Smith's prerogative with an array of women many of them just a few years older than his own children and while the

Prophet now stands astride the Mormon world like a Colossus in Nauvoo he maneuvered within the charisma of his own mystique to defy both

Church Nauvoo City and Illinois marriage laws as well as to conceal his behavior from his wife

Emma this equivalent equivocal deportment secreted by a deferential and circumspect group of men and women

Created two cultures in Nauvoo one where monogamy and fidelity prevailed the other where Eros and duplicity seemed to subvert the highest moral values and where Exonerating the

Lord's anointed became more important than telling the truth This dichotomy left

Joseph's and Emma's marriage hanging by a thread Emma spent the last three years of her husband's life

Jealously battling his errant yearnings more than once threatening to return to her family in New York unquote

Mr. McKeever goes on several Mormon historians discuss an event where Emma Smith taught and caught her husband alone in the

Quote hey Mo unquote with their 19 year old maidservant Fannie Warren Fannie Ward Alger on Page 10 of his book

Mormon polygamy van Wagner writes that there was a sexual relationship seems probable

Okay, fine. Some have argued that she became Smith's first secret plural wife

Promising the salvation of her family Smith also tried to secretly turning the page here

Marry the 15 year old daughter of his associate Heber C Kimball He also hit on the 19 year old daughter of Sydney Rigdon.

She rebuffed his advances This is the man of whom Gordon Hinckley says

I reverence him. I respect him. I admire him I honor him in June of 1844 several dissidents joined to print the

Nauvoo Expositor a newspaper that exposed the American prophets plural wife system as the town's mayor

Joseph Smith led the Nauvoo City Council to order the printing press destroyed along with all the existing copies of the paper

Peck said Illinois Governor Tom This is a Gregory Peck as he's playing the role in the movie

I guess Illinois Governor Thomas Ford intervened issued an arrest warrant and ordered

Joseph to turn himself in at Carthage the Hancock County seat Joseph Joseph at first refused

Joseph and Hiram were actually planning to flee Nauvoo and head west toward the Rocky Mountains according to the documentary history of the church volume 6 page 549

Emma Smith sent or in Porter Rockwell with a letter urging her husband to return several of Smith's followers accused him of cowardice stating that once he was gone their property would be destroyed and they left with it and They would be left and they left without house and home

States the narration his enemies were not willing to wait for a trial broker a settlement or risk

Joseph somehow Wrestling from their grip their faces daubed with mud and just to disguise their identities

The force stormed the Carthage jail in a flash. They were up the stairs and firing through the door unquote

No mention is made that both Hiram and Joseph had earlier in the day received two smuggled pistols from a friend named

Cyrus we lock also in the cell with Smith brothers were The Smith brothers were

Willard Richards and John Taylor Taylor records that when a musket ball pierced the door and mortally wounded

Hiram Smith Joseph instantly arose with a firm quick step and determined expression of countenance approached the door and pulling the six shooter left by brother wheelock from his pocket opened the door slightly and Snapped the pistol six successive times only three of the barrels.

However were discharged I afterwards understood that two or three were wounded by these discharges two of whom

I am informed died That's from documentary history of the church volume 7 page 103 we wholeheartedly agree with Richard L Bushman when he says even if Joseph Smith Trespassed on American sensibilities about freedom of the press that did not that did not license people to gun him down Despite the concept of frontier justice the attack on Carthage Jail and the killing of Smith was unjustifiable that from Mormonism research ministry

Bill McKeever very well done and that was his That was his impression of the the television show and I'd like to know what your impressions were if you're a

Mormon and you feel That mr. Smith was portrayed in a certain way Positively or negatively,

I'd like you to give us a call 1 -800 -550 -1360 I'm sorry, that's one triple eight five five zero thirteen sixty and if you're in the local

Phoenix dialing area we're at 602 -274 -1360 and Our first caller is calling in from Fresno, California Mike how are you today?

Great? Thank you Yes, my question is is there a high suicide rate among Mormon missionaries?

I think it's an excellent question. I do want to ask you a question before I answer it though, and it's kind of Well, my question is kind of curious as to what leads you to ask the question in the first place

Was there something you watched? Well, I had heard from some I don't have all the data in front of me as far as why

I You know believe that it was just reading various unconfirmed reports That didn't substantiate it with you know, any information there was some anecdotal reports that I had read about it

And I was just wondering how real it was Well, I'll give you I'll give you an alpha to make a ministry standard answer on this question because we hear it a lot

And it's not necessarily about Mormon missionaries, but Mormon youth in general a

One of the first films ever to be released In in my adult lifetime that I've ever heard of was a film called the

Godmakers. Are you familiar with that film? Yes, okay, and in the Godmakers one of the issues that is brought up is

Kind of this well, you know, they've got this really high suicide rate among youth up in Utah and It's a sensational thing to do it's a sensational thing to say because when the numbers are measured up Utah is really no no different than the rest of the nation

Utah is no really different than if you will even evangelical Christianity when it comes to this issue and and youth

The fact is is they blend right in with the norm. I don't know anything about missionaries having this problem

Quite frankly the number of missionaries that I've talked with I would be quite shocked

One of the things that it takes to be a Mormon missionary for two years out there, especially in this country and dealing with the kind of folks that Hopefully more and more evangelical

Christians are becoming more knowledgeable about Mormonism Mormon teachings and are better prepared to give an answer

But I have I've sat in front of Mormon missionaries who clearly Their faith was rocked

After our presentation and after our talking with them I've seen Mormon missionaries just jokingly after listening to dr.

White to go on for a half an hour So one of them jokingly took his badge and threw it across the room.

That was funny and we all laughed But their next question was well, what do we do now? But even in those circumstances

To my knowledge the missionaries finished their mission and that's a tough thing to do When you don't believe that the

Mormon Church is the true church So in a lot of ways what they find themselves what we found that they do is they kind of?

Reel back into what we call the Mormon testimony trying to reaffirm their belief in the

Mormon Church despite whatever doubts we've placed in their minds and So oftentimes when we talk with them, we kind of take the approach of look, you know

Let's give you some books or maybe we can send them to you after you're off your mission Listen, we know you're busy.

We know you've got two years on this mission and we don't expect you to read them right now But if you would just kind of tuck them away when you're done with your mission when you get a chance to kind of reflect back on all that's happened on your mission

Give the book a read And consider because oftentimes what happens is they really don't let that guard down until after they're off their mission

So I would be really surprised given my experience with the temperament and the the mindset that the missionaries have

That that that would be an issue. I also felt somewhat the same way and that's why I was mentioning that it was all anecdotal

Yeah, you know a nature and I really appreciate a You know rational answer in regard to that and one that you know doesn't necessarily attack them, you know personally

You know my opinion on And this is basically Alpha Omega's evaluation of the

God makers and much more. So the God makers to is that it it got into some sensational stuff and left some important information out and I think it's important for us who are involved in In this kind of ministry to be able to to say that and to be able to say

To folks because there you don't know how many times we run into Mormons were there talking with them and they go

Well, you just be you've been watching the God makers too many times, you know, and there's just all this false information in there, etc and I don't know that it's necessarily false, but it's more innuendo and a better way of Presenting that information regarding Mormon youth in my opinion would have been to say look this is an organization that Claims a tremendous amount of the population of the state of Utah and Utah has this high this this suicide rate that's right there within the norm of the rest of the country

Now if this is the one true Church If this is God's anointed

Church You follow my direction here. Yes that you would expect the suicide rate to be less

But you'd be you'd expect it to be remarkably lower, right? You would expect God to be really kind of doing a lot of different things and and given the fact that the the

Mormons Especially in Utah for the most part live the kind of life that the church goes around proclaiming that they live

They're very sweet people. They I they're very sincere. They believe what they believe intently

They do everything within their power to live The life that the Mormon Church has laid out for them to live and You see the difference.

I mean when you talk with You meet someone who's a devout Mormon, you know, this is not a general

Philistine that you run run into at work This is not just somebody that you know, you're gonna encounter on a routine basis that you know

Is like I said a secular kind of individual this some this someone who's very devout

So if that's how different they are in their lives, why is this result just the same as the rest of our society

I Really appreciate this what I consider to be a really sound answer on this and thank you very much

You bet. Thanks for calling Mike. I appreciate your call. You're welcome and Mike's called two seven.

Well, actually Mike called one eight eight eight five five zero thirteen sixty one eight eight eight five five zero

Thirteen sixty we'd like to hear from you today in a discussion on general Mormonism just kind of looking at the

Question and answers that Christians have for it. If you're LDS, I'd like to talk with you today

And I get like to get your impressions from whoever about the issue of the book

American Prophet the story of Joseph Smith and see what you thought of the movie

Like I said, I didn't get a chance to to see it but from Bill McIver's perspective it does sound like a lot was left out of The life of Joseph Smith that in my opinion as well as shared by.

Mr. McIver is pivotal in understanding who Joseph Smith was and the deception that really he perpetrated on on well -meaning people and Just to get into that and start discussing it you may want to know well if you didn't see the movie

And I don't know if they went into all this information, but his origins Where did Joseph Smith come from? Who is this guy?

And how is it that all this stuff came about? Well, first of all,

Joseph Smith was born on December 23rd 1805 in Sharon Windsor County, Vermont now

Keeping up with the the the Smith family as they moved around is very important And I don't want to get it too deep into it today

But in a future show when I get to substitute for dr. White I'm going to delve into the first division and you've heard if you've talked about Mormonism at all you are familiar with the first vision story of Joseph Smith and all the things that go along with that that is predominantly the foundation of Mormonism if the first vision didn't take place the rest of it falls like a house of cards and So as we go through this we understand that Joseph Smith was born just before Christmas on 8 in 1805 his family moved to a town called

Palmyra in New York in 1815 They then moved to Manchester in 1890 19

He was the fourth of nine Children and one of the things that folks on both sides of the fence liked to go after Joseph Smith whether positively or negatively

Was the fact that he had very little formal education. It's my understanding that Joseph Smith Essentially had a fourth grade education from the

Mormon perspective. That's a really good thing how can a man with such little education accomplish so much and from the

Critical perspective of Joseph Smith we sit back and say it explains a lot.

It explains a lot of Joseph Smith's actions and his writings and his abilities

His character is Unfortunately, his character is said to be that of the highest according to the

Mormon perspective on the issue. There's a couple of quotes here I'll be honest with you.

I I don't have Journal of Discourses in my possession anymore.

I have given the volumes away It's a 26 volume set and has very valuable Valuable quotations in it

We've gone to the LDS collectors library for our quotations, which has all that in there and I was looking around in dr

White's library this morning for the CD so that I could get a couple of quotes that I didn't have in my manual here and They were not there and the character quote from the

Mormon perspective Journal of Discourses volume 14 page 203 if you have it I Can't get a hold of because I couldn't find the

CD So I'm kind of at a little bit of a loss here, but I do have some other quotes for you Regarding Joseph Smith from Journal of Discourses volume 7 page 289

Joseph Smith holds the keys of this last dispensation and is now engaged behind the veil in the great work of the last days

No man or woman in this dispensation will ever Enter into the celestial kingdom of God without the consent of Joseph Smith From the day that the priesthood was taken from the earth to the winding up of the scene of all

To the winding up of the scene winding up the scene of all things every man and woman must have the certificate of Joseph Smith jr.

as a passport to their entrance into the mansion where God and Christ are so as as a pivotal decision maker in your salvation as a

Mormon he is Absolutely crucial I guess would be a way to to put that from Journal of Discourses volume 8 page 223 in fact, let me throw this out see if I can't get the phone lines lit up with this

There are some of you part of Alpha Omega Ministries who have the Journal of Discourses set that I gave you

You know who you are and I'm kind of hoping that you'll give a call to area code 602 274 1360 and read for us a quote from Journal of Discourses volume 7 page 289 as well as one from Journal of Discourses volume 14.

It would be very helpful Journal of Discourses volume 8 page 223 every intelligent person under the heavens that does not when informed

Acknowledge that Joseph Smith jr. Is a prophet of God is in darkness and is opposed to us and Jesus And his kingdom on earth

What do you suppose I think of them? They cannot conceive their own degradation if they could they would turn away from their wickedness

I know them, but they do not approach They do not know me. We live in an atmosphere

They do not approach they have not ability to this to see the path We walk in and I believe that that quote is from Brigham Young Part of my notes and one of the things

I was hoping to do with this set this morning was to be able to nail Down the source of the quotes and whose sermons it was from I had written that in another version

I couldn't find this morning Journal of Discourses volume 9 page 312 In the first epistle of John it is written beloved believe not every spirit

But try the spirits whether they are from God because many false prophets are gone out into the world hereby know ye

That the Spirit of God the Spirit of God every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God and every spirit that confesseth not

That Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God and that is the spirit of Antichrist wherever you have heard

That it should come and even now is already in the world This is no test to this generation for all men of the

Christian world confess that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh This generation however is not left without a test

I have taught for 30 years and still teach that he that believeth in his heart and confesseth that With his mouth that Jesus is the

Christ and that Joseph Smith is his prophet to this generation is of God and he that confesseth

Not that Jesus has come in the flesh and sent Joseph Smith with the fullness of the gospel to this generation is not of God But is

Antichrist all can who confess that Joseph Smith is sent of God in the latter days to lay the foundation of his everlasting

Kingdom no more to be thrown down and will continue to keep his commandments are born of God So we're gonna go ahead and take a break real quick here

My board op is over there quickly screening calls because I'm normally the guy screening calls

We're gonna go ahead and take a break on the dividing line. We will be right back And we're back on the dividing line today, my name is

Rich Pierce and I'm sitting in for dr James White today who is actually on the phone line with us right now, you know

James I know what you're gonna say. It's gonna be I told you so Something along something along those lines.

You always warned me always keep a hardcopy set of the journals around And here

I was gonna tell you the CDs are in the CD case right next to the computer

Get in the car and I'm heading back to Phoenix after a teaching and and all of a sudden

I hear well I was going to look this up And it's like oh, please

I understand that the person who has the set that I gave away Called and said, yeah,

I'd love to look that up for you But it's really hard to do that when I don't carry them in the car with me We both know who that is and I don't carry the set with me either especially in rental cars, but it is all there and Of course people immediately go

Oh Journal of Discourses Journal of Discourses but as we noticed last week in citing from the temple preparation manual

The Mormon Church doesn't mind quoting from the Journal of Discourses When what is taught there remains consistent with what they believe today?

Absolutely, but when it's a doctrine, they'd rather not have people discussing all of a sudden Their apologists are all over the fact as well, you know, we're not sure about the

Journal of Discourses and you know, we're not totally certain of the Accuracy and all the rest of stuff and there's a real double standard as being being used there

But everyone who's talked to me about that film has said the same thing that it It really presented

Joseph Smith and a very positive light That there was really no interaction with the information about there and that shouldn't surprise us

PBS is going to Drink deeply at the well of our society which says

You cannot judge anything because you have no moral stance to begin with and so let's not talk about his

Introduction of polygamy let's not talk about the time that His wife beat on him with a broom when she found out actually beat on the who was it that Joseph Smith read?

section 132 the Doctrine and Covenants to I think it may have been Hiram and I'd have to look at it and Said well, you know,

I Emma needs to be told of this and Joseph Smith like How you doing, I'm not gonna do it you'll do it

And she beat him out of the house with a with a broom when he tried to read it to her So that kind of stuff you you shouldn't expect

PBS is going to Barely address because they know that they're going to be accused of being quote unquote negative anti whatever else it might be

That's just the fact that you can't any longer be honest with history in our society Without being accused of being unloving unkind so on and so forth and Really just a manifestation of that.

So all those citations are on the CD. That is next to the computer in my office

Hopefully I won't find all my books on the floor when I get back there Anyways, but anyhow appreciate the work on the other citations and I just wanted to give you a ring and Bring up a couple of issues.

Okay. Well, thanks for giving us a call today James. All right and We're gonna go to our next caller right away and we're gonna go to Jill in Mesa.

How are you today Jill? How are you? I do need you to speak up so everybody can hear you real well

Yes Yes, I have you've personally read it.

Mm -hmm. Have you studied it? Well, I've read it. And yeah, I've browsed through it. I Understand certain quotes, etc.

But have you read every word? Yes Mm -hmm. Well, there is a promise in the

Book of Mormon. Mm -hmm. We're on a 10 what 30 1045 We're on I 10 4 & 5

I've had missionaries present that to me a number of times and I've I've pointed out that it is a conditional point of view that if I do all these things if each of the points that That are made there and I don't happen to have the

Book of Mormon right in front of me because we are talking about Joseph Smith today, but general Mormonism as well but The interesting thing is is that then?

Is Are these things? Gonna happen. Okay, then it's sufficient

It has to be after all these other things then it'll take place and the point is that The Bible doesn't do that.

The Bible points out that grace is a free thing Ephesians 2 8 through 10 that it is a work of God That it is a free gift of God and it is not a matter of works that you prepare yourself in advance to do

And have taken care of all these things and then once you've taken care of them then God then his grace is sufficient for you

What more what's more is is that the Book of Mormon is monotheistic It does not teach a plurality of gods.

Were you aware of that? Oh Mm -hmm. Yes, I believe in the

Book of Mormon. Well, do you believe in the Doctrine and Covenants as well? Doctrine and Covenants section 132 Plural are

I believe it's section 130 verse 22 where it talks about the plurality of gods Why are you spending your time downgrading the

Mormon Church, why don't you spend your precious time if you don't believe it Why don't you spend your precious time?

Teaching the gospel of Jesus Christ From the New Testament, that's a very good question.

I'm glad you asked it Jill the motivation for doing programs like these as well as ones on Jehovah's Witnesses Roman Catholicism and various other groups is much like a circumstance where if you were to Foresee that someone was a about to walk out in the street in front of a car

They were walking in there in danger You would have an obligation to warn them to do whatever you could to save them from impending doom

Okay Well, can I at least finish answering your question, all right, okay, so ultimately

We do these kinds of programs and we do what we do We go out to if you've ever been out to the Easter pageant in Mesa You've probably encountered our group out there passing out tracks.

I don't know if you've ever done that but We do what we do because we care

Okay, it's very serious to us. It is something that we honestly believe in our heart of hearts that the

Word of God Well, I guess Jill wasn't real happy with where I was going with this so we'll move on to Richard in Phoenix.

How are you today Richard? How you doing? All right. I had that volume 7 in my hand I do carry around with me

Glad to hear somebody does We're looking for a quotation from page 289 and the thing about these quotations is is that they are not always

Not always the whole page they're a segment, so I can't tell you which paragraph okay is particular here but it has to do with the character of Joseph Smith and I'm not sure if you were able to pick some information out there to share with us.

Sure Joseph Smith holds the keys of this last dispensation and is now engaged behind the veil in the great work of the last days

Oh, you know what? I just realized that was a mistype and I did in fact read that. Oh, you did

Okay, do you have volume 14 there? It's it's in the other room I do but what I did not read was volume 14 page 203.

Let me put you on hold rich I'll pick you up on the other side of the break. Sure, and we'll we'll read that quote.

Hang on. Okay, and we're gonna go to Gentleman by the name of Brandon in Salt Lake City, Utah I have to tell you something folks about Brandon.

I met Brandon in Salt Lake this last general conference he is a fiery young man who is a former

Mormon himself and He is very zealous to see people like Jill come to know the truth that he's come to know.

How are you today, Brandon? I'm great. I really didn't know if you'd remember me or not, sir I do have

I did have the My CD with me Discourses, it looks like you already have a volunteer on that.

Yes, I'm gonna go ahead with a different question. I had. Okay, shoot Okay, are you familiar with Stan Larson's book quest for the gold plate?

I'm afraid I'm not I'm afraid I'm not Well, maybe maybe you'll be

Familiar with what it's talking about. Okay, go ahead It's a book about the life of Thomas Stewart Ferguson, mm -hmm a

Book of Mormon archaeologist born and died a Mormon He had a really strong testimony of what he believed

He went on he got I mean the church turned him down for money.

Mm -hmm to start his organization to start archaeological search, right and He went on and started it by himself

Off of private donations. Mm -hmm What ended up happening the church finally took over?

They they gave him a fairly small assignment in it. They they turned it over to the then Apostle Howard W Hunter.

Mm -hmm And and it was called the New World Archaeological You ever heard of that? I'm afraid

I haven't I in my studies haven't dug that deep into the issue of archaeology

In Mormonism, it's been more theological and some history like for instance the history of Joseph Smith, but Go ahead and share your thoughts here.

All right. Well, my thought was that his end result he died not believing in the

History of the Book of Mormon. He thought is in the end of 19th century literature. Mm -hmm

I I have to tell you I've heard of a number of I've heard mentioned a number of Archaeologists or scholars in the

BYU arena who Honestly don't believe Mormonism to be true.

It's more their life. It's more their family Exactly. He died. Um more or less.

I would call him an atheist. He said in many letters that That no, no God existed that it was all for you know help

Mm -hmm and that and so and if you were gonna believe in a religion, why not the

Mormon Church as you know Great programs and as such and that was his dying view

But what the book doesn't go on to say in the end is whatever happened to the the New World Archaeological Foundation or where it went on to and that's that's what

I was going to ask you. It was turned over to farms. I Really wouldn't know

My best guess given farms current status within the church and it's up -and -coming

Situation Hang on just a second Brandon because I may have an answer here For you boy,

I tell you they're just calling in from all over the place This is one way to to get calls online I guess you just feign ignorance and folks will come in to help you out.

Hang on just a second Brandon James. I Understand you have an answer here Brandon's been asked a few questions about those issues

Thomas Stuart Ferguson, I think is a fascinating study in a Mormon scholar and a person who was very very important in the really,

I think in in farms even coming into existence as far as the The push on the part of Mormonism to establish a scholarly basis in history for the

Book of Mormon his Defection from the faith in essence, especially on the basis of the

Book of Abraham as well as the lack of archaeological evidence Is I think? Something the modern

Mormon Church would like to very much hide now between the delay In my calling in and turning off the radio

I didn't catch the substance of Brandon's question go ahead and ask it go ahead and ask it Brandon because I have you conference together

All right Hey, what it was was that the book its end result

It talks about him going out starting the New World Archaeological Foundation by himself without support from the church

After he found what he believed would be would turn into substantial evidence in a few years and pleading for money

Spencer W Kimball Gave agreed to the first presidency gave him money for the work

It actually eventually turned into a Church run operation I understood it was he was given a relatively small job taking off from the president of it and it was given to Howard W Hunter as the leader of the program, but what the book the book being a more or less a biography of the archaeological studies of Ferguson doesn't go past his death.

And so it doesn't really Go on to say whatever happened to the

New World Archaeological Foundation Yeah, I'm not sure what happened to it The assumption would be in light of the fact that farms has now become a part of Brigham Young University And hence is in in essence now an official organ one way or the other that if there was any substance to be passed on as far as monetarily research projects

Publications or whatever that that would be made available, but there's a my gut feeling is there's a there's a tremendous amount of embarrassment in regards to Ferguson and as you know

The church's modus operandi is generally when something like that has happened. Let it die a quiet death and Move on and don't don't do anything to a point back to to the to the embarrassment, right?

I would imagine they're probably just burying as much of that stuff as as it possible. All right.

Well, thanks Thanks for giving us a call today Brandon and James sure appreciate the rescue there.

Yeah. All right. Take care gentlemen. Thank you And we're gonna go to another break here and we'll have just a few minutes on the other end of the break to wrap this

Up, we'll be back on the dividing line And We're back on the dividing line, my name is

Rich Pierce sitting in for dr White today's sort of kind of he's come to the rescue a couple of times out on the highway there on his cell phone

So I appreciate that We're gonna continue on here Richard have you had a chance to find that quote for me?

Yes, I think I have 14 page 203. Yes, sir. Share that with us well now examine the character of the

Savior and examine the characters of those who have written the Old and New Testaments and then compare them with the character of Joseph Smith the founder of this work the man whom

God called into whom he gave the keys of priesthood and through whom he had established his church and kingdom for the last time and you will find that his character stands as Fair as that of any other man mentioned in the

Bible We can find no person who presents a better character to the world when the facts are known Than Joseph Smith jr.

The Prophet and his brother Hyrum Smith who was murdered with him Very good quote, and I appreciate you looking that up for me today

Richard. You're welcome. All right. Take care That given the environment here and this show today has gone much quicker than I thought it would be

But I want to share a couple of things for you. First of all, perhaps you were not aware that Joseph Smith was convicted of something in 1826 and I have the document from the what's called the trial bill

In front of me and also there is something that he was carrying in his pocket on the day He died that says something about where things came from and we can kind of dovetail this into the a future show on Where the first vision how the first vision came about as well as how we got the

Book of Mormon how the Book of Mormon? Came about but I want to read quickly because we are really short on time here

This is the text from the state of New York. This is the trial bill state of New York versus Joseph Smith And you can find a copy of this if you've ever seen two things

Let's see here Joseph Smith's Bainbridge, New York court trials pamphlet published by a duck by Wesley P Walters Reverend Walters He has in his life.

He has Passed away to be Lord now, but he is He was instrumental in digging up a lot of historical information and facts and cross referencing those facts with things that the the

Smith's claimed to be true or mr. Smith claimed to be true in his day and yet here after the first vision has taken place after the second vision has taken place and as I recall shortly before the third vision

This takes place warrant issued upon written complaint upon oath of mist of Peter G Bridgman who informed that one

Joseph Smith of Bainbridge was a disorderly person and an imposter prisoner brought before court

March 20th 1826 prisoner examined says that he came from the town of Palmyra and That he had been at the house of Josiah Stowell in Bainbridge most of the time since had small of time been employed by said

Stowell on his farm and Going to school that he had a certain stone Which he had occasionally looked at to determine where hidden treasures in the bowels of the earth were now if this confuses you a little bit folks it's gonna clear up a little bit when we tell the story from David Whitmer's perspective of How the

Book of Mormon came to be translated? Let's see here and that he professed to tell in this manner where gold mines were a distance underground and Looked for mr.

Stowell several times and had informed him where he could find these treasures and mr. Stowell had been engaged in digging for them that at Palmyra he pretended to tell by looking at this stone where coined money was buried in Pennsylvania and While at Palmyra had frequently ascertained in that way where lost property was

Various kinds that he had occasionally been in the habit of looking through this stone to find lost property for three years

But of late had pretty much given up on account of its injuring his health Especially his eyes making them sore that he did not solicit business of this kind and had always rather declined having

Anything to do with this business Joseph Smith was convicted in this trial And in fact folks the fact is is that Joseph Smith was convicted in this trial?

Because he pled guilty to glass looking he is in fact written up in the trial bill

As being Joseph Smith the glass looker and Let's see here.

I'm trying to quickly Get to a testimony and address to all believers in Christ From David Whitmer page 12

I will now give you a description of the manner in which the Book of Mormon was translated Joseph Smith would put the seer stone.

Hmm sound familiar Into a hat and put his face in the hat drawing it closely around his face to exclude the light and in the darkness the spiritual light would shine a piece of something resembling parchment would appear and On that appeared the writing one character at a time would appear and under it was the interpretation in English Brother Joseph would read off the

English to Oliver Cowdery who was his principal scribe and when it was written down and repeated to Brother Joseph to see if it was correct

Then it would disappear and another character with the interpretation would appear Thus the

Book of Mormon was translated by the gift and power of God and not by any power of man that according to Mr.

David Whitmer is is how the Book of Mormon came to be about I came about and folks that's called

Glass looking or necromancy. It is condemned in the Old Testament as witchcraft.

It is a pagan at best Practice and certainly is no method by which the

God of the Bible would conduct himself now some Mormons may argue that Joseph Smith gave all this up That he was no longer involved in witchcraft and they those who will acknowledge the fact that he was

Involved in witchcraft in his early life. They say well, he surrendered all this stuff and he you know

It took him a little time, but he got rid of it I'm looking at a pamphlet a a tract that Alpha Omega Ministries has produced.

We It's somewhat of a little -known tract But it is a tract called

Why was Joseph Smith carrying this in his pocket on the day? He died and I've only got a very little bit of time to to tell you about this

But I will tell you this if you'll go to www .aomin .org And email us there.

I will send you for free a copy of this tract free of charge and So you can look it over for yourself.

And so The point of the tract is that the Joseph Smith was carrying here

I'll just read it for you here real quick because I do have a few seconds the object pictured is known as a Jupiter talisman, it is an occultic talisman used in magic and Talks about dr.

Reed Durham giving an evaluation of this. This was by the way found in the vaults of the Mormon Church and As something that he had on his person when he when he died and it goes on into the practice

So the point is of all of this despite the nature of what the Mormon Church may say about Joseph Smith, the fact is he was involved in witchcraft his entire life and According to David Whitmer.

That's how the Book of Mormon came to be. We're out of time for today's dividing line Dr. White should be back with us next week and we can talk about this subject more

Thank you for listening in today The dividing line is a presentation of Alpha and Omega ministries.

You can contact us at 602 973 0 3 1 8 or you can write us at PO box 3 7 1 0 6,

Phoenix, Arizona 8 5 0 6 9 we are easy to find on the world wide web at www .aomin

.org That's www .aomin .org You can also find a complete listing of James White's books tapes debates and tracks on our website