Does Jesus’ Command to “Freely Give” Apply Today?

Selling Jesus

Subscribe

Download

Share

10

00:00

People often attempt to justify the Jesus trade by dismissing the command of Christ in Matthew 10 .8

00:05

as irrelevant to Christians today. They say that the command to freely give just doesn't apply to us anymore, so we can sell the spiritual and the sacred without any problem now.

00:16

In this episode, Conley Owens addresses the issue and argues that the command of Christ does indeed apply to us today.

00:24

Conley is the author of The Dorian Principle, a biblical response to the commercialization of Christianity, and is a pastor at Silicon Valley Reformed Baptist Church.

00:46

Does Jesus' command to freely give apply today? That is the question before us.

00:53

If you're unfamiliar with this command, in Matthew 10 .8, Jesus said, freely you receive, freely give.

00:59

One modern translation puts it a little differently, saying, you receive without paying, give without pay.

01:06

So many, including myself, have taken this as a clear indication that no minister should ever charge for ministry.

01:13

More particularly, this command continues to regulate biblical instruction today, forbidding teachers from selling biblical teaching.

01:22

I'm not limiting this just to sermons. I believe it instead extends even to things like gospel conferences, seminaries,

01:31

Christian literature, et cetera. Now that is not to say that ministry should not be financially supported.

01:37

It should. In fact, in the next two verses, Jesus explains that ministers are to be supported, saying a worker is worthy of his food.

01:47

However, this support is supposed to come through generous partners rather than sales of biblical teaching.

01:54

In the case of those initial disciples, it was to come through a worthy house, as it says in Matthew 10, 11 through 12, or a son of peace, as it says in Luke 10, six through seven, both of those passages referring to similar instances of Jesus sending out the disciples.

02:12

It's supposed to come from these worthy houses or sons of peace, because these are the ones who would support kingdom proclamation rather than coming from hearers in exchange for kingdom proclamation.

02:26

Now that is a very sound interpretation of these passages. But of course, there are many others who have rejected this interpretation.

02:34

They argue that descriptive passages should not be read prescriptively.

02:39

And it's true. A narrative passage that contains a command does not necessarily imply that the us today.

02:47

For example, in Jeremiah 13, one, the Lord tells Jeremiah to buy a loincloth.

02:52

Yet this does not mean that we should also buy a loincloth. So if Jesus tells the disciples to freely give, why does this necessarily imply that we must freely give?

03:03

The primary key in biblical interpretation is context. Does the context really indicate that this command applies to Christians today?

03:13

While narratives are definitionally descriptive, we must be prepared to recognize qualities or patterns that imply prescription.

03:23

Scripture is full of narrative and an approach that fails to find implications for the believer today and narrative fails to truly understand its message, especially given the words of second

03:34

Timothy three 16, all scripture is God breathe and is useful for instruction, for conviction, for correction, and for training in righteousness.

03:44

For example, acts two 42 says of the early Christians that they devoted themselves to the apostles teaching and to the fellowship and to the breaking of bread and to prayer.

03:56

Given that this passage describes the foundation and character of the fledgling church, the modern church should devote itself to such things as well.

04:06

Even if many aspects of acts two, speaking in tongues, mass baptisms, et cetera, are not normative for the church today.

04:15

We have an obligation to follow scripture to its logical conclusions. Consider for a moment, this obligation in light of Jesus's frequent question, have you not read and speaking to the

04:26

Sadducees Jesus argues for the resurrection on the grounds that God said he is the

04:33

God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and that he is not the God of the dead, but of the living.

04:39

Now, do those two portions of revelation when combined actually argue for the resurrection?

04:45

Apart from Jesus's words, I think most people would be ready to say something like maybe, but the safe approach is to not take scripture too far.

04:55

But according to Jesus, that's not the case at all. According to him, refusing to see the implication of scripture is just as dangerous as taking it too far.

05:07

Between these two ditches of finding prescriptions where they don't exist and failing to see them where they do, there is no superior ditch.

05:17

So let us follow scripture to its logical conclusions, what are often called the good necessary consequences of scripture.

05:24

The good and necessary consequence of Matthew 10, 8 is not merely that first century kingdom proclamation must not be sold, but the 21st century kingdom proclamation must not be sold.

05:38

While it may seem a bit backwards, I'd like to start with objections and then afterward build a positive case for the idea that Jesus's command regulates ministry today.

05:49

That is, I'm going to begin by defending the face value meaning of Matthew 10, 8 before positively arguing for it.

05:58

I'll proceed in this way because I truly do believe that the burden of proof lies on those who would reject its face value meaning that when

06:06

Jesus says we should freely give, it really means we should freely give. All right.

06:12

The first objection, objection number one, freely give only applies to miracles, not preaching or teaching.

06:20

So if you read Matthew 10, 8 in full, it says, heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse the lepers, drive out demons, freely you have received, freely give.

06:32

The rest of the imperatives in this verse are commands to perform miracles. It would seem that the command freely give or give without pay speak specifically of miracles, not preaching or other forms of ministry.

06:48

Now, for the sake of transparency, I want to mention that there are indeed a host of respectable

06:53

Christian theologians, especially beginning in the 17th century who have promoted this particular interpretation that the command to freely give only applies to miracles.

07:04

However, in my research on this matter, almost every theologian that has taken this position was contending with or trying to distance themselves from Quakers or Anabaptists more generally.

07:17

Many Anabaptist groups have historically rejected the idea that ministers should have regular financial support.

07:24

And they often used this verse to promote their rejection of salaried ministers.

07:30

The Orthodox contending with the heterodox found it easy to appeal to the miraculous context.

07:37

Now I support salaried ministry, ministry regular supported by financial partnership with other

07:44

But I do not believe this to be the best response to that contention. Matthew 10 8 does indeed speak of miracles, but Jesus' instructions to the disciples do not begin there.

07:57

Rather, He explains their activity in the preceding verse, Matthew 10 7.

08:03

As you go, preach this message. The kingdom of heaven is near. While it has a different nature than the various commands to perform miracles, it belongs in the same list.

08:15

The disciples are to freely do all of the above. Just as they are to freely perform miracles, they are to freely proclaim the kingdom of heaven.

08:25

In other words, they are to freely proclaim the gospel. All right.

08:31

Objection number two. Freely give only applies to the first mission, not subsequent ones.

08:37

Many have stated that this command of Christ is only for the first mission of the disciples.

08:43

One simple response is that this is not the only mission where Jesus instructs His disciples to freely give.

08:50

At the end of the gospels, He sends out His disciples and presses this command even further.

08:56

Let me explain this by way of comparison. At their first mission in Matthew 10 9 through 10,

09:03

Jesus said, do not carry any gold or silver or copper in your belts, no bag for your journey, nor two tunics or sandals or a staff, for the laborer deserves his food.

09:15

In other words, while He said they shouldn't charge for their message, He made provisions for their support saying, take no money bag.

09:22

In other words, they are not supposed to take extra funds with them because they are supposed to expect others to support them.

09:29

Later on, when Jesus sends out the disciples a final time in Luke 22 35 through 36,

09:35

Jesus says, when I sent you out without purse or bag or sandals, did you lack anything?

09:42

Nothing, they answered. Now, however, He told them, the one with a purse should take it and likewise a bag, and the one without a sword should sell his cloak and buy one.

09:52

In other words, while He does not repeat the command not to charge for their ministry, He goes even further by telling them to take a purse.

10:02

On the first journey, they were not to charge, but they at least were to expect support, not needing a bag of money.

10:09

When they finally go out, they are not to expect any financial assistance so that they need to take money.

10:16

Additionally, the first mission is a prototypical mission. What I mean by that is that it is designed to set the example for other missions.

10:26

We should expect that where there is a meaningful overlap with the concerns of subsequent disciples, this mission is particularly designed to establish the pattern for us to follow.

10:39

When discussing evangelism, how often are we willing to go to this passage and glean all that it has for us?

10:46

The notion of shaking the dust from our feet, the command to be as wise as serpents and innocent as doves, the command not to fear man.

10:55

These are all commands that pertain to the first mission, yet we recognize them as applying to all subsequent missions.

11:04

This is because we correctly identify the first mission as the prototypical mission.

11:09

We acknowledge it as designed to set patterns for all subsequent missions.

11:16

What distinguishes the command to freely give from any other aspect we would be willing to apply to evangelism and biblical teaching today?

11:25

I would argue that nothing does. Now, perhaps one might argue that the surrounding commands like raise the dead only apply to the first mission, but I see this as no real rebuttal to the fact that the prototypical mission must set the pattern.

11:42

The Lord is free to do as He pleases in this. He is free to specify some things particular to the first mission, to specify some things that apply to all of them.

11:53

There was a famous Anglican divine named Jeremy Taylor. He wrote that to say freely give only applies to the first mission because the surrounding commands are temporal.

12:05

It's like saying that the Sabbath must still be on Saturday because the other nine commands surrounding the fourth are eternal.

12:12

Moving on, objection number three. This objection says freely give only applies to missions to the lost, not to teaching the saved.

12:23

One might concede that this applies to future missions, but only missions to the lost and not to believers.

12:30

After all, the disciples were sent to share the good news with those who had not heard it.

12:36

Interestingly, Matthew 10 provides the perfect testing ground for this hypothesis.

12:42

Since the first mission was not only to the lost, strictly speaking.

12:48

In verse six, Jesus said, go rather to the lost sheep of Israel. It might be easy to focus on the notion of the lost sheep, but the fact of the matter is that these were the visible people of God.

13:02

They were the people who had been entrusted with the oracles of God. According to Romans three, two, they were the people who had heard the gospel preached beforehand to Abraham.

13:14

According to Galatians three, eight, undoubtedly many of these people trusted in the coming

13:20

Messiah and were the faithful ones the new Testament regards as awaiting the consolation of Israel.

13:27

Given that many in Israel were believers, this command most certainly applies to teaching believers as well.

13:35

Our last objection, number four, this objection says freely give only applies to the gospel, not all biblical teaching.

13:45

Now I hope that my response here satisfies anything that I haven't covered in any of the previous objections.

13:52

All biblical instruction, if rightly understood, is not merely distantly related to the gospel, but directly connected to the gospel.

14:03

Consider that in first Corinthians two, two, Paul says that he decided to know nothing among the

14:09

Corinthians except Christ and him crucified. Yet in Acts 20, 26 through 27, he says that if he neglected any of the counsel of God, blood would be on his hands.

14:23

So when Paul was in Corinth, did he stick only to a handful of quote unquote gospel passages or did he preach the whole counsel of God to the

14:34

Corinthians? It must have been the latter. If that's the case, then the whole counsel of God regards

14:41

Christ and him crucified. It would be improper to so distinguish the gospel and other biblical teachings such that we could charge for one, but not the other.

14:52

Consider also Colossians 1, 25, where Paul says that he became a minister to make the word of God fully known.

15:01

Two verses later in Colossians 1, 27, he describes how he makes the word fully known by proclaiming

15:09

Christ. And in the next chapter, he plainly declares that all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ.

15:18

In other words, to make any part of scripture fully known is to declare

15:24

Christ from the word. Even Jesus himself explained that all of scripture is about him and more particularly his gospel.

15:34

In Luke 24, 44 through 47, it says, Jesus said to them, these are the words

15:41

I spoke to you while I was still with you. Everything must be fulfilled that is written about me and the law of Moses, the prophets and the

15:49

Psalms. Then he opened their minds to understand the scriptures. And he told them, this is what is written.

15:58

The Christ will suffer and rise from the dead on the third day. And in his name, repentance and forgiveness of sins will be proclaimed to all nations beginning in Jerusalem.

16:09

Now, this sort of thing is very important to me and the kind of churches that I've been a part of, but maybe you come from a theological tradition that is not as eager to see

16:19

Christ and the gospel and all of scripture. If you need further persuasion on this point, please check out the wealth of literature that exists on Christocentric hermeneutics.

16:29

My favorite one of that whole lot is Dennis Johnson's, Him We Proclaim. But moving on now to create a hard distinction between the gospel and other biblical teaching is to essentially commit what

16:41

I call the milk meat fallacy. This is the idea that the gospel is the beginning of instruction, but other more advanced teaching is needed for the mature believer.

16:55

However, if you read the texts on milk and meat, like Hebrews 6, one through two, it should be apparent that the milk is not actually the gospel.

17:05

Rather the milk is what scripture also calls the elemental principles, things like laying on of hands, washings, the notion of resurrection, things like that.

17:18

While the meat on the other hand is the understanding of those things in light of the gospel.

17:25

That is the more advanced Christian instruction is, the more directly it is understood in Christ.

17:33

The gospel is meat, not milk. The entire argument there in Hebrews 6 is that in order to avoid falling away, you must ensure that you are saturated in the gospel.

17:46

The teaching of Christ. In the end, if we say the gospel is priceless, but further

17:52

Christian teaching can be offered for a charge, we misunderstand the pervasiveness of the gospel and all of special revelation and all of scripture.

18:03

And by this, we misunderstand the pricelessness of the word of God.

18:10

Now, moving on to some positive cases. Our first one is that the motivation to freely give is eternal and applies to all biblical wisdom.

18:21

My handling of objections has probably made much of my positive case already, but there are still a few things to be said.

18:29

First, Jesus provides a motivation to freely give, and it is one that persists all the way to our generation.

18:37

Jesus does not merely say freely give, but prefaces it with a rationale freely.

18:45

You received this motivation does not apply only to the first disciples.

18:50

It is still the case that we have freely received to quote Jeremy Taylor.

18:55

Again, there is in this command, something that is spiritual and of an eternal decency, rectitude and proportion.

19:05

Do you see what he's saying there? Because the symmetry exists in the command freely, you received freely give because it has such a foundational nature, because it is speaking of a principle.

19:20

It has, he says an eternal decency, rectitude and proportion. That means it still applies even now.

19:29

This does not only apply to the gospel, which has been given to us freely, but to all special revelation, which has been given to us freely.

19:37

One might argue when they teach, they are not offering what they have obtained freely, but what they have learned over much study and many hours of seminary.

19:47

However, no true understanding of scripture is possible through merely natural or secular means.

19:55

Consider the words of first Corinthians two, 12 through 13. We have not received the spirit of the world, but the spirit who is from God, that we may understand what

20:06

God has freely given us. And this is what we speak, not in words taught us by human wisdom, but in words taught by the spirit, expressing spiritual truths and spiritual words.

20:20

Is this not the understanding we are trying to impart? It is not an understanding that is taught naturally, but one that must be taught by the spirit.

20:30

This observation of motivation explains why we are willing to apply other parts of Matthew 10 to Christians today.

20:38

Why be as wise as serpents and innocent as doves? Because we are still sheep in the midst of wolves.

20:45

Why should we anticipate persecution? Because the disciple is still not above his teacher.

20:51

Why should we not fear man? Because man still cannot destroy the soul and we are still of more value than sparrows.

21:00

Likewise, why should we freely give? Because the enlightenment we are trying to impart still is not obtained naturally, but supernaturally.

21:12

Even today in our modern world, the message we have comes from special revelation and the illuminating work of the spirit.

21:21

Second positive case. The rest of the new Testament confirms that we ministers must freely give.

21:29

I believe that one of the best pieces of evidence that the command to freely give applies broadly to biblical instruction, even in our era is its confirmation elsewhere in scripture.

21:40

Now these are numerous and it is beyond the scope of this article to go into all of them, but it's worth listing several here.

21:49

First Corinthians 9 18. What then is my reward that in preaching the gospel,

21:55

I may offer it free of charge and so not use up my rights in preaching it.

22:01

Second Corinthians 11 7. Was it a sin for me to humble myself in order to exalt you because I preach the gospel of God to you free of charge?

22:12

Second Corinthians 2 17. For we are not like so many others who peddle the word of God.

22:19

On the contrary in Christ we speak before God with sincerity as men sent from God.

22:26

Third John 7 and 8. For they went out on behalf of the name accepting nothing from the

22:32

Gentiles. Therefore we ought to support such men so that we may be fellow workers for the truth.

22:39

Each one of those four verses confirms that we are supposed to freely give and there are many others as well.

22:46

This is only a sampling. Positive case number three. History confirms that the command to freely give was not a temporary ethic.

22:56

So it's worth noting that when Jesus said freely you receive freely give, he was not developing an entirely new paradigm for ministry.

23:05

He was largely affirming the pattern that already existed with rabbinical teaching. There is a mountain of scholarly research on rabbinic views of money and ministry at the time of Jesus and much of it is inconclusive.

23:18

But scholars generally agree on the fact that there was a fairly strict ethic that regulated what a rabbi could receive and in what context.

23:30

In the Talmud, Nedarim 37a 2 offers a paraphrased interpretation of Deuteronomy 4 5.

23:37

Just as I teach you for free without payment, so too you also shall teach for free.

23:43

Becker wrote 29a 8 likewise interprets Deuteronomy 4 5 as saying something similar.

23:50

Just as I learned from God for free, so too you learned from me for free.

23:57

That same reference goes on to say that even if one paid for their own training, they should still teach for free.

24:05

To summarize, the fact that there was already a rabbinic ethic that forbade charging for teaching scripture testifies to the fact that Jesus is offering an ongoing ethic that applies to Christian teaching in general, not merely a one -time ethic or something that only applies to one aspect of the

24:25

Christian message. Additionally, the early disciples affirmed the command to freely give as being a continuing injunction.

24:33

The Didache is the oldest known extra -biblical Christian writing in existence, being authored in the first century.

24:41

As far as the New Testament goes, it likely only incorporates Matthew. It even uses the phrase from Matthew 10 10, worthy of his food.

24:49

Chapter 11 of the Didache says, let every apostle, when he cometh to you, be received as a

24:56

Lord, but he shall not abide more than a single day, or, if there be need, a second likewise.

25:03

But if he abide three days, he is a false prophet. And when he departeth, let the apostle receive nothing save bread, until he findeth shelter.

25:14

But if he ask for money, he is a false prophet. And whoever shall say in the spirit, give me silver or anything else, you shall not listen to him.

25:25

So someone who comes and receives too much hospitality, asks for money, takes more than a little bread, and wants this in exchange for teaching, this early

25:35

Christian writing says that he is to be considered a false prophet. Even later in Christian history,

25:43

Matthew 10 8 was frequently referred to in battles against Simony, Simony being the selling of ordinations.

25:50

So if you read Gregory the Great, Jan Hus, John Wycliffe, or countless others that wrote against Simony, you'll see that they almost universally appealed to Matthew 10 8.

26:03

So to argue that this verse applies narrowly to the presentation of the gospel and miracles, but not further

26:10

Christian ministry in our era, is to go against a long history of the interpretation of this verse, amid an important theological controversy even.

26:20

For our final positive case, number four, the nature of the Christian message requires us to freely give.

26:29

The presentation of Christian instruction is reflective of the message itself. Because we have freely received, we should freely give.

26:37

Because special revelation and the salvation that accompanies it has been given freely, it must be offered freely.

26:46

Isaiah summarizes what we find all through the very heart of God's revealed character. Come all you who are thirsty, come to the waters and you without money, come buy and eat, come buy wine and milk without money and without cost.

27:03

The Bible itself even ends on this same note, the spirit and the bride say, come, let the one who hears say, come and let the one who is thirsty come and the one who desires the water of life drink freely.

27:18

In Matthew 10 8, the disciples offer a message of free grace. And so they offer it freely.

27:25

We likewise offer a message of free grace. So we should likewise offer it freely.

27:32

We recognize this in so many areas. We wouldn't charge for sermons.

27:38

We wouldn't charge for sitting in a pew and we would frown on those churches in the past who had things like pew rents.

27:46

Why then would we charge for any Christian teaching? Let us not fall prey to the sort of sophistry that would see how much we can get away with or how many things we can charge for.

27:58

Let us simply embrace the command of Matthew 10 8 at face value. Let us truly reflect the radical grace and generosity of our

28:07

God. Just as we have freely received, let us freely give. Thank you for listening.

28:15

You can read what you just heard over at sellingjesus .org, along with a lot of other thought -provoking articles and resources.

28:23

And please make sure to get your own free copy of Conley's book, The Dorian Principle at thedorianprinciple .org,

28:30

which will also be linked in the description. No signups or email address required. No strings attached.

28:36

Once again, we encourage you to continue meditating on the radical generosity of the

28:42

God of the Bible and partner with us in spreading the word about this podcast, the YouTube channel, and sellingjesus .org